You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Middlesbrough (Carabao Cup) match thread
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Middlesbrough (Carabao Cup) match thread


Page 9 of 10 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Bullhorn76 Flag Darlington 31 Oct 18 10.58pm

Bad tonight really bad , and look of what might of been home tie against burton then possibly a semi final , oh well best concentrate on surviving again like years gone by

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 31 Oct 18 11.09pm

Originally posted by Stuk

That was the final insult for me. Just a step or two away from goal and a jump to head it was all it needed. He did neither.

The whole game was woeful however.

He doesn't back himself or how to use any strength he might have. Andy Carroll (when off the crutches) would have found two or three of those crosses.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Oct 18 11.24pm

The fact that our fringe players succumbed to a defeat against Middlesbrough without scoring says it all.
Disgraceful and concerning.

 

palace72 Flag coulsdon 31 Oct 18 11.28pm

Expected to see a good up for it performance from a mostly second string line up tonight,i did but unfortunately it was from the boro lot.They even brought wan bissaka down to there level,prey for no first team injurys,good luck to boro in the next round,they deserved it

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Oct 18 11.37pm

Originally posted by palace72

Expected to see a good up for it performance from a mostly second string line up tonight,i did but unfortunately it was from the boro lot.They even brought wan bissaka down to there level,prey for no first team injurys,good luck to boro in the next round,they deserved it

I never saw the game but from your account we were decidely second best.Appalling and very worrying.

A PL club with the likes of Puncheon, who started, and Williams on the bench.Says it all.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 31 Oct 18 11.43pm

Originally posted by Harry Beever

He’s not as gritty as Cabaye or a half fit Cabaye and certainly not the like for like replacement that a few thought he would be

Wow from hero to zero in one game.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 31 Oct 18 11.51pm

This is it, the soul or moral or whatever you want to call it seems to have gone awol.

Burton next round then a semi final... what more do you want? Roy didn't put out a strong line up on purpose, in my opinion, he was allegedly known to not make subs last season as to make a point - now our second string side were woeful. Being unlucky is one thing, so is being well beaten, but that?

Like i said and will keep saying, we need to get parish to move aside, get the club run properly as a business, a business that wants to compete.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Elpis Flag In a pub 01 Nov 18 5.53am

Originally posted by Vaibow


Like i said and will keep saying, we need to get parish to move aside, get the club run properly as a business, a business that wants to compete.

That he is running it like a business and not a football club is the problem . We as fans would I guess all have liked a cup run . Clubs of our standing really have only the cups as a chance of actually winning something .

But what does that achieve in a business sense ? Absolutely nothing , one place higher in the premier league is financially a better place to be and why premier league clubs play their reserves in this outdated competition .


Having said that we were piss poor and got what we deserved which was nothing .Also leaves our reserves without any competitive football until January when they will be even more useless in the 3rd round of the FA cup .

 

premier fan Flag BR4 01 Nov 18 8.20am

Originally posted by PalaceDevon

however their goal was handball
and we should have had a penalty !

positives ??

I am trying !

It was hit very hard straight at him. he had no chance of getting out the way of it. Not hand ball IMO

 

slubglurge Flag welling 01 Nov 18 8.29am

Biggest criticism of the players i have is that they weren't up for it. A lot of them look like they think it is a punishment to be in the cup team instead of an opportunity

 

eric youngs headband Flag amersham 01 Nov 18 8.37am

plenty of effort, absolutely no invention. Boro defence was well organised and we couldn't unlock it. I always through the difference between prem and champ was pace. we had no pace last night.

The performance feels no better after a good nights sleep and a full english...

 


4 playoff finals, Claridge, Hopkin, Shipperley, Phillips....

Life's never dull!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Nov 18 8.41am

Originally posted by eric youngs headband

plenty of effort, absolutely no invention. Boro defence was well organised and we couldn't unlock it. I always through the difference between prem and champ was pace. we had no pace last night.

The performance feels no better after a good nights sleep and a full english...

I posted yesterday about Middlesbrough's defensive record in terms of goals conceded.This is what one has come to expect of a team managed by Pulis.

As for us,no goals,no invention - very disappointing and worrying.

 

cpj Flag Kent 01 Nov 18 9.11am

Let's face it - our first XI is poor compared to last season and our backup players are even worse. This was a chance to play a near-first team and get a win and some confidence. Instead we played a reserve team. I'd have preferred to have seen Woods, Kirby, Daly etc given a chance - see if they're good enough as AWB has turned out to be. Sorry, but Roy is clueless.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 01 Nov 18 9.25am

Yes we made 8 changes but so did they. Equally our squad included some players who cost decent money.

We get Roy wondering what on earth is going on really but we seemed to send a team out with no idea if there was a game plan let alone what it was?

I wonder (and I have raised this with reference to use of subs,) does Roy actually bother with those outside his first 11? They just seem to have no idea.

Or maybe the big jar marked price and passion got emptied at the weekend and we had no time to fill it up.

Yesterday was to me another example that a a whole club, we are going backwards.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Nov 18 9.34am

Originally posted by slubglurge

Biggest criticism of the players i have is that they weren't up for it. A lot of them look like they think it is a punishment to be in the cup team instead of an opportunity

But according to Hodgson "..... they didn't let me down in any shape or form,".

 

stanzerman Flag Hastings 01 Nov 18 9.41am

9 wasted corners. We haven't looked dangerous at corners since Scotty Dann got injured and we rarely retain possession from our own throwins.

 


Stanzerman

Jacey Flag 01 Nov 18 9.43am

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

Yes we made 8 changes but so did they. Equally our squad included some players who cost decent money.

We get Roy wondering what on earth is going on really but we seemed to send a team out with no idea if there was a game plan let alone what it was?

I wonder (and I have raised this with reference to use of subs,) does Roy actually bother with those outside his first 11? They just seem to have no idea.

Or maybe the big jar marked price and passion got emptied at the weekend and we had no time to fill it up.

Yesterday was to me another example that a a whole club, we are going backwards.

Yes,unfortunately,sliding slowly back to the Championship.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 01 Nov 18 9.44am

I'm naturally disappointed but hardly surprised.

This game was always going to be about scoring the first goal. If it had been Palace, I reckon we would have won the match. But if we had to chase it...well we saw what happened.

If I restrict comments to Meyer, Sorloth and Ayew , Meyer is a player that needs to settle into a rhythm by playing 90 minutes on a regular basis. Otherwise it's difficult to see him progressing and settling into football in this country.

Sorloth looks like a panic buy - and not a cheap one at that. It's really hard to see this player developing into the level of quality required even at Championship level.

Ayew - a last minute desperation deal. How on earth did the guy score 11 goals last season ?! I would say send him back in January, but I have little confidence in the club signing a quality alternative.

Yes, Burton at home would have been an opportunity to get into the semi finals, but we have a relegation battle ahead so at least now the focus can be on that.


 


Old, Ungifted and White

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 01 Nov 18 9.52am

'In Roy we trust', and he has faith in them, so.....

Kalkai deserves a run, not 6 minutes, IMO.

Subs an RH weak spot.


 

Bullhorn76 Flag Darlington 01 Nov 18 10.11am

Apparently pape souare was quite disappointed to not leave with 3 points lol

Edited by Bullhorn76 (01 Nov 2018 10.12am)

34A60FA6-A39A-4291-985C-F994F280C450.jpeg Attachment: 34A60FA6-A39A-4291-985C-F994F280C450.jpeg (139.84Kb)

 

Page 9 of 10 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Middlesbrough (Carabao Cup) match thread