You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread


Page 9 of 13 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 Sep 23 11.02pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

Just back from the game.

Yes Eze was poor today. Undoubtedly an exceptional player but was way off it today. Misplaced passes, caught in possession or tackled numerous times and another glaring one on one miss that should’ve put us two nil up and the game to bed.

He wasn’t the only one guilty of misplaced passes and in the first half we gifted the ball back to Villa when we were well placed, time and time again.

Joel was back to being turned inside out again and gifted them an absolute sitter on 18 mins that Johnstone did brilliantly to keep out.

Richards did well but we missed Guehi…similarly Hughes did well but we missed Lerma.

Schlupp ineffective going forward and also him, Ward and Mitchell could not work out how to close down their wide players with Cash & Digne given way too much time and space. If anything I thought Schlupp looked like he was knackered from only 30 mins in.

Mateta did ok and provided a great early cross for our goal but his first touch lets him down far too often for a Premier League player.

Ultimately we paid the price for not being 2-0 up - Eze the main culprit but Ward also missed a sitter when an Andersen knock back put it on a plate for him. Then in the 87th minute some poor defending from Mitchell let Jhon Duran cushion the ball on his chest and get a shot off unchallenged. Why do we switch off like that and concede so many late and costly goals?!

I haven’t seen the penalty / VAR decision yet but Im prepared for MOTD to p*ss me off even more when I do see it.

Back full circle to my opening remark and the point I was responding to made by by palace chick, yes Eze is a great player but he’s not beyond reproach, especially when he has such a poor and error-strewn match such as today.

Edited by Phil’s Barber (16 Sep 2023 10.21pm)

Comprehensive and from my recollection, an accurate account of the match.

There were a lot of subpar if not disastrous performances today which you may get away with occasionally but frequently will not.

We’ve a number of key players missing with a thin squad as it is, let alone our manager succumbing to bad health before kick off, but for my money it’s a very poor decision for the penalty which ultimately decided our fate.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 16 Sep 23 11.12pm

Oh it’s not a penalty, nowhere near.

Richards slides but doesn’t go through the player he’s alongside, ball side of him and hooks the ball back.

If that had gone for us I’d of course of been delighted but like to think I’d admit it. He blew immediately then took about 5 minutes to make his mind up. Bollox.

Stone me Lineker and co. agree.

Edited by Nicholas91 (16 Sep 2023 11.13pm)

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 16 Sep 23 11.15pm

How the hell has he stuck by that decision?!

You only need to watch the replay once to see that there is no foul and that Richards touches the ball twice and gets in a great challenge.

Absolutely shocking decision!

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 16 Sep 23 11.25pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Oh it’s not a penalty, nowhere near.

Richards slides but doesn’t go through the player he’s alongside, ball side of him and hooks the ball back.

If that had gone for us I’d of course of been delighted but like to think I’d admit it. He blew immediately then took about 5 minutes to make his mind up. Bollox.

Stone me Lineker and co. agree.

Edited by Nicholas91 (16 Sep 2023 11.13pm)

Yep, the fact that all 3 of them said straight away it wasn’t a pen tells you everything.

How Darren England can watch that back and still think it is a penalty is beyond me.

There’s a very obvious reason why the VAR recommended the referee go to the monitor and I’m amazed he didn’t overturn his on field decision.

We were robbed of a point there and Lineker, Shearer & Murphy clearly agree.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 17 Sep 23 1.21am

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

How the hell has he stuck by that decision?!

You only need to watch the replay once to see that there is no foul and that Richards touches the ball twice and gets in a great challenge.

Absolutely shocking decision!

Can only think he is trying to be the one who doesn't do what VAR tell him, wonker

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Teddy Eagle Flag 17 Sep 23 6.20am

Originally posted by Elpis


[Link]

I was wrong earlier when I said the rules had changed . That came from being informed as such (by another ref) when I mentioned it during another game .

Anyway

Whats going on here is that the refs and linos are not penalising encroachment ,leaving such decisions up to VAR .
VAR instruction (see link) says they dont penalise encroachment unless player becomes directly involved in play

That was Dermot Gallagher's explanation after the West Ham/Chelsea penalty when Soucek encroached - he said, "He has to stop an opponent having a shot at goal or being in a position to do that” . He then glossed over the fact that Soucek actually cleared the ball as incidental because there was no Chelsea player close enough to get to it.
Like with offside encroachment is now a subjective call on interfering with play.

 

YT Flag Oxford 17 Sep 23 7.51am

Yes it was a woeful penalty decision, however I expect we would have somehow contrived to let Villa grab a winner in some other way before the extra time was through.

The facts are that - yet again - we fail to put clear chances away and - in true Palace style - we have no idea about 'managing a game' when ahead i.e. niggly, rotation fouling, breaking up play and general disruption. You remember - what Arsenal managed to do to us with just 10 men against our 11.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 17 Sep 23 8.11am

the pen if the ref had just stuck with his decision after 1 min on var would say ok maybe wrong but didnt change his mind 20 times before sticking in 5th min ,
yes international break done us no favors expect get Olise closer to playing , to lose 3 key players only the bigger teams can cope with that , tell a lie only man city can cope ,
liked to have seen Joel switched with Richards as Richards has more pace and joel can play CH ,
we wasnt at the races only 6 shots says it all ,
these games happen so i wont read to much into it , next game we will be a different team with home support COYP

 

Zaha127 Flag 17 Sep 23 8.18am

On the plus side Edouard is doing well this season in 5 EPL games he has 4 goals. His highest was 6 goals and 3 assists in the 2021/22 EPL season.

This could be a season where he can easily score 15+ EPL goals at a minimum. With Franca and Olise still to return he will get a lot more opportunities to score. Credit to Mateta as well has done well off the bench.

Next 10 EPL games: Fulham, UTD, Forest, Newcastle, Spurs, Burnley , Everton , Luton, West Ham, Bournemouth

They do not look too bad UTD are struggling now lot of issues (Antony, Sancho etc probably the best time to play them). Newcastle are not having the same start as last season. Probably the hardest games here are West Ham and Spurs. In the next 10 games they should get over 15 pts at a minimum. Hopefully Olise and Franca return as soon as possible.

Edited by Zaha127 (17 Sep 2023 8.19am)

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 17 Sep 23 8.22am

Originally posted by YT

Yes it was a woeful penalty decision, however I expect we would have somehow contrived to let Villa grab a winner in some other way before the extra time was through.

The facts are that - yet again - we fail to put clear chances away and - in true Palace style - we have no idea about 'managing a game' when ahead i.e. niggly, rotation fouling, breaking up play and general disruption. You remember - what Arsenal managed to do to us with just 10 men against our 11.

In truth Arsenal also have far better players than us and a squad that can cope with players out injured. Our downfall yesterday was that we didn’t have a good enough squad to help when our players were knackered after 75 mins plus we didn’t get that killer second goal :-( We would most probably had got a deserved point if the ref had got his decision correct as well and then we would all be pleased. Terrible ref decision after having so long to get it right - Grrrrr!

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 17 Sep 23 8.36am

We really missed Roy. Some big calls were needed throughout the game. Roy’s skills were sorely missed.
It was glaringly clear how valuable Roy is to us.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 17 Sep 23 9.02am

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

Yep, the fact that all 3 of them said straight away it wasn’t a pen tells you everything.

How Darren England can watch that back and still think it is a penalty is beyond me.

There’s a very obvious reason why the VAR recommended the referee go to the monitor and I’m amazed he didn’t overturn his on field decision.

We were robbed of a point there and Lineker, Shearer & Murphy clearly agree.

England "VAR can I have a badge check please"

VAR "It's Palace"

England "thanks I will stick with my original decision."

 


One more point

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 17 Sep 23 9.24am

Clearly Richards first touch is on the ball, not the man (MOTD).

It takes a five minute stoppage for VAR not to see that.

Quite incredible, another VAR howler at Newcastle decided the game with Brentford.

It's a lottery, the game would be better off without it.


 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 17 Sep 23 9.27am

Originally posted by Badger11

England "VAR can I have a badge check please"

VAR "It's Palace"

England "thanks I will stick with my original decision."

England "VAR can I have a tw4t check please"

VAR "Yes,you are a tw4t"

England "thanks I will stick with my original decision."

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 17 Sep 23 9.30am

Originally posted by Sansbup

England "VAR can I have a tw4t check please"

VAR "Yes,you are a tw4t"

England "thanks I will stick with my original decision."

 


One more point

PatrickA Flag London 17 Sep 23 9.35am

I’ve been thinking could we have done things differently in the last 15 mins.
It’s always easier in hindsight of course.
We noticeably afforded Villa a bit more space in midfield as we appeared to tire so another body in midfield may have helped to block the spaces and prevent Villa picking passes.
The opposing argument of course is that attack is the best form of defence and we were causing Villa problems.
Eze and Ward both missed presentable chances to take the game away from Villa.
I’m never truly comfortable when Palace are only one ahead as we don’t keep many clean sheets.
Even v Wolves we allowed them to score a second, but fortunately had a 2 goal cushion and were able to see the game out.
In conclusion you probably just have to put it done to one of those games where we didn’t get the breaks in our favour.

 

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 17 Sep 23 9.42am

We are again done by doggy pen,gutted after the boys put in that kind of shift

Originally posted by steeleye20

Clearly Richards first touch is on the ball, not the man (MOTD).

It takes a five minute stoppage for VAR not to see that.

Quite incredible, another VAR howler at Newcastle decided the game with Brentford.

It's a lottery, the game would be better off without it.


 

eritheagle Flag Erith 17 Sep 23 9.44am

Originally posted by steeleye20

Clearly Richards first touch is on the ball, not the man (MOTD).

It takes a five minute stoppage for VAR not to see that.

Quite incredible, another VAR howler at Newcastle decided the game with Brentford.

It's a lottery, the game would be better off without it.


I agree to getting rid of VAR but weren’t both the penalties given on field (I know the assistant referee gave Newcastle’s) by the officials so would’ve been penalties anyway?

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Sep 23 10.14am

Woken up more angry about this, despite my rather athletic night in with the missus. Oh well, rugby today and then ten pints or so should do it.

Edited by ASCPFC (17 Sep 2023 10.14am)

 


Red and Blue Army!

YT Flag Oxford 17 Sep 23 10.18am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Woken up more angry about this, despite my rather athletic night in with the missus. Oh well, rugby today and then ten pints or so should do it.

Edited by ASCPFC (17 Sep 2023 10.14am)

Should do what? Make sure that the missus is safe tonight, I'd wager.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Page 9 of 13 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Aston Villa vs Crystal Palace - Match Thread