You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Female Dr Who?
November 8 2026 6.00pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Female Dr Who?


Page 9 of 23 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 18 Jul 17 5.01pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

"Whitewashing" in the entertainment industry has a long and shameful history. Think back to who played the Arabs in "Lawrence of Arabia"; it was Omar Sharif...yes...and Alec Guinness and Anthony Quinn - with Jose Ferrer as a Turk). This year, the lead Asian character from the book of "Ghost in the Shell" was played by Scarlett Johansson, which follows last year's nonsense with Emma Stone playing a half-Asian Hawaiian.

Hollywood has been replacing characters - written as people of colour (irony alert) - with white actors since day one. Seeing as Hollywood has already established that the colour of a written character's skin is irrelevant to the movie portrayal of that character, it makes the whole debate about Bond moot.

Somewhat unfairly in this specific case: the lead character in Ghost in the Shell isn't Asian, she's a cyborg, and she's not even in her original body (she's shifted form several times). She was originally Japanese, but exists in a trans-human society. Motoko aka the major loses her original body in childhood with full body prosthetic, with a cybernetic brain - hence the title - Ghost in the Shell.

Its literally about someone divorced from their physical self.

Sadly, it seems people made a lot of noise without being too familiar with the source, because as it turns out for all the films failings, Scarlett Johansson really nails the appearance from some of the anime.

Even the original author thinks she's a great adaptation. Its the exception maybe that proves the rule, but actually Scarlett Johansson is a very good

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 Jul 17 5.03pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

So you're ok with reinventing the race/colour of a written character as long as it makes more money? So much for artistic integrity.

FYI, have you noticed the increase in Hollywood movies of China as a locale and/or Chinese characters? It's not an accident. [Link]

Based on your stated principle, that money trumps art, I'm sure you're looking forward to Jet Li playing James Bond.

It has nothing to do with me. I'm not in the movie business. However, profit is the driving force behind all decisions made regarding casting. Even art for art sake still needs to eat.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (18 Jul 2017 5.05pm)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 Jul 17 5.07pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I never thought this was my stance but I'd be as happy seeing Will Smith play James Bond as I would seeing Rowan Atkinson play Martin Luther King. Both fantastic actors that would be incredibly entertaining.

What about Ron Atkinson?

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 18 Jul 17 5.10pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I've actually lost track of which side of the argument you are on. The above reads like you are against actors portraying characters of a different traditional ethnicity. I thought earlier you were for it.

1950s Bond has to be a white man because it's not credible that he'd be anything else; while a 21st century Bond can be drawn from a much more varied genetic pot. Many other characters are similarly interchangeable. I'm fine with this.

But Hollywood gets rightly criticised for replacing non-white characters with white actors just coz. The money argument doesn't always work either, because big budget movies like "Gods of Egypt" cast Gerrard Butler and some unknown Australian as it's main protagonists and Ridley Scott's "Exodus" had a cast of actors about as Egyptian as that of "Carry on Cleo". I am not fine with this.

As Hrolf showed with his contradiction over money vs. white Bond, there's no simple black and white here (pun intended).

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 18 Jul 17 5.13pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

It has nothing to do with me. I'm not in the movie business. However, profit is the driving force behind all decisions made regarding casting. Even art for art sake still needs to eat.

Great. So a non-white Bond is fine by you if it makes the Broccolis more money?

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 Jul 17 5.19pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

1950s Bond has to be a white man because it's not credible that he'd be anything else; while a 21st century Bond can be drawn from a much more varied genetic pot. Many other characters are similarly interchangeable. I'm fine with this.

But Hollywood gets rightly criticised for replacing non-white characters with white actors just coz. The money argument doesn't always work either, because big budget movies like "Gods of Egypt" cast Gerrard Butler and some unknown Australian as it's main protagonists and Ridley Scott's "Exodus" had a cast of actors about as Egyptian as that of "Carry on Cleo". I am not fine with this.

As Hrolf showed with his contradiction over money vs. white Bond, there's no simple black and white here (pun intended).

White actors usually play foreign characters because they are box office draws where as a whole cast of unknown Egyptians, for example, will sink like a stone.

I don't think this concept is dificult to grasp.

 

cpj Flag Kent 18 Jul 17 5.23pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

I don't agree with the new Doctor IF she has just got the job because she is a woman. To me that is just as sexist as a man getting the job just because he is a man.

However if she got it as she was the best candidate, good on her.

Missy is possibly my favourite character and I hope she comes back.

As a lifelong fan (haven't missed an episode since I started watching in about 1965), I hated Missy with a passion. Not sure about Jodie Whittaker - but glad it wasn't Kris Marshall who was favourite. The problem in the last few years has been the awful stories (especially Moffatt and his story arcs). Bring back decent stories and it doesn't really matter who the Doctor is. For the record, my favourite Doctors have been Pertwee, Troughton and Tennant.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 Jul 17 5.29pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

Great. So a non-white Bond is fine by you if it makes the Broccolis more money?

I want Bond to be white because I'm white and his character has always been white. If he ever becomes Black it will be because someone thinks it will make more money, not to further the success of the Black 'race'.

What ever colour he is, I will have more important things to worry about.

 

Red Al Flag Reading 18 Jul 17 5.46pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Bond is culturally specific as well. He had a Scottish father and a Swiss mother.
The simple fact is that I want Bond to be White. I am white and he has always been written as white. I'm happy with that.

How does having Scottish or Swiss parents equate to being white? Oh, and "white" doesn't need a capital letter...

 

Red Al Flag Reading 18 Jul 17 5.48pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

The difference between you and me is that I want the representation of Bond to be done well; you want white first, quality second. There's a word for that.

Well said...

 

wordup Flag 18 Jul 17 5.50pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I want Bond to be white because I'm white and his character has always been white. If he ever becomes Black it will be because someone thinks it will make more money, not to further the success of the Black 'race'.

What ever colour he is, I will have more important things to worry about.

I'm curious as to what you mean. You feel that you identify with him far more because he's white? Is how you feel about race that pronounced?

I don't ever recall seeing a Brit play a role and feel a disconnect based on skin colour. Maybe you mean something else and it's just awkwardly worded.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 Jul 17 6.00pm

Originally posted by wordup

I'm curious as to what you mean. You feel that you identify with him far more because he's white? Is how you feel about race that pronounced?

I don't ever recall seeing a Brit play a role and feel a disconnect based on skin colour. Maybe you mean something else and it's just awkwardly worded.


So you are having a meltdown and asking painfully loaded questions because I say that I prefer Bond to be White because I'm White?

You are familiar with human nature? Maybe you are superior in your own mind and think you don't you suffer from it?

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 18 Jul 17 6.05pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

White actors usually play foreign characters because they are box office draws where as a whole cast of unknown Egyptians, for example, will sink like a stone.

I don't think this concept is dificult to grasp.

This is true...currently. I was extrapolating to the point, inevitably, when the Asian box office dominates and so Hollywood will panders more heavily to that market (as it has already started doing). You seem to think your white privilege is going to last forever, when it most definitely is not.

Also, both Egypt movies sank like stones anyway, white stars be damned. The studios would've lost less money - and gained more credibility - casting middle eastern actors.

Edited by Ray in Houston (18 Jul 2017 6.07pm)

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 Jul 17 6.08pm

Originally posted by Red Al

How does having Scottish or Swiss parents equate to being white? Oh, and "white" doesn't need a capital letter...

No, obviously he is far more likely to be Black with the percentage of Black people in Scotland and Switzerland 40 or so years ago. Spare me please.

And I say it does, because Black and White is not the actual colour of the person but a simplified and accepted way to describe a certain group.

 

wordup Flag 18 Jul 17 6.12pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


So you are having a meltdown and asking painfully loaded questions because I say that I prefer Bond to be White because I'm White?

You are familiar with human nature? Maybe you are superior in your own mind and think you don't you suffer from it?

I'm not sure that asking a question about your comment can be considered a 'meltdown'. I was genuinely curious if it was that important to you.

I didn't say it's superior to think otherwise either but if it angers you that I can feel an affinity to characters of other races, that's certainly not my issue.


Edited by wordup (18 Jul 2017 6.15pm)

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 18 Jul 17 6.12pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I want Bond to be white because I'm white and his character has always been white. If he ever becomes Black it will be because someone thinks it will make more money, not to further the success of the Black 'race'.

What ever colour he is, I will have more important things to worry about.


Wow! So you're saying that a black actor could never win the role of Bond over a white actor by being a better actor; the black actor would only get the role because of someone's agenda?

Edited by Ray in Houston (18 Jul 2017 6.13pm)

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 Jul 17 6.16pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

This is true...currently. I was extrapolating to the point, inevitably, when the Asian box office dominates and so Hollywood will panders more heavily to that market (as it has already started doing). You seem to think your white privilege is going to last forever, when it most definitely is not.

Also, both Egypt movies sank like stones anyway, white stars be damned. The studios would've lost less money - and gained more credibility - casting middle eastern actors.

Edited by Ray in Houston (18 Jul 2017 6.07pm)

My white privilege? I haven't noticed any. That all sounds a bit like bigotry to me.
Maybe people who work hard to achieve get what they deserve and those that blame everyone else for their problems get what they deserve.
Just a thought.
And the Egypt movies probably bombed because they were s***.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 18 Jul 17 6.17pm

Bond is meant to be white from the books....that's obvious but it's not exactly the most important thing and it's just a fictional character.

If they brought in a black actor to play Bond I'd be ok with it just as long as it was in keeping with the character of Bond. If it's the best actor about...then blah blah and all that.

Jamie's 'trans Bond could be good' stuff just proves that he's taking recreationals into work with him.

Bond is meant to be white and male in his late thirties, early forties.....But hey...we are living in an age where a Time Lord is now a Time Lady.....all so that beta males can get excited and think they are doing something.

Not to sure how a 'lord' is meant to be female but feck it.....authenticity is for those interested in details not agendas.

Edited by Stirlingsays (18 Jul 2017 6.18pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 Jul 17 6.20pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston


Wow! So you're saying that a black actor could never win the role of Bond over a white actor by being a better actor; the black actor would only get the role because of someone's agenda?

Edited by Ray in Houston (18 Jul 2017 6.13pm)

No, only you said that in the highlighted bit.

I said I preferred Bond to be White because I'm White.
Got a problem with that?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 18 Jul 17 6.26pm

Originally posted by wordup

I'm not sure that asking a question about your comment can be considered a 'meltdown'. I was genuinely curious if it was that important to you.

I didn't say it's superior to think otherwise either but if it angers you that I can feel an affinity to characters of other races, that's certainly not my issue.

Important? Movies about a ridiculous spy?

Er no. It's just fun.

Why do you give a s***?

Edited by wordup (18 Jul 2017 6.15pm)

Important? Movies about a ridiculous spy?

Er no. It's just fun.

Why do you give a s***?

 

Page 9 of 23 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Female Dr Who?