You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Gaza Strip 'invades' Israel.
November 22 2026 1.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Gaza Strip 'invades' Israel.


Page 88 of 140 < 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 >
EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 27 Feb 24 3.10pm

Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines

The population density of Gaza is far higher than Ukraine, Russia or the disputed regions around Crimea, therefore the casualty rate logically would likely be greater on a 'per bomb' basis. Ukraine civilians have been allowed sanctuary in neighbouring countries and so civilian deaths are minimised(?). What we are seeing in Gaza is that neighbouring countries are not opening their doors. Egypt has a border with Gaza but as others have pointed out on this forum, they don't want an influx of potentially radical people who are diametrically opposed to the ruling position in Egypt. In addition they don't want to be seen as helping Israel by clearing Gaza for them. The geography, both physical and political is different.

Russia have deliberately targeted densely populated areas, hit civilians targets and used cluster bombs and other such 'unguided' artillery throughout their campaign - there's no way Russia have 'minimised' civilian deaths - they've been specifically accused of doing the opposite. Despite that, an estimated 10,000 civilians have been killed in Ukraine in just over a year of fighting. Most reports have Palestinian civilians casualties at around 30,000 in less than half that time.

Of course the geography of the regions is a huge factor, but it still does not make the Israel invasion unique in military terms, and it doesn't explain the huge discrepancies in outcome.

 

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 27 Feb 24 3.20pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Russia have deliberately targeted densely populated areas, hit civilians targets and used cluster bombs and other such 'unguided' artillery throughout their campaign - there's no way Russia have 'minimised' civilian deaths - they've been specifically accused of doing the opposite. Despite that, an estimated 10,000 civilians have been killed in Ukraine in just over a year of fighting. Most reports have Palestinian civilians casualties at around 30,000 in less than half that time.

Of course the geography of the regions is a huge factor, but it still does not make the Israel invasion unique in military terms, and it doesn't explain the huge discrepancies in outcome.

If you are a civilian in Ukraine you have options; stay put, move to another part of the country or apply to neighbouring countries for shelter. Gaza residents have nowhere to flee to; their state is too small to offer alternatives and their neighbours don’t want them. Consequently there are bound to be more casualties in Gaza. I would also mention that during WW2, the Underground was opened up to shelter civilians from German bomb attacks. Not aware that the Gaza authorities are providing the same underground tunnel protection to civilians; their citizens are expendable to bolster sympathy from the West. It appears to be working.

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 27 Feb 24 3.30pm

Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines

If you are a civilian in Ukraine you have options; stay put, move to another part of the country or apply to neighbouring countries for shelter. Gaza residents have nowhere to flee to; their state is too small to offer alternatives and their neighbours don’t want them. Consequently there are bound to be more casualties in Gaza. I would also mention that during WW2, the Underground was opened up to shelter civilians from German bomb attacks. Not aware that the Gaza authorities are providing the same underground tunnel protection to civilians; their citizens are expendable to bolster sympathy from the West. It appears to be working.

What you're describing in not allowing civilians to leave is a war crime, FYI.

As well as providing escape routes for civilians, you'd expect an advanced military conducting operations in such a region to do so with due caution to civilian life and infrastructure... but alas.

Your last line seems to suggest that the death of 30,000 civilians, many of whom are children, should somehow not bolster sympathy. If Israel wanted to stop this bolstering of sympathy, they could just stop murdering civilians?

 

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 27 Feb 24 3.52pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

What you're describing in not allowing civilians to leave is a war crime, FYI.

As well as providing escape routes for civilians, you'd expect an advanced military conducting operations in such a region to do so with due caution to civilian life and infrastructure... but alas.

Your last line seems to suggest that the death of 30,000 civilians, many of whom are children, should somehow not bolster sympathy. If Israel wanted to stop this bolstering of sympathy, they could just stop murdering civilians?

Egypt could open its border, but it doesn’t.

If Hamas didn’t hide within a civilian population, then you’d get less civilian casualties.

I am not saying that I don’t have sympathy; I am saying that Hamas is deliberately allowing its civilians to be killed for propaganda purposes.

Yes, Israel could stop, so could Hamas but there is hatred that we can’t comprehend. A return of kidnapped Israelis would help, but only now is there a glimmer of hope that this might happen. Is that because Israel has done what it has done or because Hamas realise that its Arab neighbours are not joining in on the fight?

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 27 Feb 24 4.02pm

Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines

Egypt could open its border, but it doesn’t.

If Hamas didn’t hide within a civilian population, then you’d get less civilian casualties.

I am not saying that I don’t have sympathy; I am saying that Hamas is deliberately allowing its civilians to be killed for propaganda purposes.

Yes, Israel could stop, so could Hamas but there is hatred that we can’t comprehend. A return of kidnapped Israelis would help, but only now is there a glimmer of hope that this might happen. Is that because Israel has done what it has done or because Hamas realise that its Arab neighbours are not joining in on the fight?

You just seem to trying to allocate blame to everyone except the people doing the killing... Egypt could do this, the terrorists could do that... how about the military super-power stops bombing civilians areas? That's surely point number 1 in terms of ways to save civilians.

You say "Israel could stop, so could Hamas" - what exactly could Hamas stop? How many Israeli casualties have there been since October 8th?

Which side do you think hold more hostages?

 

Behind Enemy Lines Flag Sussex 27 Feb 24 4.36pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

You just seem to trying to allocate blame to everyone except the people doing the killing... Egypt could do this, the terrorists could do that... how about the military super-power stops bombing civilians areas? That's surely point number 1 in terms of ways to save civilians.

You say "Israel could stop, so could Hamas" - what exactly could Hamas stop? How many Israeli casualties have there been since October 8th?

Which side do you think hold more hostages?

You seem to want one side to play by the rules and not the other. Would Israel be doing what it is doing if Hamas hadn’t attacked back in October?

What could Hamas do? How about agreeing to return the hostages if the Israelis stop their actions? One a day returned as long as the fighting stops; perhaps with some form of guarantees?

Who holds more hostages? Hamas. Don’t confuse people in prison with hostages?

As to stop bombing civilian areas; please tell the Israelis where Hamas fighters are located so that civilian deaths can be avoided.

There have not been Israeli casualties caused by Hamas since their initial attack that I am aware of because Israel has taken the fight to Hamas on their territory. Forces inside Lebanon have however killed civilians since.

 


hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing.

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 27 Feb 24 5.14pm

Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines

You seem to want one side to play by the rules and not the other. Would Israel be doing what it is doing if Hamas hadn’t attacked back in October?

What could Hamas do? How about agreeing to return the hostages if the Israelis stop their actions? One a day returned as long as the fighting stops; perhaps with some form of guarantees?

Who holds more hostages? Hamas. Don’t confuse people in prison with hostages?

As to stop bombing civilian areas; please tell the Israelis where Hamas fighters are located so that civilian deaths can be avoided.

There have not been Israeli casualties caused by Hamas since their initial attack that I am aware of because Israel has taken the fight to Hamas on their territory. Forces inside Lebanon have however killed civilians since.

For the umpteenth time, yes I hold Israel to a higher standard than a terrorist organisation, as should anyone. To suggest anything other than that is ludicrous.

I don’t think there’s any benefit in further exchange - your posts are just swaying further and further into parroting Israeli propaganda; Israel have no hostages, this all started on October 7th and this is the only conflict in history where combatants have hid amongst civilian populations. Apparently any responsibility to minimise civilian deaths goes away if this is the case.

What a miracle that there have no recent Israeli casualties in this desperate fight for their survival. Some war.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 27 Feb 24 5.28pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

For the umpteenth time, yes I hold Israel to a higher standard than a terrorist organisation, as should anyone. To suggest anything other than that is ludicrous.

I don’t think there’s any benefit in further exchange - your posts are just swaying further and further into parroting Israeli propaganda; Israel have no hostages, this all started on October 7th and this is the only conflict in history where combatants have hid amongst civilian populations. Apparently any responsibility to minimise civilian deaths goes away if this is the case.

What a miracle that there have no recent Israeli casualties in this desperate fight for their survival. Some war.

They’re not though are they. He puts perfectly valid reason about why it’s happening but you can’t bring yourself to admit the points made are actually how it is. Never mind though as shutting down a conversation is as good as being correct in some quarters!
Btw where do you get your figures about deaths ?

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 27 Feb 24 5.40pm

Originally posted by cryrst

They’re not though are they. He puts perfectly valid reason about why it’s happening but you can’t bring yourself to admit the points made are actually how it is. Never mind though as shutting down a conversation is as good as being correct in some quarters!
Btw where do you get your figures about deaths ?

Thanks for another excellent contribution.

Please stop replying to my posts.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 27 Feb 24 6.57pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Thanks for another excellent contribution.

Please stop replying to my posts.

Don’t post then or actually answer the question or just ignore them. I won’t be offended but silence is golden as the saying goes.
We had this out before about my reference to something about you. I stopped that but clearly it wasn’t enough.!

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 27 Feb 24 10.50pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

You just seem to trying to allocate blame to everyone except the people doing the killing... Egypt could do this, the terrorists could do that... how about the military super-power stops bombing civilians areas? That's surely point number 1 in terms of ways to save civilians.

You say "Israel could stop, so could Hamas" - what exactly could Hamas stop? How many Israeli casualties have there been since October 8th?

Which side do you think hold more hostages?

Hamas could stop shooting rockets, stop fighting in Gaza and stop using the population as human shields

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 27 Feb 24 11.06pm

Apparently Netanyahu believes that 82% of Americans support Israel in its actions in Gaza as a consequence of a recent poll.

Does that seem possible?

I can believe that 82% would say yes to a question that asked if Israel has a right to exist or retaliate with overwhelming force after the actions of Hamas, but to ignore the suffering of civilians, refuse aid and humanitarian support?

My concerns about Netanyahu predate this war. I was expressing them here months ago as he attempted to rewrite the constitution and take control of the Supreme Court. Having been in Israel just a few weeks before Hamas came over the border to murder so many and set all of the mayhem in motion I saw some of the characteristics of the Israeli people first hand. My wife describes them as the unfriendliest people she has ever spent time with and like me she has travelled widely. We spent a week on a cruise of the Eastern Med after our stay in Israel on a ship leaving from Haifa, where almost everyone was Israeli. At no point did we have any social interactions or even a “good morning”.

I don’t know the relevance other than they are very tribal, suspicious and not at all like anyone else I have encountered. They don’t think like us. Netanyahu seems the embodiment of this.

I know the USA has many people with strange ideas but 82%?

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

cryrst Flag The garden of England 28 Feb 24 12.06am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Apparently Netanyahu believes that 82% of Americans support Israel in its actions in Gaza as a consequence of a recent poll.

Does that seem possible?

I can believe that 82% would say yes to a question that asked if Israel has a right to exist or retaliate with overwhelming force after the actions of Hamas, but to ignore the suffering of civilians, refuse aid and humanitarian support?

My concerns about Netanyahu predate this war. I was expressing them here months ago as he attempted to rewrite the constitution and take control of the Supreme Court. Having been in Israel just a few weeks before Hamas came over the border to murder so many and set all of the mayhem in motion I saw some of the characteristics of the Israeli people first hand. My wife describes them as the unfriendliest people she has ever spent time with and like me she has travelled widely. We spent a week on a cruise of the Eastern Med after our stay in Israel on a ship leaving from Haifa, where almost everyone was Israeli. At no point did we have any social interactions or even a “good morning”.

I don’t know the relevance other than they are very tribal, suspicious and not at all like anyone else I have encountered. They don’t think like us. Netanyahu seems the embodiment of this.

I know the USA has many people with strange ideas but 82%?

I doubt the question was phrased like that as it’s totally loaded.
Are Israel correct in their actions after the terror attack on 7th October may be the question which gets that result.
After 9/11 and the current immigrant problem I'm not surprised.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 28 Feb 24 7.35am

Are Israel correct in utilising military force in the wholesale slaughter, displacement and starvation of an entire population ?

Would Israel be correct in utilising military force to deal specifically with terrorists ?

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 28 Feb 24 11.46am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Apparently Netanyahu believes that 82% of Americans support Israel in its actions in Gaza as a consequence of a recent poll.

Does that seem possible?

I can believe that 82% would say yes to a question that asked if Israel has a right to exist or retaliate with overwhelming force after the actions of Hamas, but to ignore the suffering of civilians, refuse aid and humanitarian support?

My concerns about Netanyahu predate this war. I was expressing them here months ago as he attempted to rewrite the constitution and take control of the Supreme Court. Having been in Israel just a few weeks before Hamas came over the border to murder so many and set all of the mayhem in motion I saw some of the characteristics of the Israeli people first hand. My wife describes them as the unfriendliest people she has ever spent time with and like me she has travelled widely. We spent a week on a cruise of the Eastern Med after our stay in Israel on a ship leaving from Haifa, where almost everyone was Israeli. At no point did we have any social interactions or even a “good morning”.

I don’t know the relevance other than they are very tribal, suspicious and not at all like anyone else I have encountered. They don’t think like us. Netanyahu seems the embodiment of this.

I know the USA has many people with strange ideas but 82%?

I doubt 82% support it frankly. All I hear is Genocide Joe, Genocide Joe - so it looks like people don't support the Biden administration on this. However, it would be interesting to hear from an American on this.

 


Red and Blue Army!

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 28 Feb 24 1.54pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

I doubt 82% support it frankly. All I hear is Genocide Joe, Genocide Joe - so it looks like people don't support the Biden administration on this. However, it would be interesting to hear from an American on this.

Agree - I'd be amazed if 82% support Israel's action in it's entirety.

I don't know if anyone has heard of/seen the Aaron Bushell video - a serving US solider who set himself on fire outside the Israeli embassy a couple of days back, but the fallout from that certainly doesn't suggest that big a majority of Americans support what Israel are doing.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 28 Feb 24 2.05pm

Bibi and Joe, 'the genocide twins'.

To see the President of the United States munching on an ice cream cone while Palestinian children are starving to death, tells you everything about the current state of the USA, and the UKs shame for supporting it.

Genocide Joe 'would like a ceasefire', in the conflict where the USA itself weaponised and financed Israel.

Blood on their hands.


 

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Feb 24 2.25pm

Why can't we just be like India and keep ourselves out of foreign affairs. Why can't we trade with the middle east and not be involved in who does what to whom?

I don't want to be implicated in anything Israel do or with anything the Palestinians do in this blood feud.

This is the American's mess and we should have stayed out of it.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 28 Feb 24 10.19pm

When you think of genocide, the first that comes to mind the Holocaust although I always think of Armenia, there are obviously others.

They are never forgotten and the victims permanently scarred and embittered through generations.

The Norwegian aid chief in Rafah, 'what they are doing will unleash a terrible revenge'.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 28 Feb 24 11.32pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Bibi and Joe, 'the genocide twins'.

To see the President of the United States munching on an ice cream cone while Palestinian children are starving to death, tells you everything about the current state of the USA, and the UKs shame for supporting it.

Genocide Joe 'would like a ceasefire', in the conflict where the USA itself weaponised and financed Israel.

Blood on their hands.


And how was your lunch today ?

 

Page 88 of 140 < 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Gaza Strip 'invades' Israel.