This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Shameful attention seeking post.
|
|
|
Quote serial thriller at 22 May 2013 8.18pm
Had quite an intense with a mate of mine today about one of the great celebrated figures of this nation's political history. I think I may have brought this up on here before but I've always held the view that Churchill is viewed as a great leader because he won. Had he lost, I believe a lot of questionable stuff the British did would have come out, but instead it's wiped under the carpet and we continue to moan about those nasty Germans with their concentration camps (an idea they knicked off us) and anti-Semitism (which was thriving in Britain in the 30s). The clearest example of this for me is the Bengal Famine. Churchill, fearful that the Japs might invade northern India, decided rather than evacuate the natives, he would just stop sending them food and shelter (in the middle of a famine) leading to millions of deaths, some claim on a similar scale as the number of Jews killed in concentration camps. When asked about this, Churchill blamed them for 'breeding like rabbits'. He also supported a Bill to sterilise the mentally disabled (I'm not making this up! [Link] a form of, err, eugenics. So let's look at the evidence: a mass-murderer, who supported racial purification, but won a lot of people over because he was a good public speaker and adopted the role as figurehead of a nation. Now who does that remind me of... Anyone willing to defend him? Edited by serial thriller (22 May 2013 8.18pm)
Everyone is entitled to my opinions |
|
| TheJudge |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote premier fan at 29 Jan 2015 8.35pm
Shameful attention seeking post. Lol. I suppose the irony of your post is lost on you.
|
|
|
Quote pefwin at 29 Jan 2015 10.39pm
So did anyone see the programme?
Pro USA & Israel |
|
| blackgirl3 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote legaleagle at 29 Jan 2015 8.59pm
Churchill was indeed a multi-faceted individual with some aspects largely very much less focused on since his elevation to national saviour status post perhaps 1945.And even then,it was a beautiful aspect of our country relative to many others,that he could be rightly lauded as a hero,but kicked out at an election when the war was over and the focus could just be on politics, without affecting his "national hero" status. The Bengal famine is not something to be proud of nor was his treatment of the miners.And his military strategy re Gallipoli in world war 1 was a fiasco.Only 3 examples. ps.blackgirl 3.He didn't send the POW's we captured back to please the Americans.It was an awful thing but a deal was cut,at Soviet insistence,that all the allies must return their respective nationals found in territory liberated by another ally to their "home country".We had very large numbers of POW's in territories liberated by the Soviet Union.If that deal hadn't been cut,a lot less than did would have made it back. Did you know quite a few never came back,disappeared at the end of the war into thin air,probably killed or sent to the Gulag and have never been accounted for,even today? Most of the people being handed back to the Soviet Union against their will weren't liberated POW's but Soviet nationals who had fought with the Nazis post 1941.That doesn't make it right but...Wonder if we would have agreed to any of our allies refusing to hand over any of our nationals who had fought with the Nazis (and very small numbers did). As for anti-semitism in Britain in the 1930's,which the OP suggests we ignore in favour of still banging on about German anti-semitism in the 1930's, forgive me but there is perhaps a very slight difference between the support for it here and the near total support for the vilest form of it leading to the industrial slaughter of millions.And that ignores the many British people who took to the streets against Mosley's fascists here,hugely supported by the unions and left wingers. Bear in mind,in the 1930's Churchill was an anti-appeaser.It was appeasers,who tended to contain in their ranks the anti-semites. The main thing he's remembered for is the decision in 1940 not to cut a deal with the Nazis post-Dunkirk.If we had lost, he wouldn't be remembered well perhaps because we'd have all been indoctrinated to think of Hitler as a laudable figure(or indeed perhaps the opposite and he would have been a hero to the "underground resistance" and the general population.) The outcome had appeasement triumphed in 1940/early 1941 would have been being in reality an indoctrinated client state of Hitler like Vichy France,though not at first under partial occupation. The Soviet Union likely would have fallen back way way further east in 1941 with the Nazis controlling even vaster swathes of its territory for decades,and The US unable to invade France due to lack of a "floating island" air and sea base in Northern/Western Europe. So,lets get real.Do I agree with him politically including his rampant imperialism? No.Did he do some very bad things? Yes.Did he do some very good things? Yes.Did he do an amazingly great thing in being a superb people's war leader when it seriously counted? Yes So,yes a need for balance and seeing beyond "national myth",but those calling for more balance (fair enough) all need to be as balanced and realistic overall as anyone else,particularly when stakes are very high and alternatives bad too and one decision or another has to be made (and,as in Bengal, he got it very wrong more than once during the war).
[Link] here is a photo english people in londons pall mall doing the nazi salut at the funeral of the german ambassador in 1936 made up of englands ruling elite there are other photos of storm troops goose stepping up the mall as well with english guardsmen,as for the russians being sent back to there death in gulags or firing squads ,churchill could have stopped it from happening ,yes it was agreed at i think the[ yalta conferance] , between stalin and f.d,r that churchill attended but said deals were done behind his back ,but 100,000s polish people who forght with the nazi s were given asylum but most never saw there homeland or families ever again which was very sad ,but churchill was a highly sensitive and complicated man ,but in my opinion more of p,r man than a leader, i think lord halifax was more the power broker at that time than churchill ,
Edited by blackgirl3 (29 Jan 2015 11.34pm) Edited by blackgirl3 (29 Jan 2015 11.51pm) Edited by blackgirl3 (29 Jan 2015 11.53pm)
|
|
| legaleagle |
|
|---|---|
|
Not harsh at all. I've had enough of Churchill ,returned POW's etc for now. Off to bed.
|
|
| blackgirl3 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote legaleagle at 30 Jan 2015 12.27am
Not harsh at all. I've had enough of Churchill ,returned POW's etc for now. Off to bed. night night
|
|
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 29 Jan 2015 6.46pm
Quote Joe Bloggs at 29 Jan 2015 5.20pm
It is one thing to discuss Churchill and wartime Britain after the event but so many things went on during those times that censorship and propaganda removed so much of the truth. We heard of Coventry and the London docks,even more bombs fell on South London--but we never heard of the bombing which Hull suffered, possibly the worst in the country and yet people living through those dreadful times were kept in ignorance of those facts. The real crime is that nothing has been done to improve Hull since... Whilst true,Jamie, it could be argued that the bombings themselves were responsible for £manyM worth of improvements.
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
|
You've got to crack some eggs to make an omlette.
Pride of South London |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.