You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilbs and Gayle
November 16 2026 1.24pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wilbs and Gayle


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
southport_eagle Flag Southport 21 Jan 14 11.48am

Watching Saturdays match against Stoke it seemed to me that Wilbs is exactly the sort of player that Dwight Gayle needs to play along side. Wilbs wins flick ons, has some classy little touches, holds the ball up well, pulls defenders away and he can give as good as her gets in a tussle. But unfortunately can't hit a barn door.

I think that he would make the yard or two of space that Gayle needs to get his shot in.

I wouldn't mind seeing how this would work against Wigan. Wigan still have a few useful defenders so it would be a thorough test of a possible partnership for the Prem.

 

Gyro1780 Flag Leatherhead, Surrey 21 Jan 14 11.51am

Nice idea for the cup match but you can't leave Chamakh out for the Premiership games. I'd prefer to see a Gayle/Chamakh partnership vs Hull.

 

cpj Flag Kent 21 Jan 14 11.54am

Quote Gyro1780 at 21 Jan 2014 11.51am

Nice idea for the cup match but you can't leave Chamakh out for the Premiership games. I'd prefer to see a Gayle/Chamakh partnership vs Hull.


Why? Not as if he does a great deal.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Jan 14 11.56am

Wilbs isn't good enough to be a primary player in a game, I like him, and he does a great job as a five or ten minute back up man to protect a lead and a more valued player.

But starting with him ahead of either Jerome or Chamakh would be insane.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Jan 14 11.57am

Quote cpj at 21 Jan 2014 11.54am

Quote Gyro1780 at 21 Jan 2014 11.51am

Nice idea for the cup match but you can't leave Chamakh out for the Premiership games. I'd prefer to see a Gayle/Chamakh partnership vs Hull.


Why? Not as if he does a great deal.

Clearly a different Chamakh than the one I've seen at Selhurst.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

ADW1988 Flag Bromley 21 Jan 14 12.38pm

Quote cpj at 21 Jan 2014 11.54am

Quote Gyro1780 at 21 Jan 2014 11.51am

Nice idea for the cup match but you can't leave Chamakh out for the Premiership games. I'd prefer to see a Gayle/Chamakh partnership vs Hull.


Why? Not as if he does a great deal.


Unbelievable!!!

Troll/cretin delete as appropriate

Edited by ADW1988 (21 Jan 2014 12.39pm)

 

sprites Flag Auckland 21 Jan 14 7.52pm

Cham can do everything wilbraham can do, just 10 times better.

 

beer man Flag Kent 21 Jan 14 8.00pm

Quote ADW1988 at 21 Jan 2014 12.38pm

Quote cpj at 21 Jan 2014 11.54am

Quote Gyro1780 at 21 Jan 2014 11.51am

Nice idea for the cup match but you can't leave Chamakh out for the Premiership games. I'd prefer to see a Gayle/Chamakh partnership vs Hull.


Why? Not as if he does a great deal.


Unbelievable!!!

Troll/cretin delete as appropriate

Edited by ADW1988 (21 Jan 2014 12.39pm)


Cretinous troll, I think

 

Mangopablo Flag south LONDON 21 Jan 14 9.24pm

I love Wilbraham and am very hopeful that Gayle will (one day) prove to be a useful finisher. However, despite some wonderful performances this season from the likes of Delaney, Gabbidon, Jedi and Jules, it is hugely apparent that Chamakh is the quality item in the whole squad and must start whenever fit (in the league). He and Ward may be the only two truly top drawer players...

 


"The course of true love never did run smooth"

thebob Flag Tatebayashi (from Croydon) 21 Jan 14 10.05pm

Why does everyone keep looking at players and not at a team? You can collect the best players in the country, put them in a team and end up with mediocrity. Look at the England team as an example.

Wilbs may not be the greatest striker, but that does not mean that he can't be a member of a great strike force. He plays a part, and the parts add up to more than they would individually.

 

Joeberto Flag Streatham Hill 21 Jan 14 10.23pm

Quote thebob at 21 Jan 2014 10.05pm

Why does everyone keep looking at players and not at a team? You can collect the best players in the country, put them in a team and end up with mediocrity. Look at the England team as an example.

Wilbs may not be the greatest striker, but that does not mean that he can't be a member of a great strike force. He plays a part, and the parts add up to more than they would individually.

No offence, I like the guy and think in the absence of any better options he can do a job of sorts.

But I think Wilbs would be prevented from being a "member of a great strike force" by the lack of his ability to strike.

 

antipodeagle Flag Wellington 22 Jan 14 4.50am

I think the argument is that he provides the "force" and someone else provides the "strike", kind of like Heskey and Owen.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Jan 14 4.36pm

Quote Joeberto at 21 Jan 2014 10.23pm

Quote thebob at 21 Jan 2014 10.05pm

Why does everyone keep looking at players and not at a team? You can collect the best players in the country, put them in a team and end up with mediocrity. Look at the England team as an example.

Wilbs may not be the greatest striker, but that does not mean that he can't be a member of a great strike force. He plays a part, and the parts add up to more than they would individually.

No offence, I like the guy and think in the absence of any better options he can do a job of sorts.

But I think Wilbs would be prevented from being a "member of a great strike force" by the lack of his ability to strike.

Aye, he couldn't strike in a union.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

shivie Flag East Sussex 22 Jan 14 4.46pm

I know January is a month where people get depressed but I didn't realise you also lost your marbles

Wilbraham is just not good enough for Prem or Championship move on

 

Hambo Flag Crawley 22 Jan 14 4.57pm

I understand the point but it only considers the attacking impact on the system and not the defensive. In my opinion Jerome already does lead the line really well, but without being a serious goal threat. Wilbraham does the same and is less of a goal threat.

What we need up front is someone who can lead the line and convert more chances than Jerome. Not sure Gayle will have the physical presence and workrate to do so - so bringing someone in seems the bestoption - which is easier said than done perhaps.

 


HOL Radio Lead Presenter and sampler of processed meats

HOL radio - Sunday nights [Link]
HOL Radio Twitter:


My Twitter:

southport_eagle Flag Southport 22 Jan 14 5.06pm

Quote Hambo at 22 Jan 2014 4.57pm

I understand the point but it only considers the attacking impact on the system and not the defensive. In my opinion Jerome already does lead the line really well, but without being a serious goal threat. Wilbraham does the same and is less of a goal threat.

What we need up front is someone who can lead the line and convert more chances than Jerome. Not sure Gayle will have the physical presence and workrate to do so - so bringing someone in seems the bestoption - which is easier said than done perhaps.

I am all in favour of getting a great new striker in. I am also keen to get Murray back in firing in the goals like last season. I do like the Jerome/Chamakh combination even though it is a bit light on goals.

I am only suggesting the Gayle/Wilbraham combination as another alternative with the players that we have. We will get injuries and suspensions and also need other options late in games.

 

Hambo Flag Crawley 22 Jan 14 5.32pm

Quote southport_eagle at 22 Jan 2014 5.06pm

Quote Hambo at 22 Jan 2014 4.57pm

I understand the point but it only considers the attacking impact on the system and not the defensive. In my opinion Jerome already does lead the line really well, but without being a serious goal threat. Wilbraham does the same and is less of a goal threat.

What we need up front is someone who can lead the line and convert more chances than Jerome. Not sure Gayle will have the physical presence and workrate to do so - so bringing someone in seems the bestoption - which is easier said than done perhaps.

I am all in favour of getting a great new striker in. I am also keen to get Murray back in firing in the goals like last season. I do like the Jerome/Chamakh combination even though it is a bit light on goals.

I am only suggesting the Gayle/Wilbraham combination as another alternative with the players that we have. We will get injuries and suspensions and also need other options late in games.


In the event we have to make changes then it's definitely an option that has its merits, I just feel that it would require a change of system. We've seen TP avoid that by picking midfielders in the role in behind the frontman so far (when Chamakh was out and when Jermome was out) , and I think that's all about maintainng the shape and discipline we have.

I guess what I am saying is although I would be interested to see what you suggest, as I would a couple of other combinations, I don't see it happening because I beleive the system we use will prevent it.

 


HOL Radio Lead Presenter and sampler of processed meats

HOL radio - Sunday nights [Link]
HOL Radio Twitter:


My Twitter:

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 24 Jan 14 9.39pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 21 Jan 2014 11.56am

Wilbs isn't good enough to be a primary player in a game, I like him, and he does a great job as a five or ten minute back up man to protect a lead and a more valued player.

But starting with him ahead of either Jerome or Chamakh would be insane.


I agree!. Wilbs is for us nothing more than a port in a storm when things really get rough. I think we have to try by all possible means to cultivate a Chammakh and Gayle partnership. Hopefully Gayle will learn and become a force to be reckoned with. This should eventually happen but of course the question is ,how long can we waite?

 

zappata Flag 24 Jan 14 10.58pm

Wilbraham is terrible.Why some palace fans seem to grow fond of mediocre triers is beyond me.

Gayle on the other hand has bags of potential,but he just isn't the sort of striker TP will start in this current system.Shame.

 

southport_eagle Flag Southport 26 Jan 14 3.50pm

This combination worked pretty well at toke yesterday. I was expecting Wilbs to flick on to Gayle but it was the other way around for the goal yesterday.

Gayle always looked dangerous running on to Wilbrahams flick-ons yesterday, Wilbraham being further forward than Chamakh had been also gave room to Puncheon and Bannan to come inside.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilbs and Gayle