You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Bournemouth Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Bournemouth Match Thread


Page 9 of 12 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 04 Dec 19 1.42pm

Taylor has obviously been having refereeing lessons from Clattenberg
Rule 1....its only Palace so they should lose
Rule 2....Palace player tackles therefore its a foul
Rule 3....Card as many as you can while allowing the opposition to kick 7 shades of s*** out of Palace players

 

TheBigToePunt Flag 04 Dec 19 1.53pm

Originally posted by sprites

Consider yourself corrected - Kelly's very much a centre back who can do a job at right back. That's from his mouth.

He might well see himself that way now (and probably quite rightly) but he was a right back at Liverpool, and we bought him to play right back. His Wikipedia page backs up my memory on this, with talk of Glen Johnson being moved over to left back to make way for the young Kelly to rampage forward. When he signed for us Ward moved over to the left for the same reason, before we signed PVA and Schlupp.

Kelly ended up fitting in a centre back when everyone was injured, and did so well that it became another string to his bow. His flexibility probably resulted in his getting a new contract last time around.

Absolutely none of this matters at all. I just wanted to be sure my memory wasn't knackered, and having done the necessary research, I thought I'd share it with you.

Point remains that we've got 8 blokes for four positions at the back, including those who, like Kelly and Schlupp, can play in more than one position. Thats plenty, we are not Man City. Spend any dosh we might have on a forward I say.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (04 Dec 2019 1.55pm)

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 04 Dec 19 1.58pm

Originally posted by Adamoc123

We had more than a few glimpses, macca had a nice shot saved well, one or 2 Townsend crosses looked very dangerous and on another day wed have scored from 2 of Lukas wicked corners. As for wasting possession deep in their half, it happens to every team, otherwise there's only ever be 1 team attacking all game.

Edited by Adamoc123 (04 Dec 2019 12.59pm)

yep point taken. Macca's was a speculative (albeit excellent) effort, and there was a couple of good crosses come in..

but as for the wasting possession, I was talking about in the 90th+ min when instead of playing keep ball by the corner flag, we did it half heartedly (and were always looking for goal opportunity), but ended up losing the ball.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 04 Dec 19 2.00pm

It's a borderline red and if it were a foul on one of our players I'd probably say fair dues. Other than that, Taylor was broadly ok.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Uphill Flag Bedford 04 Dec 19 2.30pm

Originally posted by the silurian

Taylor has obviously been having refereeing lessons from Clattenberg
Rule 1....its only Palace so they should lose
Rule 2....Palace player tackles therefore its a foul
Rule 3....Card as many as you can while allowing the opposition to kick 7 shades of s*** out of Palace players

Taylor is one of our best referees and I thought he had a good game, even handed and fairly protective of Zaha.
So far this season (touch wood) we have generally had decent refs and this 'persecution complex' is silly.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 04 Dec 19 3.25pm

For What it's worth,
I thought that it was both a Red (by current recklessness rules)
and it was not a penalty (Zaha was knocked off The ball to easily).

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 04 Dec 19 3.40pm

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

For What it's worth,
I thought that it was both a Red (by current recklessness rules)
and it was not a penalty (Zaha was knocked off The ball to easily).

I'll never come to terms with the notion that if a player is tripped or pushed, the determining factor as to whether it's a foul is whether he "goes down too easily". If a player trips or pushes an opponent, he does it with the aim of impeding his progress - which is illegal and should therefore be penalised, whatever happens to the fouled player (unless advantage is being played).

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 04 Dec 19 3.48pm

Originally posted by Uphill

Taylor is one of our best referees and I thought he had a good game, even handed and fairly protective of Zaha.
So far this season (touch wood) we have generally had decent refs and this 'persecution complex' is silly.

you have got to be joking...if hes one of the best, the others must be totally s***e..we had 6 fouls 3 bookings (maybe 4) Bournemouth 16 fouls 1 booking and you think he was fair???

Edited by the silurian (04 Dec 2019 3.49pm)

 

Littlebogreek Flag 04 Dec 19 4.04pm

Originally posted by the silurian

you have got to be joking...if hes one of the best, the others must be totally s***e..we had 6 fouls 3 bookings (maybe 4) Bournemouth 16 fouls 1 booking and you think he was fair???

Edited by the silurian (04 Dec 2019 3.49pm)

They actually had 3 bookings I think. But agree, thought he had a game best described as inconsistent.

At the game I thought red card and no pen, watched the highlights and then thought both could have gone either way.

For what it's worth, appaently the VAR report said that had either of those decisions gone the other way (a yellow card or a penalty) those decisions would also have been upheld, so effectively they were both 50/50 decisions that we were on the wrong end of but in real time understandably so. Had the referee have erred on the side of caution with the red and allowed VAR to do its job then he stays on the pitch. That said, it wasn't these that I disagreed with at the time, just felt he was very inconsistent in what he gave and what he didn't.

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 04 Dec 19 4.20pm

Originally posted by JRW2

I'll never come to terms with the notion that if a player is tripped or pushed, the determining factor as to whether it's a foul is whether he "goes down too easily". If a player trips or pushes an opponent, he does it with the aim of impeding his progress - which is illegal and should therefore be penalised, whatever happens to the fouled player (unless advantage is being played).

You're quite right, unless the laws have changed (Willo?). It's all about the intent of the fouler, not the foulee. If a foul is committed with intent it shouldn't make any difference how the player fouled reacts.

So, penalty for me, but by not giving it at least those herberts from tw4tford can pipe down about Wilf getting pens easily.

Edited by Sansbup (04 Dec 2019 4.22pm)

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 04 Dec 19 4.23pm

Originally posted by Littlebogreek

They actually had 3 bookings I think. But agree, thought he had a game best described as inconsistent.

At the game I thought red card and no pen, watched the highlights and then thought both could have gone either way.

For what it's worth, appaently the VAR report said that had either of those decisions gone the other way (a yellow card or a penalty) those decisions would also have been upheld, so effectively they were both 50/50 decisions that we were on the wrong end of but in real time understandably so. Had the referee have erred on the side of caution with the red and allowed VAR to do its job then he stays on the pitch. That said, it wasn't these that I disagreed with at the time, just felt he was very inconsistent in what he gave and what he didn't.

If the push on the Livarpool player was enough to get our perfectly good goal chalked off, then the push on Zaha was most certainly enough to give us a penalty....no one expects perfection in referees, just consistency and not favouring VVD because he plays for Livarpool when ignoring loads of fouls onn Zaha because he plays for Palace.....Taylor was Bournmouths 12 th man last night, couldnt wait to get his red card out for Sakho while ignoring loads of fouls by Billings amongst others...no consistency at all, which leads people to believe there is favouritism and possibly corruption

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 04 Dec 19 4.27pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

You're quite right, unless the laws have changed (Willo?). It's all about the intent of the fouler, not the foulee. If a foul is committed with intent it shouldn't make any difference how the player fouled reacts.

So, penalty for me, but by not giving it at least those herberts from tw4tford can pipe down about Wilf getting pens easily.

Edited by Sansbup (04 Dec 2019 4.22pm)

They will be on his case from minute 1, and WILL influence Atkinsons decision making, Wilf will get nothing other than a booking as soon as he protests about being kicked all over the park.....remember the thug Deeney admitting they go out to kick Wilf out of the game, rotating fouls thus avoiding being booked

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 04 Dec 19 4.29pm

Originally posted by Sansbup


So, penalty for me, but by not giving it at least those herberts from tw4tford can pipe down about Wilf getting pens easily.

Edited by Sansbup (04 Dec 2019 4.22pm)

Good luck with that!

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 04 Dec 19 5.06pm

Originally posted by JRW2

I'll never come to terms with the notion that if a player is tripped or pushed, the determining factor as to whether it's a foul is whether he "goes down too easily". If a player trips or pushes an opponent, he does it with the aim of impeding his progress - which is illegal and should therefore be penalised, whatever happens to the fouled player (unless advantage is being played).

I don't *think* the law has changed, but the 'Shoulder to Shoulder' Challenge as far as i'm aware is the only contact 'allowed' - i.e. stated in the rules - in a game of football.. So with this in mind this is where the strength comes in. With a fair Shoulder challenge you can knock your opponent off the ball. It's another murky area of the rules of football.
obviously I think the shoulder to shoulder bit has expanded rather over the years.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

peterg Flag Anerley 04 Dec 19 5.30pm

Well, Wilf was pushed with an arm rather than shoulder to shoulder, and then he was tripped. So it should have been a pen. However I can still see why it wasn't given and why VAR didn't think it was wrong enough to be overturned.
I thought the Sakho impact looked far worse than it was and that the Bournemouth player made the most of it. But again I can see why it was called as a red.

 


The right place at the right time

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 04 Dec 19 6.11pm

Originally posted by JRW2

I'll never come to terms with the notion that if a player is tripped or pushed, the determining factor as to whether it's a foul is whether he "goes down too easily". If a player trips or pushes an opponent, he does it with the aim of impeding his progress - which is illegal and should therefore be penalised, whatever happens to the fouled player (unless advantage is being played).

you can be knocked off the ball without being tripped or pushed.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Littlebogreek Flag 04 Dec 19 6.13pm

Absolutely agree - no one expects perfection but consistency in decision making during each game is a small thing to ask. It all does bring up a lot of questions on how VAR is used too - I think if the referee goes to a screen and sees the push, he changes his mind and awards a penalty

Originally posted by the silurian


If the push on the Livarpool player was enough to get our perfectly good goal chalked off, then the push on Zaha was most certainly enough to give us a penalty....no one expects perfection in referees, just consistency and not favouring VVD because he plays for Livarpool when ignoring loads of fouls onn Zaha because he plays for Palace.....Taylor was Bournmouths 12 th man last night, couldnt wait to get his red card out for Sakho while ignoring loads of fouls by Billings amongst others...no consistency at all, which leads people to believe there is favouritism and possibly corruption

 

Littlebogreek Flag 04 Dec 19 6.20pm

It's no coinicidence that VAR comes in and Watford are rock bottom. they can't use those tactics as much now and definitley not in the area.


Originally posted by the silurian

They will be on his case from minute 1, and WILL influence Atkinsons decision making, Wilf will get nothing other than a booking as soon as he protests about being kicked all over the park.....remember the thug Deeney admitting they go out to kick Wilf out of the game, rotating fouls thus avoiding being booked

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 04 Dec 19 6.26pm

Originally posted by Littlebogreek

They actually had 3 bookings I think. But agree, thought he had a game best described as inconsistent.

At the game I thought red card and no pen, watched the highlights and then thought both could have gone either way.

For what it's worth, appaently the VAR report said that had either of those decisions gone the other way (a yellow card or a penalty) those decisions would also have been upheld, so effectively they were both 50/50 decisions that we were on the wrong end of but in real time understandably so. Had the referee have erred on the side of caution with the red and allowed VAR to do its job then he stays on the pitch. That said, it wasn't these that I disagreed with at the time, just felt he was very inconsistent in what he gave and what he didn't.

I personally thought that it was a red and a penalty. As the ref didn't give the latter then why didn't he book Wilf for diving. From where I was standing in the Holmesdale lower and right in line with his run this was as a blatant a penalty as there could be.

 


Bring back Brolin

Spiderman Flag Horsham 04 Dec 19 6.46pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

From where I stood that was a heavily biased ref

In the first half multiple fouls against us waved away.

It looked like Wilf should have had a penalty late on. Frustrating

Totally agree, he never gives Wilf a thing. Looked like more of a push (and stood on his ankle) than Ayew on Lovren.....oh wait that was for Liverpool

 

Page 9 of 12 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Bournemouth Match Thread