You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Arsenal Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Arsenal Match Thread


Page 8 of 12 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Eaglecoops Flag CR3 11 Jan 20 2.50pm

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

Roy should have tweaked tactics to make a better go at 3 points once the arse went a man down. Terrible performance from wild. Horrible from kelly

Put everything into perspective. Massive injuries playing against a team on a bit of a role with new manager lift. I’ll take that point every day given the circumstances.

Kelly struggled a bit but he ain’t no fullback so who would you have played there?

 

EddieMac Flag 11 Jan 20 2.52pm

Originally posted by CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE

Roy should have tweaked tactics to make a better go at 3 points once the arse went a man down. Terrible performance from wild. Horrible from kelly

Kelly is a Centre back playing completely out of position up against a top top player in Aubameyang. He hasnt bbeen great lately but the chap is doing his best. I agree Wilf was very poor but he always struggles against defenders with pace and strenght.

 

Robk Flag 11 Jan 20 2.58pm

Jaïro had a great game..he’s a much better bet than PVA... better passer of the ball and better defensively ...

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 11 Jan 20 2.59pm

Good point

 

EddieMac Flag 11 Jan 20 3.02pm

Originally posted by Robk

Jaïro had a great game..he’s a much better bet than PVA... better passer of the ball and better defensively ...

I agree with you on this. The only thing PVA seems to have over him is pace. Riedwald does seem very sluggish but he deserves nothing but praise for the way he has stepped in at LB. He is still only 23 so lots of time on his side.

 

CT Charlie Flag 11 Jan 20 3.08pm

Wilf wasn't super-sharp, but Arsenal threw a handful of defenders at him, knowing we don't present a threat in the middle.

We should petition to let Luka come in only for set pieces -- terrible deliveries today.

Guaita continues to be Man of the Season.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 11 Jan 20 3.11pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

I agree with you on this. The only thing PVA seems to have over him is pace. Riedwald does seem very sluggish but he deserves nothing but praise for the way he has stepped in at LB. He is still only 23 so lots of time on his side.

Riedewald has played so little football over the last few years, and looked well overweight at several points, so it'll take time for him to get fully up to standard. However, he's looking better and better both on the ball and in defense, and given how much of a liability PVA is, I don't think it'll take long for Riedewald to overtake him in the pecking order.

 

becky Flag over the moon 11 Jan 20 3.12pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

I agree with you on this. The only thing PVA seems to have over him is pace. Riedwald does seem very sluggish but he deserves nothing but praise for the way he has stepped in at LB. He is still only 23 so lots of time on his side.

Also liked the way, at the end, when we were pressing, he was not afraid to get forward towards and even into the box and give Wilf more options

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

southnorwoodhill Flag 11 Jan 20 3.21pm

Riedewald got BBC's MOTM. What with him now settled, and Guaita with another amazing save these are two to hold onto at all costs.
A worthy point.

 

nead1 Flag 11 Jan 20 3.25pm

I thought Riedewald was the best Palace player. Amazing he has had so little game time. Confident on the ball, especially going forward, and a very good left foot. Looks a real player IN my eyes.

 

lexmark87 Flag 11 Jan 20 3.26pm

riedewald will be dropped once roys favs are fit.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 11 Jan 20 3.35pm

Originally posted by lexmark87

riedewald will be dropped once roys favs are fit.

Whilst that could happen, he has at least given Roy a decision to make that he didn’t have to before.

 

General Flag 11 Jan 20 3.43pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Whilst that could happen, he has at least given Roy a decision to make that he didn’t have to before.

Easily good enough for a midfield 3 role. Easily the best passer we have. Best technique to strike a ball. Except for Zaha and Ayew he has the best brain and vision. Best forward thought process. Best give and go attempts.

Just strange how he wouldn’t have shown this in training or given Roy the confidence he can do it over 90 mins before we were hit with these injuries.

Fingers crossed he keep this form up as I love watching him play it’s a pleasure

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 11 Jan 20 3.49pm

Originally posted by General

Easily good enough for a midfield 3 role. Easily the best passer we have. Best technique to strike a ball. Except for Zaha and Ayew he has the best brain and vision. Best forward thought process. Best give and go attempts.

Just strange how he wouldn’t have shown this in training or given Roy the confidence he can do it over 90 mins before we were hit with these injuries.

Fingers crossed he keep this form up as I love watching him play it’s a pleasure

The reason I believe is simple. Roy likes seasoned pros and places his trust in them. If they perform in training they then become favourites and will be first on the team sheet every week. Roy is a system manager and if you fit, you fit, if you don’t you don’t. He takes some persuading to go off piste.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 11 Jan 20 3.51pm

Once everyone is fit, I’d like to see him and Meyer given a run in center midfield together with one of Luka/Jimmy Mac. I think we’d look a different team with some quality in the middle of the park.

I still prefer PVA at LB though.

 

Gribbo Flag Bromley 11 Jan 20 3.55pm

Jairo rapidly turning into a top performer.
Jordan - 100% effort as usual.
VG - Makes me happy just because he is not Wayne. Earned Palace so many points this season, and again today.

Is it just me, but I cannot remember the last time Wilf had a decent game against a top 6 side, obviously excusing the fact that Arsenal were once a top 6 side, but now look so far from it, it is hard to believe.

Top tip from me - the Gooners will turn on Arteta before the end of the season. He most certainly is not the answer - 7 or 8 new players might stand them in better stead.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 11 Jan 20 4.05pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

The reason I believe is simple. Roy likes seasoned pros and places his trust in them. If they perform in training they then become favourites and will be first on the team sheet every week. Roy is a system manager and if you fit, you fit, if you don’t you don’t. He takes some persuading to go off piste.

AWB replaced ward

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 11 Jan 20 4.19pm

Originally posted by silvertop

AWB replaced ward

Sorry, I don’t follow you? AWB replaced Ward because it was Hobson’s choice ie Ward was injured. Roy, then and only then saw his ability and had no choice but to pick him. Had Ward been fit AWB would not have got his chance. Are you arguing against this point as I’m not sure what you are trying to say?

As far as I am concerned Riedewald has proved his ability, it remains to be seen whether Roy reverts to his favourites when fit.

 

lexmark87 Flag 11 Jan 20 4.25pm

riedewald was brought for his quality,awb was a youngster coming through.
hes been at the club longer than roy.
even playing out of position hes our best passer by miles.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 11 Jan 20 4.45pm

All correct

But Roy is keeping us in top off of premier league table with a second string team and yes it can be boring but it’s about as good as we are ever going to get unless money is pumped in bigtime. Which we do not have

The alternative is we don’t extend his contract end of season, bring in someone else, the style may be more attractive, but zaha is going and we’ll never get higher in table. A club our size just can’t unless we unearth Jamie Vardy part 2 and keep him

As good as wilf can be, he’s a winger. Not a striker.

We need a worldly striker

 

Page 8 of 12 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Arsenal Match Thread