You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we in financial trouble
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are we in financial trouble


Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Feb 19 5.39pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Decent post. I'd not really factored in instalment payments, which as you've pointed out create a financial hangover especially when you've shelled out 60m on two players relatively recently. Explains why the new main stand is so badly needed to increase revenue and leave us with a little more liquidity.

Also explains neatly why we aren't 'progressing' in the minds of some unrealistic supporters. If you want to be challenging for top 5, from the start point we had (dilapidated stadium, rented training ground, poor finances) then I think realistically you're looking at a 10-15 year timeframe.

Don't forget that we are also going to be ploughing money into expanding and upgrading the training facilities as well as building a new main stand, all while constantly upgrading and maintaining the current infrastructure the club owns, paying players wages and, if there's some left shelling out a few million on new players and their ever increasing weekly pay packets. Not to mention FFP. So when someone says we're treading water, it might look like that to you but I think the reality is somewhat different.

I think the key here is to do our best at building the club sustainably and slowly, investing in all areas, rather than going all in to the transfer market every year. This appears to be the approach that has been taken.

Southampton are a great example of this – and despite all of it, are currently going through a low period. It happens to every team, the key is making sure you are on a strong enough footing in all areas to give yourself the best chance of weathering whatever gets thrown at you.

QPR are the bad example. Which would you rather be?

Pardon? Challenging for top 5? What do you have in your tea?

Is this what you or anyone else expects or think we’re doing or ever intend to do?

 


COYP

Aray Flag South London 05 Feb 19 10.37pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Pardon? Challenging for top 5? What do you have in your tea?

Is this what you or anyone else expects or think we’re doing or ever intend to do?

I reckon you can forgive the OP's poor use of words in an otherwise sensible post. No one thinks we can be a Champions League hunting club but we could be eyeing a regular top half position where we dont ever come into the relegation dog fight. I think that is what he means by the club making progress and what infrastructure we require to achieve that.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Feb 19 6.16am

Originally posted by silvertop

The transfer fees may well have been paid in full by factoring agents. If so, it would be those agents who are the creditor and not Liverpool.

I've never heard of factoring agents funding transfer fees and it's a business that I know a bit about

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 06 Feb 19 6.49am

Rudi who's lining up to tell us we're in financial trouble? What do you mean?

Also, the tone of your opening comment, written as it is in the past tense, suggests that you think we might be. I can't quite tell. I appreciate you think we are constrained financially but that's a world away from financial trouble.

I agree with the rest of your post but would observe that Meyer, Guaita and Batshuayi appear to be astute decisions, although I do wonder what we pay them. I guess you alluded to that.


 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 06 Feb 19 7.44am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Don’t 3 year FFP cycles begin and end every year for every club?

Yes, but I read somewhere that the actual parameters are reviewed every three years too. Last review was 2016.

I'll see if I can find it....

[Link]

Edited by Nobbybm (06 Feb 2019 7.46am)

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 06 Feb 19 7.48am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I've never heard of factoring agents funding transfer fees and it's a business that I know a bit about

I seem to recall there was a loan from Barclays against 'guaranteed future income' a while back?

Yep. May 17 in the name of CPFC Ltd - subsequently satisfied.

Edited by Nobbybm (06 Feb 2019 8.05am)

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

silvertop Flag Portishead 06 Feb 19 9.24am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I've never heard of factoring agents funding transfer fees and it's a business that I know a bit about

I have a client (cant name) who used to own a professional football club. That's how he bought all his players.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 06 Feb 19 9.49am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I've never heard of factoring agents funding transfer fees and it's a business that I know a bit about

[Link]

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 06 Feb 19 9.53am

OK that didn't work - article about Riyad Mahrez, in a £60m transfer of the player from Leicester City to Manchester City. Australian investment bank Macquarie, provided the factoring.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 06 Feb 19 9.58am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Pardon? Challenging for top 5? What do you have in your tea?

Is this what you or anyone else expects or think we’re doing or ever intend to do?

To explain, in 10 years, if we're still in the Prem and have a new main stand, new training facilities and no doubt significantly better players, then I think it would be reasonable to expect to be in a situation where we could be expecting to occasionally break into the top 5/6 bracket, yes. Unlikely to be consistently so, but I think 10 years is fair to get to a level of say, Everton, who have broken the top 6 on occasion and are usually in and around there.

What I didn't mean is challenging for UCL places. Frankly, if Burnley with a massively overachieving team can qualify for the EL then I can't see why us sniffing around the top 6 in 10 years time is so hard to grasp.

The reason for my initial post was, to your point, down to the fact that a lot of people seem to think we should be inside the top 10 regularly. I disagree, as per my post. We had, and still have, a lot of legacy issues to deal with but we're progressing in a responsible way.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Feb 19 10.16am

Originally posted by chris123

OK that didn't work - article about Riyad Mahrez, in a £60m transfer of the player from Leicester City to Manchester City. Australian investment bank Macquarie, provided the factoring.

Found it - thanks

It isn't really factoring but that seems to be a useful term tagged on to the transaction. The article mentions that MacQuarrie funded the transaction via a secured lending facility which is a more accurate way of describing it.

In any case it's all fairly academic as if we buy a player from another club we owe the club, a bank or Uncle Tom Cobley for him and it will be a creditor in our accounts

As a matter of interest in any company commercial finance in one way or another will be available as long as the bankers have sufficient security to hang their hats on. In these cases it's a contract to pay transfer fees on a specific date and in our case it was short term funding secured against a contract with Sky to receive broadcast fees

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 06 Feb 19 10.31am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Found it - thanks

It isn't really factoring but that seems to be a useful term tagged on to the transaction. The article mentions that MacQuarrie funded the transaction via a secured lending facility which is a more accurate way of describing it.

In any case it's all fairly academic as if we buy a player from another club we owe the club, a bank or Uncle Tom Cobley for him and it will be a creditor in our accounts

As a matter of interest in any company commercial finance in one way or another will be available as long as the bankers have sufficient security to hang their hats on. In these cases it's a contract to pay transfer fees on a specific date and in our case it was short term funding secured against a contract with Sky to receive broadcast fees

Well the creditor has early access to liquidity and the bank takes some credit risk - though not much in Man City's case.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Feb 19 3.57pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

To explain, in 10 years, if we're still in the Prem and have a new main stand, new training facilities and no doubt significantly better players, then I think it would be reasonable to expect to be in a situation where we could be expecting to occasionally break into the top 5/6 bracket, yes. Unlikely to be consistently so, but I think 10 years is fair to get to a level of say, Everton, who have broken the top 6 on occasion and are usually in and around there.

What I didn't mean is challenging for UCL places. Frankly, if Burnley with a massively overachieving team can qualify for the EL then I can't see why us sniffing around the top 6 in 10 years time is so hard to grasp.

The reason for my initial post was, to your point, down to the fact that a lot of people seem to think we should be inside the top 10 regularly. I disagree, as per my post. We had, and still have, a lot of legacy issues to deal with but we're progressing in a responsible way.

Where you think we should be after 10 years in the Premier, is exactly what about another 20 clubs want. Many are in a far better position of infrastructure than us, as we have suffered from severe mis management from previous Owners.
It’s not easy to achieve, as many have found out. Why do you think it’s not difficult to be hovering around the top 6, many clubs have thrown millions at trying, but get nowhere, Everton is a good example.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Feb 19 4.30pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

Rudi who's lining up to tell us we're in financial trouble? What do you mean?

Also, the tone of your opening comment, written as it is in the past tense, suggests that you think we might be. I can't quite tell. I appreciate you think we are constrained financially but that's a world away from financial trouble.

I agree with the rest of your post but would observe that Meyer, Guaita and Batshuayi appear to be astute decisions, although I do wonder what we pay them. I guess you alluded to that.


I meant Brighton ‘fans’ or the press couldn’t wait to report we’re in financial trouble. I’ve always thought we wouldn’t be. That’s never been my concern. Hamstringing ourselves in future windows or only having 11-13 good enough because we’ve spent £30 mil and then wages of £130k per week has been, due to our almost non existent scouting.

Meyer was free but he hardly fits Roy’s prerequisite list. He’s an example. A player who’s ‘available’ rather than we’ve tempted the player and selling club to part with a player, or found an up and coming talent.

Batsman leaves in 3 months.

Vicente, good. Kouyate too, so there are signs of succeeding in transfers, but it’s got to be better, especially with activity we’ll have coming up with either or Roy, Wilf, Bissaka or Sakho leaving or just being able to spend a bit more.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Feb 19 4.37pm

Originally posted by Painter

Where you think we should be after 10 years in the Premier, is exactly what about another 20 clubs want. Many are in a far better position of infrastructure than us, as we have suffered from severe mis management from previous Owners.
It’s not easy to achieve, as many have found out. Why do you think it’s not difficult to be hovering around the top 6, many clubs have thrown millions at trying, but get nowhere, Everton is a good example.

I know. I don’t ‘expect to occasionally break into the top 5/6’ at all. Just being mid table and flirting with 7th or 8th maybe now and then will do, or not at all. And there’s a big difference between 5-6th and 7th-8th. Hundred million or 2 or 3 or more. Usually clubs with talented players tend to lose them and struggle with cheeky asking fees for replacements and/or players and attitudes that don’t fit.

 


COYP

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 06 Feb 19 4.46pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I meant Brighton ‘fans’ or the press couldn’t wait to report we’re in financial trouble. I’ve always thought we wouldn’t be. That’s never been my concern. Hamstringing ourselves in future windows or only having 11-13 good enough because we’ve spent £30 mil and then wages of £130k per week has been, due to our almost non existent scouting.

Meyer was free but he hardly fits Roy’s prerequisite list. He’s an example. A player who’s ‘available’ rather than we’ve tempted the player and selling club to part with a player, or found an up and coming talent.

Batsman leaves in 3 months.

Vicente, good. Kouyate too, so there are signs of succeeding in transfers, but it’s got to be better, especially with activity we’ll have coming up with either or Roy, Wilf, Bissaka or Sakho leaving or just being able to spend a bit more.

I think we needed a new Cabaye and Meyer looked great for it. Small, mobile, good passer, vision. Just been an average start for him, which is fairly common.

Batshuayi works if he massively cuts the relegation risk and lifts us a few places. I think he will/might.

But I do completely agree with your sentiments.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Feb 19 4.52pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I think we needed a new Cabaye and Meyer looked great for it. Small, mobile, good passer, vision. Just been an average start for him, which is fairly common.

Batshuayi works if he massively cuts the relegation risk and lifts us a few places. I think he will/might.

But I do completely agree with your sentiments.

I agree with you, and I like Meyer. I just don’t think Roy does or will. Maybe another manager will.

Jedinak and Murray took time but fitted, and I could see why Freedman bought them. The jigsaw just wasn’t ready and Jedinak was a skinny and Inaccurate passer. But Meyer will always be small. It’s whether that’s ok for the manager. Doesn’t look that way with Roy.

 


COYP

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 06 Feb 19 4.53pm

Originally posted by Painter

Where you think we should be after 10 years in the Premier, is exactly what about another 20 clubs want. Many are in a far better position of infrastructure than us, as we have suffered from severe mis management from previous Owners.
It’s not easy to achieve, as many have found out. Why do you think it’s not difficult to be hovering around the top 6, many clubs have thrown millions at trying, but get nowhere, Everton is a good example.

We are five years in. I said 10 from now, so 2029. So 15 years total from the point of promotion.

I did not say it was easy, or that it would not be difficult. What I said is that it would be reasonable to expect us to be in and around the top 5/6 teams after 15 years in the premier league, with the plans we have and the sustainable approach to progression that has been put in place, starting with buying our stadium back and securing an effective freehold on the training ground land.

Every club wants to be better each season, but not every club has the potential that we do. Look at Bournemouth, or Burnley for example.

The infrastructure point has already been covered in my post, but I'll repeat it again if I have to... As I already stated, our infrastructure now is not great but improving as a result of legacy issues but In 10 years time providing we stay in the PL we will have a new main stand and significantly updated training and academy facilities, plus a whole host of other improvements no doubt that will make us far more attractive to players, increase our cashflow and enhance our ability to develop and retain top half talent.

Everton is indeed a good example of what I was saying. They've consistently been in and around the top 6 over the last few years.

17/18 – 8th
16/17 – 7th
15/16 – 11th
14/15 – 11th
13/14 – 5th
12/13 – 6th
11/12 – 7th
10/11 – 7th

I don't think this is an unreasonable expectation (note, not an easy one) to be aiming for in ten years time (2029) providing we continue sustainably and the board deliver on infrastructure investments.

With the progress made and the improvements that are coming I certainly don't expect us to be consistently finishing in the bottom half in 10 years time. Do you?

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Feb 19 4.57pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig


I think we needed a new Cabaye and Meyer looked great for it. Small, mobile, good passer, vision. Just been an average start for him, which is fairly common.

Who knows what Meyer could do if he was given a run of games

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 06 Feb 19 5.57pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

We are five years in. I said 10 from now, so 2029. So 15 years total from the point of promotion.

I did not say it was easy, or that it would not be difficult. What I said is that it would be reasonable to expect us to be in and around the top 5/6 teams after 15 years in the premier league, with the plans we have and the sustainable approach to progression that has been put in place, starting with buying our stadium back and securing an effective freehold on the training ground land.

Every club wants to be better each season, but not every club has the potential that we do. Look at Bournemouth, or Burnley for example.

The infrastructure point has already been covered in my post, but I'll repeat it again if I have to... As I already stated, our infrastructure now is not great but improving as a result of legacy issues but In 10 years time providing we stay in the PL we will have a new main stand and significantly updated training and academy facilities, plus a whole host of other improvements no doubt that will make us far more attractive to players, increase our cashflow and enhance our ability to develop and retain top half talent.

Everton is indeed a good example of what I was saying. They've consistently been in and around the top 6 over the last few years.

17/18 – 8th
16/17 – 7th
15/16 – 11th
14/15 – 11th
13/14 – 5th
12/13 – 6th
11/12 – 7th
10/11 – 7th

I don't think this is an unreasonable expectation (note, not an easy one) to be aiming for in ten years time (2029) providing we continue sustainably and the board deliver on infrastructure investments.

With the progress made and the improvements that are coming I certainly don't expect us to be consistently finishing in the bottom half in 10 years time. Do you?

Blimey. Everton have been here over a century. Still can’t get into the top 5.

Villa. Failed. Spent too much trying.

Leeds. Failed. Spent too much trying.

Your expectations are huge, based on having a new stand and 35,000 ground. Won’t everyo else? Or much more?

7th is an achievement. Being never in danger of relegation also. Only being taken over by someone willing to make the whole ground new and pump loads of money in will get people expecting 5th at times.

 


COYP

Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are we in financial trouble