You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Next manager
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Next manager


Page 8 of 39 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Norbury Old Git Flag London 15 Nov 23 12.51pm

Two new names to add to the list to replace Roy.
Urs Fischer has brought the unfashionable Union Berlin from obscurity to the forefront of German football and European qualification over the last five years. We played his team in a pre-season friendly a few years ago in their compact stadium and lost 0-2.
Rudi Garcia has been sacked by Serie A Champions Napoli for some poor results which sees them only 4th in the league. Whilst they are 2nd in their Champions League Group they still have to play Real Madrid twice so qualification for the knockout stages is not guaranteed.
Both managers have demonstrated longevity (by football standards) and success in their managerial posts. However, Rudi Garcia may consider a job at Palace a step down where as Fischer may enjoy the similarities between his former Club and a step up to the Premier League.

 

BrentisBack Flag Beckenham 15 Nov 23 1.28pm

Originally posted by Norbury Old Git

Two new names to add to the list to replace Roy.
Urs Fischer has brought the unfashionable Union Berlin from obscurity to the forefront of German football and European qualification over the last five years. We played his team in a pre-season friendly a few years ago in their compact stadium and lost 0-2.
Rudi Garcia has been sacked by Serie A Champions Napoli for some poor results which sees them only 4th in the league. Whilst they are 2nd in their Champions League Group they still have to play Real Madrid twice so qualification for the knockout stages is not guaranteed.
Both managers have demonstrated longevity (by football standards) and success in their managerial posts. However, Rudi Garcia may consider a job at Palace a step down where as Fischer may enjoy the similarities between his former Club and a step up to the Premier League.

One thing I have noticed, is that given a choice, Parish seems to go with an English name where possible, with a couple of notable exceptions. He also tends to like someone with experience of working successfully in the Premier League. This is why I would imagine we might go for an O'Niell or Cooper. Both at this stage are employed which would go against another previous requisite of the manager we go for being immediately available.
If one of the above names became available in the summer then I'd be betting my house on them being top of Palace's managerial shortlist.

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 15 Nov 23 1.49pm

Originally posted by BrentisBack

One thing I have noticed, is that given a choice, Parish seems to go with an English name where possible, with a couple of notable exceptions. He also tends to like someone with experience of working successfully in the Premier League. This is why I would imagine we might go for an O'Niell or Cooper. Both at this stage are employed which would go against another previous requisite of the manager we go for being immediately available.
If one of the above names became available in the summer then I'd be betting my house on them being top of Palace's managerial shortlist.

Correct, and for my money he is probably right to do so.

Not every foreign manager is De Boer of course, but I imagine that particular experience has left a scar or two for Parish.

I'd expect any prospective manager who lacks experience of the league to be asked to demonstrate significant research and understanding of the culture, what tactics work for clubs with a limited budget, what tactics get the best out of our existing players, and how they will implement those tactics quickly, without large changes to the squad. It might be good if the new man has experience of blooding youngsters, but doing it in a 'development' league like France, Holland or Belgium isn't the same as trying to do it here.

When the club appointed FDB and chased Favre, Parish seemed to be looking to reinvent the wheel and become a noticeably different type of team. At that time, he talked about needing to be more proactive, especially at home.

Nowadays, I would be surprised if the next manager is asked to start a revolution. Perhaps a little evolution, but not much. Someone like O'Neill would be great if Wolves bin him (they would be silly to, but they do seem a bit silly so who knows?).

Edited by TheBigToePunt (15 Nov 2023 2.00pm)

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 16 Nov 23 12.33pm

Seems Paddy Mac might be Oxford Utd's new manager . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 16 Nov 23 12.51pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Seems Paddy Mac might be Oxford Utd's new manager . . . [Link]


It'll be a good move for him if he gets the job. If it's true that Oxford made an approach for him previously but was denied then access by Palace, presumably, he's got a decent chance of getting it.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 Nov 23 1.22pm

Originally posted by doombear


It'll be a good move for him if he gets the job. If it's true that Oxford made an approach for him previously but was denied then access by Palace, presumably, he's got a decent chance of getting it.

Would it be the worst for us too?

If he goes to Oxford and struggles it's surely a wise move for us if we were/are considering ushering him.

If he goes there and proves a sensation, where better would he go for the proverbial 'step up'?

Any middle ground there and we can keep an eye on things, a good litmus test.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

BrentisBack Flag Beckenham 16 Nov 23 1.25pm

Hopefully Paddy will take a few of our youngsters on loan if he gets the Oxford job.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 16 Nov 23 3.13pm

Seems he missed out(this time) . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

taylors lovechild Flag 17 Nov 23 6.53am

If Paddy was interviewed then that would suggest he has no expectation of taking over from Roy. To be honest I don't see Parish taking that kind of risk unless pushed anyway. More experienced managers have in the main served him best. Moyes' contrast expires this summer and rumours are it won't be extended. He has the charisma of a dead fish but he would probably be a good manager for us.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 17 Nov 23 8.50am

It will be Roy for another year or Paddy, nobody else, if we avoid any major injuries and get a couple of decent loans in Jan, i think we will finish 7th or 8th, if that happens it will be about not rocking the boat.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Teddy Eagle Flag 17 Nov 23 9.41am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

It will be Roy for another year or Paddy, nobody else, if we avoid any major injuries and get a couple of decent loans in Jan, i think we will finish 7th or 8th, if that happens it will be about not rocking the boat.

If we finished that high it would be an astonishing achievement. Not saying it won't happen but I can't shrug off the idea that we're "only" Palace and are somehow blagging it - especially with the recognised weaker spots in the team.
Optimism is an alien concept where CPFC are involved.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 17 Nov 23 9.52am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

It will be Roy for another year or Paddy, nobody else, if we avoid any major injuries and get a couple of decent loans in Jan, i think we will finish 7th or 8th, if that happens it will be about not rocking the boat.

Jeez you are optimistic. Not a snowballs chance in hell we'll finish 7/8th

Didnt get any loans in the summer, and that was knowing we were going to be without Olise, cant imagine us getting any in Jan.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 17 Nov 23 1.15pm

we have two outstanding centre backs, two outstanding central midfielders and two outstanding play makers, a a merely great left back and two top keepers - this is the closest we've been to being a genuinely 'good side, since the Southgate, Coleman, Salako, Armstrong/Stewart side that was only a couple of players away from being top 8. A reliable striker that doesn't break the bank is very hard to find admittedly, but if we can get a clever loan or that PSG fella (Timo Werner's name is circulating - though 'reliable' might not describe him) then it's not a fantasy that we could get 8th, 7th might be pushing it, but we have a lot of top, top players - and we just need an OK right back and a clinical striker who can run faster than a tortoise and we're bang there. Take the 50/1 about us for the Cup this season.

 

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 17 Nov 23 2.55pm

Originally posted by Norbury Old Git

Two new names to add to the list to replace Roy.
Urs Fischer has brought the unfashionable Union Berlin from obscurity to the forefront of German football and European qualification over the last five years. We played his team in a pre-season friendly a few years ago in their compact stadium and lost 0-2.
Rudi Garcia has been sacked by Serie A Champions Napoli for some poor results which sees them only 4th in the league. Whilst they are 2nd in their Champions League Group they still have to play Real Madrid twice so qualification for the knockout stages is not guaranteed.
Both managers have demonstrated longevity (by football standards) and success in their managerial posts. However, Rudi Garcia may consider a job at Palace a step down where as Fischer may enjoy the similarities between his former Club and a step up to the Premier League.

Union Berlin who are currently bottom of the table and can't score for love, nor money? No thanks!

 


La la la your mum

est1905 Flag 17 Nov 23 5.22pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

It will be Roy for another year or Paddy, nobody else, if we avoid any major injuries and get a couple of decent loans in Jan, i think we will finish 7th or 8th, if that happens it will be about not rocking the boat.

It will not be Paddy, You do not risk a £120m a year income on a bloke who's only Premiership managerial game was a 4 1 thumping when he said he thought we'd played well!

 

rikz Flag Croydon 17 Nov 23 5.45pm

With Everton getting a 10 point deduction, even if they are better than us, which I don't belive they are, they're definitely not 10 points better than us. Along with the other poor teams at the bottom of the table, we're pretty much guaranteed to remain in the league.

This gives us plenty of time to identify a replacement for Roy. We will be a prem club and we will be fairly attractive to most managers out there. If we don't have a replacement before the euros then we should be asking what the board are playing at. They've got plenty of time and there should be no excuses.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 Nov 23 6.32pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

It will be Roy for another year or Paddy, nobody else, if we avoid any major injuries and get a couple of decent loans in Jan, i think we will finish 7th or 8th, if that happens it will be about not rocking the boat.

This post did make me chuckle. No way will we finish 7th / 8th. Roy's best finish 11th, occurred in his first season. Luka was the top scorer interestingly enough. New manager bounce, and the team was overall slightly more balanced than that of today.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 17 Nov 23 6.37pm

Originally posted by rikz

With Everton getting a 10 point deduction, even if they are better than us, which I don't belive they are, they're definitely not 10 points better than us. Along with the other poor teams at the bottom of the table, we're pretty much guaranteed to remain in the league.

This gives us plenty of time to identify a replacement for Roy. We will be a prem club and we will be fairly attractive to most managers out there. If we don't have a replacement before the euros then we should be asking what the board are playing at. They've got plenty of time and there should be no excuses.

What on earth makes you think we would be an attractive proposition to any decent manager. We struggled to replace Roy last time and Viera was nowhere near top choice.

Any manager coming in has little or no say on new signings as we have Dougie (well at least until he goes to Manure,) we also have no money and a chairman who wants him to be the story not the manager.

I would say Luton are probably more attractive than us.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 17 Nov 23 7.07pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

What on earth makes you think we would be an attractive proposition to any decent manager. We struggled to replace Roy last time and Viera was nowhere near top choice.

Any manager coming in has little or no say on new signings as we have Dougie (well at least until he goes to Manure,) we also have no money and a chairman who wants him to be the story not the manager.

I would say Luton are probably more attractive than us.

Managing in the best, most competitive and most watched league in the world.

Money, the fact they will make twice the amount here than 99% of any other club in the world. Budget, you say we have no money, how much money do you think bottom half clubs in the other top leagues in Europe have to spend ? They would all love to spend 45 million and offer players 100k a week.

Ambition, a manager not wanting to manage in the prem is the equivalent of a player for us not wanting to play for the big 6.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 17 Nov 23 10.42pm

It's almost impossible to see McCarthy being appointed although having him on the coaching staff and his clear popularity gives the club a fall back and continuity.

The points about foreign managers are interesting and after Nuno, Favre, Frank the Plank and Vieira why would the Board want to touch one.

 

Page 8 of 39 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Next manager