You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Burnley v Palace match thread
November 16 2026 3.02am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Burnley v Palace match thread


Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Putitout Flag Oxford 05 Nov 23 11.59am

Originally posted by palace99

i disagree. whilst the 3 points were very welcome we were shocking from the first minute and had no idea how to attack. We time wasted from kick off and once we scored - great persistence from Ayew, but shocking defending - with our only chance, we just sat back and tried to run the clock down.

IMHO you need to be at games to see how things pan out - TV shows a limited view of the pitch. The top 4 , with the exception of the occasional Ayew piece of magic, is so limited. JS other than the goal was clueless and Hughes is so slow he offered nothing.

Yes we have injuries but very team has injuries. All our players are millionaires with much top flight experience.

I don't think it is unreasonable to expect them to pass the ball, move into space and maybe beat their opponent occasionally.

Our away set away is so one dimensional. If a team score early e.g. Newcastle, there is no plan B.

You are right we appear limited because without Eze,and Olise, that’s what we are, very limited . Any moan has to be to the club and its owners. Only having a great organiser in place and a supper work ethic amongst those limited players is the reason we have come through the first eleven games with 15 points . You say if we go behind no plan B maybe but we have kept 5 clean sheets , and conceded just 13 goals , The only games we have lost all top six, and only Newcastle hammered us, we are not alone in that experience.
Every club has injuries, but every club has filled out squads to cope with that ,not ours, that’s clear ,or Olise, and Eze wouldn’t the only key to a style beyond what we see.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 05 Nov 23 12.16pm

Good to take 3 points yesterday and have Eze back in the fold. One pundit mentioned Burnley were sticking to their guns to gain certain relegation as a work in progress !?! Team for next week will probably be Eze full return with one of the 3 DM's making way. If Olise can make the bench like Eze this week great. Suspect starting team for the foreseable barring injuries will be 2 from Hughes, Doucore and Lerma, possibly 3 in supposed tougher oppo, and the other 4 Schlupp, Eze, Olise, Ayew and Eduoard with 1 making way and utilised as back up. The rest will have time depending on the flow of the game. Think we will have enough points on the board come Xmas not to dabble in the market, although strengthening where weak would be nice but unlikely. This season looks like shaping up to be the same as last, 10th-15th finish.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

southnorwoodhill Flag 05 Nov 23 12.20pm

Originally posted by Putitout

You are right we appear limited because without Eze,and Olise, that’s what we are, very limited . Any moan has to be to the club and its owners. Only having a great organiser in place and a supper work ethic amongst those limited players is the reason we have come through the first eleven games with 15 points . You say if we go behind no plan B maybe but we have kept 5 clean sheets , and conceded just 13 goals , The only games we have lost all top six, and only Newcastle hammered us, we are not alone in that experience.
Every club has injuries, but every club has filled out squads to cope with that ,not ours, that’s clear ,or Olise, and Eze wouldn’t the only key to a style beyond what we see.

This is reasonable. We've beaten Sheffield Utd, Wolves, Burnley, all below us, and had a fine result against Manchester United. Losses have been against higher placed clubs, and draws against those teams around us. Roy will target the games against the lower teams to collect points.
Roy does what Roy does, and it is what it is, a fairly uninspiring watch. The end result of which will be another season in the PL, finishing around 12th, and it will be as it ever was. This team doesn't have the depth of players to progress, and that is down to the board and finance, and the the academy not rolling out a conveyor belt of PL ready talent, well not yet anyway.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 05 Nov 23 12.59pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Burnley are newly promoted in the relegation zone who played the better football and were unlucky.

We were uninspiring and the win took us from dreary mid table to dreary mid table.

They focused on where the drama was. I have no issue.

That said had we been spurs the focus would have been how ruthless they are and still win even when "ugly " etc.

I would suggest the team that plays the ‘better football’ is the one that wins.

Burnley have tried to play a ‘style’ of football that exceeds their capability and will get relegated for it. We are currently playing a ‘style’ that is pragmatic given the resource available.

Until that improves, it is probably the best approach until such time we have all players fit or additions to our limited squad.

It is what it is and was yesterday however, and we got the win, which immediately puts me in far better spirits. COYP

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Plaistow Eagle Flag 05 Nov 23 1.08pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

What are the options ?

I keep saying give Richards a chance at Right Back - he’s quicker, more athletic and mobile - he’s got a good touch ad decent distribution.

OK he may not be the long term solution - but got to be a better option than Ward right now and will stop teams targeting our right side.

COYP

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Nov 23 1.46pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

I keep saying give Richards a chance at Right Back - he’s quicker, more athletic and mobile - he’s got a good touch ad decent distribution.

OK he may not be the long term solution - but got to be a better option than Ward right now and will stop teams targeting our right side.

COYP


Whilst he is quicker and more athletic than Ward, the question is whether Richards has the nous to know where to position himself when defending at RB. As Hodgson and his team aren't taking the Richards at RB option at present it would seem reasonable to assume that they have their doubts about his ability to do the RB job.

I'm not defending Ward BTW. The alternative at present is Clyne but is he actually any better?

Of the youngsters, Imray looks promising nut was held back by injuries for most of last season. He is good going forward as well.

As an aside to those moaning about Ward being the captain, he's the club captain and that doesn't entitle him to a playing role anymore than it did for Luka in his final two years.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Nov 23 1.57pm

Well, the way I saw it, we looked like an experienced Premier League team playing against a willing and enthusiastic newcomer lacking in quality.

Burnley are consistently making mistakes at the back. So it was no surprise that they conceded two cheap goals. They also struggle to turn possession into goals. I think our gameplan was to pick them off and win the match which we duly did. Burnley could certainly not be considered unlucky, just not good enough.

Palace will probably play better in other games and lose. But yesterday did enough to get the points.

While it's true that the team have reverted back to a more pragmatic style, you can't expect to lose Olise, Zaha and Eze without there being an impact.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 05 Nov 23 2.04pm

Originally posted by palace99

i disagree. whilst the 3 points were very welcome we were shocking from the first minute and had no idea how to attack. We time wasted from kick off and once we scored - great persistence from Ayew, but shocking defending - with our only chance, we just sat back and tried to run the clock down.

IMHO you need to be at games to see how things pan out - TV shows a limited view of the pitch. The top 4 , with the exception of the occasional Ayew piece of magic, is so limited. JS other than the goal was clueless and Hughes is so slow he offered nothing.

Yes we have injuries but very team has injuries. All our players are millionaires with much top flight experience.

I don't think it is unreasonable to expect them to pass the ball, move into space and maybe beat their opponent occasionally.

Our away set away is so one dimensional. If a team score early e.g. Newcastle, there is no plan B.

You do not seem to understand that Ayew, Eze and Olise are a top class trio, Olise and soon hopefully Eze are, and will be on mega bucks, obviously the replacements when injured are not of the same quality, but we cant afford that, yes we need a RB and a CF and hopefully Franca will adapt to the role, but there will be no midfield additions in Jan, that is for sure.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

PatrickA Flag London 05 Nov 23 2.05pm

I believe yesterday was possibly one of the first times (if not the first) that Ward was taken off as a tactical substitution by Roy.
He was struggling against the winger and despite his good positioning and physical strength he can’t deal with raw pace or clever footwork.
I think this could be his last season at first team level, but he has been a brilliant player for the club.
Richards has featured in a couple of cameos as a full back and hasn’t impressed being all at sea positionally.
It might be something he could learn, but you wouldn’t want him exposed at Premier League level.
He’s athletic, competitive and decent in the air and I like him as a player but only as a centre back where he can best display his attributes.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 05 Nov 23 2.07pm

I’m sure we would all love to see Palace playing progressive attacking football like the top teams. However, to do that SUCCESSFULLY you need the right players and we simply don’t have enough of them to achieve that.

In my 50 years supporting Palace I think I’ve only ever seen one team that could play decent possession football and get results and that was the Venables team that got us promoted but which was soon undone with the sale of key players and therein lies our problem – keeping the players that can play the kind of football people hanker after.

“Look at Brighton”, people say. Yes, they have done really well the last couple of seasons but how long will they be able to sustain it? I can recall Southampton having a short spell in the top 10 but they sold too many good players and failed to replace them with adequate replacements. Brighton risk doing the same.

I wasn’t at yesterday’s game, but judging by the intermittent reports on the Beeb, we were pretty poor but we were game savvy and clinical. The score line flattered us but then we’ve lost points in games when our performance warranted a better return.
I’ll reserve judgement on our style of play until we have our 1st choice line-up match fit and playing.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 05 Nov 23 2.11pm

Originally posted by Vectis

Good call. Just because he doesn’t score many goals (last week being a rare exception) he tends to be underrated. But his work rate, close ball control and ability to hold onto the ball and draw fouls are immense. Add to that he very rarely is missing due to injury and it’s not surprising he is one of the first names on the team sheet

He is playing the best football of his career, POTY so far, as you say his close control and strength on the ball has become almost Wilfesque

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

YT Flag Oxford 05 Nov 23 2.14pm

Originally posted by mileend

Ayew 6th highest goal scorer in Palace PL History with 18, but he'd better watch out as a certain Jeffrey Schlupp has just moved up to joint 7th with 17 goals

Their popularity is well deserved!

An internet source I looked at this morning put JA on 19 and JS on 17. Whether it's 19 or 18, he is, of course, the player in the current squad with the most PL goals to his name.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

nead1 Flag 05 Nov 23 2.33pm

I was at the game yesterday and agree with most of the points about Ward; his physical presence/positioning is strong but it is the raw pace that seems to be the problem as he gets older; interestingly, when Clyne came on, the problem down the right side seemed to dissipate. Clyne has a lower centre of gravity, is a bit quicker and supports the attack more in my view. I wonder what Roy will do next week - maybe give Ward a bit of a rest?
It was also interesting to see Roy keep Hughes on for the full 90 and take of Doucoure. I sense Hughes is very much a Roy type player and wouldn't be surprised if he stays in the team next week along with Schlupp.
For me the stand out player yesterday was Andersen; very competitive, reads the game so well and make some crucial tackles.
Its also worth noting that only on one occasion if I recall, did Johnstone play out from the back. It was all much more direct - a big contrast to how Viera set his teams up.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 05 Nov 23 2.53pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Ward is so good these days that opposition players are instructed by their management to play the ball constantly down his side of the pitch, such is their awe at watching him perform. Now that's respect.

I don't think the Newcastle players could have been given that instruction a couple of weeks ago.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 05 Nov 23 3.45pm

Originally posted by doombear


Whilst he is quicker and more athletic than Ward, the question is whether Richards has the nous to know where to position himself when defending at RB. As Hodgson and his team aren't taking the Richards at RB option at present it would seem reasonable to assume that they have their doubts about his ability to do the RB job.

I'm not defending Ward BTW. The alternative at present is Clyne but is he actually any better?

Of the youngsters, Imray looks promising nut was held back by injuries for most of last season. He is good going forward as well.

As an aside to those moaning about Ward being the captain, he's the club captain and that doesn't entitle him to a playing role anymore than it did for Luka in his final two years.

But - there’s always a but - we all know Roy is stubborn - beyond that seems to have somewhat of a blind alliance to some of his favourites - of which Ward is clearly one..!!

My view on trying Richards at right back - is that he must be a better option currently than Ward - who simply looks like a major weak link in the team at this point in time..!!

Look don’t get me wrong - Ward has been an absolute stalwart for the club - but as others have said old Father Time has caught up with him and his legs seem to have gone - nothing personal against Ward just an honest observation - happens to every player in latter years..!!

Clyne - is he really any different - maybe marginally the better option of the 2 at this point in time - but certainly not the long term solution.

No nothing about Imray - so will bow to your knowledge.

At this juncture I’d give Richards a go for a few games - if it doesn’t work out - right back is an absolute priority in the January window - but that’s probably been true since AWB left for Manure..!!

On the captaincy agree doesn’t mean Ward has to play - but when he does just don’t like the message it sends - worst player Captain - but that’s me..!!

For me Guehi has to be Captain - leads by example and is the future - but again a personal opinion.

COYP

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 05 Nov 23 3.53pm

Originally posted by Vectis

Agree. We’ve tried the young progressive manager route with FDB and PV and how did that work out? Indeed, all the indignation by the media when PV was sacked. None of them now want to admit Roy is a far better manager and well suited to getting results from a squad such as ours, recently missing some of its best players and not full of expensive superstars. Indeed any of them noticed how poorly PV is performing back in France managing Strasbourg - just hovering over the relegation places.

Again, remember classic Pardew ‘entertaining’ football leading to results such as 5-4 loss away at Swansea after leading. And where are Swansea these days after being held up at one time as an example of how ‘football should be played’?

Roy and before him Pulis and Allardyce knows how to set up Palace teams to get results and the points necessary to succeed in the unforgiving Premier league. There are many clubs now languishing in the Championship or League 1 that would swap places even if it means watching football that is pragmatic and effective rather than ‘swashbuckling’ in style


FDB was never given a proper chance not a good example to use.

Pardew got us to a cup final something we had not achieved in a very long time and you could say it was with Championship level players.

Roy took one of those teams down so did Sam.

People are looking at how we played towards the end of last season and enjoyed it so why cant we play like that now again these teams that are at bottom of the league not the boring stuff which is why so many wanted Roy gone before.

Football is suppose to be entertaining

Out of interest would you be happy if Palace next season chose to go with Sam or Pullis?

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 05 Nov 23 3.59pm

agreed

Originally posted by doombear

I’m sure we would all love to see Palace playing progressive attacking football like the top teams. However, to do that SUCCESSFULLY you need the right players and we simply don’t have enough of them to achieve that.

In my 50 years supporting Palace I think I’ve only ever seen one team that could play decent possession football and get results and that was the Venables team that got us promoted but whicagre was soon undone with the sale of key players and therein lies our problem – keeping the players that can play the kind of football people hanker after.

“Look at Brighton”, people say. Yes, they have done really well the last couple of seasons but how long will they be able to sustain it? I can recall Southampton having a short spell in the top 10 but they sold too many good players and failed to replace them with adequate replacements. Brighton risk doing the same.

I wasn’t at yesterday’s game, but judging by the intermittent reports on the Beeb, we were pretty poor but we were game savvy and clinical. The score line flattered us but then we’ve lost points in games when our performance warranted a better return.
I’ll reserve judgement on our style of play until we have our 1st choice line-up match fit and playing.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 05 Nov 23 4.17pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


FDB was never given a proper chance not a good example to use.

Pardew got us to a cup final something we had not achieved in a very long time and you could say it was with Championship level players.

Roy took one of those teams down so did Sam.

People are looking at how we played towards the end of last season and enjoyed it so why cant we play like that now again these teams that are at bottom of the league not the boring stuff which is why so many wanted Roy gone before.

Football is suppose to be entertaining

Out of interest would you be happy if Palace next season chose to go with Sam or Pullis?

And who were the players that benefited from that style of play ?

Zaha - gone. Olise - injured. Eze - having to do it on his own prior to his injury.

And your question is just plain stupid.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

pssguy Flag 05 Nov 23 4.26pm

Originally posted by nead1

I was at the game yesterday and agree with most of the points about Ward; his physical presence/positioning is strong but it is the raw pace that seems to be the problem as he gets older; interestingly, when Clyne came on, the problem down the right side seemed to dissipate. Clyne has a lower centre of gravity, is a bit quicker and supports the attack more in my view. I wonder what Roy will do next week - maybe give Ward a bit of a rest?
It was also interesting to see Roy keep Hughes on for the full 90 and take of Doucoure. I sense Hughes is very much a Roy type player and wouldn't be surprised if he stays in the team next week along with Schlupp.

We all know they should have bought a right back in the summer but we are where we are. Ward has been up against two very fast wingers. Gordon and Amdouni, in the latest games and the latter went off soon after Ward so Clyne got a break. It is McNeil at Evrton next week who is a very different type of winger whom Ward should match up better against

I don't know if Doucoure was a tactical sub - he hadn't been booked - but it was odd to see last year's POTY giving way for Eze rather than the inffective Hughes. We may find out that he and Edouard had picked up the prevalent hamstring injuries at the club

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 05 Nov 23 5.49pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Yes, i watch every game complete, on TV obviously, the gap between the quality between our players and theirs was vast, our players dont panic in possession , unlike Burnleys who continually panicked on the ball, the plan to play the way we did was limited to the quality available, when Eze and Olise are match fit we will dominate most games, 5 clean sheets in 10 league games is excellent, second only to Arsenal, 8th to 14th is a superb return for a club our size, we dont have backers willing to plough millions into the club, that is the bottom line, take a look at the championship, all of them would swap position with us, footballing and financial wise.

Can you explain how Brentford a smaller club than us does not have this inferiority complex and expects to take on and beat the top clubs and regularly does. They have beaten Chelsea three times in a row away from home also this time without Toney, why can’t we aspire to be more like them as they are playIng attractive football and getting results too..There scouting system is light years better than ours, in my opinion if we improve in that department we can also be more competitive in this league on similar resources.

 

Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Burnley v Palace match thread