This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote derben at 07 May 2015 3.31pm
Quote lankygit at 07 May 2015 3.11pm
Quote derben at 07 May 2015 2.52pm
Quote lankygit at 07 May 2015 2.05pm
Quote derben at 07 May 2015 1.53pm
Please note that the thread was discussing EU immigration and that Silvertop introduced the aspect of 'protectionism'. (btw we are still waiting for answer to the question of whether immigration should be totally uncontrolled and encouraged if it is of so much benefit).
Also please note the initial subject matter of this thread was the fact that Farage claimed to support Palace, not international migration. If you read through most threads you will find that they often develop beyond a strict discussion of the original post. My question is a simple one, if immigration is of so much benefit, why shouldn't we actively encourage it - perhaps pay people to come here? No one is prepared to answer - I wonder why? So what is ok for you isn`t for the rest then? The simple question above seems to have changed somewhat from the original of less than 4 hours ago too. I've no idea what you are getting at. Silly me for imagining you would I suppose.
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
|
Quote derben at 07 May 2015 3.58pm
Quote lankygit at 07 May 2015 3.39pm
Quote derben at 07 May 2015 3.31pm
Quote lankygit at 07 May 2015 3.11pm
Quote derben at 07 May 2015 2.52pm
Quote lankygit at 07 May 2015 2.05pm
Quote derben at 07 May 2015 1.53pm
Please note that the thread was discussing EU immigration and that Silvertop introduced the aspect of 'protectionism'. (btw we are still waiting for answer to the question of whether immigration should be totally uncontrolled and encouraged if it is of so much benefit).
Also please note the initial subject matter of this thread was the fact that Farage claimed to support Palace, not international migration. If you read through most threads you will find that they often develop beyond a strict discussion of the original post. My question is a simple one, if immigration is of so much benefit, why shouldn't we actively encourage it - perhaps pay people to come here? No one is prepared to answer - I wonder why? So what is ok for you isn`t for the rest then? The simple question above seems to have changed somewhat from the original of less than 4 hours ago too. I've no idea what you are getting at. Silly me for imagining you would I suppose. Those who will not answer a simple question would make good politicians too. As I wrote earlier, maybe silvertop regarded the question to be so silly that he deemed it unworthy of reply.
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
|
Quote derben at 07 May 2015 4.05pm
Quote lankygit at 07 May 2015 4.03pm
Quote derben at 07 May 2015 3.58pm
Quote lankygit at 07 May 2015 3.39pm
Quote derben at 07 May 2015 3.31pm
Quote lankygit at 07 May 2015 3.11pm
Quote derben at 07 May 2015 2.52pm
Quote lankygit at 07 May 2015 2.05pm
Quote derben at 07 May 2015 1.53pm
Please note that the thread was discussing EU immigration and that Silvertop introduced the aspect of 'protectionism'. (btw we are still waiting for answer to the question of whether immigration should be totally uncontrolled and encouraged if it is of so much benefit).
Also please note the initial subject matter of this thread was the fact that Farage claimed to support Palace, not international migration. If you read through most threads you will find that they often develop beyond a strict discussion of the original post. My question is a simple one, if immigration is of so much benefit, why shouldn't we actively encourage it - perhaps pay people to come here? No one is prepared to answer - I wonder why? So what is ok for you isn`t for the rest then? The simple question above seems to have changed somewhat from the original of less than 4 hours ago too. I've no idea what you are getting at. Silly me for imagining you would I suppose. Those who will not answer a simple question would make good politicians too. As I wrote earlier, maybe silvertop regarded the question to be so silly that he deemed it unworthy of reply. Can you suggest less 'silly' wording that could be used to elicit an answer? Derben, I`m not your dad, I`m not your mentor, and besides, you appear to have a good enough grasp of the English language to work that one out for yourself.
quote: "No. Nor would I haul up the drawbridge and allow protectionism to ruin this country." Edited by lankygit (07 May 2015 4.22pm)
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
|
Quote dannyh at 07 May 2015 4.14pm
Right enough of this shyte. Who thinks uncontrolled boarders or unchecked immigration to the UK would be a good thing for the economy ? Simple yes no will do. No other smoke and mirrors, bulsh1t, or belittling are required. As an aside I have read through the posts on here and whilst being totally dismissive of derban's points, not one person has effectively argued against them. Derban I doff my cap mate. Well Played Sir. No. As to the aside danny, do you think Derbens question... So, as you think immigration is an unmitigated benefit that is actually the cause of everything positive happening in the country, you would encourage ever more immigration, no controls whatsoever, actively campaign and encourage the entire population of the EU to come here? ...with "everything positive".."no controls whatsoever".."entire population of the EU".. neither being what silvertop wrote or intimated, is worthy of a cap doffing? A simple yes or no will do.
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote dannyh at 07 May 2015 4.14pm
Right enough of this shyte. Who thinks uncontrolled boarders or unchecked immigration to the UK would be a good thing for the economy ? As an aside I have read through the posts on here and whilst being totally dismissive of derban's points, not one person has effectively argued against them. Derban I doff my cap mate. Well Played Sir. Thats not the choice though is it. That's resorting to a kind of strawman argument, in which you justify something by presenting the only alternative as an absurd notion (essentially a rhetorical statement, because only very stupid people would believe in no border controls). The question really about to what extent does immigration benefit the country, and the best balance between the benefits and problems generated. The sad problem of the UK, is that it often sees only polarised arguments, both of which are equally stupid (ie Free migration or stop all migration or send em all back).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
I've just realized Derben is a anagram of a well known HOL Saying/phrase!!
Pro USA & Israel |
|
|
Quote Jimenez at 07 May 2015 4.47pm
I've just realized Derben is a anagram of a well known HOL Saying/phrase!!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.