You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Window Summing Up


Page 8 of 18 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
The Dolphin Flag 01 Feb 18 6.16am

There were only 44 deals done in January - including pre-arranged ones - for players coming in to Premier League Clubs.
Three of those were ours.
A few of them were the big bucks ones where teams like us are not even at the table - they don't count in our world.
Many of them are for players we have never heard of - yes - we have two of them I know.
Many were for players this forum would not have wanted - Sturridge is an example.
A few also for lower league players going to big clubs for the future.
So - it is not all bad and not every other team has done well whilst we have done nothing.
January is a feeding frenzy and whilst I think we still have a lot to learn we are okay.
Our injuries have meant that we had a sudden need for more players and they don't just appear when you click your fingers.
We might have been working a on a few deals for a while only to find we have a depleted squad at the last minute and I think we have done okay considering.
I really don't think that SP or DF just muck about not doing anything and I don't think they deserve the level of vitriol some people on here are throwing at them!

Edited by The Dolphin (01 Feb 2018 6.29am)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 01 Feb 18 6.16am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

People are entitled to moan but honestly I don't think most of you have things in proportion.

The January window is not a window for good deals.....it isn't a window where you should be spending massive money....clubs that do this ultimately might hit lucky occasionally but in the long run it's going to bite them.....unless you overspend clubs aren't going to release good players mid season.

We are not in a desperate position but we did need another striker to go along with the midfielder and defender we already added.

Edited by Stirlingsays (01 Feb 2018 6.17am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

The Dolphin Flag 01 Feb 18 6.29am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

As i posted in another topic just now

There were only 44 deals done in January - including pre-arranged ones - for players coming in to Premier League Clubs.
Three of those were ours.
A few of them were the big bucks ones where teams like us are not even at the table - they don't count in our world.
Many of them are for players we have never heard of - yes - we have two of them I know.
Many were for players this forum would not have wanted - Sturridge is an example.
A few also for lower league players going to big clubs for the future.
So - it is not all bad and not every other team has done well whilst we have done nothing.
January is a feeding frenzy and whilst I think we still have a lot to learn we are okay.
Our injuries have meant that we had a sudden need for more players and they don't just appear when you click your fingers.
We might have been working a on a few deals for a while only to find we have a depleted squad at the last minute and I think we have done okay considering.
I really don't think that SP or DF just muck about not doing anything and I don't think they deserve the level of vitriol some people on here are throwing at them!

 

Harry Beever Flag Newbury 01 Feb 18 6.52am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by grumpymort

I think the two we purchased are worth it they most very little so if they do not work out nothing really has been lost.

the problem is that is it no other players when our manager clearly stated he needed 6 and we all know from summer we needed a lot of players yet we keep messing about trying to save few mil here or their.

if owners of are club can't front funds required for this league then get out and sell the club SP always states he loves this club and wants best for it well how is with holding funds whats best.

people was saying in summer we needed 8+ players and we got what 2-3 excluding loans and look how small and poor the squad was.

The transfer for this Lille guy was a mess Lille needed the money now they are in trouble yet we are trying to do deals with delayed payments we could of just offered how much they wanted 17m weeks ago and had him.

I want to hear SP take on this whole thing I wonder if he will do another scripted holmsdale radio show

Other thing that annoys me is i heard they have spend over 30m regarding all this planning and so on for new stand so far

looks like Cabaye will have new deal to which really he doesn't deserve one the money he is on which is high we could get much better player in he is past it now even when AP had him come here you could see his legs was going he was looked after by AP

One positive we have spend very little so come summer we should have plenty of funds no excuses this time that we spent big in Jan

Edited by grumpymort (01 Feb 2018 5.57am)

Edited by grumpymort (01 Feb 2018 6.05am)

Remember Parish at the close of the last window when we missed out on Niasse saying that meant the good news was there would be lot more to spend in January...

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 01 Feb 18 6.53am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

There were only 44 deals done in January - including pre-arranged ones - for players coming in to Premier League Clubs.
Three of those were ours.
A few of them were the big bucks ones where teams like us are not even at the table - they don't count in our world.
Many of them are for players we have never heard of - yes - we have two of them I know.
Many were for players this forum would not have wanted - Sturridge is an example.
A few also for lower league players going to big clubs for the future.
So - it is not all bad and not every other team has done well whilst we have done nothing.
January is a feeding frenzy and whilst I think we still have a lot to learn we are okay.
Our injuries have meant that we had a sudden need for more players and they don't just appear when you click your fingers.
We might have been working a on a few deals for a while only to find we have a depleted squad at the last minute and I think we have done okay considering.
I really don't think that SP or DF just muck about not doing anything and I don't think they deserve the level of vitriol some people on here are throwing at them!

Edited by The Dolphin (01 Feb 2018 6.29am)

This 100%

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 01 Feb 18 6.57am

I know enough about the football transfer business to know that I know nothing. From where I am sitting, it seems completely unregulated and full of sharks, although I can’t even be sure of that. The one thing I do know is that I am glad that the window is finished, and that it won’t be coming back next season.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 01 Feb 18 6.58am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Harry Beever

Remember Parish at the close of the last window when we missed out on Niasse saying that meant the good news was there would be lot more to spend in January...

I've lost all belief in anything that Parish says from now. It started to look likely we wouldn't get a decent CF, GK plus some much needed squad players in. I don't know why, it's been obvious what we've needed for quite literally years, but would have settled for one marquee signing.

Parish doesn't know anything about football and is full of s***!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

laddo Flag london 01 Feb 18 7.05am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by The Dolphin

As i posted in another topic just now

There were only 44 deals done in January - including pre-arranged ones - for players coming in to Premier League Clubs.
Three of those were ours.
A few of them were the big bucks ones where teams like us are not even at the table - they don't count in our world.
Many of them are for players we have never heard of - yes - we have two of them I know.
Many were for players this forum would not have wanted - Sturridge is an example.
A few also for lower league players going to big clubs for the future.
So - it is not all bad and not every other team has done well whilst we have done nothing.
January is a feeding frenzy and whilst I think we still have a lot to learn we are okay.
Our injuries have meant that we had a sudden need for more players and they don't just appear when you click your fingers.
We might have been working a on a few deals for a while only to find we have a depleted squad at the last minute and I think we have done okay considering.
I really don't think that SP or DF just muck about not doing anything and I don't think they deserve the level of vitriol some people on here are throwing at them!

Post of the year!

The fact is none of us know what goes on behind the scenes. Sadlly, a number of fans get seduced by sky making what is a pretty boring day drama and then go mental when things don't happen. We're all guilty in a way. Yesterday I was gutted we didn't spend 18m on a player I know nothing about in a position of the pitch where we're strongest. I allowed sky to make me an irrational buffoon.

Has it been our best window? Nope, injuries are making it harder to stomach. However, to blame parish and DF is harsh when none of us really know the intricacies behind transfers.

 


laddo

"People say, live fast, die young. I say live fast, die old. That's me, the non-conformist".
David Brent.

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 01 Feb 18 7.11am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by laddo

Post of the year!

The fact is none of us know what goes on behind the scenes. Sadlly, a number of fans get seduced by sky making what is a pretty boring day drama and then go mental when things don't happen. We're all guilty in a way. Yesterday I was gutted we didn't spend 18m on a player I know nothing about in a position of the pitch where we're strongest. I allowed sky to make me an irrational buffoon.

Has it been our best window? Nope, injuries are making it harder to stomach. However, to blame parish and DF is harsh when none of us really know the intricacies behind transfers.

Nice post. I have just tried to say a similar thing on another thread. I am just glad it is over.

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 01 Feb 18 7.12am

Originally posted by dp

I know enough about the football transfer business to know that I know nothing. From where I am sitting, it seems completely unregulated and full of sharks, although I can’t even be sure of that. The one thing I do know is that I am glad that the window is finished, and that it won’t be coming back next season.


^This, in spades.

 


Spirit of 1974

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 01 Feb 18 7.14am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

OK looks like people are going to be up in arms blaming Parrish for this transfer window.

It has been apparent, for anyone who has been following the Amadou saga, that this is NOT Parrish's fault.

For those who are coming on and just saying `just give them more money` and `get your cheque book out` Firstly it is nowhere near that simple. We are restricted by FFP as to what we can spend and so the fee was always on the understanding of a fee for a loan until the end of the season and then a fixed payment, which could be made once we had received more incoming funds in the form of finishing position prize money.

It was Lille who allowed negotiations to go on and then had an 11th hour change of mind as they could not recall one of their players on loan.

Although we always want a signing to come into the club I think it is worth remembering that at the beginning of January neither us as fans nor the club felt a new Defensive Midfielder was the highest priority. The club felt Amadou was a good `extra` to the window.

Of course we all want big signings, its exciting for us but not always what is best for the club. Last season we did big business in the January window which did work well for us but this put a strain on our finances in the summer signings and there is a natural legacy of this. We have spent the season concerned with the lack of strength in squad depth and we have come out of the transfer window in a better position than when we went into it. The much demanded need for a striker has been sorted with a young lad with potential. New over and CB and Midfield. The question of GK is still unanswered but I think (As I have said repeatedly) that Guiata is a done deal for the end of the season and personally I think us spending 7-8 mill (Euros) just to bring him in before the summer would be bad business. Yes he might keep us up with some great performances but he is just as likely to come and not be able to adapt or settle.

 

The Dolphin Flag 01 Feb 18 7.21am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

I suspect that most other fans forums for our direct opponents are also all bemoaning the window.
None of them can really say hand on heart that the players they have got in will do the business for them.
Our new boys might be brilliant - who had heard of Luca before he came to us - what a player we have now!
Swansea's purchases look good on paper but will they be good when push come to shove.
We still have a fit (for now)
Zaha, Sakho, Cabaye,Luca, Benteke and Townsend to name but a few.
There are 6 players who every one of the teams around us would probably want - they are already ours!
Our injuries are to Punch - none of us wanted him anymore really
Dann - a loss but probably bench now
Schlupp - a proper loss in my opinion
Wickham - hasn't played for over a year
B Sako - a loss
RLC - a loss
Three players out who REALLY matter but we have three new ones in.
It is not the problem we think it is in my opinion and I agree with Laddo - SSN and others in the media hype it all up and we start to buy in to it.
44 deals remember - that's all - for the whole of January and Sanchez and Mikatarian count as two!
We are fine!

 

Harry Beever Flag Newbury 01 Feb 18 7.22am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by laddo

Post of the year!

The fact is none of us know what goes on behind the scenes. Sadlly, a number of fans get seduced by sky making what is a pretty boring day drama and then go mental when things don't happen. We're all guilty in a way. Yesterday I was gutted we didn't spend 18m on a player I know nothing about in a position of the pitch where we're strongest. I allowed sky to make me an irrational buffoon.

Has it been our best window? Nope, injuries are making it harder to stomach. However, to blame parish and DF is harsh when none of us really know the intricacies behind transfers.


Strongest area of the pitch when fully fit squad but we’ve lost Puncheon for the season and probably Loftus Cheek by the sounds of things. Cabaye and MacArthur are a little injury prone and we have only bought Rakip in. I guess Riedewald can play there and hopefully Nya Kirby is developing very very quickly. Don’t think it’s the disaster that some are making out but we should have paid above the odds earlier for another goalkeeper or bought a promising youngster for less who could have been back until Hennessey’s contract expires at the end of the season. There must have been someone available. If we’re still in the premiership we can upgrade then. SP shrewd in employing Freedman who can shoulder responsibility if signings don’t work out, which hopefully they will.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 01 Feb 18 7.27am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Only 7 purchases were made by Premiership clubs on deadline day, just goes to show how difficult it it is to get deals completed.
With all the hype the media whip up about it, supporters expectations are are raised.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 01 Feb 18 7.30am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

I am delighted that we have bought two with potential, rather than spunk money on players at the end of their careers. This window has been slow and clubs don’t like doing deals in January.

We should have enough to get us out of trouble, injuries permitting, and then add in the summer.

Be grateful for what we have. It wasn’t so long ago that we were signing Andy Dorman and Owen Garvan.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Harry Beever Flag Newbury 01 Feb 18 7.32am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Mwncisee

OK looks like people are going to be up in arms blaming Parrish for this transfer window.

It has been apparent, for anyone who has been following the Amadou saga, that this is NOT Parrish's fault.

For those who are coming on and just saying `just give them more money` and `get your cheque book out` Firstly it is nowhere near that simple. We are restricted by FFP as to what we can spend and so the fee was always on the understanding of a fee for a loan until the end of the season and then a fixed payment, which could be made once we had received more incoming funds in the form of finishing position prize money.

It was Lille who allowed negotiations to go on and then had an 11th hour change of mind as they could not recall one of their players on loan.

Although we always want a signing to come into the club I think it is worth remembering that at the beginning of January neither us as fans nor the club felt a new Defensive Midfielder was the highest priority. The club felt Amadou was a good `extra` to the window.

Of course we all want big signings, its exciting for us but not always what is best for the club. Last season we did big business in the January window which did work well for us but this put a strain on our finances in the summer signings and there is a natural legacy of this. We have spent the season concerned with the lack of strength in squad depth and we have come out of the transfer window in a better position than when we went into it. The much demanded need for a striker has been sorted with a young lad with potential. New over and CB and Midfield. The question of GK is still unanswered but I think (As I have said repeatedly) that Guiata is a done deal for the end of the season and personally I think us spending 7-8 mill (Euros) just to bring him in before the summer would be bad business. Yes he might keep us up with some great performances but he is just as likely to come and not be able to adapt or settle.


The failure of the Amadou deal was clearly not Parish’s fault but it may not have been Lille’s either. Maybe he travelled to London in his own steam in the hope that he could force something through and was never going to be allowed. Maybe the club that Lille’s player was on loan to have led Lille on into thinking a recall was an option if they could find a better player? Maybe Amadou’s agent playing us off against West Ham complicated things. All speculation, we know nothing so shouldn’t get overly excited. The only thing I would say is if Roy thought it was important to strengthen that position we should have had plans B’s C’s and D’s or tied something down earlier:

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 01 Feb 18 7.33am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

This particular supporter's hopes were raised by what the manager said our minimum requirements were

Yes. That is certainly fair. Although managers use the media to send messages to the owners too.

 

beak Flag croydon 01 Feb 18 7.56am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

One burning question remains are these three enough to keep us In the Premiership?

 

chateauferret Flag 01 Feb 18 8.09am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Maybe not entirely our fault that the Amadou deal was not completed, but as pointed out this isn't our problem area, is it? It's our lack of attacking options that's the problem and we've brought in one untried player there but nothing that will make Benteke bother his arse for the rest of the season. Maybe Soerloth is more PL-ready than I expect. Hope so.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 01 Feb 18 8.19am

Originally posted by dp

I know enough about the football transfer business to know that I know nothing. From where I am sitting, it seems completely unregulated and full of sharks, although I can’t even be sure of that. The one thing I do know is that I am glad that the window is finished, and that it won’t be coming back next season.

Correct. Following FIFA's decision to deregulate agents the transfer world has gone bats*** crazy. There was an interesting article I read a couple of weeks ago that explained how mental things were & that FIFA were reviewing the situation in conjunction with FFP2. Problem here is they seem to be looking at it from the angle of limiting transfer fees & costs in relation to turnover which can only make life even more difficult for smaller clubs.

Heard a comment yesterday from a journo that was along the lines of situations like Guaita & Mahrez were clubs fighting back against agents & big money to try & take some control away from players & their 'representatives'.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Page 8 of 18 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up