This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
England v Wales. It might be a big game for the English fans (and maybe, perhaps, the players) but is met with indifference from a lot of the Welsh population. On the political side, a commentator (I think it was Roy Keane) summed it up pretty much last night. Why are fans moaning about beer restrictions (and crusader costumes), when they travelled to Qatar, being completely aware of their way of life and how provocative some actions might be.? And I think the one consolation for Wales is that Wayne won't be eligible to play against England after his red card. You'd think they'd have enough common sense wouldn't you? As for the LGBT issue, why not make your views known ONCE and get on with the tournament. It's an issue that existed when FIFA awarded the tournament to Qatar and might have been properly addressed then. However, it was conveniently overlooked ... I wonder why? Edited by Henry of Peckham (26 Nov 2022 7.16am)
Denial is not just a river in Egypt |
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
England v Wales. It might be a big game for the English fans (and maybe, perhaps, the players) but is met with indifference from a lot of the Welsh population. On the political side, a commentator (I think it was Roy Keane) summed it up pretty much last night. Why are fans moaning about beer restrictions (and crusader costumes), when they travelled to Qatar, being completely aware of their way of life and how provocative some actions might be.? And I think the one consolation for Wales is that Wayne won't be eligible to play against England after his red card. Edited by Forest Hillbilly (26 Nov 2022 5.07am) I guess it's hard for a country to be too passionate about a sport that they're never going to win anything in, or even qualify for the major tournaments in on a regular basis. It's like here in Malta, the locals all follow England or Italy as the national team are terrible. As to Keane, does anyone listen to that bloke? I do agree that players shouldn't be forced to get involved in politics, but having said that if you believe in freedom of speech (which I do) then I also don't think they should be gagged either. Qatar chose to host the tournament which was a political act in itself; it can't have been that naïve to think Westerners might challenge its regime and some of its more abhorrent laws. I see Saudi Arabia are considering bidding for a World Cup in the future, that could be an interesting conversation between Shearer and Linekar.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
I guess it's hard for a country to be too passionate about a sport that they're never going to win anything in, or even qualify for the major tournaments in on a regular basis. It's like here in Malta, the locals all follow England or Italy as the national team are terrible. As to Keane, does anyone listen to that bloke? I do agree that players shouldn't be forced to get involved in politics, but having said that if you believe in freedom of speech (which I do) then I also don't think they should be gagged either. Qatar chose to host the tournament which was a political act in itself; it can't have been that naïve to think Westerners might challenge its regime and some of its more abhorrent laws. I see Saudi Arabia are considering bidding for a World Cup in the future, that could be an interesting conversation between Shearer and Linekar. I agree with you. However I think the FA is backing itself into a difficult corner by (effectively) supporting the wearing of the rainbow armband but reluctantly asking players not to do so. When we return to normal football and players want to wear armbands in support of all sorts of causes, what will the FA do?
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
England v Wales. It might be a big game for the English fans (and maybe, perhaps, the players) but is met with indifference from a lot of the Welsh population. On the political side, a commentator (I think it was Roy Keane) summed it up pretty much last night. Why are fans moaning about beer restrictions (and crusader costumes), when they travelled to Qatar, being completely aware of their way of life and how provocative some actions might be.? And I think the one consolation for Wales is that Wayne won't be eligible to play against England after his red card. Edited by Forest Hillbilly (26 Nov 2022 5.07am) I agree. Edited by The Dolphin (26 Nov 2022 9.17am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by YT
I agree with you. However I think the FA is backing itself into a difficult corner by (effectively) supporting the wearing of the rainbow armband but reluctantly asking players not to do so. When we return to normal football and players want to wear armbands in support of all sorts of causes, what will the FA do? Probably support the wearing of them as long as kneeling remains alongside self flagellation due to all blokes being misogynistic bstards !
|
|
|
If KSA were awarded the tournament at least you would know where you stood, conservative dress code, no booze, no public displays of affection of any persuasion & acceptance that the Saudi take on anything else will remain pretty much the same as it was before the tournament was awarded-its a lot more clear cut & in many ways that would probably be easier to live with, if you cant accept that then don't travel - Originally posted by taylors lovechild
I guess it's hard for a country to be too passionate about a sport that they're never going to win anything in, or even qualify for the major tournaments in on a regular basis. It's like here in Malta, the locals all follow England or Italy as the national team are terrible. As to Keane, does anyone listen to that bloke? I do agree that players shouldn't be forced to get involved in politics, but having said that if you believe in freedom of speech (which I do) then I also don't think they should be gagged either. Qatar chose to host the tournament which was a political act in itself; it can't have been that naïve to think Westerners might challenge its regime and some of its more abhorrent laws. I see Saudi Arabia are considering bidding for a World Cup in the future, that could be an interesting conversation between Shearer and Linekar.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Harry Kane putting the world to rights. I'm sure we've all done this. Funny how this has not been highlighted, 6(six) teams at this WC have Addidas as their kit supplier. ALL their warm-up/training tops are white, with the black 3 stripes on the sleeve, BUT, at the end of the sleeve it morphs into rainbow colours. The comms only decided to mention Wales before they lost to Iran.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
If KSA were awarded the tournament at least you would know where you stood, conservative dress code, no booze, no public displays of affection of any persuasion & acceptance that the Saudi take on anything else will remain pretty much the same as it was before the tournament was awarded-its a lot more clear cut & in many ways that would probably be easier to live with, if you cant accept that then don't travel - The one positive that I hope comes out of this World Cup is that FIFA recognises you can't give a major tournament to a country that persecutes people based on their race, sexuality or faith. Personally I would say they should actually make it a requisite that a host country must not have any laws in place that persecute minorities. You want a major sports tournament then change your laws. Whether you agree or disagree with the actions taken by players and countries in response to FIFA and Qatar, I think all but a small section of backwash drinkers agree that making homosexuality illegal is barbaric. Also, I noticed the stadium was half empty yet again by the second half once the Qataris realised they were going to lose. I suppose when your country gives you everything without having to work for it then you feel entitled.
|
|
|
Just doing the devils advocate thing here - Major sporting events introduce guidelines that no country that persecutes anyone can hold major tournaments - the list of eligible countries is formed, everyone else realises that they cannot be considered as host unless they change their ways or form a breakaway group, which of those 2 alternatives do you think would happen? Originally posted by taylors lovechild
The one positive that I hope comes out of this World Cup is that FIFA recognises you can't give a major tournament to a country that persecutes people based on their race, sexuality or faith. Personally I would say they should actually make it a requisite that a host country must not have any laws in place that persecute minorities. You want a major sports tournament then change your laws. Whether you agree or disagree with the actions taken by players and countries in response to FIFA and Qatar, I think all but a small section of backwash drinkers agree that making homosexuality illegal is barbaric. Also, I noticed the stadium was half empty yet again by the second half once the Qataris realised they were going to lose. I suppose when your country gives you everything without having to work for it then you feel entitled.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
The one positive that I hope comes out of this World Cup is that FIFA recognises you can't give a major tournament to a country that persecutes people based on their race, sexuality or faith. Personally I would say they should actually make it a requisite that a host country must not have any laws in place that persecute minorities. You want a major sports tournament then change your laws. Whether you agree or disagree with the actions taken by players and countries in response to FIFA and Qatar, I think all but a small section of backwash drinkers agree that making homosexuality illegal is barbaric. Also, I noticed the stadium was half empty yet again by the second half once the Qataris realised they were going to lose. I suppose when your country gives you everything without having to work for it then you feel entitled. FIFA only recognise money, dont kid yourself they will change.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dubai Eagle
Just doing the devils advocate thing here - Major sporting events introduce guidelines that no country that persecutes anyone can hold major tournaments - the list of eligible countries is formed, everyone else realises that they cannot be considered as host unless they change their ways or form a breakaway group, which of those 2 alternatives do you think would happen? They probably wouldn't change their laws, but I doubt they would form a breakaway group either. I mean, these countries would hardly be that missed. In sporting terms they need tournaments like the World Cup far more than the tournaments need them. I write about the Middle East for work from time to time and they seem desperate to diversify their economies away from their strong oil dependence and sport seems a key part of their strategy to drive tourism and to create a more positive image. I saw the other day a man was sentenced to death in Saudi Arabia for refusing to leave his home to make way for a Mega City project. Having said that, we'd have our new stand by now if we could take similar steps...maybe we should think more like Newcastle supporters. Who cares about human rights if we can have success on the pitch?!
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
The one positive that I hope comes out of this World Cup is that FIFA recognises you can't give a major tournament to a country that persecutes people based on their race, sexuality or faith. Personally I would say they should actually make it a requisite that a host country must not have any laws in place that persecute minorities. You want a major sports tournament then change your laws. Whether you agree or disagree with the actions taken by players and countries in response to FIFA and Qatar, I think all but a small section of backwash drinkers agree that making homosexuality illegal is barbaric. Also, I noticed the stadium was half empty yet again by the second half once the Qataris realised they were going to lose. I suppose when your country gives you everything without having to work for it then you feel entitled. On the first point why should the tournament be restricted to countries that hold my views. Their house their rules whether I like them or not. No country is without sin. Russia, Argentina neither great paragons of liberal ideals. And homosexuality was illegal here 50 years ago. Oh we are so advanced!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
It must be the most boring football tournament ever, i have watched 2 second half's, does anyone really care what happens, i think i would rather watch I'm a celebrity, which i hate. Several of the matches have been pretty good. Worst match I've seen is England last night. I watch them on Irish TV and there's no virtue signalling. Still idiot pundits and commentators but they're too scared/polite to say anything. We must want some of that money.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
On the first point why should the tournament be restricted to countries that hold my views. Their house their rules whether I like them or not. No country is without sin. Russia, Argentina neither great paragons of liberal ideals. And homosexuality was illegal here 50 years ago. Oh we are so advanced! You're right, no country is without sin, but if those sins are enshrined in law then we have an issue. How can you promote equality and then give rewards to a country which persecutes people? Also, we're not living in the past. Should countries committing genocide be allowed to hold major tournaments? Or ones that have segregation laws? I mean, those things were very real 50 years ago (and even more recently) so based on your argument why should that be important now. Also, it's one thing saying you don't agree with homosexuality, it's a whole other thing beating and imprisoning people for it. Given people within Qatar can't speak up by law, it is important that others speak up for them. Qatar isn't a democratic country. People in Qatar do not have a voice. While people might be bothered by what they perceive to be virtue signalling those complaints sound pretty daft when you consider how some people suffer for being gay in a country like Qatar.
|
|
|
Julie Burchill wrote that this World Cup could turn out to be football's Altamont.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
These LGBQ protests in Qatar are hypocritical. If you had a real problem with it you shouldn't have gone. Nearly a hundred years ago, Eric Liddell refused to run in the qualifying heats of the 100 metres at the 1924 Paris Olympic Games, because they were held on a Sunday. That had a real consequence as he was forced to withdraw from his best event. A principle isn't really a principle if you aren't prepared to suffer for it. Instead, it's a performative declaration...aka a virtue signal. We get told that it's wrong for religious people to impose their beliefs onto others. That they shouldn't tell others how to live their lives and what is right and what is wrong. Yet, what we see here is precisely that from secularist societies. They think they can tell others how their societies should be and in effect it's the same moral superiority. The 'diversity' that they speak of is just a ruse for the simple minded. It's kind of amusing in a way considering the liberal left use to be all about moral relativism....but as you get older you come to realise that for many 'principles' are just a means to an ends and will be discarded just as easily as they are used......all that matters is winning. Footballers should respect the culture of the land they chose to play in and play football and not politics. Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Nov 2022 12.38pm) I think I would say doing something is better than doing nothing. Of course if senior players or teams pulled out that would be a bigger signal of intent, but I think FIFA cleverly left it to the last second to silence them. It seems to me the players believed they may at least have a platform to try and deliver a message, whether you or I believe that message would have any effect we'll never know. As it is the only people seeing any of these messages will largely be in countries which already protect the rights of LBTQ+ people, as in countries like Qatar and Saudi Arabia it is against the law to question those in power and any of these messages will be edited out, as were the Iranian protests in Iran. Personally I don't have any respect for the rules and laws of dictatorships, or countries which base their laws on inhumane interpretations of ancient texts. If you accept a country's laws on the basis of 'respect' then where do you draw the line? Should we also ignore the Taliban using Sharia law to justify amputations or beheadings? It's one thing saying you shouldn't take the moral high ground, but when people are speaking out against being imprisoned for being gay I think that's a pretty low bar. I mean, do you yourself actually think it's ok for people to be beaten and imprisoned for being gay? Do you personally think that law should be respected? I would hope not.
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
I think I would say doing something is better than doing nothing. Of course if senior players or teams pulled out that would be a bigger signal of intent, but I think FIFA cleverly left it to the last second to silence them. It seems to me the players believed they may at least have a platform to try and deliver a message, whether you or I believe that message would have any effect we'll never know. As it is the only people seeing any of these messages will largely be in countries which already protect the rights of LBTQ+ people, as in countries like Qatar and Saudi Arabia it is against the law to question those in power and any of these messages will be edited out, as were the Iranian protests in Iran. Personally I don't have any respect for the rules and laws of dictatorships, or countries which base their laws on inhumane interpretations of ancient texts. If you accept a country's laws on the basis of 'respect' then where do you draw the line? Should we also ignore the Taliban using Sharia law to justify amputations or beheadings? It's one thing saying you shouldn't take the moral high ground, but when people are speaking out against being imprisoned for being gay I think that's a pretty low bar. I mean, do you yourself actually think it's ok for people to be beaten and imprisoned for being gay? Do you personally think that law should be respected? I would hope not.
I understand the point you’re making TL but it still amounts to the same thing. Residents of these nations might turn round to us and point out huge single motherhood, a benefits system, the mutilation of children for anti-scientific ideology, knife culture, allowing paedophiles and murderers to live instead of chopping their bonces off, mass consumption of alcohol etc. etc. I think the point Stirling is making, and I agree with, is that whilst it’s ok to criticise and call out etc. it’s quite frankly none of our business - many horrific things have happened throughout history as a result of ‘moral high ground’ being assumed then used as an excuse to interfere with foreign peoples/territories. It is the hypocrisy and nonsensity of modern liberalism. Everyone is free to do, say and think what they want to do so long as it aligns with the central narrative. You can’t accept mass amounts of money to stage a tournament and play football from a country then turn round in the same instance and say oh btw, whilst I’m here, you’re all monsters, so I’ll take your dirty money as I am so committed to my principles, proactively, but lambast you. It’s a bit like Hitler moving the rally from Nuremberg to Jerusalem for financial reasons. The bottom line is that were people true to their principles, it would be insane to suggest staging a WC, having virtue signalled in alignment to liberal ideologies for so long, in such an intolerant nation where many rules and regulations stipulate the exact opposite to the ideology you have been trumpeting. I thought that was a pretty ubiquitous sentiment across the globe and therefore the scrutiny and ridiculing of this WC?? Anyway, as Mike Bassett would say ‘good goal Poland’, good match in the end! Edited by Nicholas91 (26 Nov 2022 3.00pm)
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.