This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
Really..!! So you’re happy with the way we are playing, results, performances etc.. Despite the resources available..!! All I can say is that you must be watching different games than me..!! COYP I note with interest that those commentators keen to defend Roy against criticism of his tactical approach often use strawman arguments to deflect from the point in question. If for example it is shown that statistical evidence suggests that the late goals we are prone to conceding are linked to our manager not keeping up with the opposing manager's substitutions, which gives the opposing side the benefit of fresh legs against our quite visibly tiring players, then these commentators will, rather than address the very valid point made, will retort with something like, "well what would you have done", or "well who should be manager then" or other such frivolous nonsense.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Robk
Have to say Mateta was terrific again today.. I think he’s been working hard on holding the ball up for others.. will keep Odsonne on the bench for a while… He looks much more like a standard centre forward than Edouard. I don’t care if he doesn’t score bundles of goals if he holds up the ball like he did today. Great performance and good effort put in, although he obviously struggles to manage 90 minutes. If I had a criticism it’s that for his height he is not dominant enough in the air.
|
|
|
Originally posted by southnorwoodhill
I note with interest that those commentators keen to defend Roy against criticism of his tactical approach often use strawman arguments to deflect from the point in question. If for example it is shown that statistical evidence suggests that the late goals we are prone to conceding are linked to our manager not keeping up with the opposing manager's substitutions, which gives the opposing side the benefit of fresh legs against our quite visibly tiring players, then these commentators will, rather than address the very valid point made, will retort with something like, "well what would you have done", or "well who should be manager then" or other such frivolous nonsense. True. I’m happy to debate with others however you can’t debate strawman arguments.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
He looks much more like a standard centre forward than Edouard. I don’t care if he doesn’t score bundles of goals if he holds up the ball like he did today. Great performance and good effort put in, although he obviously struggles to manage 90 minutes. If I had a criticism it’s that for his height he is not dominant enough in the air. Indeed. I don’t think I have seen a CF that can’t jump before. But he is improving every game.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Robk
Have to say Mateta was terrific again today.. I think he’s been working hard on holding the ball up for others.. will keep Odsonne on the bench for a while… Whatever anyone thinks of Mateta ability and goalscoring wise, at least with him up front defenders know he’s there, he puts himself about and rattles defenders
|
|
|
Originally posted by monkey
Whatever anyone thinks of Mateta ability and goalscoring wise, at least with him up front defenders know he’s there, he puts himself about and rattles defenders Very good point. If Mateta was not a big old lump he would not be a footballer. He’s a physical presence and a a glory hunting forward.With a bit of a workrate, he’s both a goal threat and a useful asset. Benteke had all the right attributes but not the mentality to match. JPM is similar. I thought he was superb today, if he played like that every game we’d only be talking about replacing Zaha, covering for Doucoure and the wing back position. Let’s hope it bodes well going forward and he can turn out similar displays. COYP
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle
Yep - that’s the problem - Roy’s game management is just so poor..!! I’m delighted with the win but lets not kid ourselves here - against a very poor Brentford side - ravaged by injuries. Yet somehow we made them look good in the last 20, when they were there to be put to the sword - why because Roy won’t use his subs - consequently we’re running out of legs..!! Just typical Roy and that’s what’s been happening for weeks..!! For me todays game and result just papers over the cracks - Roy is still so stubborn in that he will not make use of the potential that is available to him..!! No doubt today would have saved his neck - but you can see from the last 20 - what there is to look forward to for the rest of the season - same old, same old - when the potential is there - just so frustrating. Yes we’ll stay up but it will be totally uninspiring and painful to watch..!! As I said at the start of the game - irrespective of the result I’d still replace Roy - but it won’t happen..!! Parish quite happy he doesn’t have to spend any money - whilst all we’ve got to look forward to for the rest of the season is abject mediocrity..!! COYP Brentford are often used as example of how a football club with ambition should be and why cant we be like them. All of a sudden they get labelled a poor side, as we beat them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Bexley Eagle
Yes. Unfortunately I think it looked like he had picked up a knock. Wrap him in cotton wool with a 3 week break until the Arsenal game. Seemed to pull up when making a recovery run after our late corner. Looked awfully a lot like another hamstring injury. Absolutely gutting if so. The kid I'd dynamite. And after the medical team warned management about him being overworked it'd be infuriating considering we still had a bunch of subs to use.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Very good point. If Mateta was not a big old lump he would not be a footballer. He’s a physical presence and a a glory hunting forward.With a bit of a workrate, he’s both a goal threat and a useful asset. Benteke had all the right attributes but not the mentality to match. JPM is similar. I thought he was superb today, if he played like that every game we’d only be talking about replacing Zaha, covering for Doucoure and the wing back position. Let’s hope it bodes well going forward and he can turn out similar displays. COYP That’s why I couldn’t stand Benteke, I can take a striker not scoring goals if they put themselves about, give their all and contribute in other ways. Benteke was lazy and for a so called ‘big Ben’ he was lightweight and not up for a scrap. Mateta at least fights for the shirt Edited by monkey (30 Dec 2023 8.59pm)
|
|
|
100% monkey
|
|
|
An essential three points today, but we have a lot of work to do. It's going to be a hard road to survival this time.
|
|
|
Originally posted by monkey
That’s why I couldn’t stand Benteke, I can take a striker not scoring goals if they put themselves about, give their all and contribute in other ways. Benteke was lazy and for a so called ‘big Ben’ he was lightweight and not up for a scrap. Mateta at least fights for the shirt Edited by monkey (30 Dec 2023 8.59pm) As crazy a notion as it sounds, I just don’t think Benteke particularly relished being a footballer. He never looked as though he was even moderately pleased to be out on the pitch. Was such a waste; he was towering in the air, not abysmally slow, had good ball control, understood the game (when he wanted to) and could certainly finish. C’est la vie.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
An essential three points today, but we have a lot of work to do. It's going to be a hard road to survival this time. Fairest summary. Desperate lack of quality aside from the obvious.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cannoneagle
Lots of people on here talking about facts that Roy always makes late subs which doesnt ring true to me, so I've checked out the last 10 games and these ARE the facts about his subs..... I dont think that qualifies as always makes late subs. In fact the Brighton game was a terrible substitution in taking off Ayew who was doing a great cover of Mitchell and then playing an unfit Eze in his place on the left. The Chelsea match was calling out for earlier substitutions as Chelsea had done as our players were knackered. Not unlike today but we got away with it :-) Some of those substitutions you show were probably for injuries as was done in the Man City draw which probably gave us a result which wouldn’t have happened without forced changes. I still think his subs are done too late and in many cases it’s like for like which doesn’t change our formation to give the opposition something to think about? I still think Hodgson is too much old school concentrating more on the defensive side whereas the younger managers have changed with the times and attack in numbers. We got away with it today as Brentford were short of their best players. They still gave us problems, especially after their substitutions until Hodgson made changes which in my opinion should have been earlier? Very happy with the win but I’m not going overboard about it as we have much harder games ahead and those around us are now getting results other than the bottom 2
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I’m chuckling to myself after our MoTD highlights. The commentator makes quite a song and dance in raving about Mateta’s ‘dummy’ for Eze’s goal. Now, I may be wrong, but I’m quite sure he tried to control the ball and it just ran under his foot. Grateful for any other thoughts here but was amusing for me in it seeming so bizarre and only of course, because we won today!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.