You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Derby Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Derby Match Thread


Page 8 of 10 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
palace chick Flag South Croydon 05 Jan 20 4.58pm

90 minutes of Wickham today showed that we need replacements up front. Service to him wasn’t (never is to anyone) good but he is way too slow and gave away unnecessary fouls. A loan / sale to a championship side would be for the best. Also Kelly now showing how weak he is at right back. Been okay as cover and of course is better in the middle when needed. He’s play going forward on the right is awful and never when in space plays a decent killer ball to the forwards. Need a right back replacement urgently and Ward when fit isn’t the answer. We need players especially in midfield that can break defenders down rather than playing it backwards/sideways nearly all match. Today again, playing against inferior opponents that’s what we did for most of the match. I guess that’s Hodgson’s way but it’s not good to watch. Might need to play that way in next two Matches though but I see trouble ahead if we don’t change the way we are playing and get some new players in?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 05 Jan 20 5.02pm

Awful game.

Roy again shown he is so out of touch.

VAR has shown again how inconsistent it is because of the idiots that are using it hidden many miles away.

Man sent of so he will now be missing as well.

Never understood that starting line up some of the players may of needed some game time but others no way should they have been playing play the youngsters this is getting stupid now.

This has to be Roy being stubborn trying to get a point across about transfers it's the only real reason i can think of also he didn't sign that new contract yet did he?

Final thing he is again trying to play the same way every time give it a rest Roy almost all the player cant pass and this slow build up play doesn't work all the time against big teams yes i understand it but everyone else no its proven its not working he has destroyed the likes of benteke plus out once great counter attacks plus set plays which was a massive strength for us.

Edited by grumpymort (05 Jan 2020 5.04pm)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Jan 20 5.02pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

If he did that and we lost. A lot of people would still be moaning because they want a cup run. I’m with your opinion. It wasn’t worth taking the risk and no it has back fired big style.

It only back fires as the final whistle blows, we did have two wonderful Ayew moves and distributions for others to ferk up in that last five mins, so only in hindsight can Hodgson be blamed and I agree he will also see that as a mistake I'm sure, Pierrick had promising moments again so not waste of time for him.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 05 Jan 20 5.06pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I am struggling to find any positives from today.

One. We went out.

Two. Someone else has a go at taking our corners ?

 

The Dolphin Flag 05 Jan 20 5.07pm

Just got home - cold and miserable!
Awful game, Rooney strolled it, two more injuries and our Captain out for 3 games.
Hodgson deserves all he gets after that pile of poo!
I accept our injury crisis and I don't mind not progressing this year but dear oh dear that was rock bottom awful!
We should be very worried about the next month or so!

Edited by The Dolphin (05 Jan 2020 5.08pm)

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 05 Jan 20 5.11pm

We keep passing it around sideways and backwards because
no-one is moving into space and when they DO attempt a forward pass it is inevitably to a marked player who has to off-load in a hurry.

This happens time after time simply because we do not have someone confident and skilful enough to hold the ball, bring it forward and wait for some movement ahead.

A new striker ? Yes but a skilful midfield 'general' is also desperately needed.

Ronaldo would struggle with our hopeless midfield.

And, as an aside, would Guaita have saved Martin's shot?

I don't think so.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Jan 20 5.14pm

Originally posted by palace chick

90 minutes of Wickham today showed that we need replacements up front. Service to him wasn’t (never is to anyone) good but he is way too slow and gave away unnecessary fouls. A loan / sale to a championship side would be for the best. Also Kelly now showing how weak he is at right back. Been okay as cover and of course is better in the middle when needed. He’s play going forward on the right is awful and never when in space plays a decent killer ball to the forwards. Need a right back replacement urgently and Ward when fit isn’t the answer. We need players especially in midfield that can break defenders down rather than playing it backwards/sideways nearly all match. Today again, playing against inferior opponents that’s what we did for most of the match. I guess that’s Hodgson’s way but it’s not good to watch. Might need to play that way in next two Matches though but I see trouble ahead if we don’t change the way we are playing and get some new players in?

Derby are not that bad especially with that Rooney raining balls left right and centre ..he is actually what we need lol, yes Kelly kept losing our pressure as did Meyer who was equally as bad with his control and especially so with his shielding of the ball (Riedewald please show him how it's done!) Wickham is just very rusty and to suggest otherwise is ridiculous.
Ward is a million times better in Kelly's place who is himself a million times better a bit more to the left.

Edited by Tickled pink (05 Jan 2020 5.17pm)

 

.TUX. Flag 05 Jan 20 5.15pm

No Cup-run for another year then.
Gutted.

 


Buy Litecoin.

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Jan 20 5.20pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

No Cup-run for another year then.
Gutted.

Considering our injury list and game time for those in the firing line we have dodged a bullet albeit very sad for those of us who love a good old cup run.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Jan 20 5.20pm

I would like to have seen another couple of youngsters being given a start today on the assumption that a cup run was not a priority.

As it turned out the starting eleven was a lot stronger than I expected.

Which in turn suggests that the club were hoping for a go at the competition.

But...as others have pointed out, some of the players look in need of a rest. When there are no natural full backs and no Wilf or Townsend, we don't get behind the opposition. Wickham's fitness levels are woefully short of what is required at this level. And then the captain gets a totally unnecessary red card.

Put all that together and you have the dross we witnessed today.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 05 Jan 20 5.31pm

Originally posted by Uphill

We keep passing it around sideways and backwards because
no-one is moving into space and when they DO attempt a forward pass it is inevitably to a marked player who has to off-load in a hurry.

This happens time after time simply because we do not have someone confident and skilful enough to hold the ball, bring it forward and wait for some movement ahead.

A new striker ? Yes but a skilful midfield 'general' is also desperately needed.

Ronaldo would struggle with our hopeless midfield.

And, as an aside, would Guaita have saved Martin's shot?

I don't think so.

Ayew was our shining light today, he tried running and puffing at their defence but they were able to regroup and organise in numbers because we telegraphed our every move ten minutes before we did it, we missed Zaha sooooooooooooooooooooo much.

 

The Dolphin Flag 05 Jan 20 5.34pm

Their goal. Reidewald refused to close down and tackle and Kelly - again - lost Martin!
Poor defending indeed.

Edited by The Dolphin (05 Jan 2020 5.34pm)

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 05 Jan 20 5.37pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Isn't there an obligation to field your strongest side? I accept that 'strongest' is subjective in this context but you can't just put a youth side out in an FA Cup tie.

Scousers seem to of had the right idea and could well be putting out a very strong Everton side.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 05 Jan 20 5.38pm

Originally posted by Uphill

We keep passing it around sideways and backwards because
no-one is moving into space and when they DO attempt a forward pass it is inevitably to a marked player who has to off-load in a hurry.

This happens time after time simply because we do not have someone confident and skilful enough to hold the ball, bring it forward and wait for some movement ahead.

A new striker ? Yes but a skilful midfield 'general' is also desperately needed.

Ronaldo would struggle with our hopeless midfield.

And, as an aside, would Guaita have saved Martin's shot?

I don't think so.


No we keep passing it around like that because that is what has been told to do look at England under Roy even now they do the same thing it's all about keeping possession.

Yes I agree people are not moving into space but again if you are playing at this slow pace their isn't much space and out players don't have the intelligence to make or move (Rooney today showed how he still is on another level compared to all our players)

No another keeper would of of saved that shot it was poor defending from Kelly also Wayne was ball watching he should of been telling Kelly to pick the player up.

The problem is Roy and this system he has which is too strict.

Look back all the years in Prem at the styles Roy has switched to possession football as top priority not using the players we have strengths.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Texas Eagle Flag San Antonio, Texas (via Adelaide) 05 Jan 20 5.41pm

Today is another example why we need to invest in a decent striker desperately, RB and LB. Our lack of depth in the squad is alarming but our ability to change tactics when things aren't going our way is even more disturbing.

 


"Billy Gilbert really is God"

dreamwaverider Flag London 05 Jan 20 6.01pm

Originally posted by .TUX.

No Cup-run for another year then.
Gutted.

Bet Roy isn’t

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 05 Jan 20 6.18pm

Thoughts from today.
Zaha badly missed
Without Zaha we are a very different team
Lots of our players are championship level.
We were awful.
Cahill should be skipper.
Our tactics were hopeless.
Derby fans sang us out the ground.
Ayew is class. Pierrick good potential.
Wickham championship level.
Kelly should play in middle.
Luka needs the break and needs help.
Townsend missed.
Easy to say but we should look for more squad rotation. Roy obviously stuck on this one. But he is very staid. However he is working wonders for us.
We need more players. The board really needs to take action
The White Horse has way better facilities than the Arthur.
Arthur season tickets should be cheaper!!
Why close the Arthur for home fans today?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 05 Jan 20 6.42pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Derby are not that bad especially with that Rooney raining balls left right and centre ..he is actually what we need lol, yes Kelly kept losing our pressure as did Meyer who was equally as bad with his control and especially so with his shielding of the ball (Riedewald please show him how it's done!) Wickham is just very rusty and to suggest otherwise is ridiculous.
Ward is a million times better in Kelly's place who is himself a million times better a bit more to the left.

Edited by Tickled pink (05 Jan 2020 5.17pm)

However he was fouled 5 times in the first 10 minutes, out of a total of 8. Why did Oliver not produce a yellow card?

 

PatrickA Flag London 05 Jan 20 6.43pm

Was optimistic before the game when I saw the team with only one inexperienced player included.
Very disappointed with the performance subsequently and also to go out of the cup with a whimper.
We looked jaded and lacking ideas.
No creativity and pedestrian in midfield and a lack of pace and zip in the wide areas to get behind their defence.
Another goalless game from us and we’re so easy to defend against.
Yes there are injuries, but our team should have been strong enough to beat at home a mediocre Championship team who played games on Monday and Thursday during the week.
We can’t even claim to be unlucky as they deserved their win.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 05 Jan 20 6.48pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Was optimistic before the game when I saw the team with only one inexperienced player included.
Very disappointed with the performance subsequently and also to go out of the cup with a whimper.
We looked jaded and lacking ideas.
No creativity and pedestrian in midfield and a lack of pace and zip in the wide areas to get behind their defence.
Another goalless game from us and we’re so easy to defend against.
Yes there are injuries, but our team should have been strong enough to beat at home a mediocre Championship team who played games on Monday and Thursday during the week.
We can’t even claim to be unlucky as they deserved their win.

Well put, absolutely agree with you :-(

 

Page 8 of 10 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Derby Match Thread