This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
For our amusement...
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Brinscall Eagle, nothing personal against you mate, but enough of people posting what they talked with their golf buddies. Most people are idiots. He has a dumb opinion and some of those players are actually very good. Supporters tend to be unhappy abd say things that really should be disregarded. This "I was talking with my friend at a beer" needs to stop. To be fair, what Brinscall Eagle or his buddy said was true - None of the mentioned players are worth any sell on value as they are all over the age 28. Add them to an already ageing squad and it will just see us worse off in the long run.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Brinscall Eagle, nothing personal against you mate, but enough of people posting what they talked with their golf buddies. Most people are idiots. He has a dumb opinion and some of those players are actually very good. Supporters tend to be unhappy abd say things that really should be disregarded. This "I was talking with my friend at a beer" needs to stop. Mattteo, you're right. BUT, what if someone is just relaying an honest story and are happy to share the info they have ? This a forum for opinions and stories of 'inside information'. If you heard or have information, this is the platform to share it. Agreed half are nonsense, but Brinscall Eagle could actually be reinforcing what we all know from a higher source at Everton - that he is sh*te!
|
|
|
Man who spends his entire day creating fictional 10 page 'scouting reports' off the back of youtube highlight shows rubbishes actual scout as an idiot. This is brilliant.
|
|
| Brinscall Eagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Brinscall Eagle, nothing personal against you mate, but enough of people posting what they talked with their golf buddies. Most people are idiots. He has a dumb opinion and some of those players are actually very good. Supporters tend to be unhappy abd say things that really should be disregarded. This "I was talking with my friend at a beer" needs to stop. I accept the principle of what you say but in this case the person is not a supporter he is actually an ex professional and has been coaching with both Everton and Wigan and has now retired but still scouts for Everton. He is very much aware of the Everton situation and indeed has a professional valued opinion. I Matteo am only throwing in someone’s valued opinion of Tosun and others which is probably nearer the truth than your average supporters opinion like mine. COYP
|
|
|
Originally posted by JohnB
Man who spends his entire day creating fictional 10 page 'scouting reports' off the back of youtube highlight shows rubbishes actual scout as an idiot. This is brilliant. Each to his own, I like reading them and you don't have to.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JohnB
Man who spends his entire day creating fictional 10 page 'scouting reports' off the back of youtube highlight shows rubbishes actual scout as an idiot. This is brilliant. Leave out the personal insults please
|
|
|
Originally posted by dazza
I have just been told that Walker- Peters will be conformed next week on 6 month loan deal and option to buy for £15m plus add-ons. Palace have beaten 3 other clubs including Brighton & Southampton to secure the deal. Not a bad deal to be fair. I hope you're information is correct.
One more point |
|
| Brinscall Eagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Willo
On the subject of scouts, I have been in the company of those who have really had polarised views about certain players resulting in some frank discussions. As an example, many years ago I was with some scouts who had totally divergent opinions about a couple of players.One player was a Japanese chap Bolton had just acquired and the other was Michael Dawson who was with Nottm Forest at the time.One of the gentleman was excited about the Bolton acquisition whereas the other was rather less enthusiastic.The Japanese player hardly made an impact at Bolton. Opinions, opinions ! Edited by Willo (08 Jan 2020 4.23pm) Your experience Willo just goes to reinforce that football is all about opinions. Scouts report on players that they have seen and pass the information on. What the people above do with it is up to them. Managers themselves have opinions of players justifying why they should or should not buy them. There are many cases of players bought because of the opinion they would be good but turn out to be less than useful to the team. Every club can sight examples.
|
|
|
Originally posted by dazza
So I said Tosun and have kept quite and just listened the abuse and people doubting my sources well you will see in the next week that I am right. I have said many times that I only pass on what I have been told some of it tends to be rubbish some has substance. Batsman is still on cards and very much is dependent on Zaha going to Chelsea in the Summer if not before. Walkers Peters is in talks but so are 3 other clubs so not nailed on but a possibility told we are working hard to get this done loan with option to buy however another club is offering to buy now. I’m also hearing we have held preliminary talks with 2 other clubs will try to find out more before posting as don’t want to be accused of anything. The person who questioned my ITK and Dom Fifield has not heard anything ask him now if he knows I bet he does in regards to Tosun. Which makes you no different to anyone else who posts on Transfer Talk, with the exception that most don't claim that what they post is any more than guesswork, media stories and rumours or wishful thinking.
Bexley Dave Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing! "The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum) |
|
|
Originally posted by dazza
I have just been told that Walker- Peters will be conformed next week on 6 month loan deal and option to buy for £15m plus add-ons. Palace have beaten 3 other clubs including Brighton & Southampton to secure the deal. Not a bad deal to be fair. Not a bad deal???? Actually, 15 million is horrenduous. I'm not gonna name 20 right backs I'd bring, but I just tell you this: frommhere, in England,there a kid called Bogle who plays as right back for Derby. He is just 19 years old and has delievered in his 100.000 monutes career (at 19 years old!) 18 crosses which were turned in goals and has also scored 11 times. He is great going forward and has lightning speed. Club representatives have said that whievwr wants him will have to caugh up 10 million. Now that to me is a big proce, but for a 19 year old like him?? Totally worth it!! Now Walker Peters. He's also a toung lad, but not 19. He's 22,turning 23 in April. So not so young anynore. Had some runs on the right side for Tottenham and a few goal crosses, but only for a team which dominated the opponents. Besides Tottenham's first team, he has been pretty poor going forward. Just 6 assists and no goals as right back in 50.000 minutes at youth level (youth level, which is below Championship level A LOT). He won't be anymore dangerous going forward rhan Ward is. And that's particularly the reason why a better player there is needed. And anyway.....for 15 million??????????? These prices for players just because they come from Top 6 teams beed to be reassesed. If he were playing in the Championship, he would't be worth 0.6 million. There will be no re-sale value for him. He is no AWB going forward to draw the eye. Best case scenarion he will be a decent right back as Ward is and Palace will keep struggling mis-table in the PL for the next 10 years. This team will never overcome its position with such transfers.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle
I accept the principle of what you say but in this case the person is not a supporter he is actually an ex professional and has been coaching with both Everton and Wigan and has now retired but still scouts for Everton. Pk. Sorry, then. I thought this was some random guy fan.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Not a bad deal???? Actually, 15 million is horrenduous. I'm not gonna name 20 right backs I'd bring, but I just tell you this: frommhere, in England,there a kid called Bogle who plays as right back for Derby. He is just 19 years old and has delievered in his 100.000 monutes career (at 19 years old!) 18 crosses which were turned in goals and has also scored 11 times. He is great going forward and has lightning speed. Club representatives have said that whievwr wants him will have to caugh up 10 million. Now that to me is a big proce, but for a 19 year old like him?? Totally worth it!! Now Walker Peters. He's also a toung lad, but not 19. He's 22,turning 23 in April. So not so young anynore. Had some runs on the right side for Tottenham and a few goal crosses, but only for a team which dominated the opponents. Besides Tottenham's first team, he has been pretty poor going forward. Just 6 assists and no goals as right back in 50.000 minutes at youth level (youth level, which is below Championship level A LOT). He won't be anymore dangerous going forward rhan Ward is. And that's particularly the reason why a better player there is needed. And anyway.....for 15 million??????????? These prices for players just because they come from Top 6 teams beed to be reassesed. If he were playing in the Championship, he would't be worth 0.6 million. There will be no re-sale value for him. He is no AWB going forward to draw the eye. Best case scenarion he will be a decent right back as Ward is and Palace will keep struggling mis-table in the PL for the next 10 years. This team will never overcome its position with such transfers. I never formed the opinion that AWB was that impressive when going forward.At the end of the day he was a winger who never quite made it in that position and was moved to right-back.Maybe AWB will develop the attacking side of the game with more experience and in a more attack-minded team.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.