You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Is Britain a racist country?
November 21 2026 10.43pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Britain a racist country?


Page 9 of 15 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 05 Jun 15 4.26pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 4.08pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 3.41pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 04 Jun 2015 12.52pm

Quote serial thriller at 04 Jun 2015 12.04pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 04 Jun 2015 11.57am

Quote serial thriller at 04 Jun 2015 11.53am

But why should nationality even play a role in tragedy? Is it sadder if a British stranger dies than a Libyan one?


Of course it is.

Ok, lets test your logic. Is it sadder to you if your mother or father or child dies rather than a Libyan?

If so why?

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jun 2015 11.58am)


But why does nationality come in to it? There are British citizens who go out to fight for ISIS, do I feel sympathy when they die, or am I only meant to be feeling pity for those British people who have those wonderful British values which no one seems to be able to identify objectively?

No but you also probably feel a greater anger.

Its generally because we 'share' something with those people and that in turn makes the event more relevant to us and our attention. This occurs apriori, as we look at the world in relation to ourselves and our experiences, and so pay attention when factors we relate to ourselves are present in stories. Its how we understand the world and our place in it, is through relationships in the external world and our internal being.

Its a maladaptation (a beneficial evolutionary trait that has begun to outlive its benefit, but still remains present in a species because its not detrimental).

Value doesn't really come into it. These events are more real, because they're more relevant.



I disagree with this. Nationality is not an innate trait, it is a cultural unifying myth which we invent and perpetuate that is based in the material advances of humanity.

The concept of a nation is a modern ideology, developing as much from the industrial revolution, which allowed humans to interact on a larger scale at a faster rate, as it did from conquest and tribal mentality.

Thus when/if we empathise with someone merely because they identify with a similar nation to us, it is a completely arbitrary connection that we are creating. The reason nationality is so prevalent in contrast to our features, such as date of birth, hair colour etc. is because nationality is such a loaded concept, and so readily manipulated by those in authority to achieve anything from raising war funds to allowing human beings to drown in the sea.

I don't have much national feeling any more as the nation has been so f-uped by the lib-left establishment, cheered on by the likes of you. But I find it hard to see how my remaining national feelings could be in any way responsible for people drowning in the Med. (Seems to be fixation of yours, with you finding increasingly bizarre reasons for it happening.)


What were the justifications for us not saving those in the Med Derben?

In November, when we withdrew funding from Mare Nostrum, the search and rescue mission, Tory Peer Lady Anelay claimed it was to stop more migrants attempting the journey. Everyone at the time knew this was bollocks, as it proved when the numbers actually went up after we withdrew the funding. What it was really riding on was a nationalist sentiment which is hostile to the idea of any kind of migration, even for the most desperate of asylum seekers. The evidence for this is staggering. The major national newspaper calls them 'cockroaches', our intake of Syrian refugees is barely out of double figures while we are constantly reminded of the thousands of Romanians and Bulgarians who are overpopulating our land (net migration from these countries combined, interestingly, is under 8000 since 2007).

So why do we allow the mainstream media and politicians to get away with these acts of inhumanity? If you think it's anything other than nationalism, you're deluded. UKIP gained 6 million votes at the election on a ultra-nationalistic ticket, the Tories badge is a f*cking union jack, even Ed Milliband, the dangerous lefty, was spouting out on 'one-nation Labourism'. We have a conservative nationalism that doesn't want to deal with immigration, that condones us withdrawing funding for search and rescue in the Med and then turns a blind eye as thousands drown. It really is a pretty simple lineation.

Oh, and for the record, I have a wide grin on my face that you think I am one of the reasons this country's going to the dogs

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 05 Jun 15 4.28pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Jun 2015 4.09pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 4.04pm

So nationalism is an innate quality?


Tribalism is an innate quality. Nationalism is a merely an extension of it.

Whether you are for or against that probably comes down to the family or group culture that you were raised within or accepted.


Then why is it such a new phenomenon? People didn't really identify with their nation until the mid-18th century...

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

derben Flag 05 Jun 15 4.41pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 4.26pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 4.08pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 3.41pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 04 Jun 2015 12.52pm

Quote serial thriller at 04 Jun 2015 12.04pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 04 Jun 2015 11.57am

Quote serial thriller at 04 Jun 2015 11.53am

But why should nationality even play a role in tragedy? Is it sadder if a British stranger dies than a Libyan one?


Of course it is.

Ok, lets test your logic. Is it sadder to you if your mother or father or child dies rather than a Libyan?

If so why?

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Jun 2015 11.58am)


But why does nationality come in to it? There are British citizens who go out to fight for ISIS, do I feel sympathy when they die, or am I only meant to be feeling pity for those British people who have those wonderful British values which no one seems to be able to identify objectively?

No but you also probably feel a greater anger.

Its generally because we 'share' something with those people and that in turn makes the event more relevant to us and our attention. This occurs apriori, as we look at the world in relation to ourselves and our experiences, and so pay attention when factors we relate to ourselves are present in stories. Its how we understand the world and our place in it, is through relationships in the external world and our internal being.

Its a maladaptation (a beneficial evolutionary trait that has begun to outlive its benefit, but still remains present in a species because its not detrimental).

Value doesn't really come into it. These events are more real, because they're more relevant.



I disagree with this. Nationality is not an innate trait, it is a cultural unifying myth which we invent and perpetuate that is based in the material advances of humanity.

The concept of a nation is a modern ideology, developing as much from the industrial revolution, which allowed humans to interact on a larger scale at a faster rate, as it did from conquest and tribal mentality.

Thus when/if we empathise with someone merely because they identify with a similar nation to us, it is a completely arbitrary connection that we are creating. The reason nationality is so prevalent in contrast to our features, such as date of birth, hair colour etc. is because nationality is such a loaded concept, and so readily manipulated by those in authority to achieve anything from raising war funds to allowing human beings to drown in the sea.

I don't have much national feeling any more as the nation has been so f-uped by the lib-left establishment, cheered on by the likes of you. But I find it hard to see how my remaining national feelings could be in any way responsible for people drowning in the Med. (Seems to be fixation of yours, with you finding increasingly bizarre reasons for it happening.)


1. What were the justifications for us not saving those in the Med Derben?

In November, when we withdrew funding from Mare Nostrum, the search and rescue mission, Tory Peer Lady Anelay claimed it was to stop more migrants attempting the journey. Everyone at the time knew this was bollocks, as it proved when the numbers actually went up after we withdrew the funding. What it was really riding on was a nationalist sentiment which is hostile to the idea of any kind of migration, even for the most desperate of asylum seekers. The evidence for this is staggering. The major national newspaper calls them 'cockroaches', our intake of Syrian refugees is barely out of double figures while we are constantly reminded of the thousands of Romanians and Bulgarians who are 2. overpopulating our land (net migration from these countries combined, interestingly, is under 8000 since 2007).

So why do we allow the mainstream media and politicians to get away with these 3. acts of inhumanity? If you think it's anything other than nationalism, you're deluded. UKIP gained 6 million votes at the election on a ultra-nationalistic ticket, the Tories badge is a f*cking union jack, even Ed Milliband, the dangerous lefty, was spouting out on 'one-nation Labourism'. We have a conservative nationalism that doesn't want to deal with immigration, that condones us withdrawing funding for search and rescue in the Med and then turns a blind eye as thousands drown. It really is a pretty simple lineation.

Oh, and for the record, I have a wide grin on my face that you think 4. I am one of the reasons this country's going to the dogs

1. Because it is f-all to do with us?

2. Net immigration is running at 300,000 per year.

3. LOL - it is as if we had sunk the boats.
f*in union jack - bet you don't say "f*in Palestinian flag" do you?

4. Yes, people like you, laughingly passing as left wing these days, have played a roll in the lib-left wonderland that we now live in.

Edited by derben (05 Jun 2015 4.45pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 05 Jun 15 4.45pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Jun 2015 4.09pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 4.04pm

So nationalism is an innate quality?


Tribalism is an innate quality. Nationalism is a merely an extension of it.

Whether you are for or against that probably comes down to the family or group culture that you were raised within or accepted.

I'm not so sure tribalism is an innate quality either, or that its often misused to suggest 'distancing and seperation', traditional tribal groups tend towards co-operative self interest, rather than self isolationism.

Also tribes tend towards internal conflict more than external conflict. But I do get where you are coming from.

I think, the root lies in the cognitive function by which humans understand the world, in relationships of similarity and difference between their self, expectations and the external world.

The Blue eyes Brown Eyes experiment is a good example of just how simple the ideas of 'tribalism' can be constructed and reconstructed socially, rather than being inherent.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 05 Jun 15 4.50pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 4.41pm
1. Because it is f-all to do with us?

Surely acting to save lives, rather than choosing not to save lives, when you can, is a self fulfilling moral argument. Arguably, these are people in peril and grave danger - the sums involved aren't staggering (and we have a navy anyhow), so to not act doesn't really seem an option.

Just because we save them doesn't mean they have to be returned to the UK.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 05 Jun 15 4.52pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 4.28pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Jun 2015 4.09pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 4.04pm

So nationalism is an innate quality?


Tribalism is an innate quality. Nationalism is a merely an extension of it.

Whether you are for or against that probably comes down to the family or group culture that you were raised within or accepted.


Then why is it such a new phenomenon? People didn't really identify with their nation until the mid-18th century...


Where on earth did you get that from?

All that ancient history with wars between countries didn't contain any nationalism then? What an unusual take on things.
Shakespeare's Henry V then. No nationalism there then no?.....The concept of Rome and its state nationalism passed you by eh....Persia doesn't ring a bell no? God the list is massive.

Let's just say that you are just a whole heap of wrong on this.


Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Jun 2015 4.54pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Steptoe Flag 05 Jun 15 5.01pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 Jun 2015 4.50pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 4.41pm
1. Because it is f-all to do with us?

Surely acting to save lives, rather than choosing not to save lives, when you can, is a self fulfilling moral argument. Arguably, these are people in peril and grave danger - the sums involved aren't staggering (and we have a navy anyhow), so to not act doesn't really seem an option.

Just because we save them doesn't mean they have to be returned to the UK.


The same people all for us 'liberating' those in foreign nations are happy for us to leave people to drown in the sea. Nothing in it for us I assume?

Edited by Steptoe (05 Jun 2015 5.02pm)

 

derben Flag 05 Jun 15 5.02pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 Jun 2015 4.50pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 4.41pm
1. Because it is f-all to do with us?

Surely acting to save lives, rather than choosing not to save lives, when you can, is a self fulfilling moral argument. Arguably, these are people in peril and grave danger - the sums involved aren't staggering (and we have a navy anyhow), so to not act doesn't really seem an option.

Just because we save them doesn't mean they have to be returned to the UK.


Why can't the many countries who border on the Med do it? Why us? Why our problem? If it were the English Channel, perhaps.

 

SwalecliffeEagle Flag Swalecliffe 05 Jun 15 5.26pm

Nationalism is an interesting concept, and one we tend to think about as having been in existence for much longer than is the case. Yet it has only been in existence since the 1700s, roughly speaking. Before then, the world was structured largely according to kingdoms and realms. Subjects fell under the jurisdiction of a common ruler, but shared few of the unifying cultural markers such as dress and language which nationalism offers society. In that sense, as Benedict Anderson labels it, nationalism is an 'imagined community' borne from the mind and expressed through print-capitalism (institutions). Cultural identities and ties then flow from the creation of a homogeneous community and the institutions which are set up within a particular state.

Yet I believe that nationalism, although a human construct, is a natural expression, and in that sense an innate quality. Since the dawn of time, animals have marked out their territory and reacted to those that violate the boundaries laid out. We are not so different, as some would like to think. Animals naturally bond with those of the same species, and as humans we are naturally inclined to identify with those of our own racial heritage. Being a nationalist is not racist or xenophobic, it's just a modern-day expression of an age old instinct. It is not the politics of division, or at least does not have to be in the destructive sense. To evoke Khrushchev, it can and should be more about 'peaceful coexistence'.

The other thing I would like to add is that despite the ramblings of certain numpties on the extreme left, people across the world are not all the same. British people, collectively speaking, are different from the French, the French are different to the Americans, and so on and so forth. The irony is that differences between us today are the net result of nationalism. National boundaries mark different styles of institutions, and these institutions in turn mould our character. Humans have the capacity to transcend these differences, but it is neither desirable or easy to do so. That is why such a construct exists in the first place. Thus, the present bourgeois drive to create a European superstate is being pushed through with reckless speed and with no consideration of the practicalities of such a project. It is unnatural, and largely unwanted, because of our collective desire to identify ourselves with the familiar.

As for the question 'Is Britain racist?', it barely deserves qualifying with an answer. In any case, unless one were to undertake an in-depth statistical analysis of the levels of racism in each and every country, and then perform a comparative analysis, it is impossible to answer.

Edited by SwalecliffeEagle (05 Jun 2015 5.32pm)

 

SwalecliffeEagle Flag Swalecliffe 05 Jun 15 5.31pm

.

Edited by SwalecliffeEagle (05 Jun 2015 5.31pm)

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 05 Jun 15 5.39pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Jun 2015 4.52pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 4.28pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Jun 2015 4.09pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 4.04pm

So nationalism is an innate quality?


Tribalism is an innate quality. Nationalism is a merely an extension of it.

Whether you are for or against that probably comes down to the family or group culture that you were raised within or accepted.


Then why is it such a new phenomenon? People didn't really identify with their nation until the mid-18th century...


Where on earth did you get that from?

All that ancient history with wars between countries didn't contain any nationalism then? What an unusual take on things.
Shakespeare's Henry V then. No nationalism there then no?.....The concept of Rome and its state nationalism passed you by eh....Persia doesn't ring a bell no? God the list is massive.

Let's just say that you are just a whole heap of wrong on this.


Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Jun 2015 4.54pm)


Persia and Rome were Empires, not nations, and Henry V's Britain was a Kingdom. History shows that identifying primarily with your nation didn't really occur until the American and French Revolutions, ie. when popular movements formed around national autonomy arose. Up until then, people were far more likely to identify with their region, religion or town.

It may sound like I'm just being massively pedantic but it's actually incredibly significant. National identity is a product of technological progression. If you're a peasant in 16th century England, you probably will never leave your town in your lifetime, you will hear little to no information about other parts of the country, and the only time any unified national authority over you would be taxation and war. When railways, printing press etc. begin to crop up, information becomes more widespread and easier to transport, thus the emergence of national identity.

And that's why the idea that nationhood is an innate quality is a load of bollocks.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 05 Jun 15 5.45pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 4.41pm


1. Because it is f-all to do with us?

2. Net immigration is running at 300,000 per year.

3. LOL - it is as if we had sunk the boats.
f*in union jack - bet you don't say "f*in Palestinian flag" do you?

4. Yes, people like you, laughingly passing as left wing these days, have played a roll in the lib-left wonderland that we now live in.

Edited by derben (05 Jun 2015 4.45pm)


1. We were the ones who bombed them FFS!

2. Another topic for another thread.

3. Well if we withdraw funding for search and rescue missions that were saving tens of thousands of lives, maybe, just maybe, our actions were responsible for their deaths...

4. Hahaha! I love the idea we live in a 'lib-left wonderland'. You checked who's in government recently, or how well left wing parties did at the last election? And to return the compliment, I think people with your mentality are incredibly dangerous for our society

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

derben Flag 05 Jun 15 6.08pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 5.45pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 4.41pm


1. Because it is f-all to do with us?

2. Net immigration is running at 300,000 per year.

3. LOL - it is as if we had sunk the boats.
f*in union jack - bet you don't say "f*in Palestinian flag" do you?

4. Yes, people like you, laughingly passing as left wing these days, have played a roll in the lib-left wonderland that we now live in.

Edited by derben (05 Jun 2015 4.45pm)


1. We were the ones who bombed them FFS!

2. Another topic for another thread.

3. Well if we withdraw funding for search and rescue missions that were saving tens of thousands of lives, maybe, just maybe, our actions were responsible for their deaths...

4. Hahaha! I love the idea we live in a 'lib-left wonderland'. You checked who's in government recently, or how well left wing parties did at the last election? And to return the compliment, I think people with your mentality are incredibly dangerous for our society

Many of these people are from African countries other than Lybia. Most of these countries, including Lybia, are chaotic shambles - as are most African countries, South Africa is catching them up fast.

Another topic! Immigration has been a central theme in this thread.

We are not responsible for the deaths. The traffickers are and the corrupt, hopeless governments they are fleeing from.

This country has been drifting to the lib-left for many years. Yes we have a Conservative government, but it is so similar to say Blair's Labour or the Liberal twerps. Pro-EU (albeit giving us a referendum, although that is probably unwinnable), same-sex marriage (hardly a right wing measure), open door immigration, no reform of the NHS etc.

I'm sure you think anyone who doesn't agree that Socialism is the great answer to all our woes is "incredibly dangerous" for our society (you would wouldn't you?) More dangerous than the 'negligible' terrorist threat I suppose.

Edited by derben (05 Jun 2015 6.09pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Jun 15 6.15pm

We are more left wing than ever!
Sorry derder, but any credibility in your posts has disappeared.

 

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 05 Jun 15 6.30pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 6.08pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 5.45pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 4.41pm


1. Because it is f-all to do with us?

2. Net immigration is running at 300,000 per year.

3. LOL - it is as if we had sunk the boats.
f*in union jack - bet you don't say "f*in Palestinian flag" do you?

4. Yes, people like you, laughingly passing as left wing these days, have played a roll in the lib-left wonderland that we now live in.

Edited by derben (05 Jun 2015 4.45pm)


1. We were the ones who bombed them FFS!

2. Another topic for another thread.

3. Well if we withdraw funding for search and rescue missions that were saving tens of thousands of lives, maybe, just maybe, our actions were responsible for their deaths...

4. Hahaha! I love the idea we live in a 'lib-left wonderland'. You checked who's in government recently, or how well left wing parties did at the last election? And to return the compliment, I think people with your mentality are incredibly dangerous for our society

Many of these people are from African countries other than Lybia. Most of these countries, including Lybia, are chaotic shambles - as are most African countries, South Africa is catching them up fast.

Another topic! Immigration has been a central theme in this thread.

We are not responsible for the deaths. The traffickers are and the corrupt, hopeless governments they are fleeing from.

This country has been drifting to the lib-left for many years. Yes we have a Conservative government, but it is so similar to say Blair's Labour or the Liberal twerps. Pro-EU (albeit giving us a referendum, although that is probably unwinnable), same-sex marriage (hardly a right wing measure), open door immigration, no reform of the NHS etc.

I'm sure you think anyone who doesn't agree that Socialism is the great answer to all our woes is "incredibly dangerous" for our society (you would wouldn't you?) More dangerous than the 'negligible' terrorist threat I suppose.

Edited by derben (05 Jun 2015 6.09pm)

The two main nationalities of people in the Med are Syrian (who we've been bombing) and Eritrean (who have been bombed by Ethiopian arms which we sold). I know it won't mean anything because you regard me as some sociopathic Marxist but I find your lack of empathy for these people staggering considering the plight they find themselves in and the impact our foreign policy has had on them. Of course we are responsible for their deaths because our national policy actively prevented these people being saved. Washing our hands of it is criminal, these are normal people who have been killed by our bombs, tyrannised by governments we've supported then left to die by our boats.

You are rapidly replacing Matt as my favourite far-righter on HOL Derben, respect. Anyone who regards this Tory government as a bit left wing really is staggeringly to the right. But my favourite thing about you is how you are painting your own image of me in your mind, just like Himself does. I actually don't really like terrorists, and while I of course disagree with people who don't hold my political beliefs, I'm comfortable enough in the minority view knowing that, realistically, fully-automated luxury Communism is not going to come about any time soon. I'll stick to telling Tories like yourself why you're wrong

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

derben Flag 05 Jun 15 6.37pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 6.30pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 6.08pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 5.45pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 4.41pm


1. Because it is f-all to do with us?

2. Net immigration is running at 300,000 per year.

3. LOL - it is as if we had sunk the boats.
f*in union jack - bet you don't say "f*in Palestinian flag" do you?

4. Yes, people like you, laughingly passing as left wing these days, have played a roll in the lib-left wonderland that we now live in.

Edited by derben (05 Jun 2015 4.45pm)


1. We were the ones who bombed them FFS!

2. Another topic for another thread.

3. Well if we withdraw funding for search and rescue missions that were saving tens of thousands of lives, maybe, just maybe, our actions were responsible for their deaths...

4. Hahaha! I love the idea we live in a 'lib-left wonderland'. You checked who's in government recently, or how well left wing parties did at the last election? And to return the compliment, I think people with your mentality are incredibly dangerous for our society

Many of these people are from African countries other than Lybia. Most of these countries, including Lybia, are chaotic shambles - as are most African countries, South Africa is catching them up fast.

Another topic! Immigration has been a central theme in this thread.

We are not responsible for the deaths. The traffickers are and the corrupt, hopeless governments they are fleeing from.

This country has been drifting to the lib-left for many years. Yes we have a Conservative government, but it is so similar to say Blair's Labour or the Liberal twerps. Pro-EU (albeit giving us a referendum, although that is probably unwinnable), same-sex marriage (hardly a right wing measure), open door immigration, no reform of the NHS etc.

I'm sure you think anyone who doesn't agree that Socialism is the great answer to all our woes is "incredibly dangerous" for our society (you would wouldn't you?) More dangerous than the 'negligible' terrorist threat I suppose.

Edited by derben (05 Jun 2015 6.09pm)

The two main nationalities of people in the Med are Syrian (who we've been bombing) and Eritrean (who have been bombed by Ethiopian arms which we sold). I know it won't mean anything because you regard me as some sociopathic Marxist but I find your lack of empathy for these people staggering considering the plight they find themselves in and the impact our foreign policy has had on them. Of course we are responsible for their deaths because our national policy actively prevented these people being saved. Washing our hands of it is criminal, these are normal people who have been killed by our bombs, tyrannised by governments we've supported then left to die by our boats.

You are rapidly replacing Matt as my favourite far-righter on HOL Derben, respect. Anyone who regards this Tory government as a bit left wing really is staggeringly to the right. But my favourite thing about you is how you are painting your own image of me in your mind, just like Himself does. I actually don't really like terrorists, and while I of course disagree with people who don't hold my political beliefs, I'm comfortable enough in the minority view knowing that, realistically, fully-automated luxury Communism is not going to come about any time soon. I'll stick to telling Tories like yourself why you're wrong

I'm not a Tory, have never voted for them. Was a member of the Labour Party once upon a time - even canvassed for them (in the days when they represented ordinary working class people - many years ago now of course). Was also active in my trade union. In my teens I even flirted with some far left organisations like the Socialist Labour League - went on a few marches - they haven't changed much, just like now we chanted "What do we want?, "General strike", "When do we want it?", "NOW!" Then I grew up.

 

derben Flag 05 Jun 15 7.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Jun 2015 6.15pm

We are more left wing than ever!
Sorry derder, but any credibility in your posts has disappeared.

New left, what passes as left wing these days - no longer representing or helping ordinary British working people, instead concentrating on various minorities, and usually holding ordinary British working people in contempt. That's why a lot of them voted UKIP.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Jun 15 7.20pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 7.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Jun 2015 6.15pm

We are more left wing than ever!
Sorry derder, but any credibility in your posts has disappeared.

New left, what passes as left wing these days - no longer representing or helping ordinary British working people, instead concentrating on various minorities, and usually holding ordinary British working people in contempt. That's why a lot of them voted UKIP.

New left? To me left wing is socialism or variants of. It is comedic that you redefine left wing rather than saying perhaps you might have erred there.

 

derben Flag 05 Jun 15 7.28pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Jun 2015 7.20pm

Quote derben at 05 Jun 2015 7.06pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Jun 2015 6.15pm

We are more left wing than ever!
Sorry derder, but any credibility in your posts has disappeared.

New left, what passes as left wing these days - no longer representing or helping ordinary British working people, instead concentrating on various minorities, and usually holding ordinary British working people in contempt. That's why a lot of them voted UKIP.

New left? To me left wing is socialism or variants of. It is comedic that you redefine left wing rather than saying perhaps you might have erred there.

The new lib/left isn't really socialist, everyone has realised that it just doesn't work in practice. Ok, the Tories are not left as such, but they share the contempt of ordinary British working people with New Labour and the Liberals. The current Tories also share the new left bias towards minorities with same-sex marriage and pandering to various minority pressure groups and playing softly softly with the likes of the 2011 riots. The hardcore new left of course just support anything that is anti-British and anti-American (just like the old hardcore left did - I know, I associated with them). It's a sort of reverse patriotism, see how fervent they are about say Palestine.

Edited by derben (05 Jun 2015 7.33pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 05 Jun 15 8.06pm

Quote serial thriller at 05 Jun 2015 5.39pm

Persia and Rome were Empires, not nations, and Henry V's Britain was a Kingdom. History shows that identifying primarily with your nation didn't really occur until the American and French Revolutions, ie. when popular movements formed around national autonomy arose. Up until then, people were far more likely to identify with their region, religion or town.

It may sound like I'm just being massively pedantic but it's actually incredibly significant. National identity is a product of technological progression. If you're a peasant in 16th century England, you probably will never leave your town in your lifetime, you will hear little to no information about other parts of the country, and the only time any unified national authority over you would be taxation and war. When railways, printing press etc. begin to crop up, information becomes more widespread and easier to transport, thus the emergence of national identity.

And that's why the idea that nationhood is an innate quality is a load of bollocks.

Not only are you being incredibly pedantic you're also being wrong.

Nationalism is an emotion tied to tribalism. It exists whether you talking about a city-state, state, empire or nation.

Rome had nationalism....And by the way it was a nation state. You were a Roman citizen just as you are a British citizen...To argue the difference is just to play on words.

Persia became an empire.....It built up over time. Also again, to say it had no nationalism is once again to ignore what nationalism is.

And again, the idea that there was no nationalism back in the days of kings because communication was slower is to take a massively simplistic view of society. Communication may have been far slower but people still had a sense of their nation and while news took longer to travel it still bleeding traveled for goodness sake. There is evidence to prove it......Once again, read Shakespeare.

Indeed go back far far further to the ancient Greeks and read what they thought of other nations compared to themselves.

Nationalism is as old as the hills.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 9 of 15 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Is Britain a racist country?