You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > jules v henessey
November 16 2026 1.12pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

jules v henessey


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Suffolkcp Flag Bury st edmunds 04 Feb 14 6.46am

Jules says he is happy with his form , settled here and wants to stay. With tha and also having Price on our books seems to make spending 3 million on henessey a bit strange. The only reason i can see for signing henessey is that Jules won't be offered a new contract.
I hope this isn't the case and that he stays as our number 1
what do you guys think?

 

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 04 Feb 14 7.05am

I think the same, but it's what the boss thinks that matters, I doubt we would have spent £3m on an understudy, if indeed that amount was spent? A striker is what was needed in many peoples opinion, and that money should have gone there, but tony is the boss so we should find out in the next few weeks......could be interesting.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 04 Feb 14 7.28am

Jules is a legend,. that word gets banded about a lot but he deserves the title.

However Henessey was not bought for £3 million to sit on the bench, and as much as I love Jules, in the cold light of day he is an average premiership keeper and Hennessey has the physical tools to be a top keeper, plus he is highly rated by wolves fans I have spoken to.

I can see Jules leaving in the summer.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Username Flag Horsham 04 Feb 14 7.41am

Quote dannyh at 04 Feb 2014 7.28am

Jules is a legend,. that word gets banded about a lot but he deserves the title.

However Henessey was not bought for £3 million to sit on the bench, and as much as I love Jules, in the cold light of day he is an average premiership keeper and Hennessey has the physical tools to be a top keeper, plus he is highly rated by wolves fans I have spoken to.

I can see Jules leaving in the summer.

You could have just ended there. Pretty sure Dom Fifield confirmed it was between 1.5m-2m.


 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 04 Feb 14 8.22am

Just read his profile - he does get injured a lot so retaining Jules is a must.

Also - 'During the 2011–12 season, Hennessey was part of the Wolves defence that went a club record of 30 consecutive league games without a clean sheet. '

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


lankygit Flag Lincoln 04 Feb 14 8.40am

Quote Kermit8 at 04 Feb 2014 8.22am

Just read his profile - he does get injured a lot so retaining Jules is a must.

Also - 'During the 2011–12 season, Hennessey was part of the Wolves defence that went a club record of 30 consecutive league games without a clean sheet. '

To be fair though, they might have struggled to do much better that season if they had played two keepers.Didn`t they only win 4 or 5 games that year?

 


Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Feb 14 9.17am

Personally I think Jules is a better keeper and that Hennessey has been bought in as a number 2 and cover. Why change a successful keeper when your fighting a relegation battle. However, we cannot expect Speroni to have another season without a break or injury, and if we lost him, I doubt either of our reserve keepers would be up to the job.

3m, if it was that much, isn't a huge amount by Premier League standards, whats more significant is his wages.

Also having a decent back up will prove useful in terms of contract negotiations, and in keeping Jules focused on form (not that he's really ever not been good for us).

Dropping Jules for Hennesey would be a risk.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

palace99 Flag New Mills 04 Feb 14 9.43am

i really don't understand why we bought Hennessey and for the amount of money too.

Most of the transfers had logic e.g. centre back we are playing 2 over 30 year olds (who have been excellent) but Gabs is a little slow and not the tallest, and i assume Ledley was bought to take over the KG role. Similar Ince will provide us another option on the wing and is more of a goal threat.

But goalie?? If you said what other positions we are weak in well left back and centre forward would be my first choices.

Anyway, it's clear TP wants more competition and a taller option, that's fine.

Hennessey has not kicked a ball for wolves for over 2 years (i know he has been injured) and even though he has returned from a good loan spell he is still their no2. Also he will be on good money from his premier days. So i honestly though a small fee or even a free transfer would be more than enough to get wolves to release him.

Even if the £3m is with all add ons etc and the upfront payment is half that it's still a lot of money for a player who hasn't quite fulfilled his potential and is injury prone (remember Matt clarke from Bradford - another injury prone goalie we bought for 7 figures).

Then finally there's Jules. He is a fantastic servant for the club, not the most dominant at crosses, but what goalies are these days? I honestly do not think Hennessey is good enough to replace Jules this season.

Incidentally how much money are Palace playing on wage sto players who can't/don't play this season - Alexander, Garvan, Marange, Grandin, Wilbs - if each is on £5k a week that's well over 1m which seems a bit excessive to me.

 

7@burnley79 Flag Battersea 04 Feb 14 9.55am

I see it differently, Jules needed competition and now hes got it. We also needed substantial cover if Jules got injured for any reason. Imagine him out injured for 6 weeks. No disrespect to Price this isn't the championship. We need 2 quality keepers in the premiership. You cant play like we have to give us a chance on staying up and then throw it all away because you have no cover for your number 1 if he gets injured. The only way Jules wont be retained now is if we go down, because of the length of the Hennessey deal.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 04 Feb 14 10.03am

My concern is that if he is so good and what with Wolves having had a good two years in a downward spiral before getting better why on earth hasn't another club come in for him before now?

If Jules is dropped this Saturday it will be incredibly unfair and harsh.

Still TP isn't really playing our best midfielder Bannan and we are doing alright.

Just have to sit tight and hope everything works out.


 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Plane Flag Bromley 04 Feb 14 10.19am

Quote 7@burnley79 at 04 Feb 2014 9.55am

I see it differently, Jules needed competition and now hes got it. We also needed substantial cover if Jules got injured for any reason. Imagine him out injured for 6 weeks. No disrespect to Price this isn't the championship. We need 2 quality keepers in the premiership. You cant play like we have to give us a chance on staying up and then throw it all away because you have no cover for your number 1 if he gets injured. The only way Jules wont be retained now is if we go down, because of the length of the Hennessey deal.

Agree with this, as I've said before, slowly slowly

 

Eagles-Mad Flag Romford Essex 04 Feb 14 11.39am

Begovic Sorensen Butland I trust Pulises judgement on keepers.

 

Suffolkcp Flag Bury st edmunds 04 Feb 14 12.21pm

Quote Eagles-Mad at 04 Feb 2014 11.39am

Begovic Sorensen Butland I trust Pulises judgement on keepers.


Good point

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Feb 14 12.26pm

Quote Eagles-Mad at 04 Feb 2014 11.39am

Begovic Sorensen Butland I trust Pulises judgement on keepers.

He also signed Carlo Nash from Everton !


 

Hansy Flag 04 Feb 14 12.35pm

Jules is 34, and will soon start to fade. You don't get many keepers like friedel who can keep going until they are 40.

WH is 27 so I will see him as a future replacement for Jules.

Funds rising £3m is a good investment for a keeper who will be starting next season or the season after.

 

Panda_Ranger07 Flag Haywards Heath 04 Feb 14 12.46pm

Were not sure what has been said behind the scenes perhaps (especially with him opening a restaurant in Purley) Jules is planning retirement in the not too distant future and giving Pulis the heads up.

 

burtmacp Flag 04 Feb 14 2.05pm

We need strikers!
We are the lowest in PL.
GK and defense?
We are 11th.
And if you take out the few first matches with Ian H. as coach...
Our defense would be top 4!!!!
Alexander/Price were good enough.
Jules is a real legend for Palace. And for me, he has 4 to 5 more years at this level. His experience is another plus.
We need goals!!!
We could have been top 10 or about in PL if we would have converted so many chances.
Pulis is from Whales, right?
Is Henn too?
Alexander has a decent record.
Price has been supportive.
Henn? Injuries and loosing record.
I don't get it.
I hope Murray plays soon and puts it in. Otherwise those 3M were errantly spent.
Go Palace!

 

EagleRider Flag Seasalter, Kent 04 Feb 14 2.40pm

Jääskeläinen made it to 38 before he started to lose his form, but man did it go fast this season!

Maybe Pulis is looking for an insurance 2nd keeper, or maybe Speroni's going to be offered big money to stay up with a PL bottom feeder if we go down. The point is, it's all maybes and speculation, isn't it?

 

MPE Flag Maidstone 04 Feb 14 3.03pm

Speroni is number 1,and as it stands deserves that, if he got a straight red, and was out for 3 games, would anyone really be happy with Price stepping in? that is the reason Hennesey has been bought, and in time will push Speroni for the number 1 spot, and that may be as near as next season, or if he impressed may even keep speroni out of the team.

I love Speroni and want him to carry on being the number 1, but now being in the prem you need like for like to step in, and Hennesey and Alexandar dont fit that bill.

Edited by MPE (04 Feb 2014 3.03pm)

 


Just when I thought that I was out...........they pull me back in

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 04 Feb 14 5.45pm

Quote collier row eagle at 04 Feb 2014 7.05am

I think the same, but it's what the boss thinks that matters, I doubt we would have spent £3m on an understudy, if indeed that amount was spent? A striker is what was needed in many peoples opinion, and that money should have gone there, but tony is the boss so we should find out in the next few weeks......could be interesting.

Well as an ardent Palace fan for nearly seventy years I feel the boss might have at least explained to us what he has in mind. I do not say he has to explain to us but in all fairness , the fans do spend a lot of money supporting Palace and we do fill the ground so I think it makes for a much more pleasant relationship with the Club if fans know what the thinking is at both Board level and Managerial level .I for one cannot understand why at this stage we are buying a keeper when we already have a decent one and when when we cannot hit a cow in the arse with a banjo in front of goal. If Pulis does not have confidence in Price and Alexander I can understand why he would want a back up for Speroni but not for 3million quid if that is what we really spent.In my seventy years at Selhurst I have often been perplexed by what happens and what does not happen and for the most part I have lived in total disbelief and wild speculation. There has never ever been a dull moment at Selhurst and those who have suffered most through the many ups and downs have been the fans.
I have stayed faithful to The Palace because I was born and bred next door and my Dad would have been a Palace player if his Mum had agreed when he was a teenager so I'm not sure I could easily move on.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > jules v henessey