This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Palace vs Derby Match Thread
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
southnorwoodhill 05 Jan 20 6.53pm |
|
|
A probable thrown result, in the sense that it avoids further unnecessary game time for a crocked squad, with the added bonus for Hodgson of being able to give someone else the captain's armband other than the totally misfiring Milo.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Jan 20 7.17pm |
|
Originally posted by PatrickA
Was optimistic before the game when I saw the team with only one inexperienced player included. Very disappointed with the performance subsequently and also to go out of the cup with a whimper. We looked jaded and lacking ideas. No creativity and pedestrian in midfield and a lack of pace and zip in the wide areas to get behind their defence. Another goalless game from us and we’re so easy to defend against. Yes there are injuries, but our team should have been strong enough to beat at home a mediocre Championship team who played games on Monday and Thursday during the week. We can’t even claim to be unlucky as they deserved their win.
Absolutely spot on. It was a hard watch,and there cannot be any positives to take from our abject performance.
Derby are 3rd from bottom in terms of away results in the Championship.They have only won 1 of their 12 away games and that was the first game of the season at Huddersfield, but we barely laid a glove on them at our home ground.
Edited by Willo (05 Jan 2020 7.26pm)
|
Bexley Eagle Bexley Kent 05 Jan 20 7.26pm |
|
|
Ayew tried hard and the kid looked ok when he was on the ball which was far too infrequently unfortunately. All in all it was a turgid performance.
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 05 Jan 20 7.35pm |
|
|
I am not surprised by that result and it was much to be expected, Roy couldn’t give a monkeys about the cup and our Premiership status is what counts.
Our injury list and suspensions are starting to bite now, so I am thankful for the 28 points we have mustered so far...
Well done Derby you deserved the win...
|
dg1937 05 Jan 20 7.49pm |
|
|
'Ayew is class. Pierrick good potential.'
I thought these two were the only ones to emerge with much credit from that. We lacked pace, width and creativity. I don't mind losing but the performance was really poor.
|
ex hibitionist Hastings 05 Jan 20 7.52pm |
|
Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews
I am not surprised by that result and it was much to be expected, Roy couldn’t give a monkeys about the cup and our Premiership status is what counts.
Our injury list and suspensions are starting to bite now, so I am thankful for the 28 points we have mustered so far...
Well done Derby you deserved the win...
if Roy doesn't care for the cup why did he pick such a strong side?
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 05 Jan 20 8.38pm |
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Thoughts from today. Zaha badly missed Without Zaha we are a very different team Lots of our players are championship level. We were awful. Cahill should be skipper. Our tactics were hopeless. Derby fans sang us out the ground. Ayew is class. Pierrick good potential. Wickham championship level. Kelly should play in middle. Luka needs the break and needs help. Townsend missed. Easy to say but we should look for more squad rotation. Roy obviously stuck on this one. But he is very staid. However he is working wonders for us. We need more players. The board really needs to take action The White Horse has way better facilities than the Arthur. Arthur season tickets should be cheaper!! Why close the Arthur for home fans today?
Yes, Luka needs help
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 05 Jan 20 8.39pm |
|
|
Edited by Tickled pink (05 Jan 2020 8.40pm)
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 05 Jan 20 8.42pm |
|
|
Without Zaha
|
Aray South London 05 Jan 20 8.48pm |
|
|
Our midfield was terrible today.
For all my hopes that Meyer would become our midfield playmaker today he didn't do enough. Yes he got kicked a bit and then took a real one (accidental though). But before he was injured I was really disappointed how little he showed for the ball and his exceedingly safe distribution after he received - though he did give the ball away a few times!
Luka - well enough has said on his performance even before he got himself sent off. Clear red from where I was sitting.
Jimmy M huffed and puffed but didn't really get going - but he was carrying two passengers.
I do wonder whether Wickham's immobility hurt us too. You'd have to say probably. Would have been better just playing and Pierrick up front and played 4 in the middle - we needed the extra man.
As for their goal - well the fullbacks hardly covered themselves in glory. Wayne had no chance.
The injury list gets bigger - lets hope PvA or Schlupp are fit soon.
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 05 Jan 20 9.09pm |
|
Originally posted by Aray
Our midfield was terrible today.
For all my hopes that Meyer would become our midfield playmaker today he didn't do enough. Yes he got kicked a bit and then took a real one (accidental though). But before he was injured I was really disappointed how little he showed for the ball and his exceedingly safe distribution after he received - though he did give the ball away a few times!
Luka - well enough has said on his performance even before he got himself sent off. Clear red from where I was sitting.
Jimmy M huffed and puffed but didn't really get going - but he was carrying two passengers.
I do wonder whether Wickham's immobility hurt us too. You'd have to say probably. Would have been better just playing and Pierrick up front and played 4 in the middle - we needed the extra man.
As for their goal - well the fullbacks hardly covered themselves in glory. Wayne had no chance.
The injury list gets bigger - lets hope PvA or Schlupp are fit soon.
If Rooney was in our team the result would have been very different.
|
merganser 05 Jan 20 10.07pm |
|
|
I think Steve Parish had his heart set on a cup run - perhaps that’s why Roy put out an experienced side.
|
Pete53 Hassocks 05 Jan 20 10.18pm |
|
|
I'm sort of glad we didn't get an equaliser. The last thing we need is another game.
Lots of boos rang our around the ground for Wayne Rooney at the start but I have to say he put in a classy performance. There is a certain pleasure to be had in watching a top-line seasoned pro. He was calm and collected and knew exactly what he was doing. He hardly broke into a sweat and was spraying the ball around the park with unerring accuracy. In contrast our players seemed to find it a lot easier to pass the ball to the opposition than to their own team mates.
|
bideagle Bideford 05 Jan 20 10.43pm |
|
|
No ambition apart from premiership survival. Palace fans deserve more. In some ways we would be better off going down. At least we would have the right players for the championship as most are not premiership quality. We are just lucky this year that there are a few worst teams than us this year. Though if as usual we have a poor transfer window anything is possible. In at nutshell we are s***e!
|
Eaglehamster Storrington 05 Jan 20 11.08pm |
|
|
It's depressing. We are shyte without Wilf. But we knew that. Roy MUST know that. Yet nothing changes.
I confess I have no knowledge of the running of the club but I can't see any real intent to make Palace a permanent PL club.
I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.
|
merganser 05 Jan 20 11.11pm |
|
|
On MOTD, it was interesting to see Roy’s lovey-dovey stuff with Rooney BEFORE the match.
I would have preferred him to have saved the cuddles and affection until AFTER the match.
Our manager was making our opponents’ star player welcome. No wonder he had such a good game
I wonder what the Palace players thought of that.Probably not a lot.
Edited by merganser (05 Jan 2020 11.13pm)
|
StrangerThing Brisbane 05 Jan 20 11.24pm |
|
|
Glad I didnt get up for this. So , coming from the point of view of reading the score then looking at the team, two things strike me.
Camarasa is done, can it really just be that he is out of favour? Surely more to it.
The team sheet seems to be a message to the owners that the present squad cannot do without Wilf. I cant think of any other reason not to rest players and start at least one more youngster.
Other than that shame about Riedewald, a run of games was doing him good. If we do get new players, i think thats probably it for him and Max.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Jan 20 11.39pm |
|
Originally posted by StrangerThing
Glad I didnt get up for this. So , coming from the point of view of reading the score then looking at the team, two things strike me.
Camarasa is done, can it really just be that he is out of favour? Surely more to it.
The team sheet seems to be a message to the owners that the present squad cannot do without Wilf. I cant think of any other reason not to rest players and start at least one more youngster.
Other than that shame about Riedewald, a run of games was doing him good. If we do get new players, i think thats probably it for him and Max.
I suspect that Riedewald, playing out of position, has exceeded the expectations of a great number of our supporters whilst Meyer has not lived up to expectations.
Edited by Willo (05 Jan 2020 11.40pm)
|
Den1923 06 Jan 20 12.15am |
|
Originally posted by merganser
I think Steve Parish had his heart set on a cup run - perhaps that’s why Roy put out an experienced side.
What was he on when he said that!
|
kev64 Cambs 06 Jan 20 7.59am |
|
|
At end of the day, it’s down to Roy and he completely fed this one up. Playing a tired first team with no room for error cost us 3 more players out.
The tactics never change regardless .. it’s seriously becoming anti football at home and away. A really really really bad day and unfortunately Roy won’t change.
Sad to say BHA had the right idea CH may of kept them in the premier but was slowly killing the team.
Sorry Roy please retire at the end of the season
|