You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The Greens
November 22 2026 2.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Greens


Page 9 of 21 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 08 Jan 15 6.52pm

Very smart move by Cameron.

With the greens in the debate, labour have a bit of left wing competition. His hope must be that left leaning posters who are fed up with Labours centrist stand will make a move and vote green. Even a few hundred votes might make the difference in some constituencies.

Given he'll be slugging it out with UKIP for votes I can see why he'd like some competition for labour.

Ed, of course, sees the ploy. But they'll all go along with the charade. Ed will say 'chicken' and Dave will say 'it's important all parties are heard'. None admitting to the political game that really being played.

Edited by beagle (08 Jan 2015 6.53pm)

 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

The White Horse Flag 08 Jan 15 6.58pm

Presumably ultimately the broadcasters will decide though right?

The BBC will do the head-to-head one (they get first dibs and favour establishment parties) and ITV and Sky or whoever will be more than happy to do Labour in by throwing the Greens in there. Probably makes better telly and boosts viewing figures too.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 08 Jan 15 7.12pm

Quote The White Horse at 08 Jan 2015 6.11pm

What do the right-wingers think about Cameron's "I won't be involved if the Greens aren't" announcement, out of interest? Easy for me to say this as a lefty, but surely this is the most transparent electoral opportunism ever?

I wonder what I'd think if Miliband said he wouldn't be involved unless UKIP were involved. It's bloody obvious it's not for some principled reason. Do you right-wingers respect Cameron for having some political nous, or dislike him for trying to pull the other one?

I'm a right-winger and I hate Cameron.

I wonder if he cares less about damaging labour on its left flank than he does getting out of it altogether.

Brown only took part in debates because he was desperate. Dave would love to wriggle out of them.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

The White Horse Flag 09 Jan 15 12.37am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Jan 2015 7.12pm

I'm a right-winger and I hate Cameron.

I wonder if he cares less about damaging labour on its left flank than he does getting out of it altogether.

Brown only took part in debates because he was desperate. Dave would love to wriggle out of them.

But do you hate him any more or less now, or just the same?

I think if Miliband pulled this sort of stunt, people would give him credit for having some balls. Not sure it works for Cameron, he's got a reputation as a PR man so cynical moves exacerbate negative perceptions of him.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Percy of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 09 Jan 15 1.18am

It's probably called "playing chicken"!

I'm guessing Cameron has been advised by his army of leeches and brown nosers that he should not attempt to publicly debate issues with UKIP as swathes of Tory voters may switch allegiance when he speaks and they become disenchanted.

Holding on to their voters would be the Tories best chance of getting re-elected and fending off the Wallace led Labour party. Greens are not a major party but including them would open the door for everyone to participate. The public debates become a nonsense and therefore won't happen thereby deflecting attention from the fact (like it or not!) UKIP is a potential heavyweight that could attract a significant protest vote this time around?

Cameron gets re-elected King. Simples!

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt!

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 09 Jan 15 6.38am

Quote The White Horse at 09 Jan 2015 12.37am

Quote Johnny Eagles at 08 Jan 2015 7.12pm

I'm a right-winger and I hate Cameron.

I wonder if he cares less about damaging labour on its left flank than he does getting out of it altogether.

Brown only took part in debates because he was desperate. Dave would love to wriggle out of them.

But do you hate him any more or less now, or just the same?

I think if Miliband pulled this sort of stunt, people would give him credit for having some balls. Not sure it works for Cameron, he's got a reputation as a PR man so cynical moves exacerbate negative perceptions of him.

About the same.

He has a reputation as a PR man but that is apparently what the electorate likes. Cameron is way ahead on image as a leader. Blair won three elections and had about as much substance as an empty packet of cornflakes.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 09 Jan 15 9.34am

Quote The White Horse at 08 Jan 2015 6.49pm

Quote We are goin up! at 08 Jan 2015 6.22pm

Quote The White Horse at 08 Jan 2015 6.11pm

What do the right-wingers think about Cameron's "I won't be involved if the Greens aren't" announcement, out of interest? Easy for me to say this as a lefty, but surely this is the most transparent electoral opportunism ever?

I wonder what I'd think if Miliband said he wouldn't be involved unless UKIP were involved. It's bloody obvious it's not for some principled reason. Do you right-wingers respect Cameron for having some political nous, or dislike him for trying to pull the other one?

Damned if he does, damned if he doesn't. And you're a massive Labour wally which means you'd obviously rather UKIP were in there, too. At least he isn't being sneaky about it.

Surely that's exactly what he's doing? The broadcasters have made a proposal and rather than say "I think that setup wouldn't favour me" he's appropriated the cause of a party he only wants there because he thinks it will damage his main opponent!

As it happens, I'd rather UKIP weren't there. I think if we're going to have presidential style debates (they're called the "Leaders' Debates" aren't they?) we should only include people who could plausibly end up leading the country.

I can understand why you might want the Lib Dems and UKIP there, since the former has 60 odd MPs and the latter have pretty massive support and have just won an election. But the Greens (much as I agree with a lot of what they say) are a bit of a stretch and turn it into a Question Time panel, rather than a format where genuine scrutiny is likely.


But by your own admission, anyone that's even vaguely interested in politics will see what he's doing. It's hardly sneaky when it's so damned obvious. Oh and I actually agree that if UKIP are to be in there, then the Greens have a mandate, too, since they did better than the Lib Dems in the last national election that took place.

With regard to the SNP, surely there could be regional debates, since there are regional parties (there is a leader of the Scottish Labour and Scottish Conservatives).


My personal opinion, however, is that the debates don't actually help the general election campaign at all, since the whole thing becomes about the leaders' debates rather than actual policy. I mean, last time Nick Clegg got loads of praise for looking into the camera. I mean FFS are these really worth having? They are short on detail (like most modern politics) and deal with wishy-washy ideologies rather than practical solutions. NHS being a prime example. And as a Labour supporter, you'd support a one-on-one debate between Milliband and Cameron? You must be joking, Cameron would wipe the floor with him.

Edited by We are goin up! (09 Jan 2015 9.41am)

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

The White Horse Flag 09 Jan 15 9.25pm

Quote We are goin up! at 09 Jan 2015 9.34am

But by your own admission, anyone that's even vaguely interested in politics will see what he's doing. It's hardly sneaky when it's so damned obvious. Oh and I actually agree that if UKIP are to be in there, then the Greens have a mandate, too, since they did better than the Lib Dems in the last national election that took place.

Didn't everyone? They did by about 0.3% of the vote, which is hardly emphatic given how unpopular the Lib Dems are. Simple fact is that after the general election, the best case scenario for the Greens wouldn't even involve them having a tenth of the MPs the Lib Dems have. One MP is the most likely scenario and none is probably just as likely as two. If everyone who had an MP was in the debate the panel would have a dozen parties in it.

Quote We are goin up! at 09 Jan 2015 9.34am

My personal opinion, however, is that the debates don't actually help the general election campaign at all, since the whole thing becomes about the leaders' debates rather than actual policy.

I don't agree. Last time I remember discussions on Trident, the deficit, the NHS, immigration and so on. Cameron said the NHS was the most important thing to him and that he'd aim to get net immigration below 100,000. He might not have made these claims in such a public fashion without the debates.

Quote We are goin up! at 09 Jan 2015 9.34am

I mean, last time Nick Clegg got loads of praise for looking into the camera. I mean FFS are these really worth having? They are short on detail (like most modern politics) and deal with wishy-washy ideologies rather than practical solutions. NHS being a prime example. And as a Labour supporter, you'd support a one-on-one debate between Milliband and Cameron? You must be joking, Cameron would wipe the floor with him.

If he did, that wouldn't change many minds, the common perception is that he's not too bad and that Miliband's a dweeb anyway. All Miliband would have to do is match him and it'd win him a fair few votes. Cameron would be all over these debates if he had something to gain, as he did in 2010.

 


"The fox has his den. The bee has his hive. The stoat, has, uh... his stoat-hole... but only man chooses to make his nest in an investment opportunity.” Stewart Lee

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 10 Jan 15 12.42am

Quote Jimenez at 08 Dec 2014 12.48am

Quote Seth at 08 Dec 2014 12.34am

Quote Pussay Patrol at 07 Dec 2014 11.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Dec 2014 3.01pm

Quote Pussay Patrol at 06 Dec 2014 10.26am

Greens = tax

If you want a high tax economy vote green

Tax = Public Services.

If you want decent services, raise tax.


It's a proven fact low tax economies raise more tax overall.

Is it? Prove it then. Let's see your facts.


[Link]

Thanks for flagging this article but it doesn't actually support the argument that low tax raises more tax overall. It was just an article answering that that question.

Also it is important to distinguish between direct and indirect tax. The low direct tax is supported by shifting the burden of tax to poorer/ordinary people via higher VAT/indirect Tax. Thatcher and the Cameron both put up Vat while lowering elements of income tax.

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 14 Jan 15 6.00pm

I'm admittedly not a fan of the Tories at the best of times. But listening to their weasely spokesperson bang on about the Greens, as though there is any other reason for them snivelling out of the TV debates than that they're terrified their grubby little hands will be prised off their ministerial boxes, is absolutely pathetic.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Jan 15 6.03pm

[Link]

Green's membership to overtake that of UKIP.

 

elgrande Flag bedford 14 Jan 15 6.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jan 2015 6.03pm

[Link]

Green's membership to overtake that of UKIP.


Membership and votes are not the same thing.
Not that I give a s***e either way.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Jan 15 6.11pm

Quote elgrande at 14 Jan 2015 6.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jan 2015 6.03pm

[Link]

Green's membership to overtake that of UKIP.


Membership and votes are not the same thing.
Not that I give a s***e either way.


If the greens have a higher membership, then surely they have more right to be in a leaders debate than UKIP.

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 14 Jan 15 6.13pm

If it wasn't this, Cameron would have found another fig leaf to use as an excuse.

It's just the bare-faced LIES which annoy me. Any other job you'd get punished. Politicians just tell outright lies and get away with it.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

TUX Flag redhill 14 Jan 15 6.33pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jan 2015 6.11pm

Quote elgrande at 14 Jan 2015 6.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jan 2015 6.03pm

[Link]

Green's membership to overtake that of UKIP.


Membership and votes are not the same thing.
Not that I give a s***e either way.


If the greens have a higher membership, then surely they have more right to be in a leaders debate than UKIP.

Sorry but no.
As above, ''Membership and votes are not the same thing''.
In all my years I've only met 1 person who's voted for the Green Party, my best mates brother (lovely fella btw). Personally I believe they need to change the name if they ever want to attract more voters. What do they actually stand for apart from the obvious?
They've missed a trick imo. They should've called themselves UKIP/similar a while ago and then do a complete turnaround should they ever get into power, just like all the others always have/will constantly do. They're a well meaning bunch but the marketing department is beyond dumb.


 

TUX Flag redhill 14 Jan 15 6.35pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 14 Jan 2015 6.13pm

If it wasn't this, Cameron would have found another fig leaf to use as an excuse.

It's just the bare-faced LIES which annoy me. Any other job you'd get punished. Politicians just tell outright lies and get away with it.

This^.............is why I stopped voting a long time ago.
Unfortunately it'll never change.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 14 Jan 15 6.37pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jan 2015 6.11pm

Quote elgrande at 14 Jan 2015 6.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jan 2015 6.03pm

[Link]

Green's membership to overtake that of UKIP.


Membership and votes are not the same thing.
Not that I give a s***e either way.


If the greens have a higher membership, then surely they have more right to be in a leaders debate than UKIP.


Membership numbers, of any party, are completely irrelevant other than for raising funds.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 14 Jan 15 6.44pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 14 Jan 2015 6.13pm

If it wasn't this, Cameron would have found another fig leaf to use as an excuse.

It's just the bare-faced LIES which annoy me. Any other job you'd get punished. Politicians just tell outright lies and get away with it.


Why do you think the broadcasters or the other party leaders have a right to demand the PM do anything? He's not obliged to and neither are these debates A) Historical or B) Worthwhile.

What's he going to be punished for? Stating his opinion or terms?

Edited by Stuk (14 Jan 2015 6.45pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Jan 15 7.07pm

Sure that Dave the cund said theses debates were very important before the last election.

 

TUX Flag redhill 14 Jan 15 8.11pm

Quote nickgusset at 14 Jan 2015 7.07pm

Sure that Dave the cund said theses debates were very important before the last election.

Debates with those who matter to the majority of the electorate are important.
The Greens just don't happen to meet this criteria.

 

Page 9 of 21 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The Greens