You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The left and Jewish people
November 22 2026 12.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The left and Jewish people


Page 8 of 22 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Bert the Head Flag Epsom 29 Apr 16 11.57pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Yeah but it's all context. Hitler was never doing them a favour and in support of Zionism, he just wanted them gone from Germany. And he certainly hated Jews the very moment Germany waved the white flag in the trenches of Belgium. He didn't hate them after he went mad. He hated Jews all along. And you could argue was very calculated in his actions rather than being mad.

This confusion of Judaism, Zionism and Israeli Govt policy is a delicate issue and gets people into all sorts of trouble, often those who feel the need to be in the news/social media. They should either keep quiet or encourage debate over Israeli Govt policy rather than bringing in bizarre snippets of history or confusion over Jews, Judaism, Zionism, Israel.

They have a responsibility as opposition to govt but are embarrassing themselves.

 

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 30 Apr 16 12.24am

I agree of course Hitler wasn't doing Jewish people a favour with his policy of transportation and I don't think Livingstone was saying he was.

But in my view the conflation of criticism of Israeli Govt policy with antisemitism is stifling debate and supporting Israel's murder of Palestinian people; Its basically political correctness gone mad.

I accept that European history is full of dreadful acts of inhumanity (though humans definitely did it just as humans are murdering Palestinians) against Jewish people, including the massacres, pogroms and of course the holocaust.

I have recently read lots of Jewish content providers who were supposed supporters of the Labour party who have said that they cannot support the Labour Party anymore. This is basically because Corbyn won't support Israel's genocide. Well a while back I used to support Israel but I cannot support that murdering nation anymore. I am glad the Labour Party doesn't either.

Having a party that stands up for the weak against the powerful is brilliant.

Edited by Bert the Head (30 Apr 2016 12.25am)

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 30 Apr 16 1.41am

Originally posted by Bert the Head

I agree of course Hitler wasn't doing Jewish people a favour with his policy of transportation and I don't think Livingstone was saying he was.

But in my view the conflation of criticism of Israeli Govt policy with antisemitism is stifling debate and supporting Israel's murder of Palestinian people; Its basically political correctness gone mad.

I accept that European history is full of dreadful acts of inhumanity (though humans definitely did it just as humans are murdering Palestinians) against Jewish people, including the massacres, pogroms and of course the holocaust.

I have recently read lots of Jewish content providers who were supposed supporters of the Labour party who have said that they cannot support the Labour Party anymore. This is basically because Corbyn won't support Israel's genocide. Well a while back I used to support Israel but I cannot support that murdering nation anymore. I am glad the Labour Party doesn't either.

Having a party that stands up for the weak against the powerful is brilliant.

Edited by Bert the Head (30 Apr 2016 12.25am)

First, do you even know what the definition of genocide is? If Israel is committing it, brutal as Israeli government policy has sometimes been, then they've been spectacularly unsuccessful for nearly 70 years despite their possession of military might. Mind you, the UN definition fits the policies and actions of Hamas and Hizbollah. But they're your oppressed so it's ok. Right?

Livingstone explicitly claimed that it was a fact that Hitler supported Zionism. That's not just ignorant that is a lie. That is also an argument made by the extreme right when trying to deny the holocaust.

Naz Shah calling for resettlement for all Jews, as that is what her posting clearly meant, is not anti-Zionist it is racist. Has she talked about Israeli government policy being counter-productive, that would be one thing. But she didn't. She's as racist as Livingstone.

If racism and the support of groups that would exterminate whole peoples passes for standing up for the oppressed. God help us.


Edited by NickinOX (30 Apr 2016 1.46am)

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

legaleagle Flag 30 Apr 16 9.58am

I find myself right in the middle.I have posted my views earlier and I am also at times not a million miles away from the views of the individual whose comments Kermit posted.

But,just on two points:Israel's government (like quite a few others not attracting the same opprobrium ) has carried out awful policies of brutal oppression.But,its not genocide and the lazy usage of the term in this context undermines both the credibility of those who use the term and the usage where appropriate of the term.

What Israel does at times has,say, an equivalence to Turkey and the Kurds...it doesn't have an equivalence to say "us" in North America and Australia or the Spanish in Central and Latin America..or to the Holocaust, which might equate to "genocide".

In terms of Ken and Hitler, yes its true that the transfer agreement existed.Trying to negotiate to get Jews away from Germany,post Mein Kampf and Hitler coming to power? Hardly dodgy IMO on the part of the zionists or a point to be legitimately used in an anti-Israel context.. Ken's reference to such matters in the context he was speaking about (ie are there anti-Jewish views circulating in the Labour Party?) was on the other hand well dodgy.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 30 Apr 16 10.21am

It's hard for people to separate Judaism from Zionism and Judaism from Israel and it's government simply because Israel exists only because of the Jewish faith and Zionism.
In my view, Israel should not exist, It was a poorly conceived idea to appease Jews after the Holocaust and one that got quickly out of control. Anyone with a conscience must sympathise with the plight of Jews in WW2 but the allies just created one disaster from another. History supports my attitude,
When we try to separate Zionism from Judaism and the Israeli government it is reasonable to do so in the present but from a historical perspective the whole situation was created by faith and a desire to be separate. The whole of Jewish history seems to be about their desire to be separate from "Gentiles" and everyone else wishing to be rid of them. And this is where we have come to as a result.

The scourge of religion and religious delusion has a heavy human price.

 

legaleagle Flag 30 Apr 16 10.33am

That is where you unfortunately seemingly have a lack of knowledge,and in so doing are in danger of taking some hoary old canards at face value.

The zionists who created modern day zionism were secular and not motivated by religious belief. Rather, by "ethnic" identity and nascent "nationalism".The sole reason for it was as a perceived solution to centuries of getting utterly shafted and forced to be "separate"as fall guys on behalf of good old christian civilisation.(because of their ethnicty/religion).Being sick of this way of life and having despaired of being allowed to integrate fully due to pervasive anti semitism,particularly in central and eastern europe,they looked for another solution,self determination in their "ancestral" homeland from which the good old christian Romans had ever so kindly ethnically cleansed them.....which of course then tragically led to its own innate contradictions and problems...

So,while there is a valid debate about the rights and wrongs of zionism,and the rights and wrongs of Israel, and the rights and wrongs of a state in place along the apartheid like lines sought by Hamas,its not a debate based on your underlying premises.

As for the old hoary line about hard to separate Jews per se wherever they may be from zionists,because zionists are Jews,pleeaaaseeee....

Edited by legaleagle (30 Apr 2016 10.44am)

 

Hoof Hearted 30 Apr 16 11.11am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

It's hard for people to separate Judaism from Zionism and Judaism from Israel and it's government simply because Israel exists only because of the Jewish faith and Zionism.
In my view, Israel should not exist, It was a poorly conceived idea to appease Jews after the Holocaust and one that got quickly out of control. Anyone with a conscience must sympathise with the plight of Jews in WW2 but the allies just created one disaster from another. History supports my attitude,
When we try to separate Zionism from Judaism and the Israeli government it is reasonable to do so in the present but from a historical perspective the whole situation was created by faith and a desire to be separate. The whole of Jewish history seems to be about their desire to be separate from "Gentiles" and everyone else wishing to be rid of them. And this is where we have come to as a result.

The scourge of religion and religious delusion has a heavy human price.

I must admit.... the committee that came up with the plan to put Israel slap bang in the middle of the Arabs must have known it was like putting a burning stick in a wasps' nest.

It hasn't really worked has it?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 30 Apr 16 11.28am

Originally posted by legaleagle

That is where you unfortunately seemingly have a lack of knowledge,and in so doing are in danger of taking some hoary old canards at face value.

The zionists who created modern day zionism were secular and not motivated by religious belief. Rather, by "ethnic" identity and nascent "nationalism".The sole reason for it was as a perceived solution to centuries of getting utterly shafted and forced to be "separate"as fall guys on behalf of good old christian civilisation.(because of their ethnicty/religion).Being sick of this way of life and having despaired of being allowed to integrate fully due to pervasive anti semitism,particularly in central and eastern europe,they looked for another solution,self determination in their "ancestral" homeland from which the good old christian Romans had ever so kindly ethnically cleansed them.....which of course then tragically led to its own innate contradictions and problems...

So,while there is a valid debate about the rights and wrongs of zionism,and the rights and wrongs of Israel, and the rights and wrongs of a state in place along the apartheid like lines sought by Hamas,its not a debate based on your underlying premises.

As for the old hoary line about hard to separate Jews per se wherever they may be from zionists,because zionists are Jews,pleeaaaseeee....

Edited by legaleagle (30 Apr 2016 10.44am)

I'm sorry but I'm not letting you get away with that.

Zionism is a direct result of Judaism and the Jewish desire to return to the Biblical interpretation of the promised land.
You cannot just conveniently draw a distinction and claim everyone else is ignorant. There is a direct relationship.
The fact that there is not a 100% consensus among Jews about Jewish attitudes does not alter history or make the facts change.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Apr 16 11.31am

Originally posted by legaleagle

That is where you unfortunately seemingly have a lack of knowledge,and in so doing are in danger of taking some hoary old canards at face value.

The zionists who created modern day zionism were secular and not motivated by religious belief. Rather, by "ethnic" identity and nascent "nationalism".The sole reason for it was as a perceived solution to centuries of getting utterly shafted and forced to be "separate"as fall guys on behalf of good old christian civilisation.(because of their ethnicty/religion).Being sick of this way of life and having despaired of being allowed to integrate fully due to pervasive anti semitism,particularly in central and eastern europe,they looked for another solution,self determination in their "ancestral" homeland from which the good old christian Romans had ever so kindly ethnically cleansed them.....which of course then tragically led to its own innate contradictions and problems...

So,while there is a valid debate about the rights and wrongs of zionism,and the rights and wrongs of Israel, and the rights and wrongs of a state in place along the apartheid like lines sought by Hamas,its not a debate based on your underlying premises.

As for the old hoary line about hard to separate Jews per se wherever they may be from zionists,because zionists are Jews,pleeaaaseeee....

The Kibbutz movement. The problem was that those settlements that weren't such an issue with the Arabs at the time, kept spreading. It might have been a land in decay, but it was their home.

Not all Jews agree with Israeli policies but you do get the impression some are encouraged to wave the flag about in patriotism for their identity when they either have little do with the country or don't even know its direction past and present.

On the one hand I understand the Israeli paranoia, surrounded by citizens of countries who hate them. 'Israel must exist' - that's from people in the UK and US. But on the other hand there's the oppression and land grabbing. Where's Tony Blair and Gordon Brown when you need them? They can save the world.

 


COYP

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 30 Apr 16 11.43am

Originally posted by legaleagle

That is where you unfortunately seemingly have a lack of knowledge,and in so doing are in danger of taking some hoary old canards at face value.

The zionists who created modern day zionism were secular and not motivated by religious belief. Rather, by "ethnic" identity and nascent "nationalism".The sole reason for it was as a perceived solution to centuries of getting utterly shafted and forced to be "separate"as fall guys on behalf of good old christian civilisation.(because of their ethnicty/religion).Being sick of this way of life and having despaired of being allowed to integrate fully due to pervasive anti semitism,particularly in central and eastern europe,they looked for another solution,self determination in their "ancestral" homeland from which the good old christian Romans had ever so kindly ethnically cleansed them.....which of course then tragically led to its own innate contradictions and problems...

So,while there is a valid debate about the rights and wrongs of zionism,and the rights and wrongs of Israel, and the rights and wrongs of a state in place along the apartheid like lines sought by Hamas,its not a debate based on your underlying premises.

As for the old hoary line about hard to separate Jews per se wherever they may be from zionists,because zionists are Jews,pleeaaaseeee....

Edited by legaleagle (30 Apr 2016 10.44am)

This is rather typical of religious groups in general to blame everyone else for their woes. I'm sure the Nazis blames everyone else, including the Jews, for the state of Germany after WW1.
Religion has an identity. It has clothing, it has culture, it has custom that separates it form other people. You cannot then blame everyone else for isolating you when you isolate yourself by clinging on to religious doctrine and tradition. It is the minority who have to adapt and integrate in their own interests regardless of their beliefs or ethnicity.
Tolerance will always run second to self interest and when one group, the ones with the power, takes that to an extreme you have something as terrible as the Holocaust or as some might note, the displacement of Palestinians.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 30 Apr 16 11.53am

All deflecting away from more important issues in the press. They're making more of the situation than they really need to.
I wonder what bad news has been buried over the last couple of days...

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 30 Apr 16 11.54am

Originally posted by nickgusset

All deflecting away from more important issues in the press. They're making more of the situation than they really need to.
I wonder what bad news has been buried over the last couple of days...

To be fair. Ken is the gift that just keeps giving

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 30 Apr 16 11.56am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

To be fair. Ken is the gift that just keeps giving

Goes without saying...

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 30 Apr 16 12.03pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

All deflecting away from more important issues in the press. They're making more of the situation than they really need to.
I wonder what bad news has been buried over the last couple of days...

It must be a Tory plot. They are feeding Ken something to make him even more of a prat than he is already.

And to think, only a few years ago the wisdom of the Left was holding him up as the Messiah of London.

Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha!

 

johnfirewall Flag 30 Apr 16 1.53pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

All deflecting away from more important issues in the press. They're making more of the situation than they really need to.
I wonder what bad news has been buried over the last couple of days...

Are these the sort of problems you think the multiple recent accusations of Anti-semitism are overshadowing? Because this is what I've just seen from the Socialist Worker morons on the High Street:

'End the Tory Rule'
'Migrants welcome'
'The 96 were killed by the Tories'
'Stop Islamophobia'

I've no doubt the last one was intentionally selected to undermine the vile attitudes this thread was intended to address.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 30 Apr 16 10.20pm

Originally posted by johnfirewall

Are these the sort of problems you think the multiple recent accusations of Anti-semitism are overshadowing? Because this is what I've just seen from the Socialist Worker morons on the High Street:

'End the Tory Rule'
'Migrants welcome'
'The 96 were killed by the Tories'
'Stop Islamophobia'

I've no doubt the last one was intentionally selected to undermine the vile attitudes this thread was intended to address.

How many cases have their been in the last few weeks? Six maybe seven. Out of how many labour members? How quickly has each case been dealt with, the slowest was 1 day.

The press are having a field day by over exaggerating the problem in order to taint labour the week before an election.

Edited by nickgusset (30 Apr 2016 10.20pm)

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 30 Apr 16 10.57pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

How many cases have their been in the last few weeks? Six maybe seven. Out of how many labour members? How quickly has each case been dealt with, the slowest was 1 day.

The press are having a field day by over exaggerating the problem in order to taint labour the week before an election.

Edited by nickgusset (30 Apr 2016 10.20pm)

So, racism that isn't over-exaggerated is ok then? As long as it is the right type of racism. Hmmm...

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 30 Apr 16 11.06pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

So, racism that isn't over-exaggerated is ok then? As long as it is the right type of racism. Hmmm...

They're over exaggerating and implying that anti semetism is endemic within labour, which it clearly isn't.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 30 Apr 16 11.16pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

They're over exaggerating and implying that anti semetism is endemic within labour, which it clearly isn't.

I don't think it is endemic, but in my experience it was a real problem. Some of the worst racism I ever heard was a meeting where representatives of the local grouping of the SWP showed up (we were planning action against the closure of the Middlesex hospital in London), and one of their lot spent half the meeting spouting on about how Jews controlled the media and the money supply. Only a colleague of mine and me challenged this.

The real problem Labour has is that they don't think there is a problem. They're in denial.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Hoof Hearted 01 May 16 8.21am

You'd think that during an election period all sides would bring their A game to the table to try and gain as many local government seats, councils and mayors.

Sadly what we are seeing from Labour is their A game under Corbyn's leadership.

He's turned the party into a 6th form left wing debating society at best....... -.-'

Scotland has pretty much had enough of them and even the Tories are polling more than them.

I reckon they will have a hard time of it south of the border too. If Wales desert them then we could be looking at a rout.

Corbyn's position as leader will still be safe though as he is the 'future'.

 

Page 8 of 22 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The left and Jewish people