This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Casual
He needs to do what AWB did, when he got his chance. Come in and be in droppable. Morgan Gibbs White was on loan in the Championship at the age of 22. Gallagher and Mount were there at the age of 20. Guess it depends what doing 'it' means - AWB had a phenomenal season and went to Man Utd for £50m which is very rare. Rak-Sakyi could have a very successful career at Palace as Ayew's successor given Ayew is 33 at the start of next season - play across the front 3, solid player for us, doesn't ever threaten the Champions League transfer market. I think expecting him to jump from League 1 to the PL and instantly be undroppable is asking a heck of a lot, especially as many big money summer signings that are new to the PL often take months to settle in.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
Assuming Olise and Franca get back fit, it'll make a lot of sense for Rak-Sakyi to spend January - May in a Championship side. He'll get a bit of game time over the coming weeks but whatever happens, he need 20+ games this season and he'll be unlikely to get that volume at Palace when the injuries recover. Even if we don't sign anyone, we have 4 attacking spots and Eze, Olise, Ayew, Franca, Edouard, Mateta, Schlupp would expect to be ahead of him. You’re putting Franca straight in the team above Rak-Sakyi. You do realise Franca is only 19 years old in a strange country and never kicked a ball outside Brazil.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
You’re putting Franca straight in the team above Rak-Sakyi. You do realise Franca is only 19 years old in a strange country and never kicked a ball outside Brazil. You might be incorrectly assuming that he never swapped the golden sands of Copacabana Beach for a five a side on Bognor Regis beach whilst staying at Butlins?!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Goalpost1
You might be incorrectly assuming that he never swapped the golden sands of Copacabana Beach for a five a side on Bognor Regis beach whilst staying at Butlins?! He only went along on that holiday for the carnival atmosphere and beautiful women in Bognor apparently, not for footballing reasons. Edited by Nicholas91 (10 Oct 2023 2.50pm)
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
You’re putting Franca straight in the team above Rak-Sakyi. You do realise Franca is only 19 years old in a strange country and never kicked a ball outside Brazil. You think the club have spent £25m on a player that, in the second half of his debut season, they expect to be behind Rak-Sakyi, who is behind Ayew, who is behind Olise, in the pecking order? Even if we were to say they're even, Rak-Sakyi is the one that would go out on loan. Rak-Sakyi is the one who knows how the team plays, is settled in England, and really needs volume of game time. Franca is the one who needs to get used to the club, his teammates and the intensity of training and games in the Premier League and they're not going to achieve that by sending him to Bristol City for 6 months.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Confused(.com) Do you want to give him a chance, like Zaha, Moses, Mitchell. Or, do you want him to dissappear into another league? Back the lad, sink or swim, or would you rather have us pay for an expensive 'has-been' The club have a responsibility to harvest his potential and that is not going to be achieved by sitting him on the bench just to make up the numbers with the odd cameo appearance for a few minutes in games here and there. He clearly has potential otherwise he would not be where he is but he needs to have regular game time for example to sharpen the skills coaches can't give him and that is for example things like match craft and playing experience. putting him out at EPL level before he is ready may destroy him as he will not get the space or time that he has been used to in the U21 or out in league two. He needs a run in the championship to earn his spurs and build confidence. I am not asking for him to disappear all I want for him is for his progression to be carefully managed in a positive way that allows him to progress to EPL level. Rush him before he is ready and that could ruin him.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
The club have a responsibility to harvest his potential and that is not going to be achieved by sitting him on the bench just to make up the numbers with the odd cameo appearance for a few minutes in games here and there. He clearly has potential otherwise he would not be where he is but he needs to have regular game time for example to sharpen the skills coaches can't give him and that is for example things like match craft and playing experience. putting him out at EPL level before he is ready may destroy him as he will not get the space or time that he has been used to in the U21 or out in league two. He needs a run in the championship to earn his spurs and build confidence. I am not asking for him to disappear all I want for him is for his progression to be carefully managed in a positive way that allows him to progress to EPL level. Rush him before he is ready and that could ruin him. Thank you Den1923, you want him out, go somewhere else, doesn't matter where, as long as its not CPFC. That is my understanding of your post. Pity our other 'prospects' from the Academy.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Thank you Den1923, you want him out, go somewhere else, doesn't matter where, as long as its not CPFC. That is my understanding of your post. Pity our other 'prospects' from the Academy. I really do not know what you are talking about, its quite normal for younger players of EPL clubs to go out on loan to hone their skills in order that they then return with match skills earned in the championship, so that the step up to EPL playing conditions is much easier for them!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
I agree with what you say, he is not really ready for the EPL and needs to have a run in the championship to sharpen up his match skills and improve his physicality. Whilst I wish him well it going to hard to to this, by keeping the bench warm each week for a few minutes here and there. According to research, the odds are not really in his favour as only 30% of all academy players who get handed a professional contract, of that latter group 1-10 then go on to make more than 20 appearances at all tiers of full time English professional football. It's a tough call and I wish him the best of luck! With his performances for Charlton he demonstrated that he is already good enough to be a professional footballer. The question is at what level? We saw enough from him at the weekend to say that it still could be this level. I don't think he is the finished article, but I do think that this team is solid and disciplined enough to give him half a chance of succeeding. (Lets be honest he's not going to have to slot in for ward when he bombs forward!).
|
|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
With his performances for Charlton he demonstrated that he is already good enough to be a professional footballer. The question is at what level? We saw enough from him at the weekend to say that it still could be this level. I don't think he is the finished article, but I do think that this team is solid and disciplined enough to give him half a chance of succeeding. (Lets be honest he's not going to have to slot in for ward when he bombs forward!). Exactly, and just like Olise/Eze who both proved themselves in the championship before moving up a level and it it would also be good for JSR to go out on lone to get that experience so that he can hopefully the move up to EPL level and enjoy a long and happy career at the elite level of world football with Crystal Palace!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Den1923
Exactly, and just like Olise/Eze who both proved themselves in the championship before moving up a level and it it would also be good for JSR to go out on lone to get that experience so that he can hopefully the move up to EPL level and enjoy a long and happy career at the elite level of world football with Crystal Palace! I know we beat Lyon in a friendly, but world domination might take a bit longer
|
|
| palace99 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
With his performances for Charlton he demonstrated that he is already good enough to be a professional footballer. The question is at what level? We saw enough from him at the weekend to say that it still could be this level. I don't think he is the finished article, but I do think that this team is solid and disciplined enough to give him half a chance of succeeding. (Lets be honest he's not going to have to slot in for ward when he bombs forward!). Good post. He has proven himself in Div 1 (quite an achievement when he was only 19 when the loan started) and Championship teams are clearly interested.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
Morgan Gibbs White was on loan in the Championship at the age of 22. Gallagher and Mount were there at the age of 20. Guess it depends what doing 'it' means - AWB had a phenomenal season and went to Man Utd for £50m which is very rare. Rak-Sakyi could have a very successful career at Palace as Ayew's successor given Ayew is 33 at the start of next season - play across the front 3, solid player for us, doesn't ever threaten the Champions League transfer market. I think expecting him to jump from League 1 to the PL and instantly be undroppable is asking a heck of a lot, especially as many big money summer signings that are new to the PL often take months to settle in.
Fair points mate. But when the majority of eze, Dacoure, lerma, ahmada, , Franca and olise are fit , I’m not sure Rak -saki makes the bench.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Casual
Fair points mate. But when the majority of eze, Dacoure, lerma, ahmada, , Franca and olise are fit , I’m not sure Rak -saki makes the bench. I'm sure you may well be right, Franca excepted, as we have not seen him yet, from what I understand and have read he is still work in progress and of course he has no proven experience EPL football.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Casual
Fair points mate. But when the majority of eze, Dacoure, lerma, ahmada, , Franca and olise are fit , I’m not sure Rak -saki makes the bench. I think that's probably right, but then you have to consider whether all of Eze, France and Olise will all be fit and in form at the same time, all the time, and when we will sell one or two of them. Rak-Sakyi is possibly part of the succession planning, whether he goes on loan to the championship or not.
|
|
|
Originally posted by TheBigToePunt
I think that's probably right, but then you have to consider whether all of Eze, France and Olise will all be fit and in form at the same time, all the time, and when we will sell one or two of them. Rak-Sakyi is possibly part of the succession planning, whether he goes on loan to the championship or not.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.