You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manager WishList
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Manager WishList


Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
A89M Flag Streatham 02 Aug 20 8.42am

Originally posted by CPFC1965

Top post, depends entirely on what you want, turgid football again coupled with relegation and no chance of bouncing back, or a fresh approach, relegation and a chance to bounce back. We haven't the finances to buy a new squad, we're lumbered with highly paid journeymen and have a manager who's incapable of making decisions that can affect a result. Remember the Euros when Kane took all the corners, our greatest threat was never in the middle. Hodgson is 10 years past his sell buy date, 7 straight losses and you still think he's up for it. We've bought a kid from West Brom, he'll go straight to the development squad and be forgotten.

Why is this the only option? Roy kept us up against all odds when he first came in and at the beginning of this season a lot of us thought that our squad wasn't good enough to stay up, especially with the last 7 fixtures being against the top teams - he managed to get us the points before this. Yet despite this, you still think we'll go down because of him rather than the clubs inability (at this point) to back their manager in the transfer market.
Give the man credit where its due, he's done a brilliant job of keeping us away from the relegation fight with what is really a poor squad.
If Wilf goes, Roy is the man I'd feel the most confident about keeping us up.

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 02 Aug 20 9.25am

Originally posted by A89M

Why is this the only option? Roy kept us up against all odds when he first came in and at the beginning of this season a lot of us thought that our squad wasn't good enough to stay up, especially with the last 7 fixtures being against the top teams - he managed to get us the points before this. Yet despite this, you still think we'll go down because of him rather than the clubs inability (at this point) to back their manager in the transfer market.
Give the man credit where its due, he's done a brilliant job of keeping us away from the relegation fight with what is really a poor squad.
If Wilf goes, Roy is the man I'd feel the most confident about keeping us up.

We're at the point where we were all hugely relieved with a point at home to Spurs after some atrocious performances.

The are 6 short weeks until the new season.
Palace are not an attractive proposition for a new manager nor any decent and ambitious players.
Roy will have to motivate an aging, overpaid squad, with one striker, to win games again. Sorry and I hope I'm wrong but I think we are fvcked.



 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 02 Aug 20 10.31am

Originally posted by A89M

Why is this the only option? Roy kept us up against all odds when he first came in and at the beginning of this season a lot of us thought that our squad wasn't good enough to stay up, especially with the last 7 fixtures being against the top teams - he managed to get us the points before this. Yet despite this, you still think we'll go down because of him rather than the clubs inability (at this point) to back their manager in the transfer market.
Give the man credit where its due, he's done a brilliant job of keeping us away from the relegation fight with what is really a poor squad.
If Wilf goes, Roy is the man I'd feel the most confident about keeping us up.

Very very correct.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 02 Aug 20 10.33am

Originally posted by Eaglehamster

We're at the point where we were all hugely relieved with a point at home to Spurs after some atrocious performances.

The are 6 short weeks until the new season.
Palace are not an attractive proposition for a new manager nor any decent and ambitious players.
Roy will have to motivate an aging, overpaid squad, with one striker, to win games again. Sorry and I hope I'm wrong but I think we are fvcked.



You are.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 02 Aug 20 10.46am

Originally posted by CPFC1965

Top post, depends entirely on what you want, turgid football again coupled with relegation and no chance of bouncing back, or a fresh approach, relegation and a chance to bounce back. We haven't the finances to buy a new squad, we're lumbered with highly paid journeymen and have a manager who's incapable of making decisions that can affect a result. Remember the Euros when Kane took all the corners, our greatest threat was never in the middle. Hodgson is 10 years past his sell buy date, 7 straight losses and you still think he's up for it. We've bought a kid from West Brom, he'll go straight to the development squad and be forgotten.

Top league football that's what we want and that's what we have ..stop moaning about the most experienced manager we've ever had, very very very few goals come from silly stupid corners, teams are at far more risk of having goals scored against them during one then scoring one themselves.

During that England game it was reported and witnessed that the squad let the manager down, nothing to do with anything Mr Hodgson did at all.

Edited by Tickled pink (02 Aug 2020 10.49am)

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 02 Aug 20 10.53am

Originally posted by the.universal

Thing that concerns me most about Howe is his defensive record. He had seasons to put it right and didn’t manage it.

The last 2 mangers we had who didn’t give a toss about defending were Holloway and Pardew, and both didn’t end too well.

Exactly.

 

BM Flag 02 Aug 20 10.57am

Originally posted by CPFC1965

Top post, depends entirely on what you want, turgid football again coupled with relegation and no chance of bouncing back, or a fresh approach, relegation and a chance to bounce back. We haven't the finances to buy a new squad, we're lumbered with highly paid journeymen and have a manager who's incapable of making decisions that can affect a result. Remember the Euros when Kane took all the corners, our greatest threat was never in the middle. Hodgson is 10 years past his sell buy date, 7 straight losses and you still think he's up for it. We've bought a kid from West Brom, he'll go straight to the development squad and be forgotten.

The biggest red herring in football history is that England failed because Harry Kane took corners.

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 02 Aug 20 11.01am

Credit is given to Roy for keeping us up. No problem with that. Yet no credit at all for what Eddie Howe has achieved at Bournemouth.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 02 Aug 20 11.03am

Originally posted by BM

The biggest red herring in football history is that England failed because Harry Kane took corners.

Quite right. In fact it was a brilliant plan. Just didn't quite work out, due to bad luck.

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Aug 20 12.03pm

Originally posted by Eaglehamster

Like us then except we can't organise an attack.


True but we're still in the EPL.
At the end of the day, if you get your defence right you will have a better chance of staying up or achieving. Look at
1. the difference Virgil makes to the Scousers
2. the loss of Kompany without a decent replacement to the results of Citeh this season
3. Jose's philosophy wherever he goes
4. the early Wenger teams
Potterball nearly got the Weed relegated and Howe's focus on attacking football did get Bournemouth relegated.
Whilst Roy is too defensive IMO, he can still only work with what he's got, which let's face it is not a great deal on the attacking front.

Edited by doombear (02 Aug 2020 12.03pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 02 Aug 20 2.27pm

Originally posted by BM

The biggest red herring in football history is that England failed because Harry Kane took corners.

[Link]

To be fair you are right though. England failed as they didn’t attack with any pace or look like there was any kind of coherence.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 02 Aug 20 2.36pm

Originally posted by doombear


True but we're still in the EPL.
At the end of the day, if you get your defence right you will have a better chance of staying up or achieving. Look at
1. the difference Virgil makes to the Scousers
2. the loss of Kompany without a decent replacement to the results of Citeh this season
3. Jose's philosophy wherever he goes
4. the early Wenger teams
Potterball nearly got the Weed relegated and Howe's focus on attacking football did get Bournemouth relegated.

Whilst Roy is too defensive IMO, he can still only work with what he's got, which let's face it is not a great deal on the attacking front.

Edited by doombear (02 Aug 2020 12.03pm)

All valid points - but in 8 months time Roy will retire (hopefully on a high - with us winning a cup) and we must look to a long term solution. I get the defensive concerns re Howe - I share them. But Howe is still learning and developing as a manager. I’m sure he will improve this - even more so if he has the support of Roy in some other capacity at the club.
I can’t loose sight of the fact that he took Bournemouth- who were a crumby little club in the lower divisions to successive promotions (Playing a brand of football that was widely admired) and kept them in the EPL for 4 seasons Bournemouth FFS! I know he spent lots of money in recent years but he did have some terrible luck with key injuries too!

I know it’s the Palace way - but if we don’t act fast and line him up now, I fear we’ll miss out on this and end up admiring his West Ham team progressing up the league for years to come.


 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 Aug 20 2.36pm

Originally posted by doombear


True but we're still in the EPL.
At the end of the day, if you get your defence right you will have a better chance of staying up or achieving. Look at
1. the difference Virgil makes to the Scousers
2. the loss of Kompany without a decent replacement to the results of Citeh this season
3. Jose's philosophy wherever he goes
4. the early Wenger teams
Potterball nearly got the Weed relegated and Howe's focus on attacking football did get Bournemouth relegated.
Whilst Roy is too defensive IMO, he can still only work with what he's got, which let's face it is not a great deal on the attacking front.

Edited by doombear (02 Aug 2020 12.03pm)

I can’t see how anyone can argue with this post

 

mattteo Flag 02 Aug 20 9.17pm

Originally posted by doombear

At the end of the day, if you get your defence right you will have a better chance of staying up or achieving.


Actually no. If you have a better attack than defense yoi have more chances of staying up. Say you win 3 matches with 4-3 and lose 3 with 3-4. You have 9 points out of 6 matches.


If you win 1 match with 1-0,draw 4 0-0 or 1-1 and lose 1 match with 0-1, you have 7 points from 6 matches.

Multiply that by 38 matches. Yes,Bournemouth got relegated because they were poor defrnsively. But their attack wasn't that great either this year, with Callum Wilson not being the same, Ryan Fraser playing rarely as a starter and youngster Harry Wilson not being able to save them on his own. Also, injuries of David Brooks, Groenveld and many times Stanislas gave them few options.

But usually you get a higher chance of staying up with a good attack than with a good defence. It's mathematics. Of course, defence should not be neglected either. But it's better to play for 3 points even if it's once every 2 games than hold out for 2 draws.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 02 Aug 20 10.34pm

Originally posted by mattteo


Actually no. If you have a better attack than defense yoi have more chances of staying up. Say you win 3 matches with 4-3 and lose 3 with 3-4. You have 9 points out of 6 matches.


If you win 1 match with 1-0,draw 4 0-0 or 1-1 and lose 1 match with 0-1, you have 7 points from 6 matches.

Multiply that by 38 matches. Yes,Bournemouth got relegated because they were poor defrnsively. But their attack wasn't that great either this year, with Callum Wilson not being the same, Ryan Fraser playing rarely as a starter and youngster Harry Wilson not being able to save them on his own. Also, injuries of David Brooks, Groenveld and many times Stanislas gave them few options.

But usually you get a higher chance of staying up with a good attack than with a good defence. It's mathematics. Of course, defence should not be neglected either. But it's better to play for 3 points even if it's once every 2 games than hold out for 2 draws.

Build from the back always, if Benteke had performed even to half of his ability from his first season with us we would have achieved much higher and with much more joy for the watching fans.

 

Ian-VI Flag Vicenza 03 Aug 20 7.59am

Originally posted by mattteo


If you have a better attack than defense yoi have more chances of staying up.

This is never true.
Ask any manager at any level.
The teams winning leagues or staying up are in most occasions the ones with less goals conceded, not with the most goals scored. Look at the just finished Premier, Serie A etc.

Defending is much easier and less tiring than attacking, plus, if you don't concede you have at least a point, but if you concede you need to be certain to score, just to get a point.

And we are the living proof of this...

Edited by Ian-VI (03 Aug 2020 8.01am)

 


The best footie management game: [Link]

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 03 Aug 20 8.04am

Originally posted by mattteo


Actually no. If you have a better attack than defense yoi have more chances of staying up. Say you win 3 matches with 4-3 and lose 3 with 3-4. You have 9 points out of 6 matches.


If you win 1 match with 1-0,draw 4 0-0 or 1-1 and lose 1 match with 0-1, you have 7 points from 6 matches.

Multiply that by 38 matches. Yes,Bournemouth got relegated because they were poor defrnsively. But their attack wasn't that great either this year, with Callum Wilson not being the same, Ryan Fraser playing rarely as a starter and youngster Harry Wilson not being able to save them on his own. Also, injuries of David Brooks, Groenveld and many times Stanislas gave them few options.

But usually you get a higher chance of staying up with a good attack than with a good defence. It's mathematics. Of course, defence should not be neglected either. But it's better to play for 3 points even if it's once every 2 games than hold out for 2 draws.


in your mathematical scenario, both teams stay up. However, the attack strategy is higher risk because

W D L
3 0 3 (9pts)
can easily become
2 0 4 (6pts)
or even
1 0 5 (3pts)

whereas
W D L
1 4 1 (7pts)
may become
1 3 2 (6pts)
or even
1 2 3 (5pts)

If you are leading 1-0 with an attacking strategy you will not feel as comfortable as if that lead is with a defensive strategy.

It is well documented that we are the team with the fewest goals to stay up and the first team to fail to score 3 goals in any match and still stay up and yet we were safe before lockdown.

Furthermore, if we exclude the away game against Citeh where we led, fell behind and then drew, there were only two games where we took the lead and dropped points (Wolves at home and So'ton away) 4 points dropped, whereas we came back from losing positions to gain wins in both games against West Ham and draws against Arsenal (twice), Brighton, Norwich and Spurs (11 points gained from losing positions excluding the Citeh game).

How many points did teams like Bournemouth, West Ham and Villa drop from winning positions because of their dodgy defences?

In summary I would argue that a strategy based on a sound defence will over time prove more successful than one based on attack.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 03 Aug 20 8.09am

Personally I don’t see what is wrong with having a good attack and defence. It doesn’t have to be one or the other

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 03 Aug 20 8.13am

Roy Hodgson's ideal world - 38 0-0 results, 38 points, 17th position.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 03 Aug 20 8.51am

A bit left field, but, a good piece & under the radar

[Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Manager WishList