You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread


Page 9 of 11 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 22 Feb 20 8.43pm

Excellent today deserved more goals and Roy obviously identified they weren't good enough to play out from the back.

MacArthur MOM followed by PVA. Dubravka's two first half saves were up there with the best I've seen at a game.

Thought Zaha was poor and we were better for Luka's absence.

Benteke had his best game in a while but still abject when he was asked the question.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 22 Feb 20 8.49pm

Ayew was ubelievable, and James Macarthy apart from one silly early pass had a stormer, more mobile than Luka and the art of tackling survives with him in these days of safety first refereeing, popped up all over the place to stop things or start them, I think he's best used to facilitate fair players, gets stuck in then lays it off in a better position

 

Casual Flag Orpington 22 Feb 20 9.08pm

over the 24 games this season Ayew has been a better player than Zaha, I think that is fact rather than opinion now surely. Been absolute quality, instead of trying to slow play down and walk past people he picks it up and runs at them, did it in the first half and thought it was looking like another West Ham goal. Been great this year. No sentiment in football I’m afraid. Wilf you’ve been great, but time to go.
Get some youngsters in.
Good game today. Guitita ( good as usual), ayew quality, Kouyate decent, Cahill very good , liked macarthy.
Thought Tosun should have come on sooner for Benteke and Townsend/Meyer could have replaced the unsubbable Zaha

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 22 Feb 20 9.12pm

Originally posted by JRW2

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Wilf permanently had two markers on him which was always going to keep him a bit quiet. What that did though was open up the centre of midfield.


Two markers to start with, then he was quickly surrounded by four, with the result described above. And, as I imagine we all agree, if the others could have exploited the space he created, we would have won far more easily. All the same, as I said to my neighbour, he had the look of a man who didn't want to get injured.

ditto

 

CockneyRebel Flag West Harrison,NY. 22 Feb 20 9.16pm

ROY.....This is for you....

Today was without a doubt enough of your No1 choice C.BenTakeAway.... the open goals, clear cut shots on goal, etc,etc...missing them ALL..was enough to drive the wife and I "crazy"....and you stick with him....enough is enough Roy...He is NOT a goal scorer..forget it..That weak goal last time, which was a goal keeping error, and NOT a powerful, great shot, as some people say..but a feeble miss hit that Pickford was fooled by the tame shot...
We were at a complete loss, when he came out in the second half... I think ALL our other players had enough of his poor-poor play as well, and didn't really service him as they did in the first half..He might be a nice guy..but..he is NOT doing what we bought him for..useless, is being polite..sorry..
The points he has lost for us is mind blowing..not just now, but last season as well...enough Roy,,enough..

Edited by CockneyRebel (22 Feb 2020 9.19pm)

 


Here since 81...(LAST CENTURY !!).. x-Dunraven School, early 1960.... Palace 'nut' since 58....

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 22 Feb 20 9.52pm

Originally posted by CockneyRebel

ROY.....This is for you....

Today was without a doubt enough of your No1 choice C.BenTakeAway.... the open goals, clear cut shots on goal, etc,etc...missing them ALL..was enough to drive the wife and I "crazy"....and you stick with him....enough is enough Roy...He is NOT a goal scorer..forget it..That weak goal last time, which was a goal keeping error, and NOT a powerful, great shot, as some people say..but a feeble miss hit that Pickford was fooled by the tame shot...
We were at a complete loss, when he came out in the second half... I think ALL our other players had enough of his poor-poor play as well, and didn't really service him as they did in the first half..He might be a nice guy..but..he is NOT doing what we bought him for..useless, is being polite..sorry..
The points he has lost for us is mind blowing..not just now, but last season as well...enough Roy,,enough..

Edited by CockneyRebel (22 Feb 2020 9.19pm)

Er

Pretty sure Ayew has been his no1 pick this season

Tosun started instead of Benteke as soon as he came in.

Cenk will be 1st choice going forward

Ayew not a natural winger but superb in terms of work rate, tracking back and forward movement

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Casual Flag Orpington 22 Feb 20 10.22pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Er

Pretty sure Ayew has been his no1 pick this season

Tosun started instead of Benteke as soon as he came in.

Cenk will be 1st choice going forward

Ayew not a natural winger but superb in terms of work rate, tracking back and forward movement

Agree , Tosun couldn’t play against Everton and Benteke scored, can’t see him starting again after today.
Ayew or Tosun to be the number 9 , if not Ayew he will play wide.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 22 Feb 20 10.25pm

Originally posted by Casual

over the 24 games this season Ayew has been a better player than Zaha, I think that is fact rather than opinion now surely. Been absolute quality, instead of trying to slow play down and walk past people he picks it up and runs at them, did it in the first half and thought it was looking like another West Ham goal. Been great this year. No sentiment in football I’m afraid. Wilf you’ve been great, but time to go.
Get some youngsters in.
Good game today. Guitita ( good as usual), ayew quality, Kouyate decent, Cahill very good , liked macarthy.
Thought Tosun should have come on sooner for Benteke and Townsend/Meyer could have replaced the unsubbable Zaha

He's unsubbable for a reason - even when he's not performing, he draws the attention of several opposition defenders at all times. Got several players booked today and one sent off at the end, so I think it turned out to be a good idea to keep him on.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 22 Feb 20 11.01pm

Originally posted by Bangell

He's unsubbable for a reason - even when he's not performing, he draws the attention of several opposition defenders at all times. Got several players booked today and one sent off at the end, so I think it turned out to be a good idea to keep him on.

Hasn’t performed often this season , if a couple off bookings and a sending off with a minute to go for an £80 million rated player is enough for you, fair enough, not for me.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 22 Feb 20 11.16pm

Originally posted by Casual

Hasn’t performed often this season , if a couple off bookings and a sending off with a minute to go for an £80 million rated player is enough for you, fair enough, not for me.

Didn't say that he'd performed at his best this season, or that he's worth £80 million. But you suggested that he should be subbed when demonstrably, his presence on the pitch tied up Newcastle's players in keeping an eye on him, as is the case in every game. Part of the reason he's not performing so well this season is because there isn't another runner on the other wing who can also draw opposition players, so that it's very easy for other teams to double or treble up on Wilf since he's our main attacking outlet. And even when he's not playing well, he can suddenly produce something out of nothing.

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 22 Feb 20 11.25pm

Bloody brilliant today. The energy and intensity was superb. We swarmed all over them from the off.

Leader of the pack was Jimmy Mac; he had an absolute stormer. McCarthy put a great shift in too. Not really sure I can say the same of Kouyate. Goes MIA too often for my liking.

Overall though, delighted; we thrashed them 1-0

 


Spirit of 1974

EddieMac Flag 22 Feb 20 11.51pm

Originally posted by bifffabazz

Bloody brilliant today. The energy and intensity was superb. We swarmed all over them from the off.

Leader of the pack was Jimmy Mac; he had an absolute stormer. McCarthy put a great shift in too. Not really sure I can say the same of Kouyate. Goes MIA too often for my liking.

Overall though, delighted; we thrashed them 1-0

McCarthy is going to turn out to be a fantastic bit of business. I can’t see him being dropped now for the rest of the season.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 22 Feb 20 11.56pm

the 80 million pound rating comes from someone who has no idea.

Originally posted by Casual

Hasn’t performed often this season , if a couple off bookings and a sending off with a minute to go for an £80 million rated player is enough for you, fair enough, not for me.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 23 Feb 20 1.00am

Originally posted by EddieMac

McCarthy is going to turn out to be a fantastic bit of business. I can’t see him being dropped now for the rest of the season.

McCarthy has great delivery from corners,put one straight on Cahills head that crashed back off the crossbar.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 23 Feb 20 2.09am

Ayew works his socks off, BUT - misses too many clear-cut chances, most of the time try to take on too many players when a simple pass would have been better. And on the moaning scale - ten out of ten yesterday.

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 23 Feb 20 8.12am

really big 'steady the ship' win yesterday.
IF we can beat Tesco bag boys next weekend we'll in theory only be 3 points off safety.
And what a change to see a proper home side attacking display at Selhurst
we may even beat somebody by more than 1 goal before seasons done!

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

Aray Flag South London 23 Feb 20 8.18am

We actually played well, on the front foot and looked far more dynamic in midfield and up front. MacArthur was my MoM closely followed by Ayew.

I was pleased we went direct a fair bit too and Benteke played his part there. But we still couldn’t score in open play. And boy did we miss some sitters.

Wonder how badly injured Kouyate is?

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 23 Feb 20 8.26am

Originally posted by Casual

over the 24 games this season Ayew has been a better player than Zaha, I think that is fact rather than opinion now surely. Been absolute quality, instead of trying to slow play down and walk past people he picks it up and runs at them, did it in the first half and thought it was looking like another West Ham goal. Been great this year. No sentiment in football I’m afraid. Wilf you’ve been great, but time to go.
Get some youngsters in.

Good game today. Guitita ( good as usual), ayew quality, Kouyate decent, Cahill very good , liked macarthy.
Thought Tosun should have come on sooner for Benteke and Townsend/Meyer could have replaced the unsubbable Zaha

The problem is that the money will not be re-invested. It will be used to pay down debt. Look at the AWB money. So, unless it will be spent on a replacement, which it wont, I would keep him.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

PatrickA Flag London 23 Feb 20 8.49am

Whilst I’m a critic of Hodgson’s style of play this season and his rigid methods, I have to acknowledge that to amass 33 points so far this season with minimal contribution from Zaha, Townsend, Benteke and Luka is an impressive achievement.
I have previously put their bad performances down to Hodgson’s methods, but just maybe they need to look at themselves and ask if they could be contributing more.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Feb 20 8.52am

I cannot fault any of the players for their performances yesterday.Those not at the game will see the 1-0 scoreline and might conclude it was a close game.It was certainly NOT - Newcastle were disappointing and were well beaten.A 4-0 scoreline would not have flattered our team.

Made for a very pleasant drive back to the south coast and my wife said I was beaming like a gameshow dollybird when I returned to my abode!

Edited by Willo (23 Feb 2020 8.53am)

 

Page 9 of 11 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread