This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by dannyh
Surely you mean we have spent thousands of years being successfully invaded by everyone from the Vikings to the Romans (and those pesky Normans)? Have you looked at how most of our place names have come about? Anglo-Saxon (Wich / Wick, Ham etc), Norse (Thorpe, Brough,-by, etc), Roman ad nauseum? The only difference this time around is that the incumbent state is actively encouraging it - mass migration means profits and those making the profits don't give a toss about the wellbeing of the average UK citizen. Edited by Mr_Gristle (24 Feb 2016 1.42pm)
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune) |
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
I think you'll find that the locals resisted these invasions very strongly and robustly and only 'accepted' these waves of newcomers after putting up one hell of a fight. Now, we seem to surrender without even a shot being fired. Each wave of invaders became the locals, mingling with the invaded, and produced a new hybrid, ergo a multi-cultural society! If we examined the DNA of modern Britons we would discover one of the most mongrel nations in the world, and all the better for it!
I used to be immortal |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by dannyh
You left out Angles, Saxons and Normans which arguably secured the notion of a united kingdom of England (and ultimately a UK). Its probably worth noting as well that two of the seven Celtic tribes fought with the Romans against the Britons, and 'Vikings' also fought against the Angles and Saxons. There isn't really a 'British People'. Interestingly in keltoi the word pict translates as 'before us' and celtic myths suggests than even the Celts weren't the first to the Isles. Although invasion post 1066 wasn't an issue there was a lot of migration into the UK, often as a result of the UK being a dominant trade and naval power. Maybe this genetic factor x is what led to us then going out and capturing a third of the world. Originally posted by dannyh
My perosnal stance is that there should be more emphasis on intergration rather than immigration. Edited by dannyh (24 Feb 2016 11.43am) Absolutely, both by the state and individuals in society, on all divides. A factor maybe seen in EU migration not seen in other periods of immigration is that for EU residents, the migration is largely short term and temporary - Where as with Indian and Carribean migration a degree of 'permanence' was involved. Of course integration is a two way street, those who come and those who reside must both change to accommodate each other.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
Well many invaders came and stayed, Romans Vikings and Normans especially! These groups formed what Britain is today, laws, customs, language, monarchy etc. etc. And because many British cities were centres of trade, people from all over the world came and stayed as well. Even in Shakespeare's time London was a multi-cultural city and other outward-looking cities were multi-cultural as well, Bristol, Liverpool, Glasgow etc. The main places where the natives have a "you're not from round these parts" have tended to be in rural places and small towns, where they do things like hang monkeys for be Napoleon's spies. London was multi-cultural before New York even existed as a city. Not good examples. Only the ruling classes of Normans came to Britain with a few soldiers to back them up. There was certainly no large scale occupation. Romans essentially came and went and the term Viking is rather quaint. Certainly Danes came here in reasonable numbers and the Normans were essentially Norseman but a much larger proportion of the population were Angles, Saxons and Jutes with remaining majority probably being here since the post ice age migration. In short, the population of Britain has remained almost unchanged for hundreds of years if not thousands of years. Until the last 50 years, migration has had only a tiny impact on the gene pool.
|
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
Each wave of invaders became the locals, mingling with the invaded, and produced a new hybrid, ergo a multi-cultural society! If we examined the DNA of modern Britons we would discover one of the most mongrel nations in the world, and all the better for it! So we should embrace invasion rather than fight it? WW2 just a waste of time, was it?
|
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Well that's not entirely true, as each decade since WWII has been marked by periods of mass migration (After the War, Indian Migration, pakistani Migration and Afro-Caribbean Migration - all really driven by a need for employees - and all met with similar arguments about society and equally less savoury ones). The primary difference between EU migration and the previous migrations has been the tendency towards the previous migrations being permanent, rather than temporary additions to the population. I agree that migration, and populations, need to be managed, but the question always remains how to regulate fairly, without resorting to a prejudicial basis, and that's where the EU migration has been problematic, the capacity to control and direct it has been driven more by market forces than the state. For other countries in Europe its a more common experience I think, given the size of borders and entry points, where as the UK as an Island, always has had a potent capacity to regulate, control and police its borders with its neighbours (something that for most mainland European countries is a much bigger undertaking).
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
So we should embrace invasion rather than fight it? WW2 just a waste of time, was it? If any country is invaded by force of arms they, of course, have the right to fight against the invader. I'm not sure that is relevant to immigrants, though, is it? Many differing peoples have been coming peacefully to the UK for thousands of years, some settle here, some don't. Britain is an amalgam of many different peoples, and always has been.
I used to be immortal |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Not good examples. Only the ruling classes of Normans came to Britain with a few soldiers to back them up. There was certainly no large scale occupation. Romans essentially came and went and the term Viking is rather quaint. Certainly Danes came here in reasonable numbers and the Normans were essentially Norseman but a much larger proportion of the population were Angles, Saxons and Jutes with remaining majority probably being here since the post ice age migration. In short, the population of Britain has remained almost unchanged for hundreds of years if not thousands of years. Until the last 50 years, migration has had only a tiny impact on the gene pool. Its probably worth noting as well that all of these peoples have more or less a shared genetic basis. Danes, Jutes, Nordics, Angles, Saxons and Franks largely stem from the same genetic basis. Britain's population has a number of diverse cultural and genetic influences. Primarily Anglo-Saxon (Germanics), Celtic (Welsh, Irish, Scotish and Cornish). Danes and Jutes in some areas of England and the North (Suffolk, Norfolk, Scotland and Ireland. Culturally and ethnically, the Germanic and Nordics are quite close (especially Jutes and Danes). The Normans seem largely to have been a mix of Germanic and Nordics, along with Franks. Certainly the invasion of 1066 was primarily the ruling classes and their troops, but over time there was a fair amount of migration, especially following the establishment of the Franks into what would become France.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
If any country is invaded by force of arms they, of course, have the right to fight against the invader. I'm not sure that is relevant to immigrants, though, is it? Many differing peoples have been coming peacefully to the UK for thousands of years, some settle here, some don't. Britain is an amalgam of many different peoples, and always has been. The people who make up the British came here over thousands of years and in thousands.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Definitely, and it should be a concern. The danger of EU migration is, to me is greater because its non-permanent and temporary. Most expect to go home eventually - So its mainly an economic prospect. Other periods of migration have been long term which has promoted increasing integration, which may well have been undermined by the EU temporary migration - An its affect a number of the British communities.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Not good examples. Only the ruling classes of Normans came to Britain with a few soldiers to back them up. There was certainly no large scale occupation. Romans essentially came and went and the term Viking is rather quaint. Certainly Danes came here in reasonable numbers and the Normans were essentially Norseman but a much larger proportion of the population were Angles, Saxons and Jutes with remaining majority probably being here since the post ice age migration. In short, the population of Britain has remained almost unchanged for hundreds of years if not thousands of years. Until the last 50 years, migration has had only a tiny impact on the gene pool. Well your user name would suggest you were there, perhaps! Yes Viking is a bit of a "catch-all" term, but Angles, Jutes, Saxons, Danes, Norsemen etc. all arrived in numbers that were sufficient to take over large swathes of the country, and the Celtic populations(who themselves originated from central Europe and arrived much earlier) were often pushed to the "fringes".
Edited by crystal balls (24 Feb 2016 4.55pm)
I used to be immortal |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The people who make up the British came here over thousands of years and in thousands. That's fairly viable though, given the progress of industrial need during the last half of the 20th century - Especially with the demise of empire. The migration of the 50, 60s, 70s and 80s, were driven largely by boom periods and high levels of employment and fed back into society. The problem with EU migration is that unemployment remained high in areas of the UK, and it was used to undermine wage demands that would otherwise have led to an incentivisation of workers to relocate and to undercut the wage demands of those already employed. Post 2007 Recession, the pressure has just increased with stagnant wages, and rising costs and prices.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
There are tower blocks and crumbling estates the world over, and all over the UK. Bad planning and construction. But equally there are well planned and well built apartment blocks as well! People have always flocked to successful cities, whether from within the country or without. It's not just migrants from abroad who choose to live in London, but people from all over the UK as well. But London saw a loss of over 2m people between the end of the war until fairly recently, I'm sure we all know friends who have moved away in the last 25-30 years, for lifestyle reasons. The need for three and four bedroom family homes is now becoming much less than in past times, as we are tending to live in smaller groups, so one and two bedrooms are more appropriate for the future. Incidentally, as I'm sure you know, there are large parts of Croydon and Sutton, as well as many other areas, that could definitely use upgrading! Are you having a laugh? Chicken and egg. So what you're saying is (based on your 3 bedrooms) there's less and less people having or wanting 2 children. The planners and decision makers are deciding strategy based on this with less 3/4 bedroom houses because they're 'tending to live in smaller groups.' Really? How many times have people heard couples say they'd like more children and/or a bigger house but cannot afford to here/there, or at all? What next? Because we like to have our daughters have a separate bedroom to our sons, we have to accept that people are tending to live in smaller groups so it's either share rooms through teenage years or stop at 1. That's whilst other cultures don't give it a thought and have 2,3,4,5 children. Great. People in 30 years time are going to really thank us for making this choice when there's people still old enough to tell them stories of when there was enough room to make decisions you wanted and weren't restricted to.
COYP |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
So we should embrace invasion rather than fight it? WW2 just a waste of time, was it? Can we stop using the analogy of an invasion, its pure hyperbole. Given the influence of Germany over the European nations, it might well have been a waste of time. No ones fighting anyone. There are are cockmunching nobs who think they're 'fighting' or 'resisting', whether its for Islam, British Culture or England. They're still all cockmunching nobends that no one outside the idiot fringes want.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Its probably worth noting as well that all of these peoples have more or less a shared genetic basis. Danes, Jutes, Nordics, Angles, Saxons and Franks largely stem from the same genetic basis. Britain's population has a number of diverse cultural and genetic influences. Primarily Anglo-Saxon (Germanics), Celtic (Welsh, Irish, Scotish and Cornish). Danes and Jutes in some areas of England and the North (Suffolk, Norfolk, Scotland and Ireland. Culturally and ethnically, the Germanic and Nordics are quite close (especially Jutes and Danes). The Normans seem largely to have been a mix of Germanic and Nordics, along with Franks. Certainly the invasion of 1066 was primarily the ruling classes and their troops, but over time there was a fair amount of migration, especially following the establishment of the Franks into what would become France. Yep. And they were all probably outnumbered by people who had been here a lot longer in a very small population. That population took a couple of thousand years to grow from around 3 million to 50 million. If that is not a drastic unprecedented change in British society then I don't know what would be. I doub't things would have changed more if the Nazis had won WW2. How's that for emotive?
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Are you having a laugh? Chicken and egg. So what you're saying is (based on your 3 bedrooms) there's less and less people having or wanting 2 children. The planners and decision makers are deciding strategy based on this with less 3/4 bedroom houses because they're 'tending to live in smaller groups.' Really? How many times have people heard couples say they'd like more children and/or a bigger house but cannot afford to here/there, or at all? What next? Because we like to have our daughters have a separate bedroom to our sons, we have to accept that people are tending to live in smaller groups so it's either share rooms through teenage years or stop at 1. That's whilst other cultures don't give it a thought and have 2,3,4,5 children. Great. People in 30 years time are going to really thank us for making this choice when there's people still old enough to tell them stories of when there was enough room to make decisions you wanted and weren't restricted to. No he has a good point, you tend to see it in rental and property prices. The difference between 3 and four bedroomed and more properties tends more to be based on the location, than on the additional room - Where as two and three bedroomed properties generally dominate the market. The most common cause of 'larger sibling families' is through second marriages of couples, rather than people wanting to have four or five kids - Difference is that in many of these cases, there is a big age disparity among children.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
Well your user name would suggest you were there, perhaps! Yes Viking is a bit of a "catch-all" term, but Angles, Jutes, Saxons, Danes, Norsemen etc. all arrived in numbers that were sufficient to take over large swathes of the country, and the Celtic populations(who themselves originated from central Europe and arrived much earlier) were often pushed to the "fringes".
The BBC were in a community hall type place in Manchester at the weekend where Polish and British people were asked about the EU and mainly immigration. A few said most come to work, only very very came to claim and they were not wanted or respected. A couple of POLES said immigration was getting out of control. Yes, 2 Polish people here for 5 years or maybe a few more said it was out of control. Not the 'many generations' it has perhaps taken for some to get over their racial prejudice of black and asian people but 5 years or maybe a few more, and they're not British and talking about immigrants from their own country. We need migration, but we don't need uncontrolled. If they thinks it's out of control now, wait a few more years when more countries join the EU and we've already had our one and only referendum and voted in. Edited by Rudi Hedman (24 Feb 2016 5.26pm)
COYP |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Yep. And they were all probably outnumbered by people who had been here a lot longer in a very small population. That population took a couple of thousand years to grow from around 3 million to 50 million. If that is not a drastic unprecedented change in British society then I don't know what would be. I doub't things would have changed more if the Nazis had won WW2. How's that for emotive? Well I'd imagine that there would have been a lot migration from Eastern Europe and the Caribbean. Plus housing in Golders Green would probably be cheaper, and no one would want a Spurs season ticket.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Yep. And they were all probably outnumbered by people who had been here a lot longer in a very small population. That population took a couple of thousand years to grow from around 3 million to 50 million. If that is not a drastic unprecedented change in British society then I don't know what would be. I doub't things would have changed more if the Nazis had won WW2. How's that for emotive? Between 2001-2011 the average annual net migration was 190,000. The ten million you refer to is attributable to plenty of other factors not associated with immigration also. Old age, etc.
Big chest and massive boobs |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
The people who make up the British came here over thousands of years and in thousands. The population has increased by 10m over the last 50 years, but quite a lot of this was caused by an increase in the birthrate between the early 60s and the mid 70s. The number of immigrants is little more than half of that figure, though most of this has occurred since 2004, admittedly. And not all of these stay indefinitely. Of 1.1m Poles who have arrived in the UK some 300,000 have returned.
I used to be immortal |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.