You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > FA Cup next round
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

FA Cup next round


Page 8 of 10 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Midlands Eagle Flag 19 Feb 19 2.30pm

Originally posted by blackheatheagle

I fail to understand / justify the correlation between aiming FA Cup / Europa League and relegation.

Afraid of 5-6 extra game sounds to conservative for me. I am much more `best training is a real game` guy.

Not when those extra five or six games are in the back end of Mongolia on a Thursday night and we have a league match back in England three days later

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 19 Feb 19 2.38pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Not when those extra five or six games are in the back end of Mongolia on a Thursday night and we have a league match back in England three days later

So send the kids or fringe players. Never heard sny thing so stupid in my life - don't want to win thd cup in case we have to play in Europe next season - seriously?

 

RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 19 Feb 19 3.21pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Without the Premier League we are nothing. You might have noticed that we have never won the cup before and that might have something to do with the fact that we have spent the majority of our existence in the lower leagues where your players are usually bang average.

The best chance of winning any cup is staying in the Premier League. I'd have thought that was fairly obvious.

When you get to the latter stages of the cup, you must have been taking it half seriously. Clearly, the club believes that we have the players to have a cup run and get enough points in the league. Otherwise, we would be out already. A long cup run always has a knock on effect for fixtures and player performance and we are nowhere near safe yet.
I would not see winning the FA Cup as consolation for a possible decade in the Championship.


覧覧覧覧覧覧覧覧覧覧覧覧覧覧-

Not sure we are nothing without the premier league and if we never give the cup a serious crack when we get the chance what痴 it all about. We could easily try our hardest to stay in the top tier and take the cup very lightly but still mess up and get relegated so can稚 we just give it a go when we are at our strongest and have a bit of belief we can stay up. Hopefully there is only one place left for relegation so it not looking to dire atm.

 

blackheatheagle Flag Beckenham 19 Feb 19 3.24pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Not when those extra five or six games are in the back end of Mongolia on a Thursday night and we have a league match back in England three days later

This may be a fact for sure but IMHO it is not a horror story as it sounds.

Chance of meeting 3000+ miles team in any draw (elimination or group) will not be more than 5%. If we assume 3 point is lost in the league for this, that means the risk of 3 point loss is 5%. It should not be a deal when Palace lose average of 60 points every year.

5-6 game extra is extra challenge for sure and can be painful during October-November, i don`t deny that. But what i fail to understand is what is the pre-requisite to accept this challenge? Or the doors to accept this should be closed at all? Just asking.

 

jhillman Flag USA 19 Feb 19 3.31pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Not when those extra five or six games are in the back end of Mongolia on a Thursday night and we have a league match back in England three days later

Couldn't care less if we've won the FA Cup.

 

RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 19 Feb 19 3.44pm

Originally posted by jhillman

Couldn't care less if we've won the FA Cup.

覧覧覧覧覧覧覧覧覧覧覧�-

Strange comment for a Palace fan !


I would be very happy if we won the FA Cup.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 19 Feb 19 3.46pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have been in conversation with a chap who is very knowledgable about football, regarding teams who have got to an FA Cup final and then been relegated in the same season.

Wigan are the only team to have actually won the FA Cup and been relegated that season.That was back in 2013 and they have never returned to the PL.Portsmouth got to the final in 2010, were relegated and have has spells in League One and League Two.They have not returned to the top flight.Brighton got to the FA Cup final in 1983 and it too them over 30 years to get to the PL !

All these supporters had their day out in the sun for the final but one can only speculate as to whether this was any compensation for the heartbreak of relegation.

Edited by Willo (19 Feb 2019 10.51am)


TBF I and half a dozen others could've told you that

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 19 Feb 19 4.32pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

What baffles me is that you can't see that that the FA cup at any time is a distraction for Palace survival, that at the moment hangs on a thread.
I know a lot of fans put the cup above all else, but i would think the majority would consider survival more important. IMHO

Weirdos. 1 game from Wembley and some people aren't arsed. Thankfully there's more than enough fans who do give a f***

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 19 Feb 19 4.50pm

There seem to be 3 main perspectives

1. The league is the priority but a cup win would be mind blowing and you've gotta take risk in this life

2. Protect the business at all costs, the cup is a distraction to that goal

3. Go for the glory at almost any cost

I'm in group 1. I think most people are. The hope is important, the building of memories and dreams...

I knew a Charlton fan. He said they lost their love of the PL after a while...getting beaten and beaten and beaten...atmosphere lost hope...

Maybe a cup run, when they were on the up, would have galvanised them...

My lad is beyond excited about the possibility of another trip to Wembley. He's less fussed about Leicester away...

Maybe I need to sit him down and explain it's all about business and finance.

But no. I'm exactly the same. Even if I understand the priorities.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

YT Flag Oxford 19 Feb 19 4.56pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have been in conversation with a chap who is very knowledgable about football, regarding teams who have got to an FA Cup final and then been relegated in the same season.

Wigan are the only team to have actually won the FA Cup and been relegated that season.That was back in 2013 and they have never returned to the PL.Portsmouth got to the final in 2010, were relegated and have has spells in League One and League Two.They have not returned to the top flight.Brighton got to the FA Cup final in 1983 and it too them over 30 years to get to the PL !

All these supporters had their day out in the sun for the final but one can only speculate as to whether this was any compensation for the heartbreak of relegation.

Edited by Willo (19 Feb 2019 10.51am)

On the other hand, Leicester City lost an FA Cup final and were relegated the same season. I wonder what became of them! (Alright, so they lost and were relegated in 1969 - the first FA Cup Final to be televised in colour, incidentally). I believe the Foxes still hold the record of most FA Cup Final appearances without winning.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

southnorwoodhill Flag 19 Feb 19 5.08pm

Originally posted by YT

On the other hand, Leicester City lost an FA Cup final and were relegated the same season. I wonder what became of them! (Alright, so they lost and were relegated in 1969 - the first FA Cup Final to be televised in colour, incidentally). I believe the Foxes still hold the record of most FA Cup Final appearances without winning.

Wimbledon won the FA Cup, what happened to them? Go for it I say. There's no reason we can't do well in our remaining games in the PL and get to Wembley in the cup.

 

YT Flag Oxford 19 Feb 19 5.10pm

Originally posted by jhillman

Couldn't care less if we've won the FA Cup.

So you won't mind me telling you that we haven't then.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

YT Flag Oxford 19 Feb 19 5.16pm

Originally posted by iheartcpfc

Weirdos. 1 game from Wembley and some people aren't arsed. Thankfully there's more than enough fans who do give a f***

I expect that many who claim they are not interested will still hypocritically make their way down Wembley Way should we make it there, rather than offering their ticket to me at face value!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Feb 19 5.26pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


TBF I and half a dozen others could've told you that

You and "Half a dozen others" are clearly very knowledgeable on this matter.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 19 Feb 19 5.35pm

Genuinely not sure what the point of us being in the Premier League is other than trying to have a crack at the cups. We were 10 minutes away a couple of seasons ago and winning either of them would be the best day in our history.

I can also never understand why anyone wouldn't want to see us in the Europa League. Even if it made us more likely to go down, winning a cup and getting some away days against someone like Sporting Lisbon, Villareal, Feyenoord etc would be absolutely superb.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 19 Feb 19 7.09pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have been in conversation with a chap who is very knowledgable about football, regarding teams who have got to an FA Cup final and then been relegated in the same season.

Wigan are the only team to have actually won the FA Cup and been relegated that season.That was back in 2013 and they have never returned to the PL.Portsmouth got to the final in 2010, were relegated and have has spells in League One and League Two.They have not returned to the top flight.Brighton got to the FA Cup final in 1983 and it too them over 30 years to get to the PL !

All these supporters had their day out in the sun for the final but one can only speculate as to whether this was any compensation for the heartbreak of relegation.

Edited by Willo (19 Feb 2019 10.51am)


Utter f-1n tosh! These are exceptions, not rules. Watford, Everton, Villa, Hull, Newcastle, Man City, Forest, Sheff Wed, Middlesbrough, Southampton, West Ham, Stoke.....all contemporary losing finalists, all didn't get relegated.

Qu� sera, sera....

 


Spirit of 1974

Dean_CPFC Flag South london 19 Feb 19 7.15pm

No messing about worrying about scenarios and what ifs. Take each game as it comes, two week break post Watford, no excuse not to have a full strength team out. Let's go at them

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Feb 19 7.38pm

Originally posted by bifffabazz


Utter f-1n tosh! These are exceptions, not rules. Watford, Everton, Villa, Hull, Newcastle, Man City, Forest, Sheff Wed, Middlesbrough, Southampton, West Ham, Stoke.....all contemporary losing finalists, all didn't get relegated.

Qu� sera, sera....

With the greatest of respect I was highlighting teams that reached the FA Cup final and got relegated in the same season.

I certainly would not wish this scenario to unfold in respect of our beloved team.I have been perfectly clear that to 'Yours Truly' survival in the PL is more important than either reaching the FA Cup final or winning it but I accept some others have an alternative viewpoint.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 19 Feb 19 8.08pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

The Most convincing argument for the FA Cup I have read here!

The only this it does not address is the 'distraction' Element. Having 'One eye on the cup' is not a good way to garner points from a League game in this division. Like it or not, the best Way to progress as a club is to bring in the money that the Premier League offers. To win the FA Cup at the expense of the Premier League survival is short-termism and where it will benefit the Fans and give them 'those Wembley days', it'll do more damage to the club in the long run if that means relegation to the ultra competive and far Less lucrative Championship.

I am all for the FA Cup, It can do wonders for moral and gives the 2nd string a chance to impress - which can only be good for cometition. But would take PL survival first any day of the week.

I agree. But what I said was cup success inspires success in the league. Positive feedback! Have both.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 19 Feb 19 9.41pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

And yet we're in the Premier League and you don't want to go for the cup?

Not at the risk of relegation.

In the real world, it is difficult to know where to strike the balance.
We are in the quarterfinal and yet not safe by any means with the disadvantage of fixture alterations.

We are already taking on extra risk. If we make the final and stay up then great but if we go down then ten cup finals will not make up the loss of income and players.

 

Page 8 of 10 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > FA Cup next round