You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > CPFC v Brentford match thread
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

CPFC v Brentford match thread


Page 9 of 11 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 31 Dec 23 7.16am

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Really..!!

So you’re happy with the way we are playing, results, performances etc..

Despite the resources available..!!

All I can say is that you must be watching different games than me..!!

COYP

Yes with all the injurys robbed against pool thought hard against city a good header from wellbeck and chelsea game last min pen and 3 of them games we played with a high line , but no one has said who they would bring on , so i must be with alot of neutrals watching a different game to you COYP

 

Nubes Flag London 31 Dec 23 7.18am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider


Problem is that Roy is just plain out of touch. They get 5 sets of fresh legs and it immediately changes the whole balance. Credit to our guys for hanging in there. But this is why we get so many injuries. Needlessly overworked players

As simple as it sounds it is true. ‘Roy being out of touch.’ He isn’t programmed into using 4 or 5 subs and it is modern thinking/modern football.

We are constantly on the back foot after 70minutes because other teams make subs and it is actually a problem everyone complains about regarding Roy other seasons, however the newer rule of using 5 subs has highlighted we are constantly under pressure due to teams having fresh legs coupled with tactical changes (in some cases) and we are under pressure due to Roy not moving with the times related to managerial nuances.

Leaving your first 11 on for the duration of the game or for 80+ minutes is outdated - similar to playing 4-4-2.

 

The Dolphin Flag 31 Dec 23 8.25am

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Yep - that’s the problem - Roy’s game management is just so poor..!!

I’m delighted with the win but lets not kid ourselves here - against a very poor Brentford side - ravaged by injuries.

Yet somehow we made them look good in the last 20, when they were there to be put to the sword - why because Roy won’t use his subs - consequently we’re running out of legs..!!

Just typical Roy and that’s what’s been happening for weeks..!!

For me todays game and result just papers over the cracks - Roy is still so stubborn in that he will not make use of the potential that is available to him..!!

No doubt today would have saved his neck - but you can see from the last 20 - what there is to look forward to for the rest of the season - same old, same old - when the potential is there - just so frustrating.

Yes we’ll stay up but it will be totally uninspiring and painful to watch..!!

As I said at the start of the game - irrespective of the result I’d still replace Roy - but it won’t happen..!!

Parish quite happy he doesn’t have to spend any money - whilst all we’ve got to look forward to for the rest of the season is abject mediocrity..!!

COYP


This in a nutshell!

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 31 Dec 23 8.53am

I thought we played well, Eze was fitter making runs into the box, Olise was outstanding, Ayew and Mateta played well, i thought Richards did, and has played well at DM, fullbacks played well, i dont think Lerma is any better than average, and i thought Guehi was not quite on it, but 3 points, Roy will be here until the end of the season, IMO correctly, we need 2/3 players on loan to bolster the squad until the end of the season, then poach a decent manager, not the dross that is available, there is a reason why they are available

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 31 Dec 23 8.55am

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Yep - that’s the problem - Roy’s game management is just so poor..!!

I’m delighted with the win but lets not kid ourselves here - against a very poor Brentford side - ravaged by injuries.

Yet somehow we made them look good in the last 20, when they were there to be put to the sword - why because Roy won’t use his subs - consequently we’re running out of legs..!!

Just typical Roy and that’s what’s been happening for weeks..!!

For me todays game and result just papers over the cracks - Roy is still so stubborn in that he will not make use of the potential that is available to him..!!

No doubt today would have saved his neck - but you can see from the last 20 - what there is to look forward to for the rest of the season - same old, same old - when the potential is there - just so frustrating.

Yes we’ll stay up but it will be totally uninspiring and painful to watch..!!

As I said at the start of the game - irrespective of the result I’d still replace Roy - but it won’t happen..!!

Parish quite happy he doesn’t have to spend any money - whilst all we’ve got to look forward to for the rest of the season is abject mediocrity..!!

COYP

What money

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Dec 23 9.07am

A splendid victory and much needed.

I did predict a win, albeit 2-1 ! I just had a 'Feeling in my water' that we would emerge victorious against a Brentford team out of sorts, and my prognostication of victory probably shocked all and sundry on HOL !

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 31 Dec 23 9.40am

I agree with the comments on Mateta. He looks like he’s enjoying his football and linking well with Olise and Eze. Our other unsung hero in recent games has been Richards. Yesterday he looked like a defensive midfielder. He tackled strongly , won the ball for us on more than one occasion and could spot and make a decent pass. Definitely merits his place in the team.

Edited by Palacesince64 (31 Dec 2023 1.40pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 31 Dec 23 10.24am

Originally posted by Palacesince64

I agree with the comments on Mateta. He looks like he’s enjoying his football and linking well with Olise and Eze. Our other unsung hero in recent games has been Richards. Yesterday he looked like a defensive midfielder. He tackled strongly , won the ball for us on more than one occasion and could spit and make a decent pass. Definitely merits his place in the team.

Playing midfield is one of the hardest positions in football as any mistake is noticed so experience does matter.

Richards has been up and down with his performances because he is having to learn the job. I think that is why Roy is persevering with him as he can see game on game improvement.

 


One more point

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 31 Dec 23 10.31am

Considering his frame and career as a central defender, Richards is coming on in huge leaps and bounds. Yesterday was by far and away his best game in midfield and he is showing an ability to learn and develop. Incredible and very exciting because it's impossible to know where this growth will end.

It was far from perfect but it was hugely positive and frees up Lerma.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 31 Dec 23 10.34am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I’m chuckling to myself after our MoTD highlights. The commentator makes quite a song and dance in raving about Mateta’s ‘dummy’ for Eze’s goal. Now, I may be wrong, but I’m quite sure he tried to control the ball and it just ran under his foot. Grateful for any other thoughts here but was amusing for me in it seeming so bizarre and only of course, because we won today!

He 100% mis-controlled it, just look at the grimace on his face when the ball slid under his foot!

I was sat right behind it in the Lower Homesdale and you could even tell then that he had intended to control it but had missed it. It was pure luck that it found it’s way through to Eze.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Dec 23 10.37am

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

He 100% mis-controlled it, just look at the grimace on his face when the ball slid under his foot!

I was sat right behind it in the Lower Homesdale and you could even tell then that he had intended to control it but had missed it. It was pure luck that it found it’s way through to Eze.

My view entirely.

 

Martin 78 Flag Caterham 31 Dec 23 10.43am

Good all round performance and a much needed 3 points

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 31 Dec 23 10.56am

After the worst possible start, that was a well earned and deserved win. Let's hope it gives the players the boost in confidence they need.

I think it highlighted the difference between Palace and other teams in the lower half of the table. We have, in Eze and Olise, two players that can produce the extraordinary. If they stay fit, we will be fine.

Ebs actually had a very average game in my opinion. He's still not back to his pre injury best. He did well to anticipate JP's mis-control and took his chance well. Olise is developing into our most influential player.

I understand why Roy has deployed Richards at DM, and he is getting to grips with the role bit by bit, but he and Lerma are not a match made in heaven. If we are going to be active in January, then a midfield specialist is a must.

Olise will rightly have captured the headlines, but a word about Nat Clyne. Very sound again yesterday. As he has been since replacing Ward.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 31 Dec 23 11.02am

Originally posted by NEILLO

After the worst possible start, that was a well earned and deserved win. Let's hope it gives the players the boost in confidence they need.

I think it highlighted the difference between Palace and other teams in the lower half of the table. We have, in Eze and Olise, two players that can produce the extraordinary. If they stay fit, we will be fine.

Ebs actually had a very average game in my opinion. He's still not back to his pre injury best. He did well to anticipate JP's mis-control and took his chance well. Olise is developing into our most influential player.

I understand why Roy has deployed Richards at DM, and he is getting to grips with the role bit by bit, but he and Lerma are not a match made in heaven. If we are going to be active in January, then a midfield specialist is a must.

Olise will rightly have captured the headlines, but a word about Nat Clyne. Very sound again yesterday. As he has been since replacing Ward.

Apart from lettinh Potter get goal side in the first two minutes.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 31 Dec 23 11.04am

First, Olise is on a different planet, let alone different level to his teammates at the moment - thank the gods he agreed to sign a new deal as I don't think it would be unreasonable to say he was the difference between the two teams yesterday. Eze clearly is still well short of being match sharp, but if they can both stay fit it won't matter who's in charge we should not be anywhere near the relegation zone. After the game Thomas Frank even went up to Olise and clearly congratulated him for his performance he was so good.

I don't think the result tells us that much as Brentford were clearly being held together with sticky back plastic, but nonetheless as the cliché goes, you can only beat the team that is in front of you and we did. I still really hope that Roy can turn things around and go out on a high, but all yesterday really told me was that in Olise we have a new heir to Zaha's throne. The King is dead, long live the King!

Edited by taylors lovechild (31 Dec 2023 11.05am)

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 31 Dec 23 11.20am

Originally posted by cannoneagle

Lots of people on here talking about facts that Roy always makes late subs which doesnt ring true to me, so I've checked out the last 10 games and these ARE the facts about his subs.....
chelsea 79 / 90
brighton 59 / 70
man city 34 / 80 / 81 / 91
liverpool 45 / 68 / 84 / 95
bournemouth 29 / 69 / 69 / 86
west ham 82 / 87
luton 49 / 54 / 80 / 80
everton 67 / 83 / 89
burnley 58 / 70 / 70 / 86
tottenham 60 / 70 / 70 / 79

I dont think that qualifies as always makes late subs.


Only part of the facts as you haven't explained why the early subs took place, so here we go:

1. The 67th min sub against Everton saw Olise brought on for his long-awaited first game of the season after his June injury. Had he been fully match fit, he would have started the game.

2. The 2 early 2nd half subs in the Luton game arose out of injuries to Eze and Doucoure - nothing tactical about those 2 subs.

3. The 29th min sub against Bournemouth was another injury related necessity (Mitchell).

4. The HT sub against Liverpool was yet another injury forced one (Edouard).

5. The 34th min sub at the Etihad was another injury forced one (Ward)

6. The 59th min sub against Brighton (Hughes) was the only earliish tactical one as I recall as Hughes was in danger of getting a 2nd yellow.

Take those out of the equation and the complaint about Hodgson leaving his subs till too late has merit. Interestingly, in his post-match presser yesterday, Hodgson said how often Palace struggle to hold on to leads in the last part of games. Hasn't he cottoned on to the fact that players getting tired in the final 20 minutes tend to make mistakes (Eze v Chelsea). Brentford got a second wind with their 5 subs on (think fresh legs for half the outfield positions) and had they taken the chances they should have done, we would have only drawn that game. During that spell when they pegged us back it was crystal clear that we needed fresh legs BUT Hodgson refused to budge until the 86th minute.

Until Hodgson starts to make earlier subs and tactical ones to counter the opposition manager's, we will continue to concede goals in the last 10-15 minutes of matches IMO.

Finally, as someone who sits in the Glaziers section of the main stand, I'm fed up of seeing the opposition players scoring those late goals to win or draw matches.

Edited by doombear (31 Dec 2023 11.22am)

Edited by doombear (31 Dec 2023 11.23am)

 

Den1923 Flag 31 Dec 23 11.33am

This was a game we had to win and Roy and the team got the job done. As for timing of subs and team selection Roy has the C/V that as he rightly says qualifies him more than most to do this job. I personally feel for him because he has stuck with us doing a very difficult job over the years, even coming out of retirement when Parish could not find anyone to take the job. In the past others have walked away, probably because they were probably not prepared to put their own reputation on the line trying to keep us in this league with little support from the club in terms of team investment. Roy should therefore be applauded for his great achievement. The fact that he now has limited options each week in terms of team selection is not his fault that i'm afraid lies squarely with Parish and his fellow investors who have failed to provide the necessary funds for team strengthening to keep up to speed with other similar teams in this league. AS the old year ends and new one begins I would like say a big thank you to Roy and Ray for the job they are doing and wish them, the team, the club and all of you a very healthy happy and succesful new year...onwards and upwards!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 31 Dec 23 11.35am

Originally posted by doombear


Only part of the facts as you haven't explained why the early subs took place, so here we go:

1. The 67th min sub against Everton saw Olise brought on for his long-awaited first game of the season after his June injury. Had he been fully match fit, he would have started the game.

2. The 2 early 2nd half subs in the Luton game arose out of injuries to Eze and Doucoure - nothing tactical about those 2 subs.

3. The 29th min sub against Bournemouth was another injury related necessity (Mitchell).

4. The HT sub against Liverpool was yet another injury forced one (Edouard).

5. The 34th min sub at the Etihad was another injury forced one (Ward)

6. The 59th min sub against Brighton (Hughes) was the only earliish tactical one as I recall as Hughes was in danger of getting a 2nd yellow.

Take those out of the equation and the complaint about Hodgson leaving his subs till too late has merit. Interestingly, in his post-match presser yesterday, Hodgson said how often Palace struggle to hold on to leads in the last part of games. Hasn't he cottoned on to the fact that players getting tired in the final 20 minutes tend to make mistakes (Eze v Chelsea). Brentford got a second wind with their 5 subs on (think fresh legs for half the outfield positions) and had they taken the chances they should have done, we would have only drawn that game. During that spell when they pegged us back it was crystal clear that we needed fresh legs BUT Hodgson refused to budge until the 86th minute.

Until Hodgson starts to make earlier subs and tactical ones to counter the opposition manager's, we will continue to concede goals in the last 10-15 minutes of matches IMO.

Finally, as someone who sits in the Glaziers section of the main stand, I'm fed up of seeing the opposition players scoring those late goals to win or draw matches.

Edited by doombear (31 Dec 2023 11.22am)

Edited by doombear (31 Dec 2023 11.23am)

An excellent post that logically appraises the situation with irrefutable data, most welcome. I tire of all those defending Hodgson when it comes to substitutions and lack of game time for those youngsters who should be getting a run out, particularly replacing tired looking players and when 2 goals to the good with 20 minutes remaining.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (31 Dec 2023 11.36am)

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 31 Dec 23 11.38am

Great and much needed result. Olise's finish for the 1st and his against Chelski shows what a great talent he is. He's definitely destined for bigger things. Mateta is growing into his role up front with another supposed solid display, although it wasn't a dummy. Looks like Richards had another solid game in midfield. Still didn't understand why we supposedly went deeper by about 10-20 yards when 3-1 up and invited pressure, making a nervy finish. Luckily we held on and can take some heart from this performance.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Dec 23 11.41am

Originally posted by Den1923

This was a game we had to win and Roy and the team got the job done. As for timing of subs and team selection Roy has the C/V that as he rightly says qualifies him more than most to do this job. I personally feel for him because he has stuck with us doing a very difficult job over the years, even coming out of retirement when Parish could not find anyone to take the job. In the past others have walked away, probably because they were probably not prepared to put their own reputation on the line trying to keep us in this league with little support from the club in terms of team investment. Roy should therefore be applauded for his great achievement. The fact that he now has limited options each week in terms of team selection is not his fault that i'm afraid lies squarely with Parish and his fellow investors who have failed to provide the necessary funds for team strengthening to keep up to speed with other similar teams in this league. AS the old year ends and new one begins I would like say a big thank you to Roy and Ray for the job they are doing and wish them, the team, the club and all of you a very healthy happy and succesful new year...onwards and upwards!

I wholeheartedly echo these sentiments.

 

Page 9 of 11 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > CPFC v Brentford match thread