This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I don't question your figures but if more water is entering the whole in a sinking ship it doesn't really matter how many gallons come in a minute if you only have a bucket to bail out with. You will drown eventually. Analogy copyright of Hrolf. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (23 Feb 2016 6.21pm) O.k fair enough,it's a fairly strange analogy but I get your point. I'm responding to you points that immigration is responsible for the the housing crisis, which the figures don't suggest, so far. Yes, potentially and probably there is a natural limit to the population of the country, but considering we are living in more spacious households and not using the housing stock we have got efficiently I think it is fair enough to say we have not reached that point.
One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A |
|
|
Originally posted by Ketteridge
O.k fair enough,it's a fairly strange analogy but I get your point. I'm responding to you points that immigration is responsible for the the housing crisis, which the figures don't suggest, so far. Yes, potentially and probably there is a natural limit to the population of the country, but considering we are living in more spacious households and not using the housing stock we have got efficiently I think it is fair enough to say we have not reached that point. Ultimately. We must remember that each wave of migrants, and they will be continuous with world population increase and displacement, will have several children each. Most likely more than the average. Even if that trend slows for one wave of migrants, there will be another right behind them. The population will sharply increase year on year and an ever increasing proportion of them will be migrants.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Ultimately. We must remember that each wave of migrants, and they will be continuous with world population increase and displacement, will have several children each. Most likely more than the average. Even if that trend slows for one wave of migrants, there will be another right behind them. The population will sharply increase year on year and an ever increasing proportion of them will be migrants. Last year the population of London finally reached the level it was at in 1939. After many years of "mass immigration" we are back to where we were 80 years ago, So much for "overcrowding"!
I used to be immortal |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
Last year the population of London finally reached the level it was at in 1939. After many years of "mass immigration" we are back to where we were 80 years ago, So much for "overcrowding"! I'm not disputing the figure but wonder how the fcuk did they managed that without towerblocks. I know most people were on the outskirts but then they would have been less affected by the blitz.
|
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
Last year the population of London finally reached the level it was at in 1939. After many years of "mass immigration" we are back to where we were 80 years ago, So much for "overcrowding"! I don't know if you're being serious or joking. Maybe you don't know about slums and the slum clearance. Or families of 12 children and many families of many more than 1 child living on one storey of a house, sometimes in one room. Quite similar to how it can be now, with some people in social housing (some through bad fortune and some without much thought of preparing for the amount of babies they produce).
COYP |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
One has to define controlled. I would say that controlled means a stable population number much like it has been for decades before the recent mass immigration. Well that's not entirely true, as each decade since WWII has been marked by periods of mass migration (After the War, Indian Migration, pakistani Migration and Afro-Caribbean Migration - all really driven by a need for employees - and all met with similar arguments about society and equally less savoury ones). The primary difference between EU migration and the previous migrations has been the tendency towards the previous migrations being permanent, rather than temporary additions to the population. I agree that migration, and populations, need to be managed, but the question always remains how to regulate fairly, without resorting to a prejudicial basis, and that's where the EU migration has been problematic, the capacity to control and direct it has been driven more by market forces than the state. For other countries in Europe its a more common experience I think, given the size of borders and entry points, where as the UK as an Island, always has had a potent capacity to regulate, control and police its borders with its neighbours (something that for most mainland European countries is a much bigger undertaking).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by elgrande
I think we have to be careful with the term British passport holders. Somehow I suspect that most people worried about immigration, aren't worried about people leaving the UK. Doesn't matter where you are from, once you are a UK citizen you are British, irrespective of what anyone, including the citizen might believe. Part of what is great about this country has been its multiple ethnic influences on our culture, society and arts.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I don't know if you're being serious or joking. Maybe you don't know about slums and the slum clearance. Or families of 12 children and many families of many more than 1 child living on one storey of a house, sometimes in one room. Quite similar to how it can be now, with some people in social housing (some through bad fortune and some without much thought of preparing for the amount of babies they produce). Most major cities have a much greater population density than London; Paris roughly three times, many others even greater (and I'm not talking about Mexico City, Manilla or Sao Paulo, but places like Berlin, Barcelona, Amsterdam, Moscow, New York, Hong Kong, Milan etc. etc.) Most of those cities don't have any slums, they use space in a more planned considered way, and this is something London has belatedly started to do in recent years.
I used to be immortal |
|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
The thread title is just another word for "Multiculturalism the failed UK Experiment".
What we have got are groups within groups that can't/won't/refuse/ to get along due to the nature of their beliefs, usually religious, or just being anti-social: Chelsea racist types. Disappear those two and the vast majority would be just fine.
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
Most major cities have a much greater population density than London; Paris roughly three times, many others even greater (and I'm not talking about Mexico City, Manilla or Sao Paulo, but places like Berlin, Barcelona, Amsterdam, Moscow, New York, Hong Kong, Milan etc. etc.) Most of those cities don't have any slums, they use space in a more planned considered way, and this is something London has belatedly started to do in recent years.
I was talking about slums in London pre-WWII and your view that London was not overcrowded with population figures equal to then. So we all have to live in flats now because of other cities that were originally built high and with attractive architecture to the eye of the tourist? Have you seen the state and quality of life of some of those blocks of flats just outside of European cities? Incidentally, those Western European capitals are smaller when including the sprawl of cities. When is it a problem? When all of Sutton & Croydon and everything south into Banstead and Kenley is 1 and 2 bedroom flats? Is there no choice anymore apart from move further away where you've been to maintain a similar lifestyle?
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
What we have got are groups within groups that can't/won't/refuse/ to get along due to the nature of their beliefs, usually religious, or just being anti-social: Chelsea racist types. Disappear those two and the vast majority would be just fine. That may be true of London and certain other large citys, but go up North, even Luton, and there are whole towns that are no go areas if you are white, or not "from round here". It works in places like New york becuase essentially everyone in the states is an immigrant (unless you like wearing feathers and howling at the full moon), you are by the very definition no more than a 5/6th generation imigrant, American history goes back, what about 300 years, or in other words starts from when the pale face decided they liked the climate. I just don't think it's in the psyche of your average Briton to accept foriegn visitors as equals. We have spent thousands of years repelling invaders of one form or another from the Vikings to the Romans. And I think that comes out in peoples attitudes towards foreigners in the less cosmopolitan arears of the UK. And I can see why, your essentailly asking people to give ground and be accepting of others when for generations they've done exactly the opposite. My perosnal stance is that there should be more emphasis on intergration rather than immigration. Edited by dannyh (24 Feb 2016 11.43am)
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
What we have got are groups within groups that can't/won't/refuse/ to get along due to the nature of their beliefs, usually religious, or just being anti-social: Chelsea racist types. Disappear those two and the vast majority would be just fine. Have you shopped at the M&S end of Croydon or ever seen how many middle class people don't venture out of East Croydon station and just stay on the train or go over to platform 1 for the quickest route to London? Have you ever heard any literate people concerned about the level of UNCONTROLLED immigration? People are concerned about numbers and then, unfortunately fr the blinkered, there are people who just prefer being around their own kind, quite a natural wish, and a wish you have the right to. I think in time people do get used to people with the intention to stay and integrate, something it'll always be difficult with in the Muslim community and very different views on life and lifestyle. Where the current immigration differs is a lot of it is about coming to Britain, living for as cheap as possible, earning as much as possible in jobs that could be done by British youngsters if the government pulled their fingers out, and then returning back home with the money once they're done. It's not that they think of the money outflow when they see a rising community from outside, more that it's a growing area of migrants that means either they or other local people are moving away from. The rising figure year on year of those entering is above those who return back to their native country and will remain so, especially with more countries joining the EU. I don't blame them and I get along with everyone who's pleasant and doesn't hate us whilst setting up a new community we have no place being in but it is a problem you'd hear more of if you were here more often. Edited by Rudi Hedman (24 Feb 2016 11.46am)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Have you shopped at the M&S end of Croydon or ever seen how many middle class people don't venture out of East Croydon station and just stay on the train or go over to platform 1 for the quickest route to London? Have you ever heard any literate people concerned about the lever of UNCONTROLLED immigration? People are concerned about numbers and then, unfortunately fr the blinkered, there are people who just prefer being around their own kind, quite a natural wish, and a wish you have the right to. I think in time people do get used to people with the intention to stay and integrate, something it'll always be difficult with in the Muslim community and very different views on life and lifestyle. Where the current immigration differs is a lot of it is about coming to Britain, living for as cheap as possible, earning as much as possible in jobs that could be done by British youngsters if the government pulled their fingers out, and then returning back home once they're done. The rising figure year on year of those entering is above those who return back to their native country and will remain so, especially with more countries joining the EU. I don't blame them and I get along with everyone who's pleasant and doesn't hate us whilst setting up a new community we have no place being in but it is a problem you'd hear more of if you were here more often. London is a big place. West Croydon is a tiny area within. There are plenty of other 'West Croydons' in the metropolis but you would actually have to seek them out to experience it because, as you know, the rest of London, the most of it, folk from different backgrounds just live, work and mingle. There would be a huge amount of flare-ups if that were not the case. Has London overall been a failure of multi-culturalism? As a pretty peaceful and prosperous world city it's hard to argue that it has, surely? It would be like saying New York has failed too. Edited by Kermit8 (24 Feb 2016 11.55am)
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
London is a big place. West Croydon is a tiny area within. There are plenty of other 'West Croydons' in the metropolis but you would actually have to seek them out to experience it because, as you know, the rest of London, the most of it, folk from different backgrounds just live, work and mingle. There would be a huge amount of flare-ups if that were not the case. Has London overall been a failure of multi-culturalism? As a pretty peaceful and prosperous world city it's hard to argue that it has, surely? It would be like saying New York has failed too. Edited by Kermit8 (24 Feb 2016 11.55am) No it would not. New york is based and was built on the blood sweat and tears of immigrants, and has always been a place of a multicultural background since it came into existance. The whole history of modern America is built from immigrants. The UK wasnt and isnt. Toatlly different social and demographical histories as well you know Kerm.
"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'" |
|
|
Originally posted by Kermit8
London is a big place. West Croydon is a tiny area within. There are plenty of other 'West Croydons' in the metropolis but you would actually have to seek them out to experience it because, as you know, the rest of London, the most of it, folk from different backgrounds just live, work and mingle. There would be a huge amount of flare-ups if that were not the case. Has London overall been a failure of multi-culturalism? As a pretty peaceful and prosperous world city it's hard to argue that it has, surely? That proves you haven't been around much lately. People will get along with others at work, but when out of work, it's generally be with your own. Yes, there aren't riots and gang warfare but gradually people move away or notice how something that was within reach before, is now harder to attain. Go further north of Croydon and you get to Pollards Hill if you turn a left before Streatham Common. Same applies there as with other West Croydon's/Selhurst's etc. None of this does or will make any difference to me or you I can see but I know it does to others.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
That proves you haven't been around much lately. People will get along with others at work, but when out of work, it's generally be with your own. Yes, there aren't riots and gang warfare but gradually people move away or notice how something that was within reach before, is now harder to attain. Go further north of Croydon and you get to Pollards Hill if you turn a left before Streatham Common. Same applies there as with other West Croydon's/Selhurst's etc. None of this does or will make any difference to me or you I can see but I know it does to others. I was actually thinking of supermarkets when I said 'mingle' But now that you mention it surely the place hasn't changed so much since I lived there just over a decade ago that more central London from Notting Hill to Fulham, from the West End to Hoxton, on a Friday and Saturday night is not awash with all types having one giant hanging out/drinking/eating/gigging/comedy club/nightclubbing mingle? That's a lot of people. i don't doubt your descriptions of those places one jot btw. And 'yes' i get it affects the natives negatively. Some aspects of multi-culturalism have most definitely failed. Edited by Kermit8 (24 Feb 2016 12.23pm)
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
That may be true of London and certain other large citys, but go up North, even Luton, and there are whole towns that are no go areas if you are white, or not "from round here". It works in places like New york becuase essentially everyone in the states is an immigrant (unless you like wearing feathers and howling at the full moon), you are by the very definition no more than a 5/6th generation imigrant, American history goes back, what about 300 years, or in other words starts from when the pale face decided they liked the climate. I just don't think it's in the psyche of your average Briton to accept foriegn visitors as equals. We have spent thousands of years repelling invaders of one form or another from the Vikings to the Romans. And I think that comes out in peoples attitudes towards foreigners in the less cosmopolitan arears of the UK. And I can see why, your essentailly asking people to give ground and be accepting of others when for generations they've done exactly the opposite. My perosnal stance is that there should be more emphasis on intergration rather than immigration. Edited by dannyh (24 Feb 2016 11.43am) Well many invaders came and stayed, Romans Vikings and Normans especially! These groups formed what Britain is today, laws, customs, language, monarchy etc. etc. And because many British cities were centres of trade, people from all over the world came and stayed as well. Even in Shakespeare's time London was a multi-cultural city and other outward-looking cities were multi-cultural as well, Bristol, Liverpool, Glasgow etc. The main places where the natives have a "you're not from round these parts" have tended to be in rural places and small towns, where they do things like hang monkeys for be Napoleon's spies. London was multi-cultural before New York even existed as a city.
I used to be immortal |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I was talking about slums in London pre-WWII and your view that London was not overcrowded with population figures equal to then. So we all have to live in flats now because of other cities that were originally built high and with attractive architecture to the eye of the tourist? Have you seen the state and quality of life of some of those blocks of flats just outside of European cities? Incidentally, those Western European capitals are smaller when including the sprawl of cities. When is it a problem? When all of Sutton & Croydon and everything south into Banstead and Kenley is 1 and 2 bedroom flats? Is there no choice anymore apart from move further away where you've been to maintain a similar lifestyle? There are tower blocks and crumbling estates the world over, and all over the UK. Bad planning and construction. But equally there are well planned and well built apartment blocks as well! People have always flocked to successful cities, whether from within the country or without. It's not just migrants from abroad who choose to live in London, but people from all over the UK as well. But London saw a loss of over 2m people between the end of the war until fairly recently, I'm sure we all know friends who have moved away in the last 25-30 years, for lifestyle reasons. The need for three and four bedroom family homes is now becoming much less than in past times, as we are tending to live in smaller groups, so one and two bedrooms are more appropriate for the future. Incidentally, as I'm sure you know, there are large parts of Croydon and Sutton, as well as many other areas, that could definitely use upgrading!
I used to be immortal |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
Well many invaders came and stayed, Romans Vikings and Normans especially! These groups formed what Britain is today, laws, customs, language, monarchy etc. etc. And because many British cities were centres of trade, people from all over the world came and stayed as well. Even in Shakespeare's time London was a multi-cultural city and other outward-looking cities were multi-cultural as well, Bristol, Liverpool, Glasgow etc. The main places where the natives have a "you're not from round these parts" have tended to be in rural places and small towns, where they do things like hang monkeys for be Napoleon's spies. London was multi-cultural before New York even existed as a city. I think you'll find that the locals resisted these invasions very strongly and robustly and only 'accepted' these waves of newcomers after putting up one hell of a fight. Now, we seem to surrender without even a shot being fired.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.