This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Southampton vs Palace Match Thread
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
benjo Sydney 29 Dec 19 2.26am |
|
|
Dumb decision. How is there an advantage to having an arm in front of the last defender?
|
crvenaeagle 29 Dec 19 5.54am |
|
Originally posted by Phil’s Barber
The Mail on Sunday article a couple of moths back highlighted that VAR could only be accurate to a margin of error ranging anything from 13cm minimum up to potential 38.8cm!!! (due to freeze technology and judging when the ball was played). This is just a farce when they are examining it to such a microscopic degree.
Also working out where to draw the lines is done by a human and not technology so yet further room for error!
How you can decide when the ball was played, where wilf’s shoulder ends and arm begins EXACTLY and where that is in relation to a boot with a margin of error of up to almost 39cm is a flippin joke and VAR is ruining the game in its current form and interpretation.
Okay so can anybody clarify the rules for me because as far as I've always been aware the offside rule states that a player is offside when a playable part of his body is beyond the last line, i.e. Any part of his body he can use to play the ball, NOT his hands or arms yet I've seen countless times this season, including yesterday, offsides given in VAR for arms or even hands beyond the last line.
What exactly is the rule??
Edited by crvenaeagle (29 Dec 2019 5.57am)
|
bifffabazz Highworth, Wiltshire 29 Dec 19 7.30am |
|
|
Arms and hands do not count when considering offside...
Attachment: Screenshot_20191228-192436_Samsung Internet.jpg (470.67Kb)
Spirit of 1974
|
bifffabazz Highworth, Wiltshire 29 Dec 19 7.31am |
|
|
....but when you combine Andre Marriner on VAR duty and Wilf, they do...
Spirit of 1974
|
The Dolphin 29 Dec 19 7.31am |
|
|
I have been critical at times this season but VAR aside we are in a good position with decent points which considering our lack of goals and injury list is quite incredible! Well done the players, Roy and his team and CPFC generally. Come on you Palace!!
Edited by The Dolphin (29 Dec 2019 7.33am)
|
braunstoneagle the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 29 Dec 19 7.39am |
|
Originally posted by Baires Eagle
No, sorry I'm not having that! Enough is enough.... we've been striped up by VAR and the FA. Sure we're having a good season cos we're a decent club, but are you gonna sit back and say VAR was right. Fvk off right now..... if I was Wilf or Meyer I would have walked straight off the pitch ffs.
I'm livid and I'm gonna do damage over this.
You sit back and comply with VAR and the fuxking FA bvnch of cvntz do you not realise we actually have more points because of VAR?
‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway
|
Badger11 Beckenham 29 Dec 19 7.52am |
|
|
A number of dodgy VAR offside decisions this weekend have fans quite rightly up in arms.
I believe in athletics the winner is the person whose torso crosses the line rather than their head or other body part. The point being that a part of the body is specified. Now the torso may not be appropriate in football but maybe offside could be about their feet position rather than armpit offside which MOTD are calling these decisions.
Anyway it needs looking at with a clear rule for next season.
One more point
|
The Dolphin 29 Dec 19 8.08am |
|
|
It is not just the fact that goals are being chalked off which is bad for the game it is the effect on those games. We go 1-0 up early we may have won easily? Norwich would have gone 2-0 up and likely won important points. It made no difference to Brighton ultimately of course. Wilf's foot was slightly ahead of the last players foot but it was not enough of a reason and I am sure they will change it next season.
|
Jaha 29 Dec 19 9.35am |
|
|
If it doesn’t give them an unfair advantage, if a small amount of an arm or foot is minutely offside I don’t think it should be ruled out. No human can control that and it’s going to stop players from trying to run in behind. The zaha one is ridiculous to be honest, tossers who chalked that off.
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 29 Dec 19 9.35am |
|
|
..but Zaha does have huge massive underarm hair! lol
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 29 Dec 19 9.50am |
|
|
Makes you wonder what these dick heads are looking at, VAR was supposed to help the referee’s out and simplify matters, instead total confusion has taken over...
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Dec 19 9.51am |
|
Originally posted by Jaha
If it doesn’t give them an unfair advantage, if a small amount of an arm or foot is minutely offside I don’t think it should be ruled out. No human can control that and it’s going to stop players from trying to run in behind. The zaha one is ridiculous to be honest, tossers who chalked that off.
In the final analysis the VAR made a judgement as per Law 11 (Offside)which states that a player is deemed offside if any part of the head, body or feet is nearer to the opponents’ goal line than both the ball and the second-last opponent. VARs are making decisions based on the law as it stands.
We benefitted from an exceedingly marginal decision when Ayew scored at W.Ham and yesterday we suffered as a marginal decision went against us.
Whether VAR should rule on offsides at all or other parameters and protocols introduced is of course a matter for debate, there has been ample debate on this subject to-date and of course will continue.
Edited by Willo (29 Dec 2019 9.55am)
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 29 Dec 19 9.59am |
|
Originally posted by Willo
In the final analysis the VAR made a judgement as per Law 11 (Offside)which states that a player is deemed offside if any part of the head, body or feet is nearer to the opponents’ goal line than both the ball and the second-last opponent. VARs are making decisions based on the law as it stands.
We benefitted from an exceedingly marginal decision when Ayew scored at W.Ham and yesterday we suffered as a marginal decision went against us.
Whether VAR should rule on offsides at all or other parameters and protocols introduced is of course a matter for debate, there has been ample debate on this subject to-date and of course will continue.
Edited by Willo (29 Dec 2019 9.55am)
Well it wasn’t have a look again, the defender was nearer the goal..
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 29 Dec 19 10.27am |
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
It is not just the fact that goals are being chalked off which is bad for the game it is the effect on those games. We go 1-0 up early we may have won easily? Norwich would have gone 2-0 up and likely won important points. It made no difference to Brighton ultimately of course. Wilf's foot was slightly ahead of the last players foot but it was not enough of a reason and I am sure they will change it next season.
..but then again the art of defending comes into it, we especially rely on good solid defending to get results and if anyone actually thinks about it it would have been very harsh on that defending team to lose a goal in that situation too.
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 29 Dec 19 10.32am |
|
Originally posted by Willo
In the final analysis the VAR made a judgement as per Law 11 (Offside)which states that a player is deemed offside if any part of the head, body or feet is nearer to the opponents’ goal line than both the ball and the second-last opponent. VARs are making decisions based on the law as it stands.
We benefitted from an exceedingly marginal decision when Ayew scored at W.Ham and yesterday we suffered as a marginal decision went against us.
Whether VAR should rule on offsides at all or other parameters and protocols introduced is of course a matter for debate, there has been ample debate on this subject to-date and of course will continue.
Edited by Willo (29 Dec 2019 9.55am)
Yes, we have to have rules and at the moment this is how it works, once they decide and once the season starts they simply cannot change their system.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Dec 19 10.45am |
|
Originally posted by Tickled pink
Yes, we have to have rules and at the moment this is how it works, once they decide and once the season starts they simply cannot change their system.
I have heard some pundits opining that there will be changes to VAR next season but this is a matter for conjecture.
|
Teddy Eagle 29 Dec 19 11.01am |
|
|
VAR isn’t being applied as intended which was to clarify obvious mistakes or misses by the officials. Neither the Palace or Norwich goals yesterday were obvious errors. In our game Jimmy Mac was penalised when he clearly won the ball, Andy Carroll was clearly pushed over in the area but the ref ignored/missed it. Apparently VAR isn’t meant for some incidents.
|
taylors lovechild 29 Dec 19 11.12am |
|
|
I'm not against a goal being ruled out even for the narrowest of margins, but I still can't see from the photos that Wilf was offside?
So far as the rest of the game went, we were the better and more composed side up until the last quarter of the game when the players started to look really tired. Saints were able to bring on Djenepo who has looked really good this season, and against tired legs he was having a lot of fortune. Perhaps unlucky not to get 3 points, but a point seemed fair by the end.
I know many of us keep asking the question, but what is going on with Camarassa? For anyone at the games lately, does he even run the touchline during games, or does he just sit cuddled up on the bench? My only guess is that Roy knows he is leaving and that is why he won't play him. Also damning for Wickham that even though Ayew was practically walking the last 15 minutes he still didn't get on the pitch.
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 29 Dec 19 11.14am |
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
VAR isn’t being applied as intended which was to clarify obvious mistakes or misses by the officials. Neither the Palace or Norwich goals yesterday were obvious errors. In our game Jimmy Mac was penalised when he clearly won the ball, Andy Carroll was clearly pushed over in the area but the ref ignored/missed it. Apparently VAR isn’t meant for some incidents.
Very good point, but because they have started to use VAR on every single offside they cannot stop now until the season ends because changing it now would mean goals disallowed before, being allowed now ...= lol
..but you are definitely right.
Edited by Tickled pink (29 Dec 2019 11.17am)
|
pompeyeagle Relocated to Shropshire 29 Dec 19 11.37am |
|
|
I'm not complaining about yesterday's decisions that went against us because it's happened to everyone and we've had our fair share of debatable VAR decisions that have gone in our favour. The bigger problem is that the excitement of football is being ruined by VAR and they need to sort it out and soon. If I was a season ticket holder I'd be thinking seriously about whether I want to renew for next season although I am optimistic that there will be changes before then. There has to be.
|