You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need to talk about Michael....
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We need to talk about Michael....


Page 9 of 10 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 08 Jan 24 12.10pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Hope so, what we all want is Olise fit and flying ASAP, but, i think not to loan a winger with Ayew away and a question mark over Olises´s fitness is a terrible mistake

Agree.

We lost Zaha, have lost Doucoure to AfCON and now Olise's fitness is a serious doubt.

I'm not holding out hope for one incoming player let alone more however surely this has to be a priority? Our plan to scrape through this season at least is looking an increasingly precarious one.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 08 Jan 24 12.12pm

Can't remember the last time we made an impactful January signing before ~25th January. Always surprises me how long the January window takes to get going.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 08 Jan 24 12.17pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

Can't remember the last time we made an impactful January signing before ~25th January. Always surprises me how long the January window takes to get going.

It takes a while to scrape together all the loose coins around Selhurst for out transfer kitty

 


La la la your mum

palace99 Flag New Mills 08 Jan 24 1.02pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

Poor against Newcastle though wasn't he. Has a fair bit of potential going forwards, albeit nothing that troubled Trippier, and defensively he looked lost.

Worrying that he's older than Olise given how far Clarke currently is behind him. I don't think he's anywhere near being good enough to be a key attacking player for us.

Olise did all those numbers before he turned 20. Clarke didn't make his Sunderland debut until he was 21.

He may get a Premier League career but I'd be surprised if it's anywhere near the top half unless a good coach gets a really good grip of him soon. Needs to leave Sunderland ASAP to have that happen.

Spot in. I like Clarke, but Sat's game showed the difference between the Champ and the Prem.
Didn't have a great impact and defensively he was woeful.
Comparing a then 22 year old Clarke vs Olise at 18 /19 in a weaker team too is a little unfair.

I think he could be a decent signing but only at the right price - nearer £10m for me and not the £20m they'd want for him.

Maybe one for next summer?

Edited by palace99 (08 Jan 2024 1.03pm)

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 08 Jan 24 1.23pm

Originally posted by palace99

Spot in. I like Clarke, but Sat's game showed the difference between the Champ and the Prem.
Didn't have a great impact and defensively he was woeful.
Comparing a then 22 year old Clarke vs Olise at 18 /19 in a weaker team too is a little unfair.

I think he could be a decent signing but only at the right price - nearer £10m for me and not the £20m they'd want for him.

Maybe one for next summer?

Edited by palace99 (08 Jan 2024 1.03pm)

100% agree. Clarke has shown over the last 2 seasons that he can perform at that level and is worthy of a chance in the Prem.

But has to be closer to 10m as you said


 

Teddy Eagle Flag 08 Jan 24 1.25pm

Originally posted by palace99

Spot in. I like Clarke, but Sat's game showed the difference between the Champ and the Prem.
Didn't have a great impact and defensively he was woeful.
Comparing a then 22 year old Clarke vs Olise at 18 /19 in a weaker team too is a little unfair.

I think he could be a decent signing but only at the right price - nearer £10m for me and not the £20m they'd want for him.

Maybe one for next summer?

Edited by palace99 (08 Jan 2024 1.03pm)

From a simplistic point of view if any of the money clubs thought he was a viable alternative for Olise they'd buy him and save £50m while they're the focus of FFP scrutiny.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 08 Jan 24 2.56pm

The problem is we will never be able to but a ready made mid twenties established premier league player, cant afford it, Clarke would cost 25m already, and i dont think he is worth that, the two most likely players to leave in the Summer are Olise and one of the center backs, Ronnie Edwards and Morgan Whittaker should be purchased in this window for about 20m for the pair knowing you are getting 100m+ in six months

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

dreamwaverider Flag London 08 Jan 24 4.45pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Michael Olise Thigh Injury Jan 03: 'We have to nurse him through and hope he comes back as quickly as possible. The next question will be how long is he out, but I can't answer that one. We're [b]hoping this one won't be as bad as the one that put him out for six months.' No Return Date Currently Being Assessed Ruled Out

Hmmm, this dose not fill me with confidence.

Im sure Olise will be receiving maximum specialist attention and rehabilitation for his injury. But based on the original tear and immediate surgery, depending on the severity of the injury the normal full rehabilitation is 3-6 months for an athlete. This obviously depends on many factors (severity of tear, success of surgery, natural healing abilities etc etc). To return too quick and suffer another tear or strain to the same hamstring is not good news obviously. I doubt anyone will put a time frame on it, but just the fact it has re occurred in the same hamstring, I am guessing they are measuring full recovery in months not weeks.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 08 Jan 24 4.50pm

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

The problem is we will never be able to but a ready made mid twenties established premier league player, cant afford it, Clarke would cost 25m already, and i dont think he is worth that, the two most likely players to leave in the Summer are Olise and one of the center backs, Ronnie Edwards and Morgan Whittaker should be purchased in this window for about 20m for the pair knowing you are getting 100m+ in six months

This would make sense... and for that reason I wouldn't expect it to happen.

 

Goalpost1 Flag Worcester Park 08 Jan 24 5.15pm

A bit like Toney at Brentford I think it would take some wild OTT offer to prise Olise away this month.

Can't see him going to Man U with AWB coming in part-exchange. Yes we need full backs but a player valued at £50m by Man U as makeweight? Terrible value for money for a club like ours.

I can see Olise going in the summer to a CL club who'd normally be in the running for winning it, he is that good. The fact he turned down Chelsea suggests he wants to go to a club in the running for the big trophies rather than a work in progress club like Chelsea or Man U who will pay big bucks.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 08 Jan 24 5.40pm

Originally posted by Goalpost1

A bit like Toney at Brentford I think it would take some wild OTT offer to prise Olise away this month.

Can't see him going to Man U with AWB coming in part-exchange. Yes we need full backs but a player valued at £50m by Man U as makeweight? Terrible value for money for a club like ours.

I can see Olise going in the summer to a CL club who'd normally be in the running for winning it, he is that good. The fact he turned down Chelsea suggests he wants to go to a club in the running for the big trophies rather than a work in progress club like Chelsea or Man U who will pay big bucks.

We WILL get 'big bucks' as you put it in this window. His release clause according to several click-bait sites, does not come into force until July 1st.

AWB cost Manure £50m, so that's how they value him for us, so they don't have to fork our shed loads on a player who will dissappear into their ether. I, personally believe Olise will be here next season. He's got a shrewd head on his shoulders.

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

EddieMac Flag 08 Jan 24 8.59pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Im sure Olise will be receiving maximum specialist attention and rehabilitation for his injury. But based on the original tear and immediate surgery, depending on the severity of the injury the normal full rehabilitation is 3-6 months for an athlete. This obviously depends on many factors (severity of tear, success of surgery, natural healing abilities etc etc). To return too quick and suffer another tear or strain to the same hamstring is not good news obviously. I doubt anyone will put a time frame on it, but just the fact it has re occurred in the same hamstring, I am guessing they are measuring full recovery in months not weeks.

As far as I am aware it is the same hamstring but in a different place so not as severe as last injury.

 

woody6013 Flag Bundaberg Queensland 08 Jan 24 9.35pm

Here we go again, sell a major asset and we will not benefit as most of the money will fill the pockets of Parish etc. A Palace fan for 65 years (and I wonder why?) we continue to bow down to the big 6 type clubs and let them walk all over lesser teams when a superstar comes along. I feel so depressed that with having a really effective Academy, we are just breeding players who wont remain at Palace, due to the the greed that is the Premier League. Weve only just started to enjoy Michael's talent, and struggling to stay in the PL this season, due to little backup as such.
I absolutely abhore the biggest clubs who plunder as they like and its just about the money. Shame on you Parish to let down the fans so you can pad out your pockets. Where is our NEW Stadium, in all this`Im just sick of it all!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

pax3908 Flag 08 Jan 24 10.16pm

Originally posted by woody6013

Here we go again, sell a major asset and we will not benefit as most of the money will fill the pockets of Parish etc. A Palace fan for 65 years (and I wonder why?) we continue to bow down to the big 6 type clubs and let them walk all over lesser teams when a superstar comes along. I feel so depressed that with having a really effective Academy, we are just breeding players who wont remain at Palace, due to the the greed that is the Premier League. Weve only just started to enjoy Michael's talent, and struggling to stay in the PL this season, due to little backup as such.
I absolutely abhore the biggest clubs who plunder as they like and its just about the money. Shame on you Parish to let down the fans so you can pad out your pockets. Where is our NEW Stadium, in all this`Im just sick of it all!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

With you on this one Woody,where the heck does all the money go!!!


 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 08 Jan 24 11.19pm

Originally posted by woody6013

Here we go again, sell a major asset and we will not benefit as most of the money will fill the pockets of Parish etc. A Palace fan for 65 years (and I wonder why?) we continue to bow down to the big 6 type clubs and let them walk all over lesser teams when a superstar comes along. I feel so depressed that with having a really effective Academy, we are just breeding players who wont remain at Palace, due to the the greed that is the Premier League. Weve only just started to enjoy Michael's talent, and struggling to stay in the PL this season, due to little backup as such.
I absolutely abhore the biggest clubs who plunder as they like and its just about the money. Shame on you Parish to let down the fans so you can pad out your pockets. Where is our NEW Stadium, in all this`Im just sick of it all!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Who said that we are selling a major asset ? Pure media speculation given that the transfer window is open and Olise’s garnered some headlines recently.

Where does the money go ? Well the last set of accounts showed Palace running at a loss of around £25m . Your suggestion that Parish benefits from selling players is totally ludicrous as well as being without foundation.

The top clubs do have things their way, that’s largely true. But you might want to recall that last summer Parish repelled a bid from Chelsea for Olise and indeed got him to sign a new contract. I suspect you have chosen to ignore that.

If you had even a basic understanding of how football works you would understand that if the Academy is truly successful then it is a means of generating income . If we can develop an Eze or Olise ourselves and sell them on for significant fees that go towards the bottom line then Palace become more financially sustainable.

As for the “ new stadium “ which is actually a new stand, it’s clearly been a more difficult job than anticipated. Building in a residential area presents many challenges.

The Premier League isn’t difficult to fall out of love with. It’s far from a level playing field financially. In the circumstances Palace have done well to stay in it for as long as they have .

 


Old, Ungifted and White

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 09 Jan 24 1.20am

Originally posted by woody6013

Here we go again, sell a major asset and we will not benefit as most of the money will fill the pockets of Parish etc. A Palace fan for 65 years (and I wonder why?) we continue to bow down to the big 6 type clubs and let them walk all over lesser teams when a superstar comes along. I feel so depressed that with having a really effective Academy, we are just breeding players who wont remain at Palace, due to the the greed that is the Premier League. Weve only just started to enjoy Michael's talent, and struggling to stay in the PL this season, due to little backup as such.
I absolutely abhore the biggest clubs who plunder as they like and its just about the money. Shame on you Parish to let down the fans so you can pad out your pockets. Where is our NEW Stadium, in all this`Im just sick of it all!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I'm sure the Reading fans had similar feelings when we bought him.

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 09 Jan 24 3.33am

Originally posted by pax3908

With you on this one Woody,where the heck does all the money go!!!


Players salaries, running costs, ground maintenance, policing bill, utilities, loan repayments, etc

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

dreamwaverider Flag London 09 Jan 24 7.42am

Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad

Players salaries, running costs, ground maintenance, policing bill, utilities, loan repayments, etc

Not forgetting ammortised transfer payments. Most transfer fees are paid over 5 years. Helps with cashflow and FFP.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 09 Jan 24 7.43am

Originally posted by antipodeagle

I'm sure the Reading fans had similar feelings when we bought him.

Although they dont need a new stand.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 09 Jan 24 3.24pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

Who said that we are selling a major asset ? Pure media speculation given that the transfer window is open and Olise’s garnered some headlines recently.

Where does the money go ? Well the last set of accounts showed Palace running at a loss of around £25m . Your suggestion that Parish benefits from selling players is totally ludicrous as well as being without foundation.

The top clubs do have things their way, that’s largely true. But you might want to recall that last summer Parish repelled a bid from Chelsea for Olise and indeed got him to sign a new contract. I suspect you have chosen to ignore that.

If you had even a basic understanding of how football works you would understand that if the Academy is truly successful then it is a means of generating income . If we can develop an Eze or Olise ourselves and sell them on for significant fees that go towards the bottom line then Palace become more financially sustainable.

As for the “ new stadium “ which is actually a new stand, it’s clearly been a more difficult job than anticipated. Building in a residential area presents many challenges.

The Premier League isn’t difficult to fall out of love with. It’s far from a level playing field financially. In the circumstances Palace have done well to stay in it for as long as they have .

You just find it impossible to post without slagging off a poster personally whether it’s a gentle dig or a full out attack. It’s little wonder posters call you out. For someone who had a go at me for being a know it all, you do a fantastic job of it yourself.

You could have written that post very differently but you chose not to. Too many posters like that on here.

 

Page 9 of 10 < 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need to talk about Michael....