This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by kevlee
I think the word is appeasment. Give in to him basically. And he can then plan the next one. Whether or not it's 'appeasement' depends upon the terms of the peace deal. We have already made it plain that an attack on a Nato country means we will fight and that nuclear war then becomes possible. I call that drawing a line. Your take means we have to go to war with Russia and defeat them. That is playing dice with everyone's life. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Mar 2022 11.16am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Whether or not it's 'appeasement' depends upon the terms of the peace deal. Your take means we have to go to war with Russia and defeat them. That is playing dice with everyone's life. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Mar 2022 11.16am) I concur with this comment.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
What may I ask is the alternative ? Stringent sanctions and the severe effect on the Russian economy and way of life will not end this conflict.
We are between a rock and a hard place. Nato cannot get involved. Whilst we admire the resilience and fortitude of the Ukrainian people, the longer they resist, the worse, and more dangerous it will get for everyone. So it seems the best thing would be a swift end to the military resistance and a retreat into non-cooperation and guerilla war. Occupying Ukraine would present Putin with a whole new set of problems. Then the sanctions can do their work, taking a toll over time. The problem is that the Ukrainian's don't see it that way, and the Russian's appear incapable of anything other than brutal tactics of destruction. So it's likely to be a long-drawn-out process in which the whole of Ukraine gets laid to waste, with a humanitarian problem of epic proportions, energy and food shortages in Europe and Putin under increasing pressure in Russia. Can we trust a pressured Putin? Whether diplomacy can find a way through this quagmire is an open question, but so far the signs are not promising.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
We are between a rock and a hard place. Nato cannot get involved. Whilst we admire the resilience and fortitude of the Ukrainian people, the longer they resist, the worse, and more dangerous it will get for everyone. So it seems the best thing would be a swift end to the military resistance and a retreat into non-cooperation and guerilla war. Occupying Ukraine would present Putin with a whole new set of problems. Then the sanctions can do their work, taking a toll over time. The problem is that the Ukrainian's don't see it that way, and the Russian's appear incapable of anything other than brutal tactics of destruction. So it's likely to be a long-drawn-out process in which the whole of Ukraine gets laid to waste, with a humanitarian problem of epic proportions, energy and food shortages in Europe and Putin under increasing pressure in Russia. Can we trust a pressured Putin? Whether diplomacy can find a way through this quagmire is an open question, but so far the signs are not promising. It really is all dependant on the content of the diplomatic talks and I for one never believed that diplomacy would bring about an immediate cessation of hostilities. The west simply have to prevent a drawn-out conflict with human suffering and a destroyed Ukraine, and uncomfortable compromises will have to be made to prevent further bloodshed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
We are between a rock and a hard place. Nato cannot get involved. Whilst we admire the resilience and fortitude of the Ukrainian people, the longer they resist, the worse, and more dangerous it will get for everyone. So it seems the best thing would be a swift end to the military resistance and a retreat into non-cooperation and guerilla war. Occupying Ukraine would present Putin with a whole new set of problems. Then the sanctions can do their work, taking a toll over time. The problem is that the Ukrainian's don't see it that way, and the Russian's appear incapable of anything other than brutal tactics of destruction. So it's likely to be a long-drawn-out process in which the whole of Ukraine gets laid to waste, with a humanitarian problem of epic proportions, energy and food shortages in Europe and Putin under increasing pressure in Russia. Can we trust a pressured Putin? Whether diplomacy can find a way through this quagmire is an open question, but so far the signs are not promising. Putin isn't stupid, he isn't going to agree to a militarized Ukraine in a peace deal. The idea of guerilla war only becomes an option if this war doesn't end and he takes all Ukraine with no peace deal. Russia isn't a democracy, he'd send his police in and it wouldn't be pretty. The only way to less death is to give him a realistic 'out'. Sanctions aren't going to work and indeed have never worked in changing regimes. All you are doing is pushing Russia into China's hands.....which is going from the pan into the fire. South America, the middle east and sub continent will trade with both sides....there is no winning this and the sooner people can look at things realistically the better. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Mar 2022 11.33am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Putin isn't stupid, he isn't going to agree to a militarized Ukraine in a peace deal. The idea of guerilla war only becomes an option if this war doesn't end and he takes all Ukraine with no peace deal. Russia isn't a democracy, he'd send his police in and it wouldn't be pretty. The only way to less death is to give him a realistic 'out'. Sanctions aren't going to work and indeed have never worked in changing regimes. All you are doing is pushing Russia into China's hands.....which is going from the pan into the fire. South America, the middle east and sub continent will trade with both sides....there is no winning this and the sooner people can look at things realistically the better. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Mar 2022 11.33am) I am in total agreement.
|
|
|
Just in case you don’t have the patience to watch the full documentary
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
Does anyone remember why the UK and US went to war in Iraq? Maybe Putin had similar concerns for invading Ukraine! #doublestandards by most! If Putin really did want the whole of Ukraine he would have had the country within a week! He has given every chance chance to those in charge to end the war! I don't buy into the MSM that the war isint going to plan for Russia! Edited by eaglesdare (13 Mar 2022 11.52am) Wow if this is success I hate to see failure
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Putin isn't stupid, he isn't going to agree to a militarized Ukraine in a peace deal. The idea of guerilla war only becomes an option if this war doesn't end and he takes all Ukraine with no peace deal. Russia isn't a democracy, he'd send his police in and it wouldn't be pretty. The only way to less death is to give him a realistic 'out'. Sanctions aren't going to work and indeed have never worked in changing regimes. All you are doing is pushing Russia into China's hands.....which is going from the pan into the fire. South America, the middle east and sub continent will trade with both sides....there is no winning this and the sooner people can look at things realistically the better. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Mar 2022 11.33am) I agree with this. However, I don't think that precludes either long term non-cooperation or guerilla resistance, which I believe is an inevitability. Putin doesn't possess the resources to police the level of determination that exists in the Ukrainian people. It doesn't have a cadre of sympathisers in Ukraine ready to take over. There's no Oswald Mosely in Ukraine. Sanctions will work. The economic ones are already biting, but the cultural ones will hurt their pride even harder. They are the bargaining chips we can use to gradually extract concessions. China is not a friend of Russia. It needs the west much more than it needs Russia because that's where it sells things. Sure, it will buy it's oil and some food, but that means we will buy what they got from the Middle East. For sure, there are no winners. It's all a question of damage limitation and learning lessons, but we are where we are.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I agree with this. However, I don't think that precludes either long term non-cooperation or guerilla resistance, which I believe is an inevitability. Putin doesn't possess the resources to police the level of determination that exists in the Ukrainian people. It doesn't have a cadre of sympathisers in Ukraine ready to take over. There's no Oswald Mosely in Ukraine. Sanctions will work. The economic ones are already biting, but the cultural ones will hurt their pride even harder. They are the bargaining chips we can use to gradually extract concessions. China is not a friend of Russia. It needs the west much more than it needs Russia because that's where it sells things. Sure, it will buy it's oil and some food, but that means we will buy what they got from the Middle East. For sure, there are no winners. It's all a question of damage limitation and learning lessons, but we are where we are. There is a hard right in east Ukraine but they are a reasonable size in all eastern European countries....all that's a distraction on both sides....nothing in this war is about them. Oswald Mosley (never fought against his own countrymen) so that's a slur. Russia don't need a 'hard right' as they have more than enough pro Russians in East Ukraine. Personally, I don't see a successful resistance in East Ukraine but I guess we will see.....I see one if he tries to take all Ukraine...I don't think that would be sensible for Russia at all, as despite what Putin wants we won't stop supplying resistance. I'd agree with your first sentence and last two two sentences, other than that I think you're being more hopeful than realistic. Where I'm hopeful is that cold war 2 can be pulled back from....I think our politicians need to think longer term in reducing the suffering to everyone that cold war means. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Mar 2022 12.52pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
It really is all dependant on the content of the diplomatic talks and I for one never believed that diplomacy would bring about an immediate cessation of hostilities. The west simply have to prevent a drawn-out conflict with human suffering and a destroyed Ukraine, and uncomfortable compromises will have to be made to prevent further bloodshed.[/quote] But Willo, as you say, Putin will laugh at anything that is neagtive to him, or makes him look like what he did was wrong and so when you say "uncomfotable compromises" you really mean only from Ukraine and their many supporters around the globe. A one-way give in isnt a compromise. Its giving in.
Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978 |
|
|
Originally posted by kevlee
Originally posted by Willo
It really is all dependant on the content of the diplomatic talks and I for one never believed that diplomacy would bring about an immediate cessation of hostilities. The west simply have to prevent a drawn-out conflict with human suffering and a destroyed Ukraine, and uncomfortable compromises will have to be made to prevent further bloodshed.[/quote]
Edited by kevlee (13 Mar 2022 1.08pm)
Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978 |
|
|
Originally posted by kevlee
Originally posted by Willo
It really is all dependant on the content of the diplomatic talks and I for one never believed that diplomacy would bring about an immediate cessation of hostilities. The west simply have to prevent a drawn-out conflict with human suffering and a destroyed Ukraine, and uncomfortable compromises will have to be made to prevent further bloodshed.[/quote] But Willo, as you say, Putin will laugh at anything that is neagtive to him, or makes him look like what he did was wrong and so when you say "uncomfotable compromises" you really mean only from Ukraine and their many supporters around the globe. A one-way give in isnt a compromise. Its giving in. I am not calling for Ukraine to capitulate or sanctions to be ceased. Perhaps a deal could be reached concerning NATO membership and/or regions in the Donbask which houses Russian speakers and perhaps with allegiance to Russia rather than Ukraine. Unless a diplomatic solution is found, the barbarity and bloodshed within Ukraine will continue and maybe an extension of hostilities beyond this conflict.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Economists and other luminaries discussing sanctions on the radio yesterday. And lorries of aid, often get intercepted by military/militias, and much of it feeds/assists the fighters. Comparatively little gets to the needy, in spite of what we'd like to think. Just a realistic perspective, in spite of best intentions. Edited by Forest Hillbilly (13 Mar 2022 1.24pm) I think though we have learned some past lessons. Whilst sanctions are always a blunt tool, these have been quite carefully targetted. The oligarchs are being hit, and they are essential to Putin. The central bank has been hit, which will stop Russian reserves being utilised to prop up the ruble. The Swift system has been suspended, which disrupts trade. Social, sporting and cultural ties have been broken. These hurt pride and raise questions, without making people hungry. It might be a slow burner, but I think they will be effective.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I think though we have learned some past lessons. Whilst sanctions are always a blunt tool, these have been quite carefully targetted. The oligarchs are being hit, and they are essential to Putin. The central bank has been hit, which will stop Russian reserves being utilised to prop up the ruble. The Swift system has been suspended, which disrupts trade. Social, sporting and cultural ties have been broken. These hurt pride and raise questions, without making people hungry. It might be a slow burner, but I think they will be effective. For once I agree, in the past sanctions didn't work these days they are more targetted. They still might not work but hopefully they don't hurt the public but the elite. Of course some times regimes twist them into their favour. I think it was Saddam (pick your tyrant) but whoever deliberately withheld medical supplies from the public and blamed the west, of course they were never on the sanctions list. It's also about perception, if you sanction Russia the public feel that their country is being threatened and start feeling patriotic. If you target a group of elites the public may not rush to defend them. Boris's speech to the Russian people was an attempt to separate Putin and Co from the rest. I'm not sure there is much more we can do short of war. Edited by Badger11 (13 Mar 2022 1.45pm)
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I have watched another Oxford Union presentation, which I found interesting, and revealing, from another well known former MI6 insider. As with the one previously linked to, from Sir John Sawyer, this gives a detained, unemotional analysis of the background and thinking that lies behind recent events. This is from Christopher Steele, who I also gave a link to before. That though was only a brief interview. This is very much longer, detailed and wide-ranging. Steele, you will recall, was responsible for the "trump dossier", which he touches on in this presentation and makes a link to what he reported in that and what is happening in Ukraine. He obviously knows what he is talking about. No politics here. Just facts. I recommend it:- Just watched this Wisbech. Thanks for posting. Steele obviously has an in-depth understanding of the complex political issues at play and, like Sawers', his intelligent views are gripping.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
For once I agree, in the past sanctions didn't work these days they are more targetted. They still might not work but hopefully they don't hurt the public but the elite. Of course some times regimes twist them into their favour. I think it was Saddam (pick your tyrant) but whoever deliberately withheld medical supplies from the public and blamed the west, of course they were never on the sanctions list. It's also about perception, if you sanction Russia the public feel that their country is being threatened and start feeling patriotic. If you target a group of elites the public may not rush to defend them. Boris's speech to the Russian people was an attempt to separate Putin and Co from the rest. I'm not sure there is much more we can do short of war. Edited by Badger11 (13 Mar 2022 1.45pm) The action against banks, businesses and energy is already impacting the common person in the street. Russia media already portrays the west as the enemy in the same way the media is doing to Russia here. These sanctions will have the same affect all sanctions have, they will increase support for the regime. The only point of them is as a bargaining chip to normalise relations......but if they have already re-orientated their economy by that time it becomes pointless. In the meantime we all will suffer....not the elites who plot this path but the already vulnerable, everyone will be downgraded to some extent. Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Mar 2022 2.29pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.