You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs Newcastle match thread
November 16 2026 4.26am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace vs Newcastle match thread


Page 9 of 15 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
southnorwoodhill Flag 23 Oct 21 7.04pm

.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (23 Oct 2021 7.10pm)

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 23 Oct 21 7.06pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

both Everton and Norwich got smashed today.

i cannot see us smashing anybody at this level.

We’re you at the Spurs game by any chance?

 

beak Flag croydon 23 Oct 21 7.07pm

Originally posted by Painter

We lost 2-0 in the corresponding fixture last season, so your point is?

We were better off last season at this stage.

Edited by beak (23 Oct 2021 7.22pm)

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 23 Oct 21 7.11pm

Originally posted by MR100%

So pleased for Benteke with his goal, but how did he miss that chance when he was one on one
how do you complain about a referee's performance ,they are completely unaccountable ,there was clearly a push on Joel that led to the corner from which they scored

How was Wilson still on the pitch? He was on a yellow when he hauled Olise back to stop a break, cast iron yellow card. No doubt MOTD will cream themselves over his goal rather that concentrate on this. Ref should be made to account for a decision like this. Overall probably the most incompetent refereeing performance I have ever witnessed

Edited by Spiderman (23 Oct 2021 7.12pm)

 

Painter Flag Croydon 23 Oct 21 7.12pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

right you little prick tell me were you want to meet so i can beat the f*** out of you how dare you mock my loss and family loss, your big behind a keyboard what you like in real life, and i dont give a f*** if im given a red card

Your not the one, who deserves a red card, its that horrible little coward. To mock someone for losing family menbers and friends is unforgivable.

 

sultan pepper Flag 23 Oct 21 7.13pm

Don't understand the criticism of Benteke. He had a good game. 1 goal, one hit the cross bar, one the upright, might have scored a stunner were it not for the foul by Guehi. Plus great link up play and defence work.....

 

Dan Theolmesdaleroad Flag Up north 23 Oct 21 7.24pm

Originally posted by peterg

True - and we had a number of big chances and near-misses. Tekkers hits the post early on and misses with a stupendous volley in the second half that would have one it for us. Edouard hit the bar and also should have scored when he was through on their keeper. On another day we would have nailed this. But it's hard to take after the Brighton and Arsenal matches.

Yes, and it sounded like Benteke played very well, which is a positive to take away from today. Had one goal and another disallowed, hit the woodwork twice, and did his bit defensively. He had at least one glorious chance to score though that he didn't take, and we're left thinking 'if only' once again. But as you say, on another day it would've been different, and hopefully it will be next time.

 

Texas Eagle Flag San Antonio, Texas (via Adelaide) 23 Oct 21 7.29pm

Originally posted by croydon proud

Or maybe get rid of Guehi, Benny would have scored two, winning us the game, and a goal of the month to boot!

You must be kidding. Guehi is the buy of the season imho. He's not the England U/21 captain for nothing. Sure he was guilty of the shirt tug but his performances this season have been excellent. If Tekkers had put that chance away (instead of wide !) when one on one with their keeper we wouldn't even be discussing this mute point. Mind you. Tekkers was unlucky to hit the woodwork twice too, well at least we have a threat in the air up front. I had hoped PV would bring on Wilf at HT, Olise shows promise but today wasn't his day unfortunately.

 


"Billy Gilbert really is God"

Oxford Don Flag North West of SP 23 Oct 21 7.32pm

Originally posted by beak

You must be a funeral director.:'( :'( :'(

That really is in poor taste. Get a grip or at least show some respect. This forum deserves better.

 


You can't change the way things are but you can change the way you are with the way things are.

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 23 Oct 21 7.34pm

Originally posted by beak

We were better of last season at this stage.

Sooo wrong and you know it ..so stop winding fellow fans up, you fully understand performance trumps absolutely everything.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 23 Oct 21 7.42pm

Originally posted by PalaceDevon

it really is time to get rid of Benteke
even though he scores the occassional goal he misses so many
we should have win this one 5-1 if only he could work out where the goal is !

Absolute joke. He was everywhere today. The one on the deck he should score, granted. The headers, he’s one of the only forwards that even gets to them for a start. Two cracking headed goals, amazing link up play.

A joke comment.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 23 Oct 21 7.44pm

Originally posted by sultan pepper

Don't understand the criticism of Benteke. He had a good game. 1 goal, one hit the cross bar, one the upright, might have scored a stunner were it not for the foul by Guehi. Plus great link up play and defence work.....

You’ll get used to it on here. People grab onto anything to suit their agenda.

 

PatrickA Flag London 23 Oct 21 7.51pm

There’s much to admire in our play, but can anybody seriously see us keeping too many clean sheets?
The amount of draws this season is not down just to bad luck, although it’s played a part.
If we can’t keep clean sheets we’ll need to score at least two goals to win games.
Ideally press the home the advantage which our play warrants and get two goals ahead.
I thought Benteke played quite well today but, aside from the missed chances, he partially negates the effectiveness of Edouard (possibly our most natural finisher) by displacing him in the central role.
We’ve dominated for long spells v Brighton, Arsenal and today but have 3 points to show for it.
In the cold light of day we should be aiming for 6 points from these fixtures.

 

The Dolphin Flag 23 Oct 21 8.04pm

Say what you want but goals win games.
We may be good to watch but 3 shots on target against a poor side is unacceptable.
We only have 8 points and will likely get nothing against City next weekend.
Another set piece goal against as well - very poor.
Lovely to watch but points make prizes!
We need to watch out!

 

The Dolphin Flag 23 Oct 21 8.07pm

We also have 2 points less than I expected us to have at this stage of the season looking at the fixtures.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 23 Oct 21 8.07pm

More gutted after that than any other game this season.

They were there for the taking, and whilst we went at our best we did enough to have won it.

Although he looked pretty dangerous, (I think) literally all our chances fell to Benteke. Not sure if its wasteful finishing of if he did well, most likely the latter.

I still don’t think Benteke works for us in this new system, just doesn’t move enough. But potentially another debate.

One thing that will be interesting to get thoughts on is Olise vs Ayew. Olise looked great in the 2nd half when we had our tails up, but didn’t do much in the first half. Potentially instructions given to him, but he didn’t move from the line and didn’t really get involved too much.

In recent games Ayew has been pretty involved in the press and holding the ball. Maybe he is more important that ppl give him credit for.

 

YT Flag Oxford 23 Oct 21 8.11pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Say what you want but goals win games.
We may be good to watch but 3 shots on target against a poor side is unacceptable.
We only have 8 points and will likely get nothing against City next weekend.
Another set piece goal against as well - very poor.
Lovely to watch but points make prizes!
We need to watch out!

Its better that that. We've got NINE points!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Charles Flag Forest Hill 23 Oct 21 8.22pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Pains me greatly to say this but we truly are this season's Brighton

Wouldn't mind being this season's Brighton next season

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Oct 21 8.26pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

We’ve had the hardest start on place position than anyone else in the League - fact..!!

There were posters on here at the start of the season given that start saying/predicting we would be in the bottom 3 come the end of October - we are not..!!

On top of that we are playing our best and most attractive and watchable football in our 8 consecutive years and counting in the Prem..!!

Look this is a new side, new Manager, new tactics ra, ra, ra..!! Was always going to take a while to bed in - from my point of view they have already exceeded my expectations and the best is yet to come - and will only get better..!!

Yes there’s been some disappointing results - but they were in games where we have been much the better team and as I said this an evolving team and will only get better..!!

As for Roy getting more points by this stage given our start - you’ve got to be kidding me..!!

If there’s one thing on here that gives me the ache - it’s this constant reference to nostalgia through rose coloured glasses - and this is a prime example of it..!!

IMO - If Roy was in charge we would be in the bottom 3 whilst also playing cr@p football and staring at a season of the same cr@p football whilst praying for survival..!!

Whereas now I look at it as we are moving in the right direction, don’t fear anyone and looking forward to the best out of this team - which is yet to come..!!

COYP

I agree with a lot of this, apart from ‘’ IMO - If Roy was in charge we would be in the bottom 3 whilst also playing cr@p football and staring at a season of the same cr@p football whilst praying for survival..!!’’ I’m not a Roy fan, but I think your opinion on points isn’t true. Because we’ve been very close to cracking it and PV has made great progress, some fans are frustrated, when really we should be relieved it’s going in the right direction but keep backing everything in the belief we’ll be on the right side of the current fine margins.

 


COYP

Plaistow Eagle Flag 23 Oct 21 8.27pm

Still

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Sooo wrong and you know it ..so stop winding fellow fans up, you fully understand performance trumps absolutely everything.

Suspect this is a poor attempt of a tongue in cheek remark from an ardent “Roy can do no wrong” supporter..!!

COYP

 

Page 9 of 15 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs Newcastle match thread