This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
ManU V CPFC EFL Cup
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Davepalace707 Northumberland 26 Sep 23 10.12pm |
|
|
No surprise tonight given the team we put out. We’d just better hope we don’t get any more injuries. Edouarde out is going to be a big loss. Never thought I’d say that.
|
Nicholas91 The Democratic Republic of Kent 26 Sep 23 10.21pm |
|
|
Just about as bad as it gets tonight:
- Paper thin squad getting even worse - Only spent any recognisable money on two players who’ve mustered 15mins between them - (I’m guessing) state of squad leaves Roy feeling as though we’re unable to compete on more than one front (PL) - Even fringe players recognising that it’s not worth bothering in cup - JRS very far off being first team worthy and probably won’t ever get there - We offer very little in attack and nothing with one or two not in starting XI
Might just be me hitting peak despondency over tonight’s game but you can’t help but feel we should offer far, far more than we did tonight. Felt like a bit of a ‘f**k you’ to travelling fans which is where my empathy lies.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!
|
cannongilbert 26 Sep 23 10.31pm |
|
|
What we desperately need is a right back.JRS was completely outclassed, Jairo was not bad, I can't understand his labelling as not premier league standard and based on today's showing, Holding was a waste of money.Lets see a little more of that 18year old Ozoh in the future.Of course January is the time to spend some money on one or two decent signings.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Sep 23 10.32pm |
|
|
Dire and dreadful. I expected such an outcome.
|
Eaglehamster Storrington 26 Sep 23 10.33pm |
|
|
Probably wouldn't be last in the MOTD!
For years we've been sh1te without Wilf, now we're sh1te without Olise.
It's all beginning to feel very deja vu.
I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.
|
NE14T 26 Sep 23 10.41pm |
|
|
I’d never thought I’d be looking forward so much to see Ward back in the starting 11 again.
Edited by NE14T (26 Sep 2023 10.42pm)
The beatings will stop when morale improves.
|
Elpis In a pub 26 Sep 23 10.45pm |
|
|
didn't learn anything there that we didn't already know
Henderson gets injured a lot Holding is /will be way down the pecking order Full backs not good enough in the system we play that leaves them exposed to the switch in play JRS not ready Riedwald is decent with the ball but not so good without it Women commentators make me turn the volume off We still need a striker Eze is the only player that lights us up Other regulars that played looked bored Man utd second string is better than ours
Hopfully will give a better account of ourselves on Saturday and pass the ball forward a few times more than we did tonight
COYP
|
palace chick South Croydon 26 Sep 23 11.50pm |
|
|
Completely outclassed tonight. Been heading that way for last few weeks. Let’s hope the only 11 players we have that can play this Saturday can do better? Our reserves that played tonight showed they aren’t good enough :-( Even the first teamers played tonight were under par which didn’t help. Hopefully we will give them a better game on Saturday - I have my doubts?
|
southnorwoodhill 27 Sep 23 6.10am |
|
|
As each day passes the Henderson signing is proving a total mystery. How can a keeper get injured making a simple clearance? Utd laughing all the way to the bank. £20m, unbelievable. As for Holding, when the big club you pick him up from are more than happy with the few million you give them then you know he's going to be just a bit s***.
|
Spiderman Horsham 27 Sep 23 6.24am |
|
|
But Utd will have their first team out and we will be trying to play containment football
|
Spiderman Horsham 27 Sep 23 6.27am |
|
Originally posted by Pinkfluff1981
You’re actually right. I just slated Roy for his tactics but given the players he’s got to choose from he ain’t got a lot of options. We just ain’t good enough with the players we got available
I believe SP disagrees with you
|
chrisjackie Settle, North Yorkshire 27 Sep 23 6.34am |
|
|
Not sure I want to read all the treads but what I would say is the Palace Fans humour in that complete S**T show is the only positive thing - what fans in the country would still show support (OK sing sarcastic songs) ? I salut everyone who makes the effort and will be there again on Saturday. I am just relieved that we only got back at midnight after our 1.5hr journey north! p.s now I know why Joel Ward is a better choice than Clyne (oh my!)
Stay in the Yorkshire Dales - visit [Link] run by Palace Fans!
|
dreamwaverider London 27 Sep 23 8.02am |
|
|
Call me old fashioned but as soon as our boy came on with his socks half down I knew we had another dud. Pull your socks up.
|
PatrickA London 27 Sep 23 8.08am |
|
|
Anything learned from last night wasn't positive. Henderson got injured undertaking a very simple kick. Normally this could be passed off as a unlucky incident, but he has a track record of picking up injuries so it doesn't bode well.
Holding is not a dominant centre half who excels in the air or overpowers opponents.I recall him being bullied by physical players when he was at Arsenal and he lacks recovery pace. Maybe not a huge issue as he's not first choice, but I wouldn't want to rely upon him to be as first choice.
JRS doesn't look ready. It would be unfair to write him off yet, but I noted that he appeared very disheartened in the first half when Amarabat eased him off the ball with ease. JRS didn't try to take him on after that. At the same age, Wilf would have been spitting feathers and made it a personal mission to keep trying to get past his opponent.
A night to forget perhaps and move on to Saturday when we'll put out a more competitive team.
|
MrRobbo Chaldon 27 Sep 23 8.59am |
|
|
As many have pointed out the lessons were already known.
What's so disappointing to me is the subs and squad management. With the context of Roy saying we didnt have the squad to give it a proper go he then went on to:
Haul JRS of at HT, embarrassing that lad and likely killing his confidence
Decided at 3 nil, when the game was already lost to risk 2 of the players that he'd wanted to protect
Only gave Ozoh 10 mins
Didnt bother bringing Ebiowei on at all
And as a result Ayew, JPM (our only striker) and Mitchell (our only LB) played 90mins and will all start at the weekend
I'm genuinely at a loss
|
monkey Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 27 Sep 23 9.15am |
|
Originally posted by MrRobbo
As many have pointed out the lessons were already known.
What's so disappointing to me is the subs and squad management. With the context of Roy saying we didnt have the squad to give it a proper go he then went on to:
Haul JRS of at HT, embarrassing that lad and likely killing his confidence
Decided at 3 nil, when the game was already lost to risk 2 of the players that he'd wanted to protect
Only gave Ozoh 10 mins
Didnt bother bringing Ebiowei on at all
And as a result Ayew, JPM (our only striker) and Mitchell (our only LB) played 90mins and will all start at the weekend
I'm genuinely at a loss
I’d just turned round to my daughter a minute before and said he won’t bring Eze on now, he won’t risk him now the games gone. So that one baffled me as well.
|
DANGERCLOSE London 27 Sep 23 9.16am |
|
|
Match ratings
Piss poor
|
southnorwoodhill 27 Sep 23 9.32am |
|
Originally posted by monkey
As close to throwing in the towel in a competition as you can get without making it look too obvious
Edited by monkey (26 Sep 2023 10.03pm)
Yes indeed. If one examines our previous performances in this particular competition under Hodgson it becomes pretty apparent that it has been decided that our priorities lay elsewhere. However, one must make it look as though one is trying, and have the handy book of excuses ready, just in case.
Edited by southnorwoodhill (27 Sep 2023 9.41am)
|
palace99 New Mills 27 Sep 23 9.45am |
|
Originally posted by Elpis
didn't learn anything there that we didn't already know
Henderson gets injured a lot Holding is /will be way down the pecking order Full backs not good enough in the system we play that leaves them exposed to the switch in play JRS not ready Riedwald is decent with the ball but not so good without it Women commentators make me turn the volume off We still need a striker Eze is the only player that lights us up Other regulars that played looked bored Man utd second string is better than ours
Hopfully will give a better account of ourselves on Saturday and pass the ball forward a few times more than we did tonight
COYP
A good summary. In terms of Saturday, not only do we need to pass the ball forward we need to do it at speed. The slow build up never goes anywhere.
Early in the game Mateta won a free kick in their half - we took it short and it went back to the goalie. I thought free kicks were an attacking opportunity. Ridiculous
|
new_in_Wait Lewisham 27 Sep 23 9.48am |
|
Originally posted by monkey
I’d just turned round to my daughter a minute before and said he won’t bring Eze on now, he won’t risk him now the games gone. So that one baffled me as well.
I *think* the point there was to give Eze (our only game-changing player) the chance to play a bit against MU in preparation for Saturday. Just to find his feet between the MU lines and measure up against Casemiro (who will most likely play Saturday).
|