You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Brighton vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread
November 16 2026 3.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Brighton vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread


Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
southnorwoodhill Flag 16 Mar 23 9.16am

Originally posted by becky

What is it with all this cr*p people post about players 'lacking confidence'?

These are not junior trainees, these are grown men, supposedly professional footballers being paid hundreds of thousands of pounds a year to accurately and consistently kick a bag of wind around a pitch and put it inside 3 posts!

It's what they practice for for several hours, 5/6 days a week, so why is it so difficult, and why should they lack 'confidence' with all the benefits of a Premiership set up behind them?

We had too much of this nonsense with Benteke - let's pl;ease not now start attributing it to the whole team...... or if it is then get a bl**dy psychologist in to sort them out!

Sorry, rant over!

Poor things, nasty Mr Derry shouted at them and they still haven't fully recovered...

 

SwordFish Flag Peasmarsh,East Sussex 16 Mar 23 9.18am

Originally posted by becky

What is it with all this cr*p people post about players 'lacking confidence'?

These are not junior trainees, these are grown men, supposedly professional footballers being paid hundreds of thousands of pounds a year to accurately and consistently kick a bag of wind around a pitch and put it inside 3 posts!

It's what they practice for for several hours, 5/6 days a week, so why is it so difficult, and why should they lack 'confidence' with all the benefits of a Premiership set up behind them?

We had too much of this nonsense with Benteke - let's pl;ease not now start attributing it to the whole team...... or if it is then get a bl**dy psychologist in to sort them out!

Sorry, rant over!

I agree Becky to an extent however most of them are young lads given fame and fortune very quickly and it can do things to your head , if I was given fortune and fame I’d be dead in a year as I would spend on things that arnt good for me , and these lads would be the same without direction, confidence will still be an issue when the world is watching to young lads

 


“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder

barrie2301 Flag crystal palace 16 Mar 23 9.53am

The confidence issues come from the set up and management..

PV has constantly set us up for damage limitation against teams that we are capable of beating, but he has drilled into them that they are not capable, it obvious form how the players are approaching games.

The FA Cup Semi last year really highlighted to me how PV approaches a match..

He drops players for countless matches, brings them when we are chasing the game, and then complains they didn't do enough.

Olise is a young kid learning his game, has played a part in almost ever match this season so obviously in favour with PV, yet PV threw him under the bus after the mistake he made in the box last week..

PV does not know what hes doing, has not really brought anything to the club in terms of taking us to the next level.

I hope the club see sense and get rid, PV is not ready for this level of management..

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 16 Mar 23 10.02am

Originally posted by becky

What is it with all this cr*p people post about players 'lacking confidence'?

These are not junior trainees, these are grown men, supposedly professional footballers being paid hundreds of thousands of pounds a year to accurately and consistently kick a bag of wind around a pitch and put it inside 3 posts!

It's what they practice for for several hours, 5/6 days a week, so why is it so difficult, and why should they lack 'confidence' with all the benefits of a Premiership set up behind them?

We had too much of this nonsense with Benteke - let's pl;ease not now start attributing it to the whole team...... or if it is then get a bl**dy psychologist in to sort them out!

Sorry, rant over!

100%

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

taylors lovechild Flag 16 Mar 23 10.02am

Originally posted by becky

What is it with all this cr*p people post about players 'lacking confidence'?

These are not junior trainees, these are grown men, supposedly professional footballers being paid hundreds of thousands of pounds a year to accurately and consistently kick a bag of wind around a pitch and put it inside 3 posts!

It's what they practice for for several hours, 5/6 days a week, so why is it so difficult, and why should they lack 'confidence' with all the benefits of a Premiership set up behind them?

We had too much of this nonsense with Benteke - let's pl;ease not now start attributing it to the whole team...... or if it is then get a bl**dy psychologist in to sort them out!

Sorry, rant over!

They're human regardless of how much they get paid. Being high on confidence is massive in football; look what it has done to fairly average players like March for Brighton or Almiron at Newcastle. Rashford gets some belief back and suddenly everything he touches turns to gold. Alex Ferguson always maintained it was about momentum and wins breed confidence, but the opposite is also true, you only have to look at Chelsea for an obvious example of that.

 

Swindy Flag Bromley 16 Mar 23 10.14am

'Sorry but I can't agree with the negative vibes ringing out against Parish (who effectively saved our club from near liquidation) and Vieira.
We are not owned by a board with a bottomless pit of cash (some of it borrowed thanks to FA rules) nor are we owned by ruthless, unethical Saudi princes. There is a real community heart to our club that all has it's distinctive value/ importance.'

Sorry, first part of this is irrelevant now. A lot of water has gone under the bridge since then.
Also, 'if we are not owned by a board with a bottomless pit of cash', is it not the job of said board to do something about that, ie increased investment/sell out ?
Sadly, the result of their complacency is now coming home to roost !!

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 16 Mar 23 10.21am

Originally posted by Swindy

We are not owned by a board with a bottomless pit of cash (some of it borrowed thanks to FA rules) nor are we owned by ruthless, unethical Saudi princes. There is a real community heart to our club that all has it's distinctive value/ importance.'

We are owned by a board with a bottomless pit of cash but unfortunately they don't wish to spend any more on taking the club to the next level.

I read a lot about the "community heart to our club" but am not quite sure what you mean as only two of the regular first team came through the academy and half aren't even English

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 16 Mar 23 10.24am

I know there is a a lot of negativity, but I'll put my tin hat on try to be a bit more optimistic.

We had some shots! And if not for some wasteful finishing we might have scored a goal or 2.

Vieira's tactics worked very well early on. Whilst not revolutionary, it shows that the coaching set up know how to set up a team.

It was a very different shape without that ball than I've seen before. Wilf and Olise tucking right in to almost play as CM's, CD stuck on Mac Allister. Unless he went too far and then Anderson stepped out. It was instrumental in stopping them playing and us creating chances.

The goal was against the run of play and sometimes you have to hold your hands up. Sharp movement, perfectly timed run, great finish.

Unfortunately Doucoure went a bit mental and was incredibly lucky not to get sent off. We are then in a much trickier position, Luka doesn't have the legs to keep up with Mac Allister, and we have no Hughes. So he gambled with Eze. Who looked lost for most of the 2nd half. Mac Allister started to get more ball and dominate.

We had a decent flurry late on, Eze starting to find his grove, Ahamada looking spritely. JPM with a nice interchange.


Although it feels it, I don't think we are a million miles off. And think we lack 2 things:

Bravery with the ball - too often we pass back, because its no risk, when there is a completely makable pass inside/forward. If there is any pressure at all, the ball always goes back. Clyne is a key culprit of this, sh1ts himself every time he has the ball. As a result we always allow teams to organise themselves.

Urgency in attack - In Olise, Zaha and Eze, we have players who are dead talented but love more touches than needed. Coupled with the inverted wingers means we are always checking back and holding the ball vs capitalising and getting a ball in. Zaha must have got to the by line about 5 times last night, and ever time he checked back and either lost the ball or passed back. Olise was the same.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 16 Mar 23 10.49am

Originally posted by Plumpton eagle

Sorry but I can't agree with the negative vibes ringing out against Parish (who effectively saved our club from near liquidation)

---------------------------------------------------------------

I am sorry but that defence is no longer valid. We are all grateful but after 10 years in the Prem it is no longer relevant. Somehow, we are now going backwards. Seeing clubs similar to us, like Brighton, Fulham & Brentford, pulling ahead is painful to watch.

I think "the management" has been sidetracked by the new stand, indecision in strategy, direction and investment. Even the pre-season was a shambles with half the squad in Australia and the rest at home.

I do believe that the focus was on trying everything to get Gallagher back either in the summer or January. I think there was an assumption that we would not be in a relagation scrap. This has resulted in a dangerously thin squad low on quality and numbers.

Anything at Arsenal would be an absolute bonus. I hope that the international break is used to kick start the team. The World Cup break seems to have been disastrous for us. We need to come out fighting after the next break. One win might change everything.

Given my past comment's replies, I stand corrected and particularly bow to this assessment.

 

SnapperKain Flag SE25 6PU 16 Mar 23 11.15am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

They're human regardless of how much they get paid. Being high on confidence is massive in football; look what it has done to fairly average players like March for Brighton or Almiron at Newcastle. Rashford gets some belief back and suddenly everything he touches turns to gold. Alex Ferguson always maintained it was about momentum and wins breed confidence, but the opposite is also true, you only have to look at Chelsea for an obvious example of that.

You know, I use to think like this but I'm with Becky on this one. As Becky said, they train day in and day out on the best way to play football, in the most elite league in the world and are paid absolutely ridiculously staggering amounts of money to do so. The team lacking confidence, cry me a river frankly as I'm sure getting in their Bentley's and driving back to their mansions after losing last night must have been so hurtful for them, as the rest of caught a wet and cold train back to East Croydon.

I'm not buying it as an excuse anymore. As Becky said, we heard that about Benteke for what, 6 years? If I was in their position I think I'd be pretty confident in myself, it's just an excuse and they need to get over themselves frankly.


Edited by SnapperKain (16 Mar 2023 11.16am)

 


The trouble with computers, of course, is that they're very sophisticated idiots

SnapperKain Flag SE25 6PU 16 Mar 23 11.15am

Whoops duplicate!

Edited by SnapperKain (16 Mar 2023 11.16am)

Edited by SnapperKain (16 Mar 2023 11.16am)

 


The trouble with computers, of course, is that they're very sophisticated idiots

palace chick Flag South Croydon 16 Mar 23 11.21am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I know there is a a lot of negativity, but I'll put my tin hat on try to be a bit more optimistic.

We had some shots! And if not for some wasteful finishing we might have scored a goal or 2.

Vieira's tactics worked very well early on. Whilst not revolutionary, it shows that the coaching set up know how to set up a team.

It was a very different shape without that ball than I've seen before. Wilf and Olise tucking right in to almost play as CM's, CD stuck on Mac Allister. Unless he went too far and then Anderson stepped out. It was instrumental in stopping them playing and us creating chances.

The goal was against the run of play and sometimes you have to hold your hands up. Sharp movement, perfectly timed run, great finish.

Unfortunately Doucoure went a bit mental and was incredibly lucky not to get sent off. We are then in a much trickier position, Luka doesn't have the legs to keep up with Mac Allister, and we have no Hughes. So he gambled with Eze. Who looked lost for most of the 2nd half. Mac Allister started to get more ball and dominate.

We had a decent flurry late on, Eze starting to find his grove, Ahamada looking spritely. JPM with a nice interchange.


Although it feels it, I don't think we are a million miles off. And think we lack 2 things:

Bravery with the ball - too often we pass back, because its no risk, when there is a completely makable pass inside/forward. If there is any pressure at all, the ball always goes back. Clyne is a key culprit of this, sh1ts himself every time he has the ball. As a result we always allow teams to organise themselves.

Urgency in attack - In Olise, Zaha and Eze, we have players who are dead talented but love more touches than needed. Coupled with the inverted wingers means we are always checking back and holding the ball vs capitalising and getting a ball in. Zaha must have got to the by line about 5 times last night, and ever time he checked back and either lost the ball or passed back. Olise was the same.

I think that’s my view as well about last night and City the other day. We nearly got favourable results in both. Let’s get the arsenal game out the way and prepare for Leicester and the matches after. Hopefully we will get the results to stay up but it’s going to be a close thing. I also hope we stick with Edouard up front as chopping and changing doesn’t help the team or him. A bit more luck last night and the result goes our way. It’s a thin line and we are missing confidence at the moment which will come back once we get a win or just on the scoreboard? Hopefully the international break will get Hughes and our keepers back and even Macca.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 16 Mar 23 11.44am

Originally posted by SnapperKain

You know, I use to think like this but I'm with Becky on this one. As Becky said, they train day in and day out on the best way to play football, in the most elite league in the world and are paid absolutely ridiculously staggering amounts of money to do so. The team lacking confidence, cry me a river frankly as I'm sure getting in their Bentley's and driving back to their mansions after losing last night must have been so hurtful for them, as the rest of caught a wet and cold train back to East Croydon.

I'm not buying it as an excuse anymore. As Becky said, we heard that about Benteke for what, 6 years? If I was in their position I think I'd be pretty confident in myself, it's just an excuse and they need to get over themselves frankly.


Edited by SnapperKain (16 Mar 2023 11.16am)

I'm not saying we should feel sorry for them, but you'd have to be blind not to see how low on confidence some of the players are. How you fix that is another matter, but I'd be more concerned if the players looked like they didn't care. It's a shame McArthur has seemingly become injured again as he is a real leader and someone capable of lifting the team.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 16 Mar 23 11.56am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Urgency in attack - In Olise, Zaha and Eze, we have players who are dead talented but love more touches than needed. Coupled with the inverted wingers means we are always checking back and holding the ball vs capitalising and getting a ball in. Zaha must have got to the by line about 5 times last night, and ever time he checked back and either lost the ball or passed back. Olise was the same.

I keep on saying it, but this is a massive issue for me.

Zaha has developed the habit of holding the ball too long for a number of reasons.

Firstly. mindset. He has been the big fish in a small pond for too long. He does of course have confidence bordering on arrogance (as do most top players), but the habits we see now result from an almost unique experiment entitled 'What happens when an entire top-flight club relies on one player forever?'. He is partly being selfish when he holds the ball, but mostly just accepting the responsibility the club has heaped on his shoulders.

Secondly, tactics. We have moved him from the wing (including the right) where his job was to beat his man and cross it, to left-inside forward, and now to centre forward. We stopped asking him to cross it, and asked him to try and score. For many years we have left him to do that alone. He rarely has any runners past him, only support behind. He actually has a surprisingly good awareness of others and weight of pass, he just rarely gets to use either.

Third, declining pace. He has come back far too soon from hamstring injuries far too often. He cannot knock it past a fullback and race him over 10 yards anymore. A sure sign of a lazy pundit is when they say 'Palace have threat on the break with Zaha, Eze and Olise'. None of them are fast in a sprint, and Zaha in particular isn't. That's why so many counterattacks die a death at his feet.

Fourth, quality of teammate. Some of the absolute s*** we have had, and continue to have, upfront is enough to make any winger keep the ball.


The forth point is all that matters now. We can't change the first three in respect of Zaha, but Olise and Eze will develop the same tendencies if we cannot find a striker with good movement they can look for when in possession.


Edited by TheBigToePunt (16 Mar 2023 12.46pm)

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 16 Mar 23 12.55pm

Did we score yet .

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 16 Mar 23 1.36pm

Doucoure to be replaced with deep midfield role and passing ability for Andersen, Richards in back 4.

Originally posted by MrRobbo

I know there is a a lot of negativity, but I'll put my tin hat on try to be a bit more optimistic.

We had some shots! And if not for some wasteful finishing we might have scored a goal or 2.

Vieira's tactics worked very well early on. Whilst not revolutionary, it shows that the coaching set up know how to set up a team.

It was a very different shape without that ball than I've seen before. Wilf and Olise tucking right in to almost play as CM's, CD stuck on Mac Allister. Unless he went too far and then Anderson stepped out. It was instrumental in stopping them playing and us creating chances.

The goal was against the run of play and sometimes you have to hold your hands up. Sharp movement, perfectly timed run, great finish.

Unfortunately Doucoure went a bit mental and was incredibly lucky not to get sent off. We are then in a much trickier position, Luka doesn't have the legs to keep up with Mac Allister, and we have no Hughes. So he gambled with Eze. Who looked lost for most of the 2nd half. Mac Allister started to get more ball and dominate.

We had a decent flurry late on, Eze starting to find his grove, Ahamada looking spritely. JPM with a nice interchange.


Although it feels it, I don't think we are a million miles off. And think we lack 2 things:

Bravery with the ball - too often we pass back, because its no risk, when there is a completely makable pass inside/forward. If there is any pressure at all, the ball always goes back. Clyne is a key culprit of this, sh1ts himself every time he has the ball. As a result we always allow teams to organise themselves.

Urgency in attack - In Olise, Zaha and Eze, we have players who are dead talented but love more touches than needed. Coupled with the inverted wingers means we are always checking back and holding the ball vs capitalising and getting a ball in. Zaha must have got to the by line about 5 times last night, and ever time he checked back and either lost the ball or passed back. Olise was the same.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 16 Mar 23 1.57pm

Originally posted by becky

What is it with all this cr*p people post about players 'lacking confidence'?

We had too much of this nonsense with Benteke - let's pl;ease not now start attributing it to the whole team...... or if it is then get a bl**dy psychologist in to sort them out!

Sorry, rant over!

Yes, and, looking further back, with Ade Akinbiyi and Gareth Taylor, both of whom would go on a scoring spree once they'd got their first goal - some hope!

 

Terry Ven Flag 16 Mar 23 2.50pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

To me last night's result and performance stemmed from very low confidence rather than tactics. We caught Brighton off guard by playing the high press and really should have taken the lead, but as soon as we went 1-0 down the players visibly seemed to sink deeper. Andersen made fewer long passes and the ones he did didn't find their man, Eze was awful and showed no belief in himself, Olise was too slow to make decisions, Mitchell's crosses were poor and Edouard looked lost.

Doucoure for all his hard work (and a couple of goal-saving challenges) needs to learn when to hold back from a challenge. I think he was saved by the fact Caicedo had just made a similar challenge without getting booked. Eze was the wrong player to replace him with as it gave Brighton more freedom in midfield and I have to say Mac Allister was head and shoulders the best player on the pitch. At least he won't be with Brighton next season (unless they break his legs). The one change I'll never understand is replacing Olise with Ayew when we're losing (unless he was injured). Ayew is a player who is much better defensively and at holding onto the ball, but that's it.

The only way confidence improves is with a win. Brighton were so bad at passing out from the back it was like they felt sorry for us. Arsenal will not be so generous and it is hard to see anything but a resounding defeat. While I've been more patient with Vieira than most in the end it is all about results and he must know his time is running out.

It goes without saying that Whitworth should be our MOTM for stepping up and being brave.

"Brighton were so bad at passing out from the back"??? I must have been at a different game to you! They only got it wrong once that i recall, but otherwise they passed us us death. We had some encouraging moments when our high press rattled them out of their stride but frankly they were playing the football...

 

CT Charlie Flag 16 Mar 23 3.36pm

Challenges:

1) We don't have a single attacker who is fast.

2) Only Wilf is a skilled enough dribbler to beat defenders 1 v 1. Ayew can draw fouls, but he seldom creates a shot. Eze can slip past defenders only in midfield and while on the run. Olise can step behind a defender, but he must then deliver the ball immediately or he'll be caught.

3) No member of the squad is above average at heading of the ball. Most are below the Prem standard.

Unless Vieira & staff can drill some wonderfully creative or intricate patterns of movement into the squad, goals will mostly derive from mistakes and second chances afforded us by the opposition.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 16 Mar 23 3.39pm

Originally posted by CT Charlie

Challenges:

1) We don't have a single attacker who is fast.

2) Only Wilf is a skilled enough dribbler to beat defenders 1 v 1. Ayew can draw fouls, but he seldom creates a shot. Eze can slip past defenders only in midfield and while on the run. Olise can step behind a defender, but he must then deliver the ball immediately or he'll be caught.

3) No member of the squad is above average at heading of the ball. Most are below the Prem standard.

Unless Vieira & staff can drill some wonderfully creative or intricate patterns of movement into the squad, goals will mostly derive from mistakes and second chances afforded us by the opposition.

Why do we just pass free kicks along the back line? We win some of the most fouls in the league yet do nothing with our free kicks. When you're not scoring would you not be better off to get the big guys in the box and launch it in.
In fairness, was the same with Roy too, however, we were scoring some from open play then.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Brighton vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread