You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end
November 22 2026 2.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end


Page 9 of 25 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Nov 14 12.41pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 26 Nov 2014 12.10pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 26 Nov 2014 8.58am

Quote serial thriller at 24 Nov 2014 5.19pm

You also can 'just give everyone a payrise' as we saw just the other week when the Tories raised the minimum wage, and as we see in the fact that Labour and the Greens want to increase it further. You also can have rent control, which we did before 1980, around the time the housing market exploded.

Er, possibly a bit misleading there. “Before 1980”… ie, before Thatcher... they started decontrolling rents in 1957, ie, a long way before 1980. It was very *gradual* (you could only re-adjust rent once tenants had moved on) and there was lots of to-ing and fro-ing (Labour re-controlled, then de-controlled, and so on). The 1980 Housing Act wasn’t a Thatcherite Big Bang by any means.

I could also bore everyone with a lecture about the dangers of Rachmanism and how de-controlling rents is not just about rampant profit-mongering, but can also help to avoid slum landlords and underinvestment, but let’s not let that get in the way of an idiotic lefty rant.

I just had to pick you up on the “before 1980” comment, because it was lazy and misleading.

And as for this:

Quote serial thriller at 24 Nov 2014 5.19pm

I believe the abolition of Private Property would be of more use

I’m not even going to comment. Just leave it to hang there while I gaze at in wonderment.


Come on Johnny... surely you can buy in to "All property is theft"

That's why Marx drank Camomile you know.

I don't really see an issue with the idea of a society without personal ownership per se. What is hard to see is a route from where we are now, to where that would be, that didn't really involve a lot of things being burned down and a few civil wars over the matter

Edited by jamiemartin721 (26 Nov 2014 12.42pm)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 26 Nov 14 12.43pm

Jeez, guess I should probably defend myself then.

To call for the abolition of private property has not, historically, necessarily been an implausibly radical concept. I read a pretty interesting thing about the Levellers the other day, from around the Civil War period in England, and they argued from a religious perspective that as property had only ever been gained via oppression, theft or murder, and that this contradicted the teachings of Christianity that in an ideal Roundhead society would be practiced.

Likewise, in the early 20th century when Bolshevism was on the rise in much of the world, the concept of the justice or injustice of private property was widely discussed. Important to point out that this was held within conversations of Communism in theory, and certainly wasn't a policy effectively carried out by Soviet Russia, where the beauraucratic corruption very much lead to certain individuals enjoying exclusive access to private capital and property.

So these things have been genuinely discussed. But sadly in the post-Cold War period, to even suggest such a thing is to be roundly mocked as having views which are perhaps impractical, or even totally implausible.

And property is still based on those three things: oppression, theft or murder, and thus should still therefore be challenged. And I don't mean paying your mortgage involves a blood sacrifice, I mean that the very idea you must pay for a stable habitat to live in and the reason someone else has any right to claim ownership is a f*cking joke. The Queen still owns 6,600 million acres of land. How did she get that? What need has one person to own so much land, other than to extract money from her tenants through a rent which she ultimately can arbitrarily fix, and why should she own it when it's simply been passed down to her via her murdering, thieving oppressive regal predecessors?

A post-private property society wouldn't mean kicking you out of your home, it would simply mean that the primitive animal need to have a roof over your head wouldn't be decided on your financial clout. I agree with Jamie that this view is so far from the political mainstream at the minute that it would probably take a revolution to occur, but isn't that the depressing point, that we have reached a stage where the idea of certain human beings 'owning' large masses of land at the detriment of almost all other human beings is just accepted without thought?

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 26 Nov 14 3.17pm

Needless to say, I simply don't accept the premise that private property is based on "oppression, theft or murder". Maybe in the 11th century, but today? Don't be daft.

On the contrary, private property is one of the biggest guarantors of freedom we have. Certainly more robust than the flimsy protections provided by a universal suffrage democracy and representative government.

Abolish private property and you have two options:

1. Anarchy. During periods of which oppression, theft and murder tend to thrive.

2. Some kind of collective organisation running things "on behalf of" individuals. Again, the historical precedents of this aren't good.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

npn Flag Crowborough 26 Nov 14 3.58pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Nov 2014 12.43pm

Jeez, guess I should probably defend myself then.

To call for the abolition of private property has not, historically, necessarily been an implausibly radical concept. I read a pretty interesting thing about the Levellers the other day, from around the Civil War period in England, and they argued from a religious perspective that as property had only ever been gained via oppression, theft or murder, and that this contradicted the teachings of Christianity that in an ideal Roundhead society would be practiced.

Likewise, in the early 20th century when Bolshevism was on the rise in much of the world, the concept of the justice or injustice of private property was widely discussed. Important to point out that this was held within conversations of Communism in theory, and certainly wasn't a policy effectively carried out by Soviet Russia, where the beauraucratic corruption very much lead to certain individuals enjoying exclusive access to private capital and property.

So these things have been genuinely discussed. But sadly in the post-Cold War period, to even suggest such a thing is to be roundly mocked as having views which are perhaps impractical, or even totally implausible.

And property is still based on those three things: oppression, theft or murder, and thus should still therefore be challenged. And I don't mean paying your mortgage involves a blood sacrifice, I mean that the very idea you must pay for a stable habitat to live in and the reason someone else has any right to claim ownership is a f*cking joke. The Queen still owns 6,600 million acres of land. How did she get that? What need has one person to own so much land, other than to extract money from her tenants through a rent which she ultimately can arbitrarily fix, and why should she own it when it's simply been passed down to her via her murdering, thieving oppressive regal predecessors?

A post-private property society wouldn't mean kicking you out of your home, it would simply mean that the primitive animal need to have a roof over your head wouldn't be decided on your financial clout. I agree with Jamie that this view is so far from the political mainstream at the minute that it would probably take a revolution to occur, but isn't that the depressing point, that we have reached a stage where the idea of certain human beings 'owning' large masses of land at the detriment of almost all other human beings is just accepted without thought?


I own a house (well, me and the bank do), and to the best of my knowledge, nobody has ever been murdered, stolen from, or oppressed on the way to that situation - not even historically (it was a clay quarry - a lump of which was sold off, a house built in the 50s, which I subsequently bought).

your posts (while I don't often agree) usually contain a semblance of sense - that one just seems ridiculous.

Does your 'no private property' idea extend to ALL property, i.e. your personal possessions, clothing, cars, etc?

 

Pawson Palace Flag Croydon 26 Nov 14 4.45pm

Surely if you work hard and are a productive member of society you should be entitled to have a home you can call your own?

If the state housed, watered and fed everyone would anything ever be done?

There has to be a reward for hard work, enterprise and innovation otherwise what is the point if everything you've worked for is taken away?

I bought my flat at the tender age of 22 and the idea that I wouldn't own it doesn't sit right with me. I've forgone a hell of lot to be able to afford that place and even some 5 years later it's still not easy. It's also made me work hard in order to better myself so I can life more comfortably and not have to worry about money in later life.

Part of this is the problem with some people my age, they simply don't want to roll up their sleeves and get on with it. The sense of entitlement and having everything on a plate for them is such a cancerous mind-set that is spreading rapidly.

 


Pride of South London
Upper Holmesdale Block P

Stuk Flag Top half 26 Nov 14 4.50pm

Why are you lot even trying to debate the notion of abolishing private property, when just three words are needed.

Don't be daft.

 


Optimistic as ever

ghosteagle Flag 26 Nov 14 5.26pm

Quote serial thriller at 26 Nov 2014 12.43pm

Jeez, guess I should probably defend myself then.

To call for the abolition of private property has not, historically, necessarily been an implausibly radical concept. I read a pretty interesting thing about the Levellers the other day, from around the Civil War period in England, and they argued from a religious perspective that as property had only ever been gained via oppression, theft or murder, and that this contradicted the teachings of Christianity that in an ideal Roundhead society would be practiced.

Likewise, in the early 20th century when Bolshevism was on the rise in much of the world, the concept of the justice or injustice of private property was widely discussed. Important to point out that this was held within conversations of Communism in theory, and certainly wasn't a policy effectively carried out by Soviet Russia, where the beauraucratic corruption very much lead to certain individuals enjoying exclusive access to private capital and property.

So these things have been genuinely discussed. But sadly in the post-Cold War period, to even suggest such a thing is to be roundly mocked as having views which are perhaps impractical, or even totally implausible.

And property is still based on those three things: oppression, theft or murder, and thus should still therefore be challenged. And I don't mean paying your mortgage involves a blood sacrifice, I mean that the very idea you must pay for a stable habitat to live in and the reason someone else has any right to claim ownership is a f*cking joke. The Queen still owns 6,600 million acres of land. How did she get that? What need has one person to own so much land, other than to extract money from her tenants through a rent which she ultimately can arbitrarily fix, and why should she own it when it's simply been passed down to her via her murdering, thieving oppressive regal predecessors?

A post-private property society wouldn't mean kicking you out of your home, it would simply mean that the primitive animal need to have a roof over your head wouldn't be decided on your financial clout. I agree with Jamie that this view is so far from the political mainstream at the minute that it would probably take a revolution to occur, but isn't that the depressing point, that we have reached a stage where the idea of certain human beings 'owning' large masses of land at the detriment of almost all other human beings is just accepted without thought?

Good post.

 

ghosteagle Flag 26 Nov 14 5.26pm

Quote Stuk at 26 Nov 2014 4.50pm

Why are you lot even trying to debate the notion of abolishing private property, when just three words are needed.

Don't be daft.


I think the three words you are looking for are

People too greedy.

 

elgrande Flag bedford 26 Nov 14 5.33pm

So I have worked hard all my life,managed to keep a roof over my head,clothe and feed 4 children,seen them grow up to be good members of our society(all working and paying their taxes).
And own my own home,and all the time I have been doing it wrong and a bad member of the human race because I own things,


f*** off back to a nice communist state and enjoy yourself.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

elgrande Flag bedford 26 Nov 14 5.34pm

Quote ghosteagle at 26 Nov 2014 5.26pm

Quote Stuk at 26 Nov 2014 4.50pm

Why are you lot even trying to debate the notion of abolishing private property, when just three words are needed.

Don't be daft.


I think the three words you are looking for are

People too greedy.


Why is it greedy to work hard and have things,please tell.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

ghosteagle Flag 26 Nov 14 5.37pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 26 Nov 2014 3.17pm

Needless to say, I simply don't accept the premise that private property is based on "oppression, theft or murder". Maybe in the 11th century, but today? Don't be daft.

On the contrary, private property is one of the biggest guarantors of freedom we have. Certainly more robust than the flimsy protections provided by a universal suffrage democracy and representative government.

Abolish private property and you have two options:

1. Anarchy. During periods of which oppression, theft and murder tend to thrive.

2. Some kind of collective organisation running things "on behalf of" individuals. Again, the historical precedents of this aren't good.

You realise that number two is the form of government we currently have right???

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 26 Nov 14 8.52pm

Quote ghosteagle at 26 Nov 2014 5.37pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 26 Nov 2014 3.17pm

Needless to say, I simply don't accept the premise that private property is based on "oppression, theft or murder". Maybe in the 11th century, but today? Don't be daft.

On the contrary, private property is one of the biggest guarantors of freedom we have. Certainly more robust than the flimsy protections provided by a universal suffrage democracy and representative government.

Abolish private property and you have two options:

1. Anarchy. During periods of which oppression, theft and murder tend to thrive.

2. Some kind of collective organisation running things "on behalf of" individuals. Again, the historical precedents of this aren't good.

You realise that number two is the form of government we currently have right???

Ha ha, fair point. Depending on how you interpret "collective".

I honestly think you're all completely bonkers wanting to abolish property. Quickest possible way to murderous tyranny there is!

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

matt_himself Flag Matataland 26 Nov 14 10.57pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 26 Nov 2014 8.52pm

Quote ghosteagle at 26 Nov 2014 5.37pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 26 Nov 2014 3.17pm

Needless to say, I simply don't accept the premise that private property is based on "oppression, theft or murder". Maybe in the 11th century, but today? Don't be daft.

On the contrary, private property is one of the biggest guarantors of freedom we have. Certainly more robust than the flimsy protections provided by a universal suffrage democracy and representative government.

Abolish private property and you have two options:

1. Anarchy. During periods of which oppression, theft and murder tend to thrive.

2. Some kind of collective organisation running things "on behalf of" individuals. Again, the historical precedents of this aren't good.

You realise that number two is the form of government we currently have right???

Ha ha, fair point. Depending on how you interpret "collective".

I honestly think you're all completely bonkers wanting to abolish property. Quickest possible way to murderous tyranny there is!

One massive blocker for me is that the Kumar Rouge declared private property illegal.

That didn't end up well. The largest genocide in history. However, it will probably be deemed 'progressive' by the sorts who think that a caliphate under ISIS is 'progressive'.

Misguided fools.


 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 26 Nov 14 11.36pm


I wonder how many of those that are slagging of Brand have actually read 'revolution'

Edited by nickgusset (26 Nov 2014 11.38pm)

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 26 Nov 14 11.45pm

Revolution:

[Link]

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 27 Nov 14 12.05am

That Cock Brand was on the Wendy Williams show this morning *Super knockers Wendy*

 


Pro USA & Israel

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 27 Nov 14 12.41am

Quote matt_himself at 26 Nov 2014 10.57pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 26 Nov 2014 8.52pm

Quote ghosteagle at 26 Nov 2014 5.37pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 26 Nov 2014 3.17pm

Needless to say, I simply don't accept the premise that private property is based on "oppression, theft or murder". Maybe in the 11th century, but today? Don't be daft.

On the contrary, private property is one of the biggest guarantors of freedom we have. Certainly more robust than the flimsy protections provided by a universal suffrage democracy and representative government.

Abolish private property and you have two options:

1. Anarchy. During periods of which oppression, theft and murder tend to thrive.

2. Some kind of collective organisation running things "on behalf of" individuals. Again, the historical precedents of this aren't good.

You realise that number two is the form of government we currently have right???

Ha ha, fair point. Depending on how you interpret "collective".

I honestly think you're all completely bonkers wanting to abolish property. Quickest possible way to murderous tyranny there is!

One massive blocker for me is that the Kumar Rouge declared private property illegal.

That didn't end up well. The largest genocide in history. However, it will probably be deemed 'progressive' by the sorts who think that a caliphate under ISIS is 'progressive'.

Misguided fools.


Apart from the Holomodor, the Great Leap Forward, the Holocaust, etc.

Mind you, you do have a point as many were committed by socialist governments (including some nationalist ones). The good of the many...

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

matt_himself Flag Matataland 27 Nov 14 12.48am

Quote NickinOX at 27 Nov 2014 12.41am

Quote matt_himself at 26 Nov 2014 10.57pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 26 Nov 2014 8.52pm

Quote ghosteagle at 26 Nov 2014 5.37pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 26 Nov 2014 3.17pm

Needless to say, I simply don't accept the premise that private property is based on "oppression, theft or murder". Maybe in the 11th century, but today? Don't be daft.

On the contrary, private property is one of the biggest guarantors of freedom we have. Certainly more robust than the flimsy protections provided by a universal suffrage democracy and representative government.

Abolish private property and you have two options:

1. Anarchy. During periods of which oppression, theft and murder tend to thrive.

2. Some kind of collective organisation running things "on behalf of" individuals. Again, the historical precedents of this aren't good.

You realise that number two is the form of government we currently have right???

Ha ha, fair point. Depending on how you interpret "collective".

I honestly think you're all completely bonkers wanting to abolish property. Quickest possible way to murderous tyranny there is!

One massive blocker for me is that the Kumar Rouge declared private property illegal.

That didn't end up well. The largest genocide in history. However, it will probably be deemed 'progressive' by the sorts who think that a caliphate under ISIS is 'progressive'.

Misguided fools.


Apart from the Holomodor, the Great Leap Forward, the Holocaust, etc.

Mind you, you do have a point as many were committed by socialist governments (including some nationalist ones). The good of the many...


I would suggest you look at the percentage of the Cambodian population that the right on Socialist brothers in the Khmer Rouge slaughtered for what constituted the greatest genocide in history.

These people were sick f***s.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 27 Nov 14 6.38am

Brand doesn't promote socialism, but Anarcho-syndicalism so I don't know why people are going down that particular avenue...
Shows that they don't know what they're talking about when they stag him off.

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 27 Nov 14 8.21am

Quote nickgusset at 26 Nov 2014 11.36pm


I wonder how many of those that are slagging of Brand have actually read 'revolution'

Edited by nickgusset (26 Nov 2014 11.38pm)


I have heard PLENTY from him, thank you very much.

Including a cringeworthy performance on 'Start the Week', places on which are normally reserved for scholars or people with genuine talent (neither of which applies to Mr Brand) where he was given lots of time to discuss his book and the points contained within.

It was not enough to induce me to want to read it. It sounded very lightweight, full of higgledy-piggledy bits of vaguely collectivist stuff he's picked up off the internet. I've got better things to do with my time than read 'Revolution'.

I don't need to read his book. The guy is all over the media (especially the BBC which fawns over him for some reason) and has put more than enough into the public sphere for me to make my mind up. Which I have. He is a c*ck.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Page 9 of 25 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Russell Brand - class warrior or complete bell end