You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Southampton vs Palace Match Thread
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Southampton vs Palace Match Thread


Page 9 of 11 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Teddy Eagle Flag 29 Dec 19 11.48am

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

I'm not complaining about yesterday's decisions that went against us because it's happened to everyone and we've had our fair share of debatable VAR decisions that have gone in our favour. The bigger problem is that the excitement of football is being ruined by VAR and they need to sort it out and soon. If I was a season ticket holder I'd be thinking seriously about whether I want to renew for next season although I am optimistic that there will be changes before then. There has to be.

Absolutely. It seems VAR is being used to find reasons not to allow goals rather than overrule those wrongly disallowed.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 29 Dec 19 5.57pm

If the last defender and forward are dead inline with each other, it is deemed onside. Wilf was in line with the last defender,but it went against us...

The system needs revising, just seen a Wolves goal disallowed against Liverpool again a supposed offside. Liverpool have very few in any decisions go against them...

 

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 29 Dec 19 6.24pm

VAR is a good thing but I think the powers that be havent thought it through properly. I say this because it is a human that draws the line to see where the advancing player has a body part that could score is over that lne. As per wilf yesterday the line must have been drawn down his armpit as his feet/legs/head were onside and his arm was out over the imaginary line.
Echo the fans sentiments as per goal celebration as it takes several minutes for VAR to check and this is too long especially if the goal is disallowed.

COYP

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Dec 19 7.37pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Absolutely. It seems VAR is being used to find reasons not to allow goals rather than overrule those wrongly disallowed.

We of course benefitted from VAR when Ayew scored in the dying embers at W.Ham.

Just heard that 22 goals have been ruled out by very marginal offside calls.I don't know how many goals have been awarded due to a marginal calls.In the final analysis VAR is adjudicating based strictly on the current law.If the law is changed then VAR would have to adhere to the amended offside law.

I understand the protocols about "Clear and obvious" in relation to VAR but this has moved on to "If it's offside, it's offside" and has to be ruled accordingly.

Someone the other day in a local establishment expressed the sentiments in a gruff tone, words to the effect that VAR should NOT rule on offsides and that there would no longer be the controversy that currently exists!

Edited by Willo (29 Dec 2019 7.40pm)

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 29 Dec 19 8.00pm

Originally posted by Willo

We of course benefitted from VAR when Ayew scored in the dying embers at W.Ham.

Just heard that 22 goals have been ruled out by very marginal offside calls.I don't know how many goals have been awarded due to a marginal calls.In the final analysis VAR is adjudicating based strictly on the current law.If the law is changed then VAR would have to adhere to the amended offside law.

I understand the protocols about "Clear and obvious" in relation to VAR but this has moved on to "If it's offside, it's offside" and has to be ruled accordingly.

Someone the other day in a local establishment expressed the sentiments in a gruff tone, words to the effect that VAR should NOT rule on offsides and that there would no longer be the controversy that currently exists!

Edited by Willo (29 Dec 2019 7.40pm)

thank you for only indirectly alluding to the use of bad language, can't have been easy for you

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 29 Dec 19 8.07pm

Originally posted by Willo

We of course benefitted from VAR when Ayew scored in the dying embers at W.Ham.

Just heard that 22 goals have been ruled out by very marginal offside calls.I don't know how many goals have been awarded due to a marginal calls.In the final analysis VAR is adjudicating based strictly on the current law.If the law is changed then VAR would have to adhere to the amended offside law.

I understand the protocols about "Clear and obvious" in relation to VAR but this has moved on to "If it's offside, it's offside" and has to be ruled accordingly.

Someone the other day in a local establishment expressed the sentiments in a gruff tone, words to the effect that VAR should NOT rule on offsides and that there would no longer be the controversy that currently exists!

Edited by Willo (29 Dec 2019 7.40pm)

But prior to VAR offsides were decided on the position of a players feet rather than his shoulder.
I heard someone debating, semi-seriously whether offsides should be decided when the player passing the ball makes contact with the ball or when it actually leaves his boot.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 29 Dec 19 8.09pm

..in the game with Man.C v Sheffield.U the ref had himself completely in the way of a Sheffield player preventing him from controlling the ball and Man.C immediately went forward and scored with half the Sheffield players with their arms in the air! ..unbelievable to watch, could not understand why the ref didn't bring the ball back, he 100% totally got in the way! Very strange decision.

Where was VAR?

Edited by Tickled pink (29 Dec 2019 8.10pm)

 

The Yorkshire Eagle Flag Great Ouseburn, N Yorkshire 29 Dec 19 9.02pm

It seems that VAR is now running (ruling) the game. It not only takes away the excitement and controversy we have all spent years debating after a game - good and bad - but, in my opinion, is not serving the purpose it was introduced for.
The on-field ref is almost a non authoritative role now. Why do they not firstly refer to the pitch side screens and the request a VAR opinion not be led by them.
Admittedly, ‘rules are rules, but a hand or elbow ‘beyond the line’ is not within the spirit of the game and again in my opinion, is spoiling our beautiful game.

Sourness made a point, post the Liverpool game earlier, suggesting offside should be determined by any players “body part” being the “ right side of the line! Interesting...I say do away with offside altogether and have what back in the day was a ‘goalhanger’

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 29 Dec 19 9.04pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

But prior to VAR offsides were decided on the position of a players feet rather than his shoulder.
I heard someone debating, semi-seriously whether offsides should be decided when the player passing the ball makes contact with the ball or when it actually leaves his boot.

What was his "tone"?

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 29 Dec 19 9.38pm

Looking at the highlights thought Vincente did well between the sticks, particularly at the end. In previous seasons we would probably of lost 2-1 after conceding the lead and panicking at the back.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

silvertop Flag Portishead 29 Dec 19 9.40pm

Originally posted by Booted Eagle

Looking at the highlights thought Vincente did well between the sticks, particularly at the end. In previous seasons we would probably of lost 2-1 after conceding the lead and panicking at the back.

Which makes the links with man city all the more concerning.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 29 Dec 19 9.59pm

Originally posted by silvertop

What was his "tone"?

Slightly despairing/ironic. He wasn’t being entirely serious but trying to highlight how daft this could get.
It was on Soccer Supplement about three weeks ago but I can’t remember who it was that said it.

 

The Dolphin Flag 30 Dec 19 8.14am

Originally posted by silvertop

Which makes the links with man city all the more concerning.

What link to City - I guess I have missed something?

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 30 Dec 19 8.28am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

What link to City - I guess I have missed something?

Probably more "sky sports news understands.." bollox from the 2 proven liars kaveh and darmesh.
Silly season approaching again.
Believe nothing til it happens.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Dec 19 9.10am

Originally posted by silvertop

Which makes the links with man city all the more concerning.

One of the pre-requisites at Man C is that a goalkeeper is good with his feet in terms of kicking, distribution etc etc and whilst Guaita is an excellent shot-stopper I don't believe that his strengths lie when the ball is at his feet.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 30 Dec 19 9.57am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

What link to City - I guess I have missed something?

Apparently in a Spanish newspaper.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 30 Dec 19 10.12am

While the Offside Rule remains as it is, we will continue to see these ridiculous ' armpit ' decisions.

Combine that with the way in which VAR is being employed and we have the mess that we are witnessing every weekend.

I thought that VAR was only going to be used to analyse events where there was some uncertainty - not look for reasons to disallow goals.

VAR overturned Anthony Taylor twice in the Spurs v Chelsea game when he got it hopelessly wrong ( shock, horror ) with the Spurs 'keeper incident and Son's petulance and that was good use of the technology although I still don't know how Taylor could get it so wrong in the first place.

If VAR is here to stay then the authorities need to either change the offside rule or review how VAR is to be used.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

cryrst Flag The garden of England 30 Dec 19 10.31am

With VAR the ref should have a look pitch side with lines and all.
Not to the public on tv.
That way it's his or her decision on whether it was clear and obvious.
Then erase so never to be seen again.
Trust in refereeing then would surely return.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Dec 19 10.35am

Originally posted by NEILLO

While the Offside Rule remains as it is, we will continue to see these ridiculous ' armpit ' decisions.

Combine that with the way in which VAR is being employed and we have the mess that we are witnessing every weekend.

I thought that VAR was only going to be used to analyse events where there was some uncertainty - not look for reasons to disallow goals.

VAR overturned Anthony Taylor twice in the Spurs v Chelsea game when he got it hopelessly wrong ( shock, horror ) with the Spurs 'keeper incident and Son's petulance and that was good use of the technology although I still don't know how Taylor could get it so wrong in the first place.

If VAR is here to stay then the authorities need to either change the offside rule or review how VAR is to be used.

Statistics revealed that the Assistants were getting offside decisions right 98% of the time so in effect there were hardly any mistakes made.

With the introduction of VAR we now have "Armpit gate" and other controversies, week on week to the extent that supporters are enraged and totally fedup with the incessant debate that surrounds this issue, not forgetting of course the injustices they see in such hairline decisions.Games are stopped, VAR checks are not concluded with sufficient alacrity and this is having a negative affect on the entertainment factor of football and the PL.

There is an argument that with the very high percentage of correct offside calls which used to be made pre-VAR, the technology should be used solely to determine penalties,simulation and red cards and whilst of course there will still be controversy and debate, there will not be this furore we have at the present time.

There is also the argument that as in cricket, where an umpire's decision not to award LBW stands if Hawkeye adjudges that a ball would only have just touched the stumps, a degree of elasticity could be introduced in terms of VAR and offsides.

As things stand, VAR is having a negative affect on players and supporters so changes are necessary.VAR is mired in controversy and confusion.

Edited by Willo (30 Dec 2019 10.38am)

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 30 Dec 19 10.57am

Originally posted by Willo

Statistics revealed that the Assistants were getting offside decisions right 98% of the time so in effect there were hardly any mistakes made.

With the introduction of VAR we now have "Armpit gate" and other controversies, week on week to the extent that supporters are enraged and totally fedup with the incessant debate that surrounds this issue, not forgetting of course the injustices they see in such hairline decisions.Games are stopped, VAR checks are not concluded with sufficient alacrity and this is having a negative affect on the entertainment factor of football and the PL.

There is an argument that with the very high percentage of correct offside calls which used to be made pre-VAR, the technology should be used solely to determine penalties,simulation and red cards and whilst of course there will still be controversy and debate, there will not be this furore we have at the present time.

There is also the argument that as in cricket, where an umpire's decision not to award LBW stands if Hawkeye adjudges that a ball would only have just touched the stumps, a degree of elasticity could be introduced in terms of VAR and offsides.

As things stand, VAR is having a negative affect on players and supporters so changes are necessary.VAR is mired in controversy and confusion.

Edited by Willo (30 Dec 2019 10.38am)

That’s a very fair summation.
No idea how old linesmen are but how do they stay in line with teenage flyers when professional players get left in their wake?

 

Page 9 of 11 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Southampton vs Palace Match Thread