You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy, FFS pick Meyer!!!
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy, FFS pick Meyer!!!


Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
stayloa Flag Beckenham 02 Mar 19 7.51pm

Originally posted by daven

The player is class, he is not playing to his full potential but lets give Roy a bit of slack because we dont know what goes on behind the scenes.
He will get back to his best and then we will have a player worth double what we paid.
We are in a great position to be able to nurture him rather than destroy him.

What, £0?

 

Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 02 Mar 19 8.51pm

I did go to the game and was pleased to see him starting after all the cries for his inclusion from the the start by the forum. He had no impact of any significance on the game. When pressed and tackled he appeared to have no answer. In other games when he has come on as a substitute he has been very effective playing little triangles in forward positions. Today’s game did not enable him to do that. It might be he will be more effective against the top six type sides than the blood and thunder type teams. Not saying he is not a good player just think he is more limited in adapting to different styles of opposition than the likes of Jimmy Mac. Schlupp and Kouyate

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 03 Mar 19 12.18am

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

I did go to the game and was pleased to see him starting after all the cries for his inclusion from the the start by the forum. He had no impact of any significance on the game. When pressed and tackled he appeared to have no answer. In other games when he has come on as a substitute he has been very effective playing little triangles in forward positions. Today’s game did not enable him to do that. It might be he will be more effective against the top six type sides than the blood and thunder type teams. Not saying he is not a good player just think he is more limited in adapting to different styles of opposition than the likes of Jimmy Mac. Schlupp and Kouyate

Very good post. Sounds like you actually watch the games.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 03 Mar 19 12.34am

Originally posted by stayloa

What, £0?

£6-7mlion signing on fee

 

YT Flag Oxford 03 Mar 19 7.05am

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

I did go to the game and was pleased to see him starting after all the cries for his inclusion from the the start by the forum. He had no impact of any significance on the game. When pressed and tackled he appeared to have no answer. In other games when he has come on as a substitute he has been very effective playing little triangles in forward positions. Today’s game did not enable him to do that. It might be he will be more effective against the top six type sides than the blood and thunder type teams. Not saying he is not a good player just think he is more limited in adapting to different styles of opposition than the likes of Jimmy Mac. Schlupp and Kouyate

Like ManC and Spurs (cup) against whom he played and against whom we won. Or ManU (away) where we drew. He also came on after an hour against Arsenal and made a difference.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 03 Mar 19 8.00am

Originally posted by daven

The player is class, he is not playing to his full potential but lets give Roy a bit of slack because we dont know what goes on behind the scenes.
He will get back to his best and then we will have a player worth double what we paid.
We are in a great position to be able to nurture him rather than destroy him.

Double nothing equals, err nothing.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 03 Mar 19 8.22am

He was clearly frustrated himself yesterday and I'm sure I wasn't the only one who thought he was going to get himself sent off. In fact I think he was subbed within minutes of his booking which he should have no complaints over.
Burnley are a physical team and I was surprised that Jimmy Mac wasnt starting. Not his best game but he is a quality player that has brought much needed skills to the team. I agree that he is more suited to more floor based match. I mean how many times did the ball go from keeper to keeper yesterday??

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 03 Mar 19 9.36am

The German Jose Campana. He will have to make do with game time from the bench for the time being, which is where his best performances have come from. The opposition is irrelevant, he did not take his opportunity again yesterday. Very good player but still has a lot to do to prove he’s good enough.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 03 Mar 19 10.02am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

The German Jose Campana. He will have to make do with game time from the bench for the time being, which is where his best performances have come from. The opposition is irrelevant, he did not take his opportunity again yesterday. Very good player but still has a lot to do to prove he’s good enough.

Sorry, whilst I agree with most of what you say I can’t agree with that highlighted. He has played well against the technically gifted sides but not against the cloggers (well, at least not until they tire). His cameo against Utd was excellent and he changed the dynamic of the game with his quick incisive passing. I agree he is nowhere near the finished article however I do think he is capable of starting the game very much dependent upon the opposition, (horses for courses if you like). I admit to being surprised he started against Burnley however I think that was more to do with Roy giving McArthur a rest.

Some foreign players take a season to adapt to the pace of the PL. I think he is one of those players and I hope that next year we will see better things from him.

 

midlandspalace Flag kidderminster 03 Mar 19 10.33am

My son saw the game against United and sent me comments such as "Meyer makes us a different team, always on the half turn".

I saw the game yesterday and sent him comments such as "Meyer is too lightweight, not up to this type of game, booked and then substituted".

I think this gives some support to the comments above about the type of game/opposition he needs in order to thrive.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 03 Mar 19 11.24am

I think a really good player can do well against any type of opposition .


With Meyer we are either talking inconsistency , or if only performing against the top sides maybe an attitude problem . i.e. only raises his game when he is interested , if indeed he actually does.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Mar 19 11.28am

Originally posted by midlandspalace

My son saw the game against United and sent me comments such as "Meyer makes us a different team, always on the half turn".

I saw the game yesterday and sent him comments such as "Meyer is too lightweight, not up to this type of game, booked and then substituted".

I think this gives some support to the comments above about the type of game/opposition he needs in order to thrive.

It's up to him to compose and impose himself, not quite good enough yet.

 

Tequila Sunrise Flag 03 Mar 19 11.32am

Looked off the pace yesterday.
Good player but in the wrong league. I can see him going back to the Bundesliga at some stage.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 03 Mar 19 11.37am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

It's up to him to compose and impose himself, not quite good enough yet.

Isn't this why he came to Palace? (well, part that and part the famous singing fans. Yesssss!!!!) So that he could be nurtured up to the top level. Well judging by his performances (aka Man Utd) he is making very good progress, but yesterday showed he is not there yet. He couldn't hope for a better mentor than RH. The more the season goes on the more I am starting to realise that RH is head and shoulders above most posters on here. Just look what he has achieved with Schluppie, and many more starting to shine big time. We are fast becoming a very exciting outfit.

 

JohnB Flag 03 Mar 19 11.39am

Whilst yesterday's game wasn't the right one to stick him in from the off, it will help him in the long run when it comes to getting used to the speed and physicality of the league. He is still young and given his size it was always going to take a season for him to adjust and get used to the style here.

I hope we stick with him and I hope he gets to start a few on the spin to build up his confidence. I think he could be a big player for us next year especially if he can do the right work over the summer to couple his quality with a bit of strength and conditioning.

I see far too many people on here write signings off after a couple of games as if they expect players to come in set the world alight. People saying Batshauyi isn't the signing for us after a couple of starts despite scoring two goals already.

We need to give players time to settle, Klopp is a fantastic example of doing this with players like Fabinho barely featuring for the first half of the season and now flourishing as he was brought in at the right time. Same with Keita. These two players look fantastic but they are being introduced slowly and with patience. We need to give our players more time before getting on their back and doubting their abilities.

Edited by JohnB (03 Mar 2019 1.08pm)

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 03 Mar 19 12.08pm

I don’t think anyone is writing him off just yet. He has on occasions looked excellent. I agree he changed the game against united. He seems best suited to when the game opens up and he can drift into space playing in neat little triangles with incisive passing. Yesterday’s game did not suit. He so far has been most effective as annimpact sub. I hope in time that he can be more than that.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 03 Mar 19 1.16pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Isn't this why he came to Palace? (well, part that and part the famous singing fans. Yesssss!!!!) So that he could be nurtured up to the top level. Well judging by his performances (aka Man Utd) he is making very good progress, but yesterday showed he is not there yet. He couldn't hope for a better mentor than RH. The more the season goes on the more I am starting to realise that RH is head and shoulders above most posters on here. Just look what he has achieved with Schluppie, and many more starting to shine big time. We are fast becoming a very exciting outfit.

agree 100

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 03 Mar 19 1.25pm

He didn’t have a great game yesterday but writing him off would be unreasonable. He hasn’t had a chance to have a run in the side and get up to speed. Macca has been hit and miss this season as well, I do think Meyer needs more time and when he is up to speed will be a very useful player.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 03 Mar 19 2.26pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Isn't this why he came to Palace? (well, part that and part the famous singing fans. Yesssss!!!!) So that he could be nurtured up to the top level. Well judging by his performances (aka Man Utd) he is making very good progress, but yesterday showed he is not there yet. He couldn't hope for a better mentor than RH. The more the season goes on the more I am starting to realise that RH is head and shoulders above most posters on here. Just look what he has achieved with Schluppie, and many more starting to shine big time. We are fast becoming a very exciting outfit.

Yes you are completely right, Hodgson has been brilliant since the day he started with us and has been bringing the player out of Meyer in exactly the correct way, there is simply no one better out there to manage our level of players.
I'd give him another five years if he wanted it.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 03 Mar 19 5.03pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Yes you are completely right, Hodgson has been brilliant since the day he started with us and has been bringing the player out of Meyer in exactly the correct way, there is simply no one better out there to manage our level of players.
I'd give him another five years if he wanted it.

if he wants it and God wants it! Two more years then kick him upstairs and let him run the place from top to bottom

 

Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy, FFS pick Meyer!!!