You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James McCarthy (SIGNED) (LOCKED)


Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Ecopalace Flag Wickham 06 Aug 19 10.46pm

Originally posted by Dhutch23

I dont see the point of this transfer. 8 million on a player who will not improve the team, will be the 5th choice cm thats even before the potential move of camarassa. We need a RB, winger/striker preferably younger, as the ageing squad is a worry. We must have money if we are prepared to spend 8 million on a player who has played a handful of games in the last few years.

Agree, terrible signing IMO. What a waste of money. Why are we not buying a right back and striker. Another aging sicknote on our books.

 

Bholl85 Flag Guildford 06 Aug 19 10.47pm

Whilst I agree this is hugely underwhelming it seems to me that the general consensus on this site is that we have a competitive starting 11 but no depth to the squad. I agree with this sentiment.
However, if a player like McCarthy has been told by Everton that he has NO future there and if Hodgson likes him enough to want him here then is it such a bad move for both parties? McCarthy has more chance of game time with us than with Everton; whether we like to admit it or not Everton are a club that are moving forward light years faster than us with their investment and ownership. We get an experienced Premier League player for a relatively low fee that will presumably offer an option in midfield rather than take up a starting position and he offers cover for injuries which we seem to rack up at an alarming rate. Yes he's not exciting, no he's not young, yes he's had injuries but could he do a job? Probably.
Personally I would like to see Luke Dreher get more of an opportunity but realistically Roy isn't the manager for that... And, he's also had bad injuries but that seems to be forgotten because he's "one of our own"!!

 

new_in_Wait Flag Lewisham 06 Aug 19 10.47pm

Originally posted by Dhutch23

I dont see the point of this transfer. 8 million on a player who will not improve the team, will be the 5th choice cm thats even before the potential move of camarassa. We need a RB, winger/striker preferably younger, as the ageing squad is a worry. We must have money if we are prepared to spend 8 million on a player who has played a handful of games in the last few years.

So we will have McArthur, McCarthy, Luka, Meyer, and Kouyate who can play in central mid (technically, Schlupp and Riedewald can play there too). We usually play with three. If Camarasa comes in too, we will have six first-team central mids. This spells trouble to me for several reasons. We are either planning for life post-Luka which is bad or Meyer will be pushed on the wing for good, which is bad.

I have nothing against bulking up in central mid but do not do so with a very injury-prone player who has hardly played in the past 20 months.

 

davehuggins Flag 06 Aug 19 10.52pm

It's Wilf gone, only my opinion. If he goes will have lots of different options and sure Luka is going as well. Very depressing and hope I am completely wrong.

 

mattteo Flag 06 Aug 19 10.52pm

Originally posted by Bholl85

Whilst I agree this is hugely underwhelming it seems to me that the general consensus on this site is that we have a competitive starting 11 but no depth to the squad. I agree with this sentiment.
However, if a player like McCarthy has been told by Everton that he has NO future there and if Hodgson likes him enough to want him here then is it such a bad move for both parties?

You're saying it as if he were a free player, which would have made it a decent move.

But no. There were 8 million paid for this guy who hasn't played 2 matches in a row since 2017!

Edited by mattteo (06 Aug 2019 10.54pm)

 

Master Coin Flag 06 Aug 19 10.55pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

It's Wilf gone, only my opinion. If he goes will have lots of different options and sure Luka is going as well. Very depressing and hope I am completely wrong.

If Wilf is going you’d have thought this would be part of a swap deal rather than a separate transfer so Everton could use it as leverage. The fact this is a separate transfer suggests to me that we aren’t selling Zaha. I might be wrong though.

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 06 Aug 19 10.58pm

Meyer being pushed up front...

Andros Meyer Wilf

 

Ecopalace Flag Wickham 06 Aug 19 10.59pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Meyer being pushed up front...

Andros Meyer Wilf

Did you just make that up?

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 06 Aug 19 11.02pm

If he gets and stays fit it will be a good buy - he's always looked competent if unspectacular - I've always seen him as a box-to-box midfielder more than in a holding role, and he was very highly rated as youngster at Hamilton, you may laugh but the general expectation up there was he was definitely going to be playing at top class level and be an international when he was 16, but as matteo rightly points out his fitness is a big if

 

Bholl85 Flag Guildford 06 Aug 19 11.03pm

Nobody's ever free are they? Sometimes there's no upfront fee to the "selling" club but then often the player/agent wants a fee and the wages are more. Perhaps this deal involves more upfront and less in wages? Who knows?!!
Regardless, my point is that it's dull, unambitious, slightly concerning, very Palace-like but maybe, just maybe not all bad...

Originally posted by mattteo

You're saying it as if he were a free player, which would have made it a decent move.

But no. There were 8 million paid for this guy who hasn't played 2 matches in a row since 2017!

Edited by mattteo (06 Aug 2019 10.54pm)

 

Casual Flag Orpington 06 Aug 19 11.06pm

It’s a shame that we are giving 8 million for someone, and I hope that he gets/stays injured so that Meyer isn’t on the bench.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 06 Aug 19 11.11pm

Originally posted by Casual

It’s a shame that we are giving 8 million for someone, and I hope that he gets/stays injured so that Meyer isn’t on the bench.

Thee other Black Eagle is our new signing

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 06 Aug 19 11.11pm

Why why why why why? We have little money, we have other positions to fill, and we're spending millions on another player so old he has no resale value and so crocked he might not actually play 10 games for us, in the one position we're actually well-stocked!

I really hope we actually have some money and we're getting a good striker and right back, because if we're as skint as we think and we're spunking 75k a week on Cahill and then McCarthy, it'll be moronic financial mismanagement even by our standards.

 

pssguy Flag 06 Aug 19 11.14pm

In spite of the fact that he was on loan all of last year, Bolasie has played way more than twice as much as McCarthy for Everton over past three seasons

 

The Beger Flag Croydon 06 Aug 19 11.46pm

3m not 8m, apparently.

 


I am not a bot. No, seriously, I'm not.

Hudsoneagle Flag 07 Aug 19 12.23am

BBC quoting £2.5m as the fee on their website. Same amount we paid for Ayew isn’t it?

 

mileend Flag East London 07 Aug 19 1.06am

Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

BBC quoting £2.5m as the fee on their website. Same amount we paid for Ayew isn’t it?

the BBC upped it to £3 million

sounds more reasonable given the gamble on his long term fitness, one year left on his contract and no doubt still decent wages

[Link]

the £8m was total rubbish, the same as most stuff spouted on the media - and obviously not much of a balancing figure to the £20m shortfall on Wilf's asking price

 

Beanyboysmd Flag 07 Aug 19 1.08am

Not unhappy with this signing, he will probably be 3rd or 4th choice to begin with but once he is 100% he could be 2nd or 3rd. Everton fans loved him before his injury, he has a proper footballing heart, the one thing that's required for our midfield...

 

IMilburn Flag Chiang Rai / Rayong 07 Aug 19 6.11am

Not unhappy either, especially if the fee is £3 million.

I look at it from the perspective that we have lost midfielders Mutch, Williams and Puncheon from the squad as at last August, and are now replacing them with McCarthy and (hopefully) Camarasa. From that perspective, I believe the midfield is stronger. Add to that the constant chatter about Riedewald's departure, Luka's contract, McArthur's shortcomings, a lack of strength in depth and a lack of creativity in midfield - these two signings provide additional options and cover (provided of course that McCarthy can stay fit) and hopefully beef up our creativity with Camarasa.

Still need a RB, striker and possibly a LB too.

 

JohnB Flag 07 Aug 19 6.28am

If this is instead of Camarasa then it's a big disappointment and in an area of the team where we already have 3 very similar players.

3-4 years ago I would have been over the moon with this.

Someone has clearly told Dougie at some point in his life that it's important to have a strong spine of the team, so he's decided to just buy as many keepers, centre backs and central midfielders in the hope that when he's questioned he can just say 'oooch ayye, but we've gotta nae strong spine laddy!'

 

Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic