You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Holmesdale Singing Section (LOCKED)


Page 9 of 71 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 17 Oct 18 7.59am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

That's for something different according to the Standard as it's about establishing a signing section - presumably for deaf fans


"Palace, though, are committed to creating a large signing section in the area behind the goal and will not go back on their decision"

Is that the singing equivalent of 'jazz hands' clapping?

As the club "will not go back on their decision" any discussion seems a bit pointless. Is Parish going to spend the whole meeting with his fingers in his ears going LA LA LA LA!?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 17 Oct 18 9.01am

This whole saga is now resembling one of Brian Rix's Whitehall Farces!

Edited by PZ Eagle (17 Oct 2018 9.02am)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

bicycle repair man 17 Oct 18 9.22am

The so called "fanatics" and Parish have turned CPFC in to a laughing stock.
It's embarrassing that he is pandering to the "singers" at the expense of loyal long standing supporters.

 

cpfanron Flag andover 17 Oct 18 9.25am

Holmesdale singing section, I've been a Crystal Palace fanatical fan for 60 years, and remember standing in the Holmesdale road end, its a pity that area behind the goal couldn't be returned to a standing section, just like the introduction black and white picture illustrates. Or build up that lower corner section of the Holmesdale A-B-C area with more singing and chanting, Flag waving Palace fans. So lets get together and try to sort this out so that all fans can enjoy the atmosphere at Selhurst park. If we've got to keep all seat stadiums, then let those loyal Palace fans have their favourite seats. " PALACE FOR EVER"

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 17 Oct 18 11.23am


I would like The HF back, but not like this.

Badly handled by the Club, who have seemingly issued no commumication or offered any discussions. How did they think the Fans would react?

The compensation offered seems to be a token gesture. At the very least the displaced fans should be offered a cut price/free season ticket for next season - and first dibs on seat choices in the new stand(at a price equatable to their current ticket). This would at least ensure that the Block E fans would still give the loyal supporters a good seat, and with the newer facilities and could be moved in Groups so the friends who have sat near one another for 10+ years can again sit near each other in the new world,albeit after a year or so in the wilderness.


Personally I cant wait for this sorry episode to end so we can move onto the next Episode....of "A Palace Minute" - this'll be a stonker!

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

bicycle repair man 17 Oct 18 1.48pm

All Palace fans should be treated equally,Parish didn't have to do anything.
If the "diehard" HF wanted to flounce off he should have let them ,instead of upsetting many more Palace fans,he simply caved in.
Everyone in the lower tier will be affected because of the selfishness of a hundred or so ,and a weak chairman.

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 17 Oct 18 2.12pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider


Read palace in frog land post above you and if you read it with an open mind you will realise how far off the mark you are. To suggest SP should resign shows your total lack of understanding of the corporate structure of CPFC. it is not owned by the fans nor are the seats. Premier league football is a very odd corporate product becoming odder and more unbalanced by the season. Eventually it will change, it has to, but for the time being it is here to stay and you need to understand it and move with it or you will remain in a miserable place where you and quite a few thousand fans clearly are.


I did read with a completely open mind. SP has ultimately to take blame for the problems that now exist. It doesn't matter where you stand on the HF or a singing section but I think everyone agrees the situation from start to current position has been mismanaged. The question is why? and Who ? and are they held responsible.

The fact is that only a very small part of support was consulted. So does the Singing section have support and active support (people who want to take part). How big is that active support among existing supporters? Without this vital info no part of ground should have been allocated.

There are a lot of potential scenarios that could now exist including refusal of planning permission to new stand, Refusal of permission to take part in a safe standing trial. Closure of Lower Holmesdale on safety grounds. The Fact is only time will tell and a lot will depend on behaviour of the Singing section.

What if the season ticket holders who have 25 year tickets challenge these changes in Courts? and win? The fact is with the proper consultation the disruption would have been minimised.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 17 Oct 18 3.33pm

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood

The fact is that only a very small part of support was consulted. So does the Singing section have support and active support (people who want to take part). How big is that active support among existing supporters? Without this vital info no part of ground should have been allocated.


It has massive support from Brighton (and other clubs) who wanted to make us look like idiots; Parish should have perhaps taken a look at the names on that petition (he's apparently signed it many many times himself) before he accepted it as a mandate for backing the HF.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Grey Greez Flag 17 Oct 18 5.28pm

Thankfully I’m Arthurwaite,but my mates,SwanleyWald,Bigginill Phil And Shirley Walt are very concerned,been seated together for many a season.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Oct 18 5.40pm

Originally posted by Grey Greez

Thankfully I’m Arthurwaite,but my mates,SwanleyWald,Bigginill Phil And Shirley Walt are very concerned,been seated together for many a season.

Troll alert. Read his previous posts

 

It's only a game Flag Praa Sands 17 Oct 18 6.31pm

Like many have stated on this thread, there is no argument that the HF massively improve the atmosphere inside Selhurst with their noise & displays.
On looking back at the clubs statement made on the 2nd September, they stated they had advised the HF that they felt it would be hugely unfair and disruptive to existing block E season ticket holders to move them out of their seats at the start of the current season, but they promised to review the matter when the main stand was rebuilt and many more options would be available to those displaced.

The HF then decided not to take up their 100 or so ST’s in block B and the atmosphere in the 4 home games played so far has not been good, although I’m of the opinion that this is mainly due to the team’s performances. If we had scored in any of the 4 home games played so far this season, the crowd atmosphere even without the HF would have had Selhurst rocking.
Just one month on, the club have changed their minds and basically caved into to the demands of the HF by advising 400 existing season ticket holders who occupy the rear 16 rows of block E, that they will not be able to renew their season ticket from next season. Offers of a 50% discount for an alternative seat & loyalty points are of little comfort & use when there is very limited choice of good viewing seats available and certainly not in groups of 2-4 for some of those who sit with friends &/or and family. These seats not only offer an excellent view, but are covered, with close access to the toilets & entrance/exit. If the club had stood by their original decision and waited until the main stand is rebuilt, when c8k more capacity becomes available, I’m sure many of the 400 would have understood & accepted the situation. With comments relating to possible delays of the main stand rebuild, this is even more relevant and why existing block E holders should be allowed to remain until the main stand has been rebuilt. I have 2 friends who have been ST holders in affected Block E rows since the stand was built in 1995 & they are very disillusioned with what is happening. Surely long-standing loyalty is worthy of better treatment or maybe the ‘Palace Family’ is no more & perhaps ‘ISLEY46’ isn’t so cynical after all? (see post 12.02pm yesterday on page 12). I don’t see the HF being loyal or living up to their ‘THESE TWO COLOURS UNITE US ALL’ banner & not too late for a U turn Mr Parish.

I have been in the LH back row of block F since the stand was built and with the HF standing directly to the right from next season, with flags waving, I’ll probably have to stand for most of the game and I’m not sure that drum will do my tinnitus any good, so roll on the main stand rebuild!


 


A stockbroker urged me to buy a stock that would triple its value every year. I told him, at my age, I don't even buy green bananas!


Grey Greez Flag 17 Oct 18 6.37pm

Troll I’m not my friend,Grey Greez on Facebook &PS4;Check me out please Bud.

Originally posted by Spiderman

Troll alert. Read his previous posts

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 17 Oct 18 6.48pm

Originally posted by Grey Greez

Grey Greez is my Facebook Page,troll I’m not &#128542;

I am sorry, anyone that makes the comments you have made about Jordon Mutch simply can't be taken seriously as a Palace fan.

Edited by Mapletree (17 Oct 2018 6.49pm)

 

Grey Greez Flag 17 Oct 18 7.11pm

Only a bit of banter Bro,WILF injured bothers me,Palace Through and Through Me,Name calling me aTroll From a Someone who can’t check me out is low,I don’t care though,I have a life,unlike some,nervous for Sunday though,draw will do,fingers and everything crossed,message me on Facebook the accuser of me trolling,I add you as a buddy,no probs,no hard feelings,just a result Sunday!

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Oct 18 7.16pm

can we please stick to the subject rather than digging each other out

 

Grey Greez Flag 17 Oct 18 7.24pm

I totally agree Bro,sticking to the subject,I’m not sure,but Steve Parish meeting fans to discuss things?Hopefully positive news,I’m confident all will be sorted,regarding seats etc,as long as I can see Selhurst football pitch,I be over the moon watching us from any seat,stand etc,all will work its self out,atmosphere etc,all us lot are upbeat about things.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 17 Oct 18 7.56pm

[quote=It's only a game;3375001]

Like many have stated on this thread, there is no argument that the HF massively improve the atmosphere inside Selhurst with their noise & displays.
On looking back at the clubs statement made on the 2nd September, they stated they had advised the HF that they felt it would be hugely unfair and disruptive to existing block E season ticket holders to move them out of their seats at the start of the current season, but they promised to review the matter when the main stand was rebuilt and many more options would be available to those displaced.

The HF then decided not to take up their 100 or so ST’s in block B and the atmosphere in the 4 home games played so far has not been good, although I’m of the opinion that this is mainly due to the team’s performances. If we had scored in any of the 4 home games played so far this season, the crowd atmosphere even without the HF would have had Selhurst rocking.
Just one month on, the club have changed their minds and basically caved into to the demands of the HF by advising 400 existing season ticket holders who occupy the rear 16 rows of block E, that they will not be able to renew their season ticket from next season. Offers of a 50% discount for an alternative seat & loyalty points are of little comfort & use when there is very limited choice of good viewing seats available and certainly not in groups of 2-4 for some of those who sit with friends &/or and family. These seats not only offer an excellent view, but are covered, with close access to the toilets & entrance/exit. If the club had stood by their original decision and waited until the main stand is rebuilt, when c8k more capacity becomes available, I’m sure many of the 400 would have understood & accepted the situation. With comments relating to possible delays of the main stand rebuild, this is even more relevant and why existing block E holders should be allowed to remain until the main stand has been rebuilt. I have 2 friends who have been ST holders in affected Block E rows since the stand was built in 1995 & they are very disillusioned with what is happening. Surely long-standing loyalty is worthy of better treatment or maybe the ‘Palace Family’ is no more & perhaps ‘ISLEY46’ isn’t so cynical after all? (see post 12.02pm yesterday on page 12). I don’t see the HF being loyal or living up to their ‘THESE TWO COLOURS UNITE US ALL’ banner & not too late for a U turn Mr Parish.

I have been in the LH back row of block F since the stand was built and with the HF standing directly to the right from next season, with flags waving, I’ll probably have to stand for most of the game and I’m not sure that drum will do my tinnitus any good, so roll on the main stand rebuild!


I share the opinion regarding performances. We've had much the better of the game in two of them but been clueless at the business end. Even against Southampton we had enough chances to get something.

It's not like we've been on the back foot and needed a lift.

I'm also not sure how the HF reconcile their supposed anti-corporate ethos with forming a contrived "singing section" (FFS) with the club at the expense of long term season ticket holders.

It's so poor from both the club and HF it's almost funny. How to turn yourselves from a respected club into a bit of laughing stock.


 

.TUX. Flag 17 Oct 18 9.30pm

Originally posted by bexleydave


I'd say we've already more than achieved that. How would we respond to another club starting a "singing section"?

I guess the vast majority of fans across the country would welcome it. We all like a good atmosphere don't we?

It's very close to putting out cardboard clappers or a paper flag on every seat.

Only in your world David.

 


Buy Litecoin.

stujii Flag 18 Oct 18 1.34am

[quote=It's only a game;3375001]

Like many have stated on this thread, there is no argument that the HF massively improve the atmosphere inside Selhurst with their noise & displays.
On looking back at the clubs statement made on the 2nd September, they stated they had advised the HF that they felt it would be hugely unfair and disruptive to existing block E season ticket holders to move them out of their seats at the start of the current season, but they promised to review the matter when the main stand was rebuilt and many more options would be available to those displaced.

The HF then decided not to take up their 100 or so ST’s in block B and the atmosphere in the 4 home games played so far has not been good, although I’m of the opinion that this is mainly due to the team’s performances. If we had scored in any of the 4 home games played so far this season, the crowd atmosphere even without the HF would have had Selhurst rocking.
Just one month on, the club have changed their minds and basically caved into to the demands of the HF by advising 400 existing season ticket holders who occupy the rear 16 rows of block E, that they will not be able to renew their season ticket from next season. Offers of a 50% discount for an alternative seat & loyalty points are of little comfort & use when there is very limited choice of good viewing seats available and certainly not in groups of 2-4 for some of those who sit with friends &/or and family. These seats not only offer an excellent view, but are covered, with close access to the toilets & entrance/exit. If the club had stood by their original decision and waited until the main stand is rebuilt, when c8k more capacity becomes available, I’m sure many of the 400 would have understood & accepted the situation. With comments relating to possible delays of the main stand rebuild, this is even more relevant and why existing block E holders should be allowed to remain until the main stand has been rebuilt. I have 2 friends who have been ST holders in affected Block E rows since the stand was built in 1995 & they are very disillusioned with what is happening. Surely long-standing loyalty is worthy of better treatment or maybe the ‘Palace Family’ is no more & perhaps ‘ISLEY46’ isn’t so cynical after all? (see post 12.02pm yesterday on page 12). I don’t see the HF being loyal or living up to their ‘THESE TWO COLOURS UNITE US ALL’ banner & not too late for a U turn Mr Parish.

I have been in the LH back row of block F since the stand was built and with the HF standing directly to the right from next season, with flags waving, I’ll probably have to stand for most of the game and I’m not sure that drum will do my tinnitus any good, so roll on the main stand rebuild!


I think you forgot to mention the petition plus support from the supporters clubs who want to create a greater atmosphere at Selhurst

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 18 Oct 18 2.08am

In the FYP podcast I am fairly sure SP said a decision had been taken and it would cost the club a lot of money ( sigh ).

THat being the case what's the point of meeting a delegationof those who will have their seats " compulsorily puchased " unless there is a possibility of reversing the decision or meaningfully increasing the compensation, both of which seem unlikely

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Page 9 of 71 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic