You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Forest match thread
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Forest match thread


Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
eaglesdare Flag 09 Oct 23 10.15am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Olise-esque.

I think Jes has the ability, he just severely lacks confidence which I'd think it extremely harsh to put him down for, he's a young lad breaking into the PL for the first time.

My hope is that we do blood him well and with a bit more confidence gained we'll see the finished article at some point. May just be me but the sense I got of him was that he is currently stifled by the necessity and inclination to just 'not f**k up' which is prominent at the top level now (look at the boring Arsenal vs City game yesterday).

I perhaps optimistically like to imagine with a loosening of inhibition and risk aversion, we may see the full potential of what he has to offer as a winger and attacking player. Either way, he should have our full support until then.

I did notice that forest doubled up on Rak Saki when he came on. he will do well when we get another attacking player back playing the other side.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 09 Oct 23 10.47am

I'd be worried if I was Forest after Saturday - they've played essentially a Palace reserve/Carabao Cup side and in the second half in particular were under pressure for long periods. There won't be many worse 11s they come up against this season.

Very good point in the context of a shocking injury list. Guehi and Andersen in particular really stepped up and took a lot of responsibility in that performance. Clear that some in that squad are carrying small injuries too, Edouard being one.

Delighted that we've now got a week off. Just getting Lerma and Doucoure back will make a huge difference to the team's ability to play higher up the field.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

palace99 Flag New Mills 09 Oct 23 11.09am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

All in all, a good performance everything considered.

I'm not sure any manager around can do what Roy does. Its isn't pretty, but they make it very difficult for teams to play against. ITs certainly not progressive but I'm glad we have him to navigate us at the moment.

The positives are that we've got a really solid defensive unit. and tactically everyone knows what to do.

Add Olise, Eze and the future balon dor winner Franca into the mix and that looks like a very good team. And a much more healthy squad.

It's funny how many supporters felt the performance was good.

Personally, i'm delighted with the point, but let's be honest we rode our luck at times and only really had 1 real chance in the whole 90 minutes.

Yes, we had injuries, but some of these have been out all season (Olise etc) and from the team that won at Man U there were only 2 real changes (Eze and Doucoure) as surely Ward for clyne is a like for like.
Whilst the line up had no natural creativity they were all experienced prem players. Maybe supporters are being too generous?

Whilst i blame the board for the lack of investment in attacking positions and Roy's line up and game plan was pragmatic seeing my team running down the clock for most of the game was quite disappointing IMHO.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 09 Oct 23 11.09am

I've only managed to catch the forest-centric MOTD highlights so Far on this game, but suffice to say when I saw Doucoure out as well as Lerma; and saw a midfield of Hughes, Jairo and Schlupp, I thought we we're gonna have a bad day.
amazed that we managed to keep a clean sheet and get a point from this game. Well done lads..Our Defence is top-notch.


 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

TrickyboyVn Flag Ho Chi Minh City 09 Oct 23 11.11am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

To be fair that was the only mistake I recall him making. He really is a solid keeper and all round I think a slight improvement on Guaita.

He's one of our better players tbh and love having him there.

Why on earth we paid 20m for back up (whose now injured) ??

We could have got a good midfield creative for that (almost) - should have gone for Ward-Prowse

Reideweld (know I've spelt that wrong) is so off the pace and never a PL player.

Good see Hughesy getting run of games.

But as one poster says 12 points from 8 games is admirable considering state of squad.

COYP

 

TrickyboyVn Flag Ho Chi Minh City 09 Oct 23 11.16am

However, though JRS was a breath of fresh air and fair play to the lad.

He's like a new signing too and with a few games could really help us.

Well done JRS you did great for a youngster and hope you go on to great things (with us tho)

 

Painter Flag Croydon 09 Oct 23 1.28pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Olise-esque.

I think Jes has the ability, he just severely lacks confidence which I'd think it extremely harsh to put him down for, he's a young lad breaking into the PL for the first time.

My hope is that we do blood him well and with a bit more confidence gained we'll see the finished article at some point. May just be me but the sense I got of him was that he is currently stifled by the necessity and inclination to just 'not f**k up' which is prominent at the top level now (look at the boring Arsenal vs City game yesterday).

I perhaps optimistically like to imagine with a loosening of inhibition and risk aversion, we may see the full potential of what he has to offer as a winger and attacking player. Either way, he should have our full support until then.

Rak- Sakyi is 2 years older and more experienced than Franca, who is being built up as a wonder kid. People are expecting these youngsters to be prolific straight away, it isn’t going to happen, it takes time a Roy knows exactly how to introduce young players.
I have a nagging feeling that Franca will be another Max Meyer, introduced with huge hype, but couldn’t deliver.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 09 Oct 23 2.07pm

Originally posted by Painter

Rak- Sakyi is 2 years older and more experienced than Franca, who is being built up as a wonder kid. People are expecting these youngsters to be prolific straight away, it isn’t going to happen, it takes time a Roy knows exactly how to introduce young players.
I have a nagging feeling that Franca will be another Max Meyer, introduced with huge hype, but couldn’t deliver.

I too share that anxiety but rather than anticipating his failure I'm just lightening my expectations for Franca to be some sort of hybrid of Ronaldinho, Kaka and R9. It'll be what it'll be and I'll spare judgment until then.

The thought of equating any youngster to a winning lottery ticket is prominent amongst fans and I've always had a problem with this. Very, very few top professionals have burst onto the scene and set it alight immediately. I'm more inclined toward the approach/attitude you've articulated for youngsters Painter, and see us as fans and a club adopt that approach, as opposed to billing them as 'the next x' immediately only to shoot them down if they fall short of this.

I recently discovered Johnny Williams is only 30 which shocked me and goes to show that I heard more hype for him, and for longer, than I think even his playing career has now been. He wasn't quite Iniesta and wasn't ever going to be. Let JRS improve until such a point his finished article isn't enough or his progress too slow for us to accommodate it.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 09 Oct 23 3.09pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I too share that anxiety but rather than anticipating his failure I'm just lightening my expectations for Franca to be some sort of hybrid of Ronaldinho, Kaka and R9. It'll be what it'll be and I'll spare judgment until then.

The thought of equating any youngster to a winning lottery ticket is prominent amongst fans and I've always had a problem with this. Very, very few top professionals have burst onto the scene and set it alight immediately. I'm more inclined toward the approach/attitude you've articulated for youngsters Painter, and see us as fans and a club adopt that approach, as opposed to billing them as 'the next x' immediately only to shoot them down if they fall short of this.

I recently discovered Johnny Williams is only 30 which shocked me and goes to show that I heard more hype for him, and for longer, than I think even his playing career has now been. He wasn't quite Iniesta and wasn't ever going to be. Let JRS improve until such a point his finished article isn't enough or his progress too slow for us to accommodate it.

At least players like Campana and Williams went on to have decent enough careers. Williams was a Wales regular. We don't know about Rak-Sakyi or Franca yet. I should look up what happened to that lazy idiot Meyer. I'm thinking Belgian league two or three. Read a piece on Sorloth the other day. A half decent striker now apparently. Funny how these things happen.

 


Red and Blue Army!

palace99 Flag New Mills 09 Oct 23 4.38pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

At least players like Campana and Williams went on to have decent enough careers. Williams was a Wales regular. We don't know about Rak-Sakyi or Franca yet. I should look up what happened to that lazy idiot Meyer. I'm thinking Belgian league two or three. Read a piece on Sorloth the other day. A half decent striker now apparently. Funny how these things happen.

Whilst Jonny Williams' career has been severely limited by injuries, it is surely a stretch to say he has had a decent career after leaving us.
After leaving for Charlton (on a free) he played 2 of his 3 seasons in div 1 and after a brief spell in the championship with Cardiff, where he was released, he has played the last 3 seasons in div 2.
I have watched his progress over the last 5 or 6 seasons and he rarely plays a full 90 minutes.
Although he still gets in the Wales squads, most of his appearances seem to be off the bench.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 10 Oct 23 4.39am

My thoughts were the experience of Ayew, Hughes, Guehi and Anderson helped get us the point. We will hopefully in due course be able to bring in Henderson (if selected) Ward, Doucoure, Lerma, Eze, Olise, Schlupp and Franca (if selected) Our bench will then include players like Hughes, Clyne, Richards, Rak Saki as well as Riedwald (who will surely come on for the run out) and we are going to be very competitive.
Feel the Newcastle and Spurs games though are going to come at a bad time for us with our injury crisis and they both been teams in good form.

Edited by viveasheagle (10 Oct 2023 4.53am)

 

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Oct 23 4.47am

Originally posted by TrickyboyVn

He's one of our better players tbh and love having him there.

Why on earth we paid 20m for back up (whose now injured) ??

We could have got a good midfield creative for that (almost) - should have gone for Ward-Prowse

Reideweld (know I've spelt that wrong) is so off the pace and never a PL player.

Good see Hughesy getting run of games.

But as one poster says 12 points from 8 games is admirable considering state of squad.

COYP

Eww god no.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 10 Oct 23 6.15am

Umm Ward Prowse has proven to be a bit of an inspiration for Wet Spam, I know we used to be frustrated with him because he was always winding Wilf Up but he can still contribute.

Originally posted by sprites

Eww god no.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 10 Oct 23 6.59am

Originally posted by Painter

Rak- Sakyi is 2 years older and more experienced than Franca, who is being built up as a wonder kid. People are expecting these youngsters to be prolific straight away, it isn’t going to happen, it takes time a Roy knows exactly how to introduce young players.
I have a nagging feeling that Franca will be another Max Meyer, introduced with huge hype, but couldn’t deliver.

I have the opposite feeling to you and have a feeling he is going to shine given time. Some players seem to have this calm assurance about them which I get off Franca, plus if you watch his reels he seems adept at what we are good at which is counter-attacking at speed with strength and skill. Hodgson was also unusually candid (for him) after watching him in training in saying the lad clearly has talent.

The fact is we aren't going to know until he gets on the pitch and with our current injury crisis that might be sooner rather than later.

 

YT Flag Oxford 10 Oct 23 7.33am

Originally posted by TrickyboyVn

He's one of our better players tbh and love having him there.

Why on earth we paid 20m for back up (whose now injured) ??

We could have got a good midfield creative for that (almost) - should have gone for Ward-Prowse

Reideweld (know I've spelt that wrong) is so off the pace and never a PL player.

Good see Hughesy getting run of games.

But as one poster says 12 points from 8 games is admirable considering state of squad.

COYP

I think that's the Dutch version of the stuff you pour in when your car radiator leaks and which, perhaps appropriately in the context, never works very well.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 10 Oct 23 7.40am

Originally posted by TrickyboyVn

He's one of our better players tbh and love having him there.

Why on earth we paid 20m for back up (whose now injured) ??

We could have got a good midfield creative for that (almost) - should have gone for Ward-Prowse

Reideweld (know I've spelt that wrong) is so off the pace and never a PL player.

Good see Hughesy getting run of games.

But as one poster says 12 points from 8 games is admirable considering state of squad.

COYP

Agree but spam had something we didnt , European football , so such is , but Lerma is just as good sadly injured at the moment

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 10 Oct 23 8.34am

Originally posted by mtp1958

Agree but spam had something we didnt , European football , so such is , but Lerma is just as good sadly injured at the moment

Indeed and he was transferred for £30 Mill !
Lerma, free transfer and thus far has proved an inspired purchase.
I was not aware that JWP was ever on our radar.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 10 Oct 23 8.47am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Umm Ward Prowse has proven to be a bit of an inspiration for Wet Spam, I know we used to be frustrated with him because he was always winding Wilf Up but he can still contribute.

Bloody right, he would’ve been a great signing, especially now Wilf has gone, as soon as JWP buried his first free kick in the top corner, I think I would’ve forgiven him.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 10 Oct 23 8.52am

This is pure wild speculation, but when JWP wasn't picked for England (again) I couldn't help but wonder if his antics with Wilf are what has cost him his place. Southgate is often a guest at Palace and seems to have some connections with us still. Is it possible he remembers JWP being a little rat and decided he didn't want that around England? I would find that hilarious if that was the case. It's unlikely, but regardless each time he isn't picked I have a little chuckle.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 10 Oct 23 8.56am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

This is pure wild speculation, but when JWP wasn't picked for England (again) I couldn't help but wonder if his antics with Wilf are what has cost him his place. Southgate is often a guest at Palace and seems to have some connections with us still. Is it possible he remembers JWP being a little rat and decided he didn't want that around England? I would find that hilarious if that was the case. It's unlikely, but regardless each time he isn't picked I have a little chuckle.

That would be a pretty left field reason!

JWP must be so disillusioned. Form, sharpness and standard of football now counts for nothing.

 

Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Forest match thread