You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 9.39am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Marco Silva (LOCKED)


Page 8 of 30 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
laddo Flag london 25 May 17 7.16am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

Where I would prefer mancini, dismissing silva is odd. The fact he made hull even resemble a premier league side was in itself a miracle. Remember, this is a club that had 13 senior players in august, had lost their manager, sacked another manager in December, got silva in but weeks later sold their two best players in Livermore and Snodgrass.

It's true, he looked lost against us in that last game but what was he supposed to do once 2-0 down. He has a lot to prove but quite frankly, with the other names out there I wouldn't be too sad if this happened.

 


laddo

"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist".
David Brent.

LONDONMAN 25 May 17 7.19am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by homes

You talk about clueless then you mention Ranieri

I know Silva is highly rated but that is all. If Mancini is a possibility then it has to be him, his currently favourite.

Mancini was 16/1 on Tuesday after Allardyce quit. Now 17/10 - I would say he is the strong candidate, not Silva.

The only issue for me is who will form Mancini's backroom team if he does become Palace boss.

Potentially it could be Lombardo, but it would be great to think some of the staff that joined with Sam will stay.

The fitness and spirit of the players went up noticeably from January onwards - although every manager usually has in own favourites that follow from job to job.

 


Hi! I'm Ed Winchester!

dannyboy1978 Flag 25 May 17 7.23am

My main worry is he is not a big enough character to control the egos in the dressing room. Also will he attract the big signings?

 

Flightsequence Flag 25 May 17 7.36am

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

My main worry is he is not a big enough character to control the egos in the dressing room. Also will he attract the big signings?

Very good point. I think handling the players is gauged on what success you have on the training ground and on the pitch. If they think he knows what he's doing, they will be ok. Ranieri at Leicester was ok, then they turned on him when things started to go wrong. I suppose only Mancini could probably handle the big names. I'm really nervous about the next manager appointment. It could be sink or swim time. So disrupting!

Edited by Flightsequence (25 May 2017 9.18am)

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 25 May 17 8.05am

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

My main worry is he is not a big enough character to control the egos in the dressing room. Also will he attract the big signings?

I think if you look at it practically, in the short term we do not need 'big' signings, we actually need a few squad signings. Silva lost Livermore and snood grass in Jan and purchased a few lesser known players, several for around 2 to 3 mill. He actually made approx 3.5 mill in profit in dealings in Jan and improved his team. We spent 40 mill to do this. I think it's obvious he has a good knowledge of players around the continent who could strengthen the squad ready for next season. If he is successful at Palace after doing this his reputation maybe enough to help attract 'bigger' signings next season.

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 25 May 17 8.08am

Originally posted by Dan89

Terrible appointment in my opinion. He Lost at home to Sunderland. 7 defeats in 9 away from home. We smashed them 4-0. He's left he's last 2 job after a year. If this man is so good why didn't he keep hull up. Typical Palace cheap appointment.

To be fair Hull were dead in the water and he gave them a chance. With better players and a decent transfer budget I think he could be a good appointment. Of course any manager comes with risk but we have to get someone.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 May 17 8.41am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by laddo

Where I would prefer mancini, dismissing silva is odd. The fact he made hull even resemble a premier league side was in itself a miracle. Remember, this is a club that had 13 senior players in august, had lost their manager, sacked another manager in December, got silva in but weeks later sold their two best players in Livermore and Snodgrass.

It's true, he looked lost against us in that last game but what was he supposed to do once 2-0 down. He has a lot to prove but quite frankly, with the other names out there I wouldn't be too sad if this happened.

This all over.

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 May 17 8.49am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by OneMax

Its a good job some of you are not responsible for selecting our next Manager, lets leave to the board who seem to know something about football.

But we are all allowed to an opinion however misplaced or cranky.

Edited by OneMax (25 May 2017 6.42am)

Do you think these qualities refer to Messrs Harris & Blitzer in terms of selecting our next manager ?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 May 17 8.52am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by Dan89

no one had even heard of silva in 2016. Hes's still the manager that conceded 11 goals in last 2. They conceded a lot of goals from set pieces included when silva been in charge(not another pardew). 2 clean sheets in 14games. The pulis and Sam stint proves we need a solid structure.

He's all results achieved at hull in the prem:-

Jan 14th W 3-1 b'mouth - home
Jan 22nd L 2-0 Chelsea - away
Feb 1st. D 0-0 Man Utd - away
Feb. 4th w 2-0 Liverpool- home
Feb. 11th L 2-0 Arsenal - Away
Feb. 25th D 1-1 Burnley - home
Mar. 4th L 3-1 Leicester- Away
Mar 11th. W 2-1 Swansea - home
Mar 18th L 4-0 Everton- away
Apr. 1st. W 2-1 West Ham - home
Apr. 5th W 4-2 m' boro - home
Apr. 8th L 3-1. Man City - away
Apr. 15th L 3-1. Stoke - away
Apr. 22nd w 2-0 Watford- home
Apr 29th D 0-0. Southampton- away
May 6th L 2-0 Sunderland - home
May 14th L 4-0 C Palace - away
May 21 st L 7-1 Spurs - home

He may of had a poor squad to work with but trying to outscore the opponent isn't what we do successfully.

All of those losses you'd expect them to lose apart from Sunderland. He had a brilliant response from a sh1t squad that was made even worse in January. If it wasn't for the Sunderland result we could be arguing which championship manager to bring in and how much we should 'want' hull to pay for a, b, or c players.

Are you sure you know what you're talking about? All you keep doing is saying he was relegated whilst ignoring the BS situation he had to deal with which you've had explained to you over and over and was remarkable he almost had them survive, yet you type out the same win ratio this, that, the other 16 hours a day.

Don't you think all managers know how to defend deep and play on the counter, and if they have the players to implement it, all the better? It could actually be discussed at interview stage.

 


COYP

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 25 May 17 8.52am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

I wanted Mancini before Allardyce was appointed.

We would be foolish to dismiss him.he ticks all the boxes.

Knows the premier league. is a proven winner.will attract top players.

What's not to like.hope this happens.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 May 17 8.53am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by black eagle.

I wanted Mancini before Allardyce was appointed.

We would be foolish to dismiss him.he ticks all the boxes.

Knows the premier league. is a proven winner.will attract top players.

What's not to like.hope this happens.

.......Only ever worked with huge budgets.

 


COYP

Top_Don_Cpfc Flag Brixton 25 May 17 9.05am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

.......Only ever worked with huge budgets.

This!

What was his record record at Galatasaray like?

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 25 May 17 9.05am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

.......Only ever worked with huge budgets.

Was thinking that myself and maybe we are thinking way above our station. Silva is more realistic.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 May 17 9.05am

Originally posted by Willo

I have been speaking to a couple of Palace supporters tonight and they were BOTH totally against Silva joining, in fact they asked me to pass their feelings on to Parish !

One of them didn't have an alternative in mind, the other one was pro-Hodgson.

The fact you've said a Palace fan was pro Hodgson emphasises even more that you are a troll and a Brighton one incidentally.

The other one didn't have one in mind because he was stroking his copy of the Argus and some deluded Brighton love in cr&p whilst the of you laugh how clever they think you are whilst you waste everyday of your life unsuccessfully trying to send a whole fanbase off in the wrong direction.

Haven't you got anything else to do other than google or wiki search the thread topic, paste their career details and troll?

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 May 17 9.10am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by bubble wrap

Was thinking that myself and maybe we are thinking way above our station. Silva is more realistic.

Only very limited PL experience.
Only won things with Olympiakos (No real competitors in Greece) and Sporting (Only 1 of 3 teams that really win anything in Portugal).
And I wouldn't say that the leagues in Greece and Portugal are exactly competitive.
We could be in a real relegation battle yet again and if we go down we need someone to bring us back up again - can you see Silva doing this ?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 May 17 9.13am

Originally posted by Andy_G

To be fair Hull were dead in the water and he gave them a chance. With better players and a decent transfer budget I think he could be a good appointment. Of course any manager comes with risk but we have to get someone.

Give up. Dan89 sees everything in black and white and if you didn't survive, you're sh1t. If that was the case the same 16 or 17 managers would barely ever change. We'd also not have playing for us:

Ward, Dann, MacArthur, PVA. There's more I can't be bothered to think of.

In fact why sign any of the players we e signed apart from Cabaye and Benteke? They're all failures and beneath us.

 


COYP

chateauferret Flag 25 May 17 9.15am

Didn't have an alternative in mind = no f***ing clue
Pro-Hodgson = no f***ing clue

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 May 17 9.16am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

Originally posted by bubble wrap

Was thinking that myself and maybe we are thinking way above our station. Silva is more realistic.

The Silva Southampton are interested in yet some on here think because he only just took an appalling hull squad down he's no good.

Good job Parish always gets a manager to perform for a decent length of time before manager wants to leave (or Pardew).

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 25 May 17 9.18am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The fact you've said a Palace fan was pro Hodgson emphasises even more that you are a troll and a Brighton one incidentally.

The other one didn't have one in mind because he was stroking his copy of the Argus and some deluded Brighton love in cr&p whilst the of you laugh how clever they think you are whilst you waste everyday of your life unsuccessfully trying to send a whole fanbase off in the wrong direction.

Haven't you got anything else to do other than google or wiki search the thread topic, paste their career details and troll?

I mistakenly believed that this was a serious thread, NOT one where fellow supporters engage in rhetorical grandstanding and total and unadulterated hogwash to boot.I refuse to "Swim" around at the shallow end of the debate.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 25 May 17 9.18am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Marco Silva ??? ~ You are joking right ???' by Guntrisoft

Why are you never capable of just contributing to an existing thread on the exact same topic?

 

Page 8 of 30 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic