You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Everton match thread
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Everton match thread


Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
The Yorkshire Eagle Flag Great Ouseburn, N Yorkshire 12 Nov 23 8.35am

I’ve always been a fan of Ayew but not sure leading the line is his strength? Vertically challenged, so not going to be a target man. Nevertheless worth a try, and would Schlup, given his physical presence?
Our lack of goals is of course concerning, but equally IMO, are how many goals we concede from crosses and dead-ball situations, when we are blessed with two decent central defenders. Our defence get caught flat-footed too many times and doesn’t attack the ball enough.
On the pen question, Howard Webb and his tribe should be hung out to dry with such decisions. All the pundits agreed it was a foul. VAR in general needs a complete review... especially handball. What happened to the basic hand to ball rule not has it deflected off a bootlace to an elbow!
Defeat v Toffees sucks! “Tomorrow will be a better day”

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 12 Nov 23 8.39am

In the cold light of day the players and management should be ashamed. Losing at home to a team below us like Everton and conceding goals the way we did is unacceptable.
No one player is excluded from this.


 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

stancummins Flag 12 Nov 23 8.52am

i dont really understand the hand wringing and negative comments , i thought we played well , much better than the previous 3 home games, yesterday we were out Hodgsoned by Everton I agree about Dacoure if he is fit enough for the bench he is fit enough to start. Also thought Eze ripped them another one but one negative for him is he needs to shoot more, there are times he chooses to pass instead of pulling the trigger as in first half when he tried to square the ball to Eduard . I thought Lerma was OK but he needs to score more, i believe he got half a dozen last year, but missed a good one in the second half. Hughes just isnt premiership quality so the loss of Dacoure was huge, All in all we continue to play like that we will win more than we lose

 

Den1923 Flag 12 Nov 23 9.01am

This was a loss at home to a team that was below us in the table and it is simply not acceptable if we want to continue to progress in this league. It does not matter how well we may have played we lost the game and that highlights our weakness in defending high balls in to the box and our weaknesses in attack.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 12 Nov 23 9.17am

Originally posted by Den1923

This was a loss at home to a team that was below us in the table and it is simply not acceptable if we want to continue to progress in this league. It does not matter how well we may have played we lost the game and that highlights our weakness in defending high balls in to the box and our weaknesses in attack.

Any capable opposition manager will have realised by now that the route to our goal is past our distinctly lack lustre full backs and via crosses which our centre halves don't defend effectively. It's a real problem for Hodgson from a tactical viewpoint.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 12 Nov 23 9.34am

Originally posted by Uphill

As has been said many times before: We are suffering for not buying a striker in the transfer window.

There have been many instances of a relative cheap buy from the Championship paying off

Instead it seems we gambled on one or two fairly expensive strikers from Europe that didn't materialise.

Like Mr Hodgson's tactics - no Plan B !

What is this mysterious Plan B? If a manager makes a or any number of subs, then its a change from Plan A.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 12 Nov 23 9.40am

Originally posted by VSEagle215

Cannot wait for season to be over already. Hodgson sucks the life out of me. Appointment made no sense except to stay up and the football is incredibly boring. We never beat Everton, except under Vieira. It is 15th or 16th this season at best. What a complete waste of a season.

If that comment relates to yesterday, I can hardly believe you said it. I thought it was one of the most entertaining (Palace) games I've seen in months.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 12 Nov 23 9.48am

Ward was perhaps caught flat footed for the first goal, but the other two goals were down to the midfield. First Lerma fails to push up meaning Doucoure is onside for Everton's second, and then Hughes switches off and doesn't track Gueye for the third.

Everton were very efficient with their chances but it's also worth mentioning that their form of late has been good. This is not the Everton of the start of the season. The early goal set the tone and it was a highly entertaining game. Compared to Spuds where we sat off them and did nothing we at least tried to push. Once Olise and Eze are fully fit we are going to be a different beast.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 12 Nov 23 9.55am

I find it difficult to align "we played well" to the simple fact that we conceded 3 goals and lost, and 3 sloppy goals at that. Congratulations to Dyche for the tactical smarts to get players forward in numbers in the opening minute, surely a deliberate decision to ruffle Roy's preference for the 0-0 until half time schtick.
Doucoure's absence and the ensuing defensive display illustrates just how much his presence is missed.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Nov 23 10.00am

Originally posted by JRW2

If that comment relates to yesterday, I can hardly believe you said it. I thought it was one of the most entertaining (Palace) games I've seen in months.

I for one never departed Selhurst Park feeling I had been "Entertained", I exited sullen faced and at my splenetic worst after a defeat and mulling over the fact that we had won only 1 of our 6 home games and lost 3 out of our last 4 games.


Edited by Willo (12 Nov 2023 10.06am)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 12 Nov 23 10.16am

Anyone defending Edouard on here has not a clue about how a decent striker should play. He can’t pass the ball, he can’t hold it up, he’s slow when it’s at his feet, he’s useless in the air, he doesn’t read the offside line well, he loses it way too often when in possession. It’s also pointless saying he doesn’t get the correct supply because most of the time he’s stood in the wrong place anyway. At times he makes Benteke look like he was athletic.

The only problem is, despite that, he’s still better than Mateta. So the only choice until we put our hands in our pockets is to play Ayew at CF which is a possibility now both Eze and Olise are back.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 12 Nov 23 10.20am

Originally posted by Willo

I for one never departed Selhurst Park feeling I had been "Entertained", I exited sullen faced and at my splenetic worst after a defeat and mulling over the fact that we had won only 1 of our 6 home games and lost 3 out of our last 4 games.


Edited by Willo (12 Nov 2023 10.06am)

You can tell when Roy is perturbed, when he sits there silently, rubbing his chin. Fortress Selhurst Park is but a pipe dream at present.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Nov 23 10.43am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You can tell when Roy is perturbed, when he sits there silently, rubbing his chin. Fortress Selhurst Park is but a pipe dream at present.

We have only won 1 of our 6 home games this season.
I believe we only won 6 out of 19 home games in each of the previous 2 seasons.
Suffering Season-Ticket holders with a number totally disgruntled.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 12 Nov 23 10.53am

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

No I want someone who makes and picks a team from the best available resources- Roy didn’t do that today, he played his favourites and it backfired..!!

It’s that simple - surely you can see that..!!

Olise was fit - why not play him from the start - why wait - we’ve been crying out for his return all season..!!

If Decoure is fit enough for the bench then play him - why play a sub standard Hughes..!!

Just doesn’t make sense..!!


No I don't see either of your statements as being correct.
1. Doucoure came off with a hamstring issue against Burnley and only trained on Friday. Roy sensibly didn't want to start him.
2. There is a big difference between being fit and match fit. Olise may well have been fit but not having played at all this season was unlikely to have been match fit. When players have been out for that long you don't suddenly start them and expect them to perform.
3. For those who want Richards at RB, he's played there for us and didn't convince.
4. Franca still isn't ready. I expect he will be at some point later in the season but not this side of the New Year IMO.

Hodgson started what he considered (and I tend to agree) was his best XI given the circumstances. One might genuinely debate whether Clyne should have played instead of Ward, but other than that, I really don't see who else Hodgson could have started with.

It was the starting XI I expected and was happy with given the limitations.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 12 Nov 23 10.58am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Anyone defending Edouard on here has not a clue about how a decent striker should play. He can’t pass the ball, he can’t hold it up, he’s slow when it’s at his feet, he’s useless in the air, he doesn’t read the offside line well, he loses it way too often when in possession. It’s also pointless saying he doesn’t get the correct supply because most of the time he’s stood in the wrong place anyway. At times he makes Benteke look like he was athletic.

The only problem is, despite that, he’s still better than Mateta. So the only choice until we put our hands in our pockets is to play Ayew at CF which is a possibility now both Eze and Olise are back.

Edouard isn't the type of player you are expecting, hardly. And yet he's our top scorer, funny that.
Here he is on the chart, about right, given our league position. Should we acquire a forward with the qualities that you espouse then we can compare the difference that player would make to the overall contribution.
Haaland has only scored 11 so far, and he plays for the best team in the country...

[Link]

 

Painter Flag Croydon 12 Nov 23 11.03am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Edouard isn't the type of player you are expecting, hardly. And yet he's our top scorer, funny that.
Here he is on the chart, about right, given our league position. Should we acquire a forward with the qualities that you espouse then we can compare the difference that player would make to the overall contribution.
Haaland has only scored 11 so far, and he plays for the best team in the country...

[Link]

Evan Ferguson the current Brighton next big player has same stats as Edouard.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 12 Nov 23 11.09am

Originally posted by Painter

Evan Ferguson the current Brighton next big player has same stats as Edouard.

Is that a good thing or a bad thing? I note with interest the stats of Nketiah, who a few here wanted - nothing better than Edouard, and he plays for a better team.
Don't get me wrong, Edouard isn't particularly brilliant, but he is scoring and is responsible for around half our goal tally. What does that say about how we line up and play the game?

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 12 Nov 23 11.11am

Originally posted by VSEagle215

Cannot wait for season to be over already. Hodgson sucks the life out of me. Appointment made no sense except to stay up and the football is incredibly boring. We never beat Everton, except under Vieira. It is 15th or 16th this season at best. What a complete waste of a season.


Vieira was lucky that that clown Lampard was in the other dugout. The fact remains that we have an horrendous record against Everton (1 win in the last 18 PL games) and apart from the home win 2 years ago we haven't beaten them at home since the 1990s.

Given the rest of your comments, there's obviously no point in you turning up to or commenting on any future Palace games this season as you've clearly said it all here.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 12 Nov 23 11.17am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Edouard is like Benteke, in that he is abject sh-t, but will be playing for us for the next 5 years. I can't imagine a future where OE will not be our starting striker every match.

Another poster chatting nonsense.

How many times does it need to be said you need to use the strength of players both have not been used correctly.

Look at the Palace striker which have been poor yet they go to other clubs and perform wonder why that is.

Ed is currently our top scorer he has 6 not bad if he continues he could be close to 14-15 for the season.

I see other posters claiming he had lots of chances no he didn't Palace had 4 on target all game (what stood out was he was caught offside a few times when he shouldnt have been)

I have seen a fair few posts in here from southnorwoodhill and he has multi valid points.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 12 Nov 23 11.19am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Edouard isn't the type of player you are expecting, hardly. And yet he's our top scorer, funny that.
Here he is on the chart, about right, given our league position. Should we acquire a forward with the qualities that you espouse then we can compare the difference that player would make to the overall contribution.
Haaland has only scored 11 so far, and he plays for the best team in the country...

[Link]

I don’t necessarily see a decent CF as an out and out goal scorer who is always in the right place and finishes 50% of all shots as they are very rare (Kane, Haaland, etc), however I do expect them to be able to control the ball and hold it up, link up play, work the offside line, attack the ball aerially and generally make a nuisance of themselves. By the nature of their position they should be scoring double figures a season anyway so whilst I’m happy with the goals Edouard has scored I wouldn’t call it an exceptional return. I do see him lacking though in so many other areas of a decent CF’s attributes.

In short I’d rather have a Glenn Murray type player back in the side, or if we want to play slightly differently a super quick small CF in the mould of Vardy or our very own Andy Johnson. More than one way to skin a cat, but I don’t think Edouard would even catch it.

 

Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Everton match thread