This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Crystal Palace vs. Liverpool Match Thread
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Eaglecoops CR3 23 Jan 22 4.31pm |
|
|
We don’t need a calm assessment of the game, we need a calm explanation of that refs performance.
|
Putitout Oxford 23 Jan 22 4.36pm |
|
|
We couldn’t moan about losing. They completely dominated us for half an hour. Gave away really poor first goal, and then contrived to miss two good chances before half time. Second half we should have taken more than one of our chances, and who knows, might even have won the game. The sickener is the pen, we were still in with a chance ,Liverpool, we’re on the back foot, and we had a definite chance to get a point. That is until the pen that wasn’t. We might have lost the game, but that pen that wasn’t got them off of any sort of hook they might have been on for the final eight minutes or so. Very worrying that any ref should see that as a pen let alone the two that gave it.
|
taylors lovechild 23 Jan 22 4.38pm |
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
A final point on this debacle. Why is it that the only three people on the planet who thought it was a penalty are Jota, Friend and the VAR to55er?
I just don’t get how a system designed to get rid of sh1te decisions has actually created more since its existence?
To be fair, I don't think even Jota thought it was a penalty. It must have brought back memories for Benteke and the days of cheating for Liverpool.
Klopp being rather insincere in post match interview saying "If VAR and the referee said it was a penalty then it must be". Vieira storming ahead to cut off Friend in the tunnel. Derry seemed to be pulling on the knuckle dusters.
|
silvertop Portishead 23 Jan 22 4.38pm |
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
It's all very well blaming the ref and VAR lads, but our play lost us that game.
We were too slow to get started and missed at least 3 fine opportunities. OK, so that was never a penalty.......but.
Sorry but bollox.
2 dodgy goals that never were. It doesn't matter that liverpool won the 1st half hour. We won the next hour.
But for that cnut Freind it could have been a draw or even win. Even the liverpool channel conceded we were unlucky.
|
adelaar Edgware 23 Jan 22 4.40pm |
|
|
I am utterly speechless at that refereeing performance. He ruined what was a good game with that 'penalty' (what a joke). Good second half performance, we gave them far too much respect in the first 45 mins. Maybe even deserved a draw by the end. Cheers Kevin you'll be getting your bonus from the PL board this weekend!
|
Eaglecoops CR3 23 Jan 22 4.42pm |
|
Originally posted by Putitout
We couldn’t moan about losing. They completely dominated us for half an hour. Gave away really poor first goal, and then contrived to miss two good chances before half time. Second half we should have taken more than one of our chances, and who knows, might even have won the game. The sickener is the pen, we were still in with a chance ,Liverpool, we’re on the back foot, and we had a definite chance to get a point. That is until the pen that wasn’t. We might have lost the game, but that pen that wasn’t got them off of any sort of hook they might have been on for the final eight minutes or so. Very worrying that any ref should see that as a pen let alone the two that gave it.
I don’t think there is any argument mate about how the match panned out. It was easy to understand what went wrong and we did spurn chances, but we were badly wronged by the ref today and there is no other way of describing that.
|
slubglurge welling 23 Jan 22 4.45pm |
|
|
To be fair to Friend he didnt award a pen but when they are called to the monitor they always change the decision
|
taylors lovechild 23 Jan 22 4.45pm |
|
Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer
It's all very well blaming the ref and VAR lads, but our play lost us that game.
We were too slow to get started and missed at least 3 fine opportunities. OK, so that was never a penalty.......but.
At half-time I'd have agreed, but by full-time I think we have every right to say the officials had a big hand in the loss. On one occasion Benteke is played through and is onside behind the defence, but the linesman calls it offside straight away rather than allowing play to go on. Prior to that Olise sustains a clear head/neck injury but Friend doesn't call a halt until Liverpool's attack breaks down. These are two of many incidents that got less attention but showed either Friend and his officials were poor, or biased. The penalty will get the headlines but everything went Liverpool's way today from handball decisions, to fouls, to bookings and to offside calls.
With regard to the penalty, you instantly saw the pressure lift once they scored it. Before that they were miscuing passes and panicking, so who is to say we wouldn't have equalised? The pen killed the game.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 23 Jan 22 4.47pm |
|
Originally posted by slubglurge
To be fair to Friend he didnt award a pen but when they are called to the monitor they always change the decision
We might as well have women reffing games, at least we know they don’t have any balls (sorry Becky).
|
peterg Anerley 23 Jan 22 4.54pm |
|
|
I've been reading the comments by Liverpool supporters about the match report in the Guardian. Almost all think the penalty decision was a joke. At the match I saw Friend trying to justify his decision to the Palace players afterwards. Their expression said: You're having a laugh. It was a shocking performance by Friend all round, capped by one of the worst penalty decisions I have ever seen. Who can think of one that was worse?
The right place at the right time
|
becky over the moon 23 Jan 22 5.05pm |
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
We might as well have women reffing games, at least we know they don’t have any balls (sorry Becky).
You can joke, but Sian Massey-Ellis is about the only referee's assistant that I've never seen a wrong offside decision from - such a shame they have never let her referee a PL match, as women do, very successfully in other countries.
A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers
|
KLEAGLE2 Shirley 23 Jan 22 5.07pm |
|
|
I'm also hugely disgusted with the Benteke 'offside' decision. Alot of very obvious offsides are not given straight away and yet Benteke was flagged straight away while well onside and found himself in great attacking position. Something ain't right.
At half-time I'd have agreed, but by full-time I think we have every right to say the officials had a big hand in the loss. On one occasion Benteke is played through and is onside behind the defence, but the linesman calls it offside straight away rather than allowing play to go on. Prior to that Olise sustains a clear head/neck injury but Friend doesn't call a halt until Liverpool's attack breaks down. These are two of many incidents that got less attention but showed either Friend and his officials were poor, or biased. The penalty will get the headlines but everything went Liverpool's way today from handball decisions, to fouls, to bookings and to offside calls.
With regard to the penalty, you instantly saw the pressure lift once they scored it. Before that they were miscuing passes and panicking, so who is to say we wouldn't have equalised? The pen killed the game.
|
BlueJay UK 23 Jan 22 5.14pm |
|
|
Showed glimmers late on but not really a game we expected to win anyway if we're honest
|
samprior Hamburg 23 Jan 22 5.16pm |
|
|
A very frustrating day.
We didn't start playing until 35th min and by that time we were somewhat fortunate to not be further behind.
Missing several clear cut chances certainly slowed our momentum.
However most frustrating is the two VAR instigated decisions. They explained for the Liverpool second goal that Firmino in an offside position did not impact the gk or players - how that can be when he challenges for the ball and causes Mitchell to be dragged out of position. Unbelievable. Then comes the penalty which I'm yet to see anyone agree with other than VAR and the ref. Absolutely ruined what would have been an entertaining last 10 mins of the game.
They say you need a bit of luck to beat the "big" teams... today we had none.
Positive displays from Olise, Schlupp and Mateta.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 23 Jan 22 5.17pm |
|
Originally posted by becky
You can joke, but Sian Massey-Ellis is about the only referee's assistant that I've never seen a wrong offside decision from - such a shame they have never let her referee a PL match, as women do, very successfully in other countries.
Not the message I was trying to send Becky as I’m more concerned about the lack of balls of Friend not sticking with his original decision, but I do take your point.
|
dynamicdick Dormansland 23 Jan 22 5.20pm |
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
We might as well have women reffing games, at least we know they don’t have any balls (sorry Becky).
Why should they change their minds as you say no balls nor VAR (Pawson). Scared stiff of upsetting Liverpool! Disgraceful.
Bring back Brolin
|
davenotamonkey 23 Jan 22 5.23pm |
|
|
Three:
(I'll concede the offside wasn't VAR)
|
Plumpton eagle East Sussex 23 Jan 22 5.23pm |
|
|
I think the Benteke dive for Liverpool against us was worse thuan today. But that referee didn’t have VAR and this one did. What has happened to clear and “obvious errors only” are the remit of VAR?
The so called explanation for the first Liverpool goal and the not offside decision was also poor. Firminho was interfering with play and attempted to play the ball in an offside position.
I really don’t understand how they (the on pitch and stockleyPark teams) are allowed to get away with this.
I don’t believe it is an FA backed pro big team conspiracy but then I didn’t realise beer, wine, party food and bring your own booze in the evening was a work event not a party.
Bin VAR I say. It is turning football into Strictly or Bake Off. Next there will be a countdown or a pause for dramatic effect before the final decision is announced.
VAR is becoming another way that the lesser teams can be controlled by the PL. Remember Harry Kane’s red card tackle the other week. Where was VAR then?
|
PatrickA London 23 Jan 22 5.24pm |
|
|
Our best spell in the game seemed to me to coincide with when we moved to a 442 with Olise wide right and Shlupp wide left (where he looks far more comfortable). We had more width and looked dangerous, attacking with pace and purpose. For some reason we changed this and put on Ayew wide left and moved Schlupp inside again. Vieira has said he wishes to play 433 and when all the players are available this can work. However, with the players currently available I think there is an argument that 442 or 451 being the way to go. It gives us more numbers in midfield, more width and provides more service to the striker(s).
|
davenotamonkey 23 Jan 22 5.25pm |
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Put a former footballer in the panel and they’d never give that as a penalty. These tw@ts haven’t looked at the intent and face of Jota once. Absolute joke, but they need the premier league to be tighter at the top so they make the penalty happen by making the ref make the wrong call.
Notice how he tries a little flick with his foot to lob VG, but misses it because the er... the... umm.. the ball has run away from him? Then he shifts direction.
Cheat, aided by what can only be corruption by this stage. I would forgive it if it were incompetence, but too many decisions in this game stacked against us.
|