You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Watford match thread
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace v Watford match thread


Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 07 Mar 20 10.07pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

We’ve played that way the whole season until Newcastle at home. I grant you Hodgson has had Parish and shareholders pile shyte on his plate but Hodgson has played the same stand off football since we lost RLC. We haven’t always needed to but we have.

Then we got into Newcastle’s faces, deserved that, edged the Brighton away game and edged this one v Watford imo seeing as they could’ve scored first. Either of those could’ve sen draws. Don’t get me wrong, I’m happy with the last 3 matches and strong performances even though we were slow to turn interceptions into attack today but it isn’t down to injuries as you think. It is Hodgson’s preferred football unless he has another RLC who carries the ball in addition to one or two wingers because there’s very little pattern of attacking play usually. In the RLC days there were a lot of triangles into the box but I haven’t seen much effective team play attacking wise this season for the most part. It’s far too slow and we don’t exploit the opposition caught running back or in front of the ball. (Notice Macarthur and Zaha not understanding each other with balls either to run on to or come towards and Zaha expecting the other or more accurately not moving)

Sadly unless we get lucky in the loan market and Hodgson gets the finished article or top top quality like RLC I expect that to continue.

Maybe the academy players not being blocked by signings might help lol. Nice one Steve. We’re all 13.

It's never bad to err on the side of caution is it and considering our positioning today I think you're being slightly hard on our manager there.

So, are you being critical of our managers ability to move players forward with the ball? or are you being critical of the clubs ability to find suitable players to help our manager move the ball forward?

 

EddieMac Flag 07 Mar 20 10.08pm

Originally posted by Johng

I agree with all of this. We have been stubborn and resolute in defence but we have also very much had the rub of the green over the last few games. Zaha is not playing well and there is little penetration up front. Given that we're pretty much safe, I'd like to see Hodgson drop Wilf for a game or two and give Andros a run with either Jordan playing more on the left or centrally (putting CB on the bench and giving Schlupp a run too.

We are more than safe and the only time we looked in trouble was the weekend of the Newcastle game and the only reason we were in that trouble is because we were decimated with injuries over Xmas and beyond.

We now have a full strength squad to finish off the season and I for one am feeling very positive about it.

 

EddieMac Flag 07 Mar 20 10.15pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

We’ve played that way the whole season until Newcastle at home. I grant you Hodgson has had Parish and shareholders pile shyte on his plate but Hodgson has played the same stand off football since we lost RLC. We haven’t always needed to but we have.

Then we got into Newcastle’s faces, deserved that, edged the Brighton away game and edged this one v Watford imo seeing as they could’ve scored first. Either of those could’ve sen draws. Don’t get me wrong, I’m happy with the last 3 matches and strong performances even though we were slow to turn interceptions into attack today, but it isn’t just down to injuries as you think. He’ll leave attacking players on the bench when they’re needed or have us sitting back or holding back in possession whatever the score at times. It is Hodgson’s preferred football unless he has another RLC who carries the ball in addition to one or two wingers because there’s very little pattern of attacking play usually. In the RLC days there were a lot of triangles into the box but I haven’t seen much effective team play attacking wise this season for the most part. It’s far too slow and we don’t exploit the opposition caught running back or in front of the ball. We find ourselves letting them get behind the ball and we go back to CB or keeper. (Notice Macarthur and Zaha not understanding each other with balls either to run on to or come towards and Zaha expecting the other or more accurately not moving)

Sadly unless we get lucky in the loan market and Hodgson gets the finished article or top top quality like RLC I expect that to continue because we won’t do it without.

Maybe the academy players not being blocked by new signings might help lol. Nice one Steve. We’re all 13.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (07 Mar 2020 9.25pm)

IYou have mentioned a lot about how we used to play when we had RLC but we don’t have him anymore so it is impossible to play the same way. I do agree we played some lovely football around that time but we in a better position in the table and that will do me.

Are you trying to blame Roy on McCarthur and Zaha not understanding each other ? McCarthur’s passing was all over the shop today and has absolutely nothing to do with tactics.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Mar 20 10.17pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

It's never bad to err on the side of caution is it and considering our positioning today I think you're being slightly hard on our manager there.

So, are you being critical of our managers ability to move players forward with the ball? or are you being critical of the clubs ability to find suitable players to help our manager move the ball forward?

Both share criticism. Roy does not have to play the same way until Newcastle and Parish kerplunk with our squad has been taking liberties for years. Liberties with various situations and people.

Teams around the world do not play with RLC only or defensive training drills if they don’t. The speed at which we act after winning possession when the opposition are in front of the ball and not setup for our attack is inexcusable. Our player with the ball may as well put his studs on the ball, shout ‘Ready?’ and play the first pass sideways once we have 10-11 to play through.

I’m not asking for Pardew or FDB again but a bit more urgency. That has clearly not happened but could a bit more.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (07 Mar 2020 10.22pm)

 


COYP

Johng Flag 07 Mar 20 10.32pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

We are more than safe and the only time we looked in trouble was the weekend of the Newcastle game and the only reason we were in that trouble is because we were decimated with injuries over Xmas and beyond.

We now have a full strength squad to finish off the season and I for one am feeling very positive about it.

We only won that game because the opposition were very poor and because of an excellent free kick. The results against Brighton and Watford today were tight and could have gone either way (or been draws). Fortune has been smiling upon us but our performances have been scrappy and scoring goals is proving difficult. Our back line is immense but our Premier League status is unsustainable if we don't start to develop a more attacking style which properly builds with pace from our midfield.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Mar 20 10.43pm

Originally posted by Johng

We only won that game because the opposition were very poor and because of an excellent free kick. The results against Brighton and Watford today were tight and could have gone either way (or been draws). Fortune has been smiling upon us but our performances have been scrappy and scoring goals is proving difficult. Our back line is immense but our Premier League status is unsustainable if we don't start to develop a more attacking style which properly builds with pace from our midfield.

Right, apart from we were in Newcastle’s faces from the off. Maybe they weren’t prepared for that but Roy’s strategy on the day was a big factor in us beating Newcastle at home.

 


COYP

EddieMac Flag 07 Mar 20 11.06pm

Originally posted by Johng

We only won that game because the opposition were very poor and because of an excellent free kick. The results against Brighton and Watford today were tight and could have gone either way (or been draws). Fortune has been smiling upon us but our performances have been scrappy and scoring goals is proving difficult. Our back line is immense but our Premier League status is unsustainable if we don't start to develop a more attacking style which properly builds with pace from our midfield.

We won the Newcastle game because we scored a goal and won the game and deserved to win the game. Every game in this division is tight, the majority of games could have went either way and that includes a lot of Liverpool’s games including today’s against Bournemouth.

What do you expect in our games ? To be beating teams 5 and 6 nil?

 

EddieMac Flag 07 Mar 20 11.09pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Right, apart from we were in Newcastle’s faces from the off. Maybe they weren’t prepared for that but Roy’s strategy on the day was a big factor in us beating Newcastle at home.

And what about the other 9 wins this season ? Where they because of luck or our tactics or the opposition being rubbish?

We have won the same amount of games as Wolves who are high flying and in 5th position.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Mar 20 11.37pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

And what about the other 9 wins this season ? Where they because of luck or our tactics or the opposition being rubbish?

We have won the same amount of games as Wolves who are high flying and in 5th position.

We were not in the faces of most of those opponents. We either edge it or wait till the next week or the week after.

 


COYP

Eustace H. Plimsoll Flag Aldershot 08 Mar 20 12.30am

Originally posted by Johng

We only won that game because the opposition were very poor and because of an excellent free kick. The results against Brighton and Watford today were tight and could have gone either way (or been draws). Fortune has been smiling upon us but our performances have been scrappy and scoring goals is proving difficult. Our back line is immense but our Premier League status is unsustainable if we don't start to develop a more attacking style which properly builds with pace from our midfield.

As all the evidence clearly demonstrates.

Oh, wait...

 


As a woman, I can step aside, or step up my game...

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 08 Mar 20 1.57am

Originally posted by Johng

We only won that game because the opposition were very poor and because of an excellent free kick. The results against Brighton and Watford today were tight and could have gone either way (or been draws). Fortune has been smiling upon us but our performances have been scrappy and scoring goals is proving difficult. Our back line is immense but our Premier League status is unsustainable if we don't start to develop a more attacking style which properly builds with pace from our midfield.

How about saying our players played so brilliantly that they simply prevented Newcastle from doing anything and that PVA's brilliant free kick that won the game was indeed the icing on the cake ...now, does that not sound much better then what you wrote and does that not reflect what actually happened much better then what you wrote?

Also you're writing as if we now only have about three games to play and that we are practically doooomed! being stuck where Villa are lol .....get a grip man.

 

StrangerThing Flag Brisbane 08 Mar 20 5.04am

So it’s March, we are four points off a Champions League place, Benteke is looking good again, I have my tickets for Brisbane and Townsville, (the Roars badge is surreally wandering around the advertising hoardings) . If only I’d used the third wish to rid the world of the pandemic!

 

The Dolphin Flag 08 Mar 20 6.42am

Great result. Three single goal wins on the bounce. Three clean sheets. 39 points with 9 games to go. What's not to like!

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 08 Mar 20 8.27am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

We’ve played that way the whole season until Newcastle at home. I grant you Hodgson has had Parish and shareholders pile shyte on his plate but Hodgson has played the same stand off football since we lost RLC. We haven’t always needed to but we have.

Then we got into Newcastle’s faces, deserved that, edged the Brighton away game and edged this one v Watford imo seeing as they could’ve scored first. Either of those could’ve sen draws. Don’t get me wrong, I’m happy with the last 3 matches and strong performances even though we were slow to turn interceptions into attack today, but it isn’t just down to injuries as you think. He’ll leave attacking players on the bench when they’re needed or have us sitting back or holding back in possession whatever the score at times. It is Hodgson’s preferred football unless he has another RLC who carries the ball in addition to one or two wingers because there’s very little pattern of attacking play usually. In the RLC days there were a lot of triangles into the box but I haven’t seen much effective team play attacking wise this season for the most part. It’s far too slow and we don’t exploit the opposition caught running back or in front of the ball. We find ourselves letting them get behind the ball and we go back to CB or keeper. (Notice Macarthur and Zaha not understanding each other with balls either to run on to or come towards and Zaha expecting the other or more accurately not moving)

Sadly unless we get lucky in the loan market and Hodgson gets the finished article or top top quality like RLC I expect that to continue because we won’t do it without.

Maybe the academy players not being blocked by new signings might help lol. Nice one Steve. We’re all 13.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (07 Mar 2020 9.25pm)


Top post Rudi. With the emergence of Billy Gilmore at Chelsea I would be surprised if they would block an offer for RLC. If he was added to our emerging quality squad we could probably work around his physical issues by not playing him too much. A big buy.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 08 Mar 20 8.35am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider


Top post Rudi. With the emergence of Billy Gilmore at Chelsea I would be surprised if they would block an offer for RLC. If he was added to our emerging quality squad we could probably work around his physical issues by not playing him too much. A big buy.

Benteke Ayew etc in the dressing room corner near the end. Sheer class. Consumate skill. Magical moment. What an afternoon.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 08 Mar 20 8.37am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider


Top post Rudi. With the emergence of Billy Gilmore at Chelsea I would be surprised if they would block an offer for RLC. If he was added to our emerging quality squad we could probably work around his physical issues by not playing him too much. A big buy.

While I loved RLC when he was here surely the big issue is long term fitness. Has he even played a competetive match this season? He could be another Oxlade C / Walcott - on the sick bench more thn playing. You cant blow all your cash on a part time player.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 08 Mar 20 8.49am

Not a great spectacle, but we got what we deserved. Watford up to their old tactics of rotational fouling and clearly supported by a sub standard referee.

Not sure why Wilf was booked since he was the one being fouled time and again. The goal was well worked and Ayew took the chance really well too, the goal keepers view was blocked by the centre backs which helped.

You can’t argue with 3 x 1 nil wins back to back, can you?....

 

EddieMac Flag 08 Mar 20 8.59am

Originally posted by Tickled pink

How about saying our players played so brilliantly that they simply prevented Newcastle from doing anything and that PVA's brilliant free kick that won the game was indeed the icing on the cake ...now, does that not sound much better then what you wrote and does that not reflect what actually happened much better then what you wrote?

Also you're writing as if we now only have about three games to play and that we are practically doooomed! being stuck where Villa are lol .....get a grip man.

Well said.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 08 Mar 20 9.49am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider


Top post Rudi. With the emergence of Billy Gilmore at Chelsea I would be surprised if they would block an offer for RLC. If he was added to our emerging quality squad we could probably work around his physical issues by not playing him too much. A big buy.

Do you seriously think that our budget would enable us to pay top money for a player and then only play him selectively ?!

Dream on....

 


Old, Ungifted and White

EddieMac Flag 08 Mar 20 10.08am

Originally posted by NEILLO

Do you seriously think that our budget would enable us to pay top money for a player and then only play him selectively ?!

Dream on....

The post you replied to says a lot about the type of garbage that gets posted on this site.

 

Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Watford match thread