This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
A UN team has concluded that sexual violence, including rape and gang rape, was committed during the Hamas attacks in Israel on 7 October.
|
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Originally posted by HKOwen Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow The pentagon have today confirmed a number of 25,000 dead Palestinian women and children since October, and that’s not including civilian men, nor all of the victims still buried under rubble. All of that fake grandstanding around the source of the numbers is the latest weak excuse to fall away. 25,000 women and children - how can it be anything but a genocide? What is your definition of Palestine? Clearly too difficult a question ======= Anybody there? It's very odd behaviour sending multiple chasers on a football message board - no one owes you a response. It's particularly weird from a poster who themselves is incapable of engaging with full posts, and seems to only have the capacity to pick out one-liners. As I said in my last post on this thread: "You'll note when there is a particularly horrific atrocity such as with the aid trucks yesterday, there is a load of diversion on definitions and sources and all sorts of other semantics, none of which should have any difference on someone's willingness to condemn such actions." Very strange bloke.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
I think we agree really, these things always occur in wars. I would point out that allied bombing killed many more than the Blitz did. Also, did the USA really need to drop a second atom bomb? Israel’s aim is to as completely as possible wipe out Hamas, as the US did to ISIS. There are of course many civilian casualties and Israel should do all it can to minimise them. Of course there will be future terrorist attacks on Israel and on the West. That would happen anyway regardless of what Israel is doing. It would happen even if Israel was utterly destroyed and all the Jews there killed, as the Islamists want – having done that they would want to concentrate on attacking the West. Islamism is our enemy and we should be fighting it not supporting it. Using WWII as a barometer for morality in war is just a ridiculous starting point - we all recognise it was abhorrent and most of the world have spent their time since doing what they can to avoid it ever happening again. The war against the Islamic State is a better comparable; In the 5+ years of the campaign, 8,317–13,190 civilians were killed by Coalition airstrikes in Iraq and Syria (per Airwars). The Coalition's own count was less than 1500 civilian casualties during the campaign. Given Israel's campaign has been running for less than 6 months, with a civilian death toll conservatively at double that of a 5-year campaign... do you see the issue? Go and read the coverage of the ISIS campaign and you will note that the Coalition forces (particularly the US) were heavily criticised throughout for what were considered as unacceptable levels of civilian dead - if they'd have conducted themselves as Israel has, I can't even imagine the fallout.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
It's very odd behaviour sending multiple chasers on a football message board - no one owes you a response. It's particularly weird from a poster who themselves is incapable of engaging with full posts, and seems to only have the capacity to pick out one-liners. As I said in my last post on this thread: "You'll note when there is a particularly horrific atrocity such as with the aid trucks yesterday, there is a load of diversion on definitions and sources and all sorts of other semantics, none of which should have any difference on someone's willingness to condemn such actions." Very strange bloke. So you keep don't have a definition of Palestine, fair enough.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Ask yourself, not worth engaging with you. Finally, we agree on something. Edited by silvertop (05 Mar 2024 5.03pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
A UN team has concluded that sexual violence, including rape and gang rape, was committed during the Hamas attacks in Israel on 7 October. That was never in any doubt as they filmed and posted it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by georgenorman
Do you think that the US needed to drop the second atomic bomb? Good question; probably not.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I recognise the problem with moralising over past wars where bomb targeting technology was different to now. However, I can't support attacking non military targets and we did that using plenty of loosely connected 'total war' justifications.....it's weak at any time but when the war is won....well...I'll just say it's not for me. As for Japan, the problem with the argument that we needed to drop a nuclear bomb on civilians to stop a war is that it's a level of barbarism I can't accept. Not well known and kept from most people is that Japan had put out feelers for a conditional surrender but Truman rejected it....it was unconditional or nothing for him. Once I heard that the justifications for dropping that bomb became very weak. Sure, you don't get the unconditional surrender but I don't buy the argument that you kill hundreds of thousands of people to get the kind of peace you want. A conditional surrender is all in the detail, there was no need to invade. If Japan had had the bomb we wouldn't have done it....It's a kind of evil and there should be a line beyond we shouldn't travel and I think that happened there. Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Mar 2024 2.35pm) Interested to know how valid that approach was, what authority the person who made that approach had and what conditions were proposed. There was a tentative suggestion from their Soviet ambassador that they use the USSR to broker some deal. However, he had no authority to progress this, the USSR were not remotely interested, and Tojo would never have even dared suggest the loss of face on conditions the Allies would have reasonably demanded from any surrender. I think this is a revisionist, anti-bomb motivated non fact. For my part, the loss of hundreds and thousands of lives is barbarism, but a drop beside the tens of millions lost in the Asian theatre, who would have perished had the war continued there, and who would have died in the securing by Stalin of a pan-European USSR.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
That was never in any doubt as they filmed and posted it. Well yes, but the real point is that even the anti-Israel UN has made it official.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Good question; probably not. Well Dresden didn’t stop Germany so the second bomb cemented the japs not wanting to carry on.
|
|
|
Hamas still don’t believe that rapes and gang rapes happened even through the anti Jew BBC are reporting that the anti Jew UN are saying it happened.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Interested to know how valid that approach was, what authority the person who made that approach had and what conditions were proposed. There was a tentative suggestion from their Soviet ambassador that they use the USSR to broker some deal. However, he had no authority to progress this, the USSR were not remotely interested, and Tojo would never have even dared suggest the loss of face on conditions the Allies would have reasonably demanded from any surrender. I think this is a revisionist, anti-bomb motivated non fact. For my part, the loss of hundreds and thousands of lives is barbarism, but a drop beside the tens of millions lost in the Asian theatre, who would have perished had the war continued there, and who would have died in the securing by Stalin of a pan-European USSR. Japan had been beaten back to its islands. Personally I don't question the obvious truth that they wanted to know what conditions would entail. The idea that this has to be announced officially is surely unrealistic. America had the cards at this stage. It could have chosen several other courses of action other than dropping the bomb or invasion. It could have blockaded Japan and continued strategic bombing. It could have taken a Japanese delegation to observe a testing of the atomic bomb and thus given its leadership fair warning of the consequences of refusing terms. Personally I view that Truman would accept nothing but the unconditional surrender requirement and was prepared to level Japan to get it. Purely upon humanitarian grounds as a European....as was his genetic stock, I can't defend that deliberate killing of hundreds of thousands of civilians. As for Stalin....We should have let Hitler fight him on one front. Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Mar 2024 11.40pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Hamas still don’t believe that rapes and gang rapes happened even through the anti Jew BBC are reporting that the anti Jew UN are saying it happened. just because media outlets are saying it, doesn't mean it necessarily happened. The have no evidence. A bit like the Aid workers were involved.
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
just because media outlets are saying it, doesn't mean it necessarily happened. The have no evidence. A bit like the Aid workers were involved. Whereas you accept Hamas propaganda without question, of course.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Hamas still don’t believe that rapes and gang rapes happened even through the anti Jew BBC are reporting that the anti Jew UN are saying it happened. Rather a lot of Jews work for or with the BBC. I assume you are referring to all those at the BBC who are not Jewish? Edited by silvertop (06 Mar 2024 9.25am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Japan had been beaten back to its islands. Personally I don't question the obvious truth that they wanted to know what conditions would entail. The idea that this has to be announced officially is surely unrealistic. America had the cards at this stage. It could have chosen several other courses of action other than dropping the bomb or invasion. It could have blockaded Japan and continued strategic bombing. It could have taken a Japanese delegation to observe a testing of the atomic bomb and thus given its leadership fair warning of the consequences of refusing terms. Personally I view that Truman would accept nothing but the unconditional surrender requirement and was prepared to level Japan to get it. Purely upon humanitarian grounds as a European....as was his genetic stock, I can't defend that deliberate killing of hundreds of thousands of civilians. As for Stalin....We should have let Hitler fight him on one front. Edited by Stirlingsays (05 Mar 2024 11.40pm) But Japan had not been beaten. It was an ultra nationalist state and would have continued to fight on. When the ammo ran out, old men and boys would have attacked machine gun wielding GIs with broken garden fences, frying pans and anything else that came to hand. Meanwhile, the women would continue to leap off cliffs, bridges and tall buildings. The US would have lost about as many who died in the Bombs, but the number of combatants and noncombatants who would have perished in the slaughter of defending to the last man would have been in the millions. Hitler applied the same policy but that eventually unraveled; but only after millions more had died. Japan had a very different culture and would have obeyed their God/Emperor to the bitter end. That ended with the bomb. We agree on Stalin.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Hamas still don’t believe that rapes and gang rapes happened even through the anti Jew BBC are reporting that the anti Jew UN are saying it happened. Belief and denial are very different things. It's hard for them to deny something their own fighters filmed and posted. Given that, an odd reaction from them and one that is unlikely to serve their purpose.
|
|
|
Originally posted by The groover
Hamas are really f***ing their own people over. They invaded and murdered civilians in the first place. Then they took hostages. Now they wont release those hostage to end the war and allow the free flow of aid. The other problem is that they wont learn from this its a vicious circle. True, but I guess the Israeli government are f***ing their people over too. Would you want to be a normal Israeli now? Or even a Jew anywhere basically? They're now fair game for Islamic radicals and governments around the world will turn a blind eye. There are Israelis in my partner's family - one Zionist who lives near the settlements and the others are not happy at all and live abroad. They're disgusted with what's happening. But, in general, they all get tarred with the same brush.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
True, but I guess the Israeli government are f***ing their people over too. Would you want to be a normal Israeli now? Or even a Jew anywhere basically? They're now fair game for Islamic radicals and governments around the world will turn a blind eye. There are Israelis in my partner's family - one Zionist who lives near the settlements and the others are not happy at all and live abroad. They're disgusted with what's happening. But, in general, they all get tarred with the same brush. I used to work in an office where I was effectively the token Gentile. Many diaspora jews quite understandably see most news items as whether those events are good or bad for the Jews. From the initial and justifiable sympathy felt worldwide, including in the Islamic world, this has turned to very bad for the Jews.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.