You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Austerity Works
November 22 2026 1.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Austerity Works


Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
silvertop Flag Portishead 23 Feb 16 10.31am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Me too, but they should not be performing work for profit or jobs that are otherwise done by paid workers. Nick's example is exactly how these schemes get abused - and then derailed - essentially creating slave labour.

Community projects staffed by the unemployed is something I can get behind - Maybe with an incentive bonus to welfare. We shouldn't be punishing people for not having a job, or being made unemployed.

Under an older scheme, I worked for 6 months in an office for no pay except they gave me lunch and travel money. The social stuck £10 a week on my dole.

Exploited? Yes. However, the firm took me on at the end of 6 months and I have never looked back. The career has hardly been without the odd pot hole; but at least I have had one.

People who dismiss schemes such as this as slave labour etc. are short sighted. Both sides benefit. In tough recruiting times, employers employ from the employed. Apply from almost any kind of gainful employment and you have a hope.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 23 Feb 16 10.35am

Originally posted by silvertop

Under an older scheme, I worked for 6 months in an office for no pay except they gave me lunch and travel money. The social stuck £10 a week on my dole.

Exploited? Yes. However, the firm took me on at the end of 6 months and I have never looked back. The career has hardly been without the odd pot hole; but at least I have had one.

People who dismiss schemes such as this as slave labour etc. are short sighted. Both sides benefit. In tough recruiting times, employers employ from the employed. Apply from almost any kind of gainful employment and you have a hope.

I think your case (and I'm pleased for you) is an exception not the rule, unless you can persuade me otherwise.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 16 10.47am

Originally posted by silvertop

Under an older scheme, I worked for 6 months in an office for no pay except they gave me lunch and travel money. The social stuck £10 a week on my dole.

Exploited? Yes. However, the firm took me on at the end of 6 months and I have never looked back. The career has hardly been without the odd pot hole; but at least I have had one.

People who dismiss schemes such as this as slave labour etc. are short sighted. Both sides benefit. In tough recruiting times, employers employ from the employed. Apply from almost any kind of gainful employment and you have a hope.

Me too, YTS worked out great for me. But for a lot of people it wasn't true. The system needs to be set in advance to ensure that its not producing a 'slave labour' force. I don't mind people working unemployed towards a real prospect of a job or employment, that's how it should work - Like an Intern job.

But there are also the horror stories of people essentially being exploited. It has to be towards gainful employment - ie a career. Just providing people to work for Tesco's or JD Sports isn't enough - It has to always be to the benefit of individual, society and company.

Not a means by which the unemployed are punished.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 16 10.51am

Originally posted by nickgusset

Interestingly, those on 'workfare' schemes are not counted in unemployment figures.

Indeed, because Politics is always about looking like you're doing something, than actually doing something. True of both sides.

Its like dealing with poverty, simply by changing the definition, rather than the issue. Sickens me. The only thing lower than a career politician is a sex offender.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 23 Feb 16 11.35am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I'm curious as to what kind of dole scheme they're on that pays so well. That said, an mobile phone, TV, drinking 'premium lager' and getting a takeaway is hardly the life of Riley. A lot of people who are unemployed, and on benefits, also work legally and essentially top up their benefits.

The problem with a food voucher system is you'd also need a transport voucher system, clothing voucher system, fuel purchase voucher system, utility voucher system etc. The problem isn't with handing these vouchers out, its with private firms recouping them, and then being credited which is a logistic nightmare to implement - Especially if you want the vouchers to be traceable to the person they were issued to. These schemes when tried before elsewhere in the world have only lead to greater cost to the state, increased problems for the unemployed, a black market in the vouchers.

You're creating barriers/excuses again.

I'm talking about FOOD vouchers, that could be redeemed somewhere within a reasonable walking distance.

Issuing them with food vouchers ensures food is provided for them and their family.

If they are stupid enough to then trade the food or vouchers for cash to buy fags/booze/drugs etc then it just proves my point about the futility of trying to help "no hopers".

 

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 23 Feb 16 12.05pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Me too, YTS worked out great for me. But for a lot of people it wasn't true. The system needs to be set in advance to ensure that its not producing a 'slave labour' force. I don't mind people working unemployed towards a real prospect of a job or employment, that's how it should work - Like an Intern job.

But there are also the horror stories of people essentially being exploited. It has to be towards gainful employment - ie a career. Just providing people to work for Tesco's or JD Sports isn't enough - It has to always be to the benefit of individual, society and company.

Not a means by which the unemployed are punished.


A good scheme that is well targeted and with clear outcomes will be of great benefit. Companies will potential face cost when taking on new staff especially if that role needs specific training. If the cost of training outweighs the productive of that trainee then a company may potential take a short term decision to not employ that trainee. This,in the long term, will have a knock on effect for company as they will begin to lack the trained staff but also for the government and economy as whole, lower tax revenue a less skilled workforce etc. In those circumstances it is sensible that a government steps in and fills that gap.
The problem is DWP don't seem to have many figures on the effectiveness of the schemes and there own reports seem to suggest it does not any have effect on either long term employment or reduction in benefits. [Link] .

Currently 104,000 people are on government supported training schemes if you assume that all of them are doing a job that would otherwise be at minimum wage of an 18-20, so a fairly conservative estimate of the make up of workfare. That equates to £1 billion pound of labour cost that business are avoiding by using work fare. Every little bit helps I suppose.

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 16 12.07pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

You're creating barriers/excuses again.

I'm talking about FOOD vouchers, that could be redeemed somewhere within a reasonable walking distance.

Issuing them with food vouchers ensures food is provided for them and their family.

If they are stupid enough to then trade the food or vouchers for cash to buy fags/booze/drugs etc then it just proves my point about the futility of trying to help "no hopers".

So what about clothing, transport and fuel (getting to interviews and work), bills etc presumably they'd still receive cash for them then? Also things like Internet and mobile phones are essential in looking for work.

The problem still remains that even if you bypass the risks of trade and sell on, that you have to create an entire bureaucracy around the vouchers being redeemed for money by the assorted companies accepting them and then paying those recipients, and making it worth their while to participate (as they'll have to wait to be able to receive their money for the food).

The advantage of using existing currency systems, is that this system is already in place, accepted and operating. This administration and set up would be a very expensive undertaking. Essentially its adding a new form of currency exchange that isn't really necessary.

To me, it seems like ultimately being a waste of money aimed at dealing with a minority those on welfare.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

silvertop Flag Portishead 23 Feb 16 4.32pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

I think your case (and I'm pleased for you) is an exception not the rule, unless you can persuade me otherwise.

I am saying it doesn't strictly matter. Unless you are being employed under actual slave conditions, you are still employed even if what you do appears on the face of it to be exploitation, drudgery or whatever. Having been out of work 4 times in my life for no fault of my own, I couldn't buy a job while out of work. Get a job labouring on a building site or breaking boxes at BHS or doing anything that can be construed as gainful employment and prospective employers will be more likely to consider you. If you say you are currently "looking for work", your application will be binned with no further consideration.

The issues about employers abusing the system and the government cooking the books are valid. However, if you are without employment and without hope simply entering the employment market in any capacity is one rung on the ladder; and once you are there you get the extra free jump up another rung as you can use the posting as a platform to get a better job. Seriously, any person who uses the system well doesn't give a hoot about whether they are no longer part of the unemployment statistics.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 16 4.40pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I am saying it doesn't strictly matter. Unless you are being employed under actual slave conditions, you are still employed even if what you do appears on the face of it to be exploitation, drudgery or whatever. Having been out of work 4 times in my life for no fault of my own, I couldn't buy a job while out of work. Get a job labouring on a building site or breaking boxes at BHS or doing anything that can be construed as gainful employment and prospective employers will be more likely to consider you. If you say you are currently "looking for work", your application will be binned with no further consideration.

The issues about employers abusing the system and the government cooking the books are valid. However, if you are without employment and without hope simply entering the employment market in any capacity is one rung on the ladder; and once you are there you get the extra free jump up another rung as you can use the posting as a platform to get a better job. Seriously, any person who uses the system well doesn't give a hoot about whether they are no longer part of the unemployment statistics.

Slave conditions - Forced to work in return for sustenance, shelter and accommodation.

I'm a 'take anything' kind of guy. When I was unemployed in my late 20s, I applied for anything - but then I could also afford to as I had low overheads - Its a different story if you have dependents.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (23 Feb 2016 4.42pm)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 24 Feb 16 4.16pm

[Link]


Scroungers!

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 24 Feb 16 7.02pm

'Austerity Works' = new road sign set up by Southern Gas for excuse of repeated roadworks.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 28 Feb 16 5.59pm

We are losing our lollipop patrols here in Devon to save a measly £250,000 after more enforced budget cutbacks.

And knowing some of the roads that will be affected it is only a matter of time for the worst news possible for any parents

Some things should be untouchable and kids' safety should be top of the list.

Hate the council for doing this and hate the government for pressurising them into having to make such decisions. Beyond criminal. Wholly immoral and just plain wrong.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Bert the Head Flag Epsom 28 Feb 16 10.49pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

You're creating barriers/excuses again.

I'm talking about FOOD vouchers, that could be redeemed somewhere within a reasonable walking distance.

Issuing them with food vouchers ensures food is provided for them and their family.

If they are stupid enough to then trade the food or vouchers for cash to buy fags/booze/drugs etc then it just proves my point about the futility of trying to help "no hopers".

We all know that capitalism has highs and lows. If someone has worked and paid tax and then a low sweeps in and they are unemployed they should be afforded dignity rather than just a meal.

There is a growing case list of companies that take advantage of state handouts every bit as much as the scapegoated unemployed. If we have a decent welfare system based on contributions through work - like the one Maggie removed - then we can go back to the principle that while the sun shines people work and pay in to the welfare system and when it rains and global forces push up unemployment, then they take out.

The myth is that there is a large group of welfare claimants who are perpetually taking the piss. The truth is that work is less secure and lower paid and there is a large group of people claiming welfare because of poor wages (to subsidize good profits at the shareholder end) or experiencing intermittent bouts of unemployment.

I think that people who have shares in the railways who earn a dividend for investing in a company that is bailed out by the tax payer every year, are scrounging far more than anyone who doesn't want to work. Its the same with people who bought post office shares cheap and then quickly sold them. Its just a state handout to someone who has a bit of spare cash.




 

johnfirewall Flag 28 Feb 16 11.41pm

Originally posted by Bert the Head


I think that people who have shares in the railways who earn a dividend for investing in a company that is bailed out by the tax payer every year, are scrounging far more than anyone who doesn't want to work. Its the same with people who bought post office shares cheap and then quickly sold them. Its just a state handout to someone who has a bit of spare cash.


Working your way out of poverty (and let's not use that word lightly, because there are some very successful people who came from literally nothing, which is a lot less than even the longest term unemployment benefit claimants have) to be able to purchase a few Royal Mail shares is a lot more admirable than not bothering.

It was another thread where Nick Gusset contested the assertion that the left are anti-business but there you go. If Delboy and Rodney had become millionaires most you lot would be calling them cnuts.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 28 Feb 16 11.56pm

Originally posted by Bert the Head

We all know that capitalism has highs and lows. If someone has worked and paid tax and then a low sweeps in and they are unemployed they should be afforded dignity rather than just a meal.

There is a growing case list of companies that take advantage of state handouts every bit as much as the scapegoated unemployed. If we have a decent welfare system based on contributions through work - like the one Maggie removed - then we can go back to the principle that while the sun shines people work and pay in to the welfare system and when it rains and global forces push up unemployment, then they take out.

The myth is that there is a large group of welfare claimants who are perpetually taking the piss. The truth is that work is less secure and lower paid and there is a large group of people claiming welfare because of poor wages (to subsidize good profits at the shareholder end) or experiencing intermittent bouts of unemployment.

I think that people who have shares in the railways who earn a dividend for investing in a company that is bailed out by the tax payer every year, are scrounging far more than anyone who doesn't want to work. Its the same with people who bought post office shares cheap and then quickly sold them. Its just a state handout to someone who has a bit of spare cash.




Anyone who doesn't want to work, shouldn't get anything surely?

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 29 Feb 16 8.00am

Originally posted by Kermit8

We are losing our lollipop patrols here in Devon to save a measly £250,000 after more enforced budget cutbacks.

And knowing some of the roads that will be affected it is only a matter of time for the worst news possible for any parents

Some things should be untouchable and kids' safety should be top of the list.

Hate the council for doing this and hate the government for pressurising them into having to make such decisions. Beyond criminal. Wholly immoral and just plain wrong.

You've got bugger all constructive to do all day (watching Fake Taxi and eating 'South London Tapas' are not constructive uses of a mans time). Why don't you volunteer as a lollipop man?

If you care as much as you say you do, do something about it!

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 29 Feb 16 10.23am

Originally posted by johnfirewall

Working your way out of poverty (and let's not use that word lightly, because there are some very successful people who came from literally nothing, which is a lot less than even the longest term unemployment benefit claimants have) to be able to purchase a few Royal Mail shares is a lot more admirable than not bothering.

It was another thread where Nick Gusset contested the assertion that the left are anti-business but there you go. If Delboy and Rodney had become millionaires most you lot would be calling them cnuts.

There is nothing wrong with being rich or well off - That's absurd - The problem occurs when as a society you have such a disproportionate distribution that is the problem.

When you look at how wealth distribution maps out, its clear that there is a problem, where so much of the wealth belongs to such a tiny section of society.

No one who works 40 hours a week should be in poverty.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 29 Feb 16 10.28am

Originally posted by matt_himself

You've got bugger all constructive to do all day (watching Fake Taxi and eating 'South London Tapas' are not constructive uses of a mans time). Why don't you volunteer as a lollipop man?

If you care as much as you say you do, do something about it!

Because replacing people who are paid for a job with people who do it for free is a symptom of the problem.

The problem of cuts isn't resolved by 'free workers', that just encourages laying people off, and replacing them with cheap or free labour.

Work should be paid, and paid fairly. It shouldn't be cheap migrant labour to keep wages low, and it shouldn't be volunteers. People who work should be fairly rewarded for doing so, not racking up debts to make ends meet.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 29 Feb 16 10.39am

Originally posted by Bert the Head

We all know that capitalism has highs and lows. If someone has worked and paid tax and then a low sweeps in and they are unemployed they should be afforded dignity rather than just a meal.

There is a growing case list of companies that take advantage of state handouts every bit as much as the scapegoated unemployed. If we have a decent welfare system based on contributions through work - like the one Maggie removed - then we can go back to the principle that while the sun shines people work and pay in to the welfare system and when it rains and global forces push up unemployment, then they take out.

The myth is that there is a large group of welfare claimants who are perpetually taking the piss. The truth is that work is less secure and lower paid and there is a large group of people claiming welfare because of poor wages (to subsidize good profits at the shareholder end) or experiencing intermittent bouts of unemployment.

I think that people who have shares in the railways who earn a dividend for investing in a company that is bailed out by the tax payer every year, are scrounging far more than anyone who doesn't want to work. Its the same with people who bought post office shares cheap and then quickly sold them. Its just a state handout to someone who has a bit of spare cash.

You really do live in a dream world Bert.

For a start anyone that has invested any money in the railways would be showing a hefty loss right now. Small dividends don't compensate for drastic reductions in share prices when the markets get spooked by China's growth slowing, Oil prices dropping or bad news in general.

I guess you're not averse to a bargain Bert? If your local sweet shop was selling easter eggs cheap you wouldn't buy them? Same goes for shares - yes I bought and sold them and made money but I've lost on other shares I've bought on occasions... it's a gamble the stock market... you win some you lose some.

The line I've highlighted in red is laughable - that is no myth. One family in my road has a 23 year old son that never works but is always in our local club drinking and going outside for a smoke and to chat to his mates on his iPhone. The only day he gets out of bed before noon is his day to report in to the Job shop or whatever it is called.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 29 Feb 16 10.50am

Originally posted by matt_himself

You've got bugger all constructive to do all day (watching Fake Taxi and eating 'South London Tapas' are not constructive uses of a mans time). Why don't you volunteer as a lollipop man?

If you care as much as you say you do, do something about it!


How's the jet lag you poor diddums?

I don't know how you do it: Work for 25 years, now help to run a business, have a family and do up houses.

Oh,wait. That's not you, Your the guy who spends his other time whingeing and telling everyone over and over about his African connections trying to convince.


It's difficult to squeeze Fake Taxi and tapas in more than twice a week these days due to whatnot. Austerity gone crazy.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Austerity Works