This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Team of the 'Noughties'
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Eating the Burger Chichester 22 Jan 14 10.08am |
|
|
I'm writing a piece for my site about the Crystal Palace team of the 'noughties' and am interested to see who you guys think should make the team?
Any player to play for the club between the 2000/2001 season to the 2009/2010 season qualifies.
For everything Palace keep it here at Eating the Burger! [Link]
|
OscarTheGrouch Dartford 22 Jan 14 10.10am |
|
|
alan lee
|
daneagle Bromley 22 Jan 14 10.15am |
|
|
Aj Ashley cole Darren Ambrose Aki rhilati Damien Delaney Nathaniel Clyde Glenn Murray Julian Speroni Wilfred zaha
9 favourites there struggling on centre backs is where I struggle had good ones but who do you put in there
Why, for the love of god why!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
|
Part Time James 22 Jan 14 10.16am |
|
|
For me:
Speroni Granville Fonte Popovic Clyne Watson Hughes Riihilati Routledge Johnson Morrison
EDIT done now as I originally picked two players that either didn't join until after the period suggested, or didn't really play for us until after the period. Zaha was originally in my team, but having not really played much first team football in the timespan I have removed him.
Edited by Part Time James (22 Jan 2014 10.21am)
|
Eating the Burger Chichester 22 Jan 14 10.19am |
|
Quote daneagle at 22 Jan 2014 10.15am
Aj Ashley cole Darren Ambrose Aki rhilati Damien Delaney Nathaniel Clyde Glenn Murray Julian Speroni Wilfred zaha
9 favourites there struggling on centre backs is where I struggle had good ones but who do you put in there
Half of these guys didn't play for the club until the current decade, Murray, Zaha, Delaney, etc. I agree though thinking of a great centre half of that era is a struggle, Fan Zihy or Jose Fonte perhaps?
For everything Palace keep it here at Eating the Burger! [Link]
|
Eating the Burger Chichester 22 Jan 14 10.21am |
|
Quote Part Time James at 22 Jan 2014 10.16am
For me:
Speroni Granville Fonte Popovic Ward Watson Hughes Riihilati Zaha Johnson Morrison
I wanted Zaha in the mix but he didn't really fit in with the potential formation the other players would fall into in midfield/attack so before any smarty pants tells me I have duplicated any positions, I just sort of picked a keeper, four defenders, four midfielders and two strikers without consideration as to whether they'd play well as a unit. So there.
EDIT: I just noticed you said it only went up to the end of the noughties (the clue was in the title). I'll rethink this and stop being such a numpty!
Edited by Part Time James (22 Jan 2014 10.17am)
Yeah to be fair, I was thinking of a standard 4-4-2 as well for the article, although that would mean one of freedman/morrison would have to miss out
For everything Palace keep it here at Eating the Burger! [Link]
|
Part Time James 22 Jan 14 10.26am |
|
Quote daneagle at 22 Jan 2014 10.15am
Aj Ashley cole Darren Ambrose Aki rhilati Damien Delaney Nathaniel Clyde Glenn Murray Julian Speroni Wilfred zaha
9 favourites there struggling on centre backs is where I struggle had good ones but who do you put in there
I think Murray signed for us in 2011, Delaney in 2012 and Zaha only played 1 first team game in the time period. I did the exact same thing when I started answering the question though!
|
lil j-eagle little bookham 22 Jan 14 10.29am |
|
|
speroni
granville/cole hall fonte boyce/butterfield (clyne hit his peak after 2010 really)
routledge/moses watson riihilahti ambrose
Freedman Johnson
Messi, you're good, but you can't hit a ball like ambrose
|
Part Time James 22 Jan 14 10.29am |
|
Quote Eating the Burger at 22 Jan 2014 10.21am
Quote Part Time James at 22 Jan 2014 10.16am
For me:
Speroni Granville Fonte Popovic Ward Watson Hughes Riihilati Zaha Johnson Morrison
I wanted Zaha in the mix but he didn't really fit in with the potential formation the other players would fall into in midfield/attack so before any smarty pants tells me I have duplicated any positions, I just sort of picked a keeper, four defenders, four midfielders and two strikers without consideration as to whether they'd play well as a unit. So there.
EDIT: I just noticed you said it only went up to the end of the noughties (the clue was in the title). I'll rethink this and stop being such a numpty!
Edited by Part Time James (22 Jan 2014 10.17am)
Yeah to be fair, I was thinking of a standard 4-4-2 as well for the article, although that would mean one of freedman/morrison would have to miss out
I've revised it now so that it fits the time period better (removed Ward and Zaha who clearly didn't belong in my post). There are a couple of players in my selection I can't help thinking weren't the best in their position during the 'noughties' but I'm sure some statto will correct me either with some constructive criticism or a big facepalm!
|
antonycpfc London/Manchester 22 Jan 14 10.31am |
|
|
Speroni Boyce Hudson Popovic Granville Moses Mullins Rihilati Routledge AJ Freedman
|
Part Time James 22 Jan 14 10.33am |
|
Quote lil j-eagle at 22 Jan 2014 10.29am
speroni
granville/cole hall fonte boyce/butterfield (clyne hit his peak after 2010 really) routledge/moses watson riihilahti ambrose
Freedman Johnson
That's an interesting one, I never really even considered that.
I have also picked Speroni in goal but I'm wondering whether during the time period suggested Kiraly was a better keeper. No doubt I prefer Speroni now, but he's gradually got better over time and I can't remember where he was in his progression at the turn of the decade.
|
lil j-eagle little bookham 22 Jan 14 10.38am |
|
Quote Part Time James at 22 Jan 2014 10.33am
Quote lil j-eagle at 22 Jan 2014 10.29am
speroni
granville/cole hall fonte boyce/butterfield (clyne hit his peak after 2010 really) routledge/moses watson riihilahti ambrose
Freedman Johnson
That's an interesting one, I never really even considered that.
I have also picked Speroni in goal but I'm wondering whether during the time period suggested Kiraly was a better keeper. No doubt I prefer Speroni now, but he's gradually got better over time and I can't remember where he was in his progression at the turn of the decade.
his 3 POTY in a row were 2007/08-2009/10 i think, so for me he deserves to be in
Messi, you're good, but you can't hit a ball like ambrose
|
Eating the Burger Chichester 22 Jan 14 10.41am |
|
Quote Part Time James at 22 Jan 2014 10.33am
Quote lil j-eagle at 22 Jan 2014 10.29am
speroni
granville/cole hall fonte boyce/butterfield (clyne hit his peak after 2010 really) routledge/moses watson riihilahti ambrose
Freedman Johnson
That's an interesting one, I never really even considered that.
I have also picked Speroni in goal but I'm wondering whether during the time period suggested Kiraly was a better keeper. No doubt I prefer Speroni now, but he's gradually got better over time and I can't remember where he was in his progression at the turn of the decade.
I think Speroni actually played in the final three seasons of this decade as the first choice Keeper, including in the season that saw us stay up on the final day of the season. So he definitely merits his place in the side. Kiraly although was our first choice in the prem was nowhere near the standard of Jules.
For everything Palace keep it here at Eating the Burger! [Link]
|
Eating the Burger Chichester 22 Jan 14 10.44am |
|
|
Surprised nobody so far has mentioned Shaun Derry in the centre of midfield? Amassed close to 200 appearances over the decade and was integral in both the promotion winning team, and the 2010 last-day survival team.
For everything Palace keep it here at Eating the Burger! [Link]
|
daneagle Bromley 22 Jan 14 11.23am |
|
Quote Eating the Burger at 22 Jan 2014 10.19am
Quote daneagle at 22 Jan 2014 10.15am
Aj Ashley cole Darren Ambrose Aki rhilati Damien Delaney Nathaniel Clyde Glenn Murray Julian Speroni Wilfred zaha
9 favourites there struggling on centre backs is where I struggle had good ones but who do you put in there
Half of these guys didn't play for the club until the current decade, Murray, Zaha, Delaney, etc. I agree though thinking of a great centre half of that era is a struggle, Fan Zihy or Jose Fonte perhaps?
Absolutely correct should have read question better....took me 1min to put those together...apologies. Take Murray zaha and Delaney out. Reckon the others fall into the top 11 and fonte is a good shout.
Why, for the love of god why!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
|
Arthur Blackpudding 22 Jan 14 12.17pm |
|
Quote lil j-eagle at 22 Jan 2014 10.29am
speroni
granville/cole hall fonte boyce/butterfield (clyne hit his peak after 2010 really)
routledge/moses watson riihilahti ambrose
Freedman Johnson
Can't argue with that I'd chose Moses, Cole and Butterfield out of the choices.
|
Eating the Burger Chichester 22 Jan 14 1.05pm |
|
Quote Arthur Blackpudding at 22 Jan 2014 12.17pm
Quote lil j-eagle at 22 Jan 2014 10.29am
speroni
granville/cole hall fonte boyce/butterfield (clyne hit his peak after 2010 really)
routledge/moses watson riihilahti ambrose
Freedman Johnson
Can't argue with that I'd chose Moses, Cole and Butterfield out of the choices.
Granville did play well over 100 games for the club and was involved in the team that took us to the prem though? Cole only played a handful of games, as good as he was in those games, hard to select him in a team of the decade
For everything Palace keep it here at Eating the Burger! [Link]
|