This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by big_palace_fan
Please keep posting. You're doing more good for the Remain camp than you are for Brexit through your utter drivel and illogically thought through views. Also FYI, the biggest risk to your personal safety is (touch wood) almost certainly not terrorism. Personal diet / habits such as alcohol, air quality (check the facts for yourself [Link] a sudden stroke, a heart attack, getting hit fatally by a car are all far more likely occurances than being victim of a terrorist attack. I sincerely hope nope of these tragic events happen to you (were are all human and Palace fans at the end of the day regardless of views of Brexit). Thanks. That's the best laugh I had all day. You were actually being serious weren't you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Thanks. That's the best laugh I had all day. You were actually being serious weren't you. Wholly serious. What do you consider the greatest threats to your life?
|
|
|
Originally posted by big_palace_fan
Wholly serious. What do you consider the greatest threats to your life? I was replying to a comment about increased risk of conflict not about this months edition of Men's health. Stop it please.
|
|
|
Originally posted by big_palace_fan
An entirely non-exhaustive list of reason: 1) Peace. Increasing cultural, economic and political ties with fellow EU states has helped secure the longest peace time in Europe since the Roman Empire. It would be folly to understate the role the EU has played in maintaining peace on the 100th anniversary of the Battle of the Somme where no few than 60,000 British men on the first day were marched to their death. 2) Economic success. Millions of jobs directly reliant on free trade with the EU. Talk of trade deals with around the world are not likely and will take time even if they do happen. 3) Cheaper costs - no roaming charges for phones coming in soon, cheaper imports, cheaper labourers (admitedly at the expense of some people - but what doesn't have winners and losers?). 4) Increased global influence and sway. Does anyone really think in 100, 50 or even 10 years any of the future world powers would listen to us without the considerable sway we hold within Europe? The largest common market in the world. When America, China and India walk to us it is largely because we are a leading member of the EU, not because we are aging Britain. 5) Fiscal contribution made by immigrants - blame government for poor planning not migrants coming here to work hard and get on. 6) Financial markets. Upon leaving, perceived riskiness of UK government debt will rise and so will the interest we pay on it - for any economists out there this just means higher taxes in the future (Ricardian Equivalence).
I am not saying the EU is faultless and certain groups haven't lost out by being a member. When you stand in the booth to place your vote, think will I be better or worse off for Britain remaining or leaving? What about my children and their children after them? There can be only one sensible answer. Remain.
Be quite you idiot with your pro EU propaganda, peace has absolutely nothing to do with the eu, think your mixing the eu with nato
|
|
|
Originally posted by rikz
Be quite you idiot with your pro EU propaganda, peace has absolutely nothing to do with the eu, think your mixing the eu with nato The nobel peace prize for 2012 was awarded to the eu "for over 6 decades the eu has contributed to the advancement of peace and reconciliation, democracy and human rights in Europe'
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 02 May 16 10.01am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by JohnyBoy
The nobel peace prize for 2012 was awarded to the eu "for over 6 decades the eu has contributed to the advancement of peace and reconciliation, democracy and human rights in Europe' No it wasn't... it was called the Common Market when it was created and was just a trading agreement to benefit the largest economic nations in Europe. There was no talk of political or economic union. The last referendum in the UK in 1975 was on the basis of a trade agreement with Europe only. The public were misled. Nato and the United Nations have done more for peace in Europe than the EU.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
No it wasn't... it was called the Common Market when it was created and was just a trading agreement to benefit the largest economic nations in Europe. There was no talk of political or economic union. The last referendum in the UK in 1975 was on the basis of a trade agreement with Europe only. The public were misled. Nato and the United Nations have done more for peace in Europe than the EU. And what was the aim of the common market - amongst other things to integrate trade between major European nations so they rely on each other, because more assimilated and hence don't war.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
No it wasn't... it was called the Common Market when it was created and was just a trading agreement to benefit the largest economic nations in Europe. There was no talk of political or economic union. The last referendum in the UK in 1975 was on the basis of a trade agreement with Europe only. The public were misled. Nato and the United Nations have done more for peace in Europe than the EU. Dont agree that anyone was misled, eu or common market was always about free trade and the largest component of trade is people. Saying its all about federalism is misleading tho. Agree that Nato and UN have had their role is resolving conflict but its the EU that has been the driver of peace, reconciliation and human rights which was correctly acknowledged by the Nobel prize for peace. Nato or the Un have never been shortlisted to my knowledge
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 02 May 16 10.44am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by big_palace_fan
And what was the aim of the common market - amongst other things to integrate trade between major European nations so they rely on each other, because more assimilated and hence don't war. The aim of the common market was solely to increase trade between nations and at favourable rates (a trading club). Nobody mentioned political or fiscal union or surrendering sovereignty at the outset. As I've already mentioned, none of this was on the agenda in 1975 when the nation was last asked to vote. Stop posting untruths... I actually voted yes in 1975, but I would have voted no if I was aware of what some politicians at the time and in the intervening years had secretly planned for the "Common Market".
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 02 May 16 10.54am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by JohnyBoy
Dont agree that anyone was misled, eu or common market was always about free trade and the largest component of trade is people. Saying its all about federalism is misleading tho. Agree that Nato and UN have had their role is resolving conflict but its the EU that has been the driver of peace, reconciliation and human rights which was correctly acknowledged by the Nobel prize for peace. Nato or the Un have never been shortlisted to my knowledge You are just being cantankerous and silly Johnny. Lasting peace in Europe comes from learning lessons from two world wars and stepping back from the brink. USA, Russia and China have more influence on world peace than the EU. French fishermen and farmers and German car makers don't give a flying fcuk about the EU laws, human rights or the sense of fair play when it suits them and they exploit our goodwill. The EU works because we always back down, pay more than we should be paying to be members and allow ourselves to be bullied. This was demonstrated by Cameron's pathetic recent attempt to get concessions from the other EU nations. You're not convincing anyone with your lasting peace is down to the EU argument.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
You are just being cantankerous and silly Johnny. Lasting peace in Europe comes from learning lessons from two world wars and stepping back from the brink. USA, Russia and China have more influence on world peace than the EU. French fishermen and farmers and German car makers don't give a flying fcuk about the EU laws, human rights or the sense of fair play when it suits them and they exploit our goodwill. The EU works because we always back down, pay more than we should be paying to be members and allow ourselves to be bullied. This was demonstrated by Cameron's pathetic recent attempt to get concessions from the other EU nations. You're not convincing anyone with your lasting peace is down to the EU argument.
PS I think you will find that many are convinced by the lasting peace argument for the EU including the Nobel committee. Putin and Le Pen maybe be saying differently I grant you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hoof Hearted
No it wasn't... it was called the Common Market when it was created and was just a trading agreement to benefit the largest economic nations in Europe. There was no talk of political or economic union. The last referendum in the UK in 1975 was on the basis of a trade agreement with Europe only. The public were misled. Nato and the United Nations have done more for peace in Europe than the EU. Indeed. And the Nuclear deterrent has done more than any of them.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Indeed. And the Nuclear deterrent has done more than any of them. Quite so. The main reason there weren't wars in Europe post-WW2 was because Europe's biggest historical troublemaker (Germany) was chopped in half and because of the huge US and Soviet military presence. To suggest that the EU takes the credit for peace in Europe for 70 years is, frankly, utterly risible.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
Quite so. The main reason there weren't wars in Europe post-WW2 was because Europe's biggest historical troublemaker (Germany) was chopped in half and because of the huge US and Soviet military presence. To suggest that the EU takes the credit for peace in Europe for 70 years is, frankly, utterly risible. so you think the European convention on human rights which constitutes EU law, drafted by British legal experts for abuses against state power after WW2 and allows European citizens the right
|
|
|
Originally posted by JohnyBoy
so you think the European convention on human rights which constitutes EU law, drafted by British legal experts for abuses against state power after WW2 and allows European citizens the right All that was enshrined in UK law anyway. Who needs Europe?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
All that was enshrined in UK law anyway. Who needs Europe? Because the wars have been with Europe (well two world wars), we need a legal framework that doesn't have a separate legal system for each country as stated by the very British lawyers who wrote the framework for Europe.
|
|
|
Originally posted by JohnyBoy
Because the wars have been with Europe (well two world wars), we need a legal framework that doesn't have a separate legal system for each country as stated by the very British lawyers who wrote the framework for Europe. Why do we need the same legal framework? You've lost me....
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
Why do we need the same legal framework? You've lost me.... As an example in cross border disputes, we needed the same legal framework for human rights in Northern Ireland's Good Friday agreement because the nationalists did not accept UK law and the loyalists did not accept Irish law. Rightly or wrongly is irrelevant (and has probably been laboured in other threads) because they all accepted European law that gave human and therefore political freedoms and rights to all. We have subsequently had peace there for 20 odd years thankfully
|
|
|
Originally posted by JohnyBoy
As an example in cross border disputes, we needed the same legal framework for human rights in Northern Ireland's Good Friday agreement because the nationalists did not accept UK law and the loyalists did not accept Irish law. Rightly or wrongly is irrelevant (and has probably been laboured in other threads) because they all accepted European law that gave human and therefore political freedoms and rights to all. We have subsequently had peace there for 20 odd years thankfully So now you claim that the EU was responsible for peace in Ireland as well? So if they had chosen US law, would that mean that America won the peace?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.