This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 09 Jan 2015 11.44am
In which case wouldn't she have had a better case, i.e. than being drunk of her own consent. Bear in mind she didn't met Evans until after she was in the room and had sex with Donaldson. Quote Stirlingsays at 09 Jan 2015 11.44am
I'm pointing out the absurdity of the judgement. The idea that you can imply consent from minutes before intercourse takes place when you aren't there. It not about consent, she was incapable of consent. Its about whether it is reasonable of the defendents to believe she had consented. For Actus and Mens rae to be qualified, 'guilty mind' must be demonstrated - If Donaldson's actions were those of a reasonable man then he is innocent (or at least not guilty because its not beyond reasonable doubt for him to have believed consent was genuine. Quote Stirlingsays at 09 Jan 2015 11.44am
This girl says she wasn't aware what was going on.....How can that be consent? I'm pointing out the illogical and arrogant nature of the assumption. See above. Quote Stirlingsays at 09 Jan 2015 11.44am
No one doubts she said yes, what is in doubt is that her capacity to reliably give consent was diminished. Which means McDonald and Evans are required to at least demonstrate they believed consent (ie your word isn't just enough). Quote Stirlingsays at 09 Jan 2015 11.44am
This girl said neither had consent.....The court delivered the most illogical judgement possible......They convicted one and freed another based purely on assumption. No the prosecution demonstrated that she was not capable of giving reasonable consent. Her own statement was that she did not remember the events in question. Quote Stirlingsays at 09 Jan 2015 11.44am
She was, by the definition of the offence, and the requirements of british law, raped by Ched Evans, who had sex without her consent, and could show no basis on which it was reasonable for him to believe she could give consent. Quote Stirlingsays at 09 Jan 2015 11.44am
I cannot know which is actually true but I suspect from what I gather that this isn't a safe conviction. It safe enough that his appeal was turned down at the first hurdle because it offered no new evidence that spoke to the question of the conviction (Ironically if he said he didn't have sex with her, he'd have been found not guilty - as there was no evidence of sexual activity between Evans and the victim, other than his and Donaldsons statements. Quote Stirlingsays at 09 Jan 2015 11.44am
Those who claim with confidence to know that this girl was definitely raped are in my view way over confident in their assumptions. Edited by Stirlingsays (09 Jan 2015 11.49am) Certainty in convictions is very rare, even where confessions of guilt have been produced, there have been cases where people were found to have been not guilty. Even in the most nailed on conviction, there must exist a tiny chance that its not valid. Its probable beyond reason that Evans raped that girl, and that he went to that room specifically to have sex with the victim, a woman he had never met or had any grounds to assume wanted to have sex with him. It is not reasonable by his actions to think he could, as a reasonable man, have believed she had consented.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stuk at 09 Jan 2015 3.24pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Jan 2015 3.18pm
Quote Ray in Houston at 09 Jan 2015 3.01pm
Quote Stirlingsays at 09 Jan 2015 11.44am
If she wasn't raped but intended both to be convicted for her financial gain then she had tricked both....Hence, 'had'.
How the hell is there any financial gain for her in this? Especially as she doesn't seem to have sold her story, meanwhile Evans has been all over the press.
He's used the publicity of the case to pursue a legal fund and support towards appeal and a case review. Not all gain is purely financial. The victim of a crime is generally allowed to sell their story once the case has been heard.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
|
|
|
Quote eagles2011 at 09 Jan 2015 11.07pm
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 10 Jan 2015 7.50pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Jan 2015 11.23am
Why so touchy? If she was so drunk how would she know what she was getting up to? I've seen girls on nights out getting up to stuff they would be ashamed of in the morning, but thought it was hilarious at the time. Ched Evans insists it was consensual and proceeded on that basis. The girl may well have led him on once he appeared in the room which she may have suggested he do earlier in the evening. No one knows for sure what was said or done and all I'm doing is pointing out possible scenarios or explanations. I don't understand why my comments are regarded by you as loathsome........ you seem to float between Mr Jack the lad to Mr Prude/Unreasonable at the flick of a switch these days mate. If she was raped and he did it, she has my sympathy and support, but it seems a bit complex to prove without any lingering doubt.
There's no smoking gun just speculation and interpretation being present4d as facts that prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Not for me. Other than the conviction beyond reasonable doubt, the evidence is stacked against him, and demonstrates a) he had sex b) she couldn't give consent c) he had no basis on which to credibly claim he could have believed consent was given. That's beyond reasonable doubt, not just in my opinion, but in the consensus of British law. There isn't really a scenario where by he has a defence, unless he can present evidence that is a) new b) disputes those three key factors. What happened in the room is irrelevant, once he admitted to having sex with her. But other than that, yeah. Edited by jamiemartin721 (10 Jan 2015 9.39pm)
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 10 Jan 2015 11.30am
Quote Ray in Houston at 09 Jan 2015 3.09pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 09 Jan 2015 12.07pm
I suggest that this girl brought all of this on herself and the fact that she was drunk was no excuse.
Your mate's roommate saw that you had 20 quid in your wallet and helps himself to it, leaving you high and dry in the morning. Is he a thief, or is that ok because you'd already given your mate some? Edited by Ray in Houston (09 Jan 2015 5.28pm)
Of course he's a thief in that basic scenario. He might not be though if he also asked me to borrow the £20 and during my drunken stupor I said yes but couldn't remember giving my consent when I woke up. No, he'd be a thief, unless he could demonstrate that, as consent in all things legal is defined by a necessity of implicit understanding by all parties. He would only be innocent if he could reasonably be said to have believed you capable of making that decision or by way of actions was led to believe your consent to take the money.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.